Wednesday, 6 December 2006

Junior Miner Picks & Comments

I asked a friend who posts on Kitco under the name "Trotsky" to analyze some preliminary findings released on Douglas Lake Mineral’s website on November 24th. In addition I asked for a few of his favored picks in the junior miner sector from a valuation standpoint.

I have two reasons for asking Trotsky to do this.
  • He is a highly respected poster and much more knowledgeable than I am at analyzing drill results.
  • I want to eliminate potential charges of bias because of ads that appear on this blog.
Following is a review of DLKM (Douglas Lake Minerals), MRB (Metallica Resources), CRCUF (Canarc Resources), and OZN (Orezone), all by Trotsky except as noted.

Douglas Lake Minerals
Trotsky:
From what I can tell, this is very early in the exploration process - rock chip samples from artisanal workings are a very preliminary investigation. But the results are indeed very good. This is the type of result that justifies a more in-depth exploration, and one can probably already speculate that the probability of this turning into an economically viable deposit is quite high, because it's very near to surface. This appears to be a narrow-vein high-grade deposit, comparable to PMU's El Dorado/Minita project in terms of structure.

However, at this stage all one can really say with confidence is "This looks very promising". Whether it is truly viable depends on the actual size of the resource, metallurgical testing (i.e. what gold recoveries are possible) and other, extraneous factors as well (for instance, access to water and power). Tanzania is of course very prolific - when you find gold there, chances are good that you'll find a lot of it. If they're lucky and this turns out to be comparable to PMU's find, it could be a company-maker but emphasis must be placed on could. What IS certain is that this looks very worthy of an intensive exploration program.

Technically the stock appears poised for a run after putting in what appears to be an a-b-c wave 2 correction from the initial run-up. The 50-day moving average has begun to rise and appears poised to make a bullish cross with the 100-day moving average, which in turn has begun to flatten, and the price is just above both. This actually looks like an ideal entry point, but there is the caveat that it will of course depend on what the gold price is doing forthwith. A protective stop should be considered at the recent reaction low at 1.25, or just below it, but hard stops on thinly traded issues have their own risks as well.
DLKM (Douglas Lake Minerals)
Mish:

Following is a chart I put together a chart depicting the technical action Trotsky just described.
Click on the chart for an enhance image.



Since asking Trotsky for his analysis, I have confirmed the results released by Douglas Lake were indeed preliminary results and not the results of more extensive drilling that I wrote about in Chicago Natural Resources Conference Highlights. Those results were delayed and are now expected (but not guaranteed) to be out by the end of December.

Trotsky has again volunteered to analyze those drill results once they are published. Based on images of core samples in the Conference Highlights post (click to see some neat images) I am expecting favorable results, but the results will be posted regardless of what the findings are.

What follows now are three additional picks made by Trotsky also based on drill results and perceived value.

MRB (Metallica Resources)
Trotsky:
Quick Summary
84 million shares outstanding, 106 million fully diluted
MRB has no debt, and from 2007 onward will have considerable cash flows from Cerro (a gold/silver mine in Mexico). The bulk of MRB’s value is its 30% stake in El Morro, a gold/copper property in Chile. Technically, the stock has recently broken out from a base built over several months. A retest of the break-out point at or near $3.75 may be a reasonable entry point. Click on the above link for additional information about Metallica Resources.

Target for this stock is $8-$9 provided the gold price remains firm. On December 4th MRB announced a private placement of 6.67 million shares at C$ 4.50/share plus warrants (exercise price C$ 5.60, duration 3 years) for gross proceeds of C$ 34.5 million to the company. This placement may create some short term weakness in the stock that one might use to accumulate.

Projects:
1. The Cerro San Pedro gold/silver mine in Mexico
Planned start-up: early 2007, 115K oz. gold equivalent (85K oz. gold, 2m. oz. silver) per annum.
Proven & Probable Reserves: 2.03 million oz. gold-equivalent
Measured & Inferred Reserves: 3.197 million oz. gold-equivalent total
Cash cost per gold oz. net of silver credits: $126 (at $600 gold and $9 silver)
Other: This project has been delayed a bit due to legal challenges involving the explosives permit, but MRB has won every single court case to date, and the explosives permit has recently been reinstated. Further challenges seem unlikely, but they can’t be ruled out entirely. In short, there remains a risk, but it’s probably a small risk at this stage.

2. 30% stake in El Morro, Chile
El Morro is a large gold/copper porphyry, in which Xstrata is earning a 70% stake by funding a feasibility study (this involves 10's of millions of dollars in exploration drilling, assaying, modeling, etc.) Per the November 13th update by Xstrata, MRB's 30% share of resources is 1.91 billion pounds of copper and 2.47 million ounces of gold in the measured and indicated categories and 0.67 billion pounds of copper and 0.82 million ounces of gold in the inferred category.

3. Rio Figueroa, Chile
This is another gold/copper porphyry system in the early stage of exploration with very encouraging results so far. One hole intercepting 108 metres contains 0.40% copper and 0.96 grams per ton gold. A second hole intercepting 158 metres contains 0.36% copper and 0.37 grams per ton gold. In addition, a near surface copper oxide orebody has been identified, and a copper-gold sulphide orebody just below it.
CRCUF (Canarc Resources)
Trotsky:
Quick Summary
68 million shares outstanding, 79million fully diluted
CRCUF's main property is New Polaris, a high grade gold orebody in British Columbia. CRCUF also has a royalty stakes in the Bellavista mine (Costa Rica) and an outright 80% stake in Benzdorp after the earn-in is completed. Benzdorp is located in Suriname (Africa). Technically the stock looks quite bullish, and sits just below long term resistance in the 0.80 c. region. In spite of having risen quite a bit since its 2005 low, the stock remains cheap considering the underlying value of the properties. It is therefore a good buy on any short term reactions. Click on the above link for additional information about Canarc Resources.

Projects:
1. The Bellavista royalty
Bellavista is an open pit heap leach mine in Costa Rica owned by Glencairn Gold Corp. It produces 60K. oz. per annum at a cash cost of $257/oz. The projected mine life is 7 years. Canarc exchanged its ownership stake in the project for a net profit royalty of 5.7% during the first payback period, rising to 10.4% during the second payback period and 20.2% thereafter. Canarc currently plans to sell this royalty, which has a NPV of $3.3m. according to a 2005 study.

2. New Polaris
New Polaris is where the bulk of Canarc’s value lies. This is a high grade gold orebody in British Columbia, Canada that supported a small scale mining operation in the past (from 1936 to 1942 and 1946 to 1951), producing about 240K oz. The property is currently subject to a phase 3 drilling program, and a number of spectacular drill results have been achieved to date with high grade visible gold mineralization and notable intersections grading 44.7 grams per ton over 6.2 metres (including 108 grams per ton over 1 metre), 22.5 grams per ton over 3.05 metres (including 48.9 grams per ton over 0.6 metres), and 16.1 grams per ton over 12.4 metres (including 118.5 grams per ton over 0.9 metres).

A new resource estimate, a mine plan, the initial economic evaluation and a mining permit application should be forthcoming by the end of this year. Clearly the results to date are extremely encouraging and make it very likely that a mining operation will be established. The resource update will likely show an 800K. oz. or better resource The company’s original target was to prove up 600K. oz., but the drill results have exceeded expectations, which could support a 60K oz. per annum or better mining operation. This mine alone could be worth about $1.10-$1.30 / share, assuming 35 m. shares would have to be issued for financing.

3. Benzdorp, a large gold-copper porphyry in Suriname (South America) is the ‘sleeper’ property of CRCUF that could potentially turn out to be a multi-million ounce resource. The mineralization begins at surface and is largely shear and saprolite-hosted, similar to CBJ’s Gross-Rosebel and KGC’s Paracatu. Canarc can earn an 80% stake by making annual cash payments of $250,000, expending $5million on exploration (more than that has been spent by now) and delivering a feasibility study by October 2008. Exploration at Benzdorp has temporarily taken a backseat to finalizing the New Polaris project, but results to date have been very encouraging. Several mineralized zones have been discovered, with most work focused on the 750 by 250 metres JQA zone which contains gold and copper in a quartz-diorite porphyry stockwork in saprolite. Notable intersection from drilling in 2005 included: 169 m. of 0.60 grams per ton (including 12 m. of 1.08 grams per ton and 10.5m. of 1.01 grams per ton) , 400 m. of 0.48 grams per ton (including 120 m. of 1.14 grams per ton), 315 m. of 0.45 grams per ton (including 25 m. of 1.01 grams per ton), 238 m. of 0.52 grams per ton , 256m. of 0.55 grams per ton (including 44 m. of 1.09 grams per ton). These are definitely economic grades considering this is porphyry starting from the surface and amenable to open pit mining. Subsequent metallurgical testing revealed that very high recoveries could be achieved.

Canarc also holds about 10% of Endeavor Silver, and a stake in privately held Aztec Silver. Major shareholders in Canarc are ABX and KGC either of which could be a future joint venture partner for Benzdorp, since the development of a large gold/copper porphyry requires a large initial investment.
OZN (Orezone)
Trotsky:
Quick Summary
117.1 m. shares outstanding, 124m. fully diluted.
Orezone is another Canadian based exploration company with the majority of its properties located in West Africa. It holds 10 properties (most of which are in Burkina Faso), covering some 8,900 square kilometres, which makes it the largest explorer in Burkina. Of these properties, the flagship Essakane, Segala and Bondi are considered the most important. Orezone also holds the Kossa property in Niger just across the border from Essakane, as well as a 50% joint venture interest in 2 further Niger properties and two permits in Mali. OZN acquired most of its interests during the final stages of the gold bear market when interest in such acquisitions was low, and the time to buy was at hand. Today most of them look like potential winners. Click on the above link for additional information about Orezone.

Technically, OZN was been very strong until April of 2006 but the long term uptrend that had been in place until then was broken in the May/June swoon in the gold sector. Since then, the stock has traded sideways in a tight band between $1.30 and 1.70. This several months long consolidation has now allowed the price to converge with the flattening 100 and 50 day moving averages, and the current price could be a decent entry point. Future news flow from ongoing drilling campaigns and the final feasibility study/project development decision on Essakane could reignite the stock.

Projects:
1. Essakane is a joint venture with GFI, which has opted to earn a 60% stake by bringing the project to the bankable feasibility study stage. Its 1.9m. oz. resource now makes Essakane the biggest known gold resource in Burkina. GFI's commitment nearly guarantees that a mine will be built. A recent preliminary assessment report outlined that the likely cash cost of production will be about $265/oz. producing ca. 310K oz. per annum over an 8 year mine life. A capital investment of roughly $128 million will be required for OZN to participate in the project at a 40% rate. A very conservative initial assessment showed a relatively paltry 15.8% Internal Rate of Return at a 10% discount and $625 gold price, which created some temporary pressure on OZN's share price. However, my feeling is that the market is underestimating the project's potential, as it seems likely that re-assaying will reveal somewhat higher grades. Other ways to improve project economics are also under investigation. For example: optimization of the pit slope is thought to improve the stripping ratio from the preliminary study's from 5.4:1 to 4.4:1 with obvious implications for cash costs.

2. Sega and Bondi
After Essakane, the Segala and Bondigui deposits are the most advanced projects of OZN and it holds a 100% interest in both, subject to a 3% net smelter royalty in Sega's case). Repadre (now IAG) previously estimated a resource of 300K oz. at 2.88 grams per ton at Sega, but OZN believes the deposit could ultimately host between 1m.-to 2m. oz. High grade discoveries at Sega as well as the large intercepts of lower grade ore strongly suggest the presence of an economically viable deposit.
Bondi has similarly had a number of impressive intercepts and it appears highly likely that either Sega or Bondi or both will eventually progress to the feasibility stage.

3. Kossa, Niger
Kossa is a project across the border from Essakane, and is hosted in the same sedimentary basin. The permit covers 2000 square kilometres and initial drilling has shown results very similar to the Burkina Faso properties in that large lower grade zones host high grade shoots at depth. This looks like a highly prospective
permit as well.

4. Other properties:
OZN has 2 more properties in Niger (Namaga and Koriya) optioned from Greencastle resources, whereby OZN earns a 50% interest by spending $1m. in exploration over 3 years, which rises to 75% upon preparation of final feasibility studies. Initial drilling has already shown encouraging results such as 22m. at 2.4 grams per ton at Koriya and 10m at 4.9 grams per ton at Namaga. Other properties in Burkina include Bombore and Golden Hill, both of which have been subject to previous exploration work by predecessor companies and show great promise (especially Bombore).
$HUI
Mish:

Seasonal factors should remain strong through the end of January. Shorter term the $HUI has put in a Demark trend exhaustion signal but the weekly chart technically looks sound. We may see a consolidation period for a week or two but the medium term bullish case remains intact as long as 335-340 holds. If it doesn't, one will need to reassess the nature of the drop (does it look corrective in nature as opposed to a real trend change). Brian McAuley, my partner in the Survival Report, sent me the following chart and comments just this morning:
Here is a weekly chart of the HUI. I would not surprised at all if the HUI declined to test the recent breakout (black line) and/or the 20 week MA: both reside in the 325-335 range. If the HUI is preparing to rally beyond the 401 high it also would not be surprising if that preparation took some time. There is a chance that such a rally could be quite explosive (from an Elliot Wave point of view), so I half expect the HUI to try and throw some people off if that's the case.

Click on chart for an easier to read view.

Note: I redrew the above chart as the one Brian sent had a scale not suitable for publishing in this blog.

Those wishing to add to (or enter) this sector may with to consider waiting for a pullback to the breakout line or 20EMA as shown in the above chart, or simply adding on dips on an individual issue basis.

Gold and the US Dollar
Trotsky:
(From an Email on December 6th but also posted on Voy–The Kitco refugees gold and metals forum)

A break below 640 on gold can't be good near term. Unfortunately, public bearishness on the dollar is at a fever pitch again. A recent Economist cover is particularly concerning. The Economist also put in the low for the dollar LAST time around (an Economist cover announcing a 'disappearing dollar' coincided perfectly with a 2 year low). The Economist is by now famous for spotting trends just as they end, and has become one of the most reliable contrary indicators magazine-cover-wise anywhere on the planet. Their classic 'drowning in oil' cover that promised $5 oil within days of oil making a historic low in the $10/bbl. region that was followed by a 700% price rally forever stands as a stark reminder of this fact. So yet ANOTHER bearish cover story on the dollar is quite disturbing here, as gold has lately taken its cues from the moves in the dollar.

However, I would also like to point out that the dollar's moves against other fiat currencies are not necessarily an impediment to its continued long term devaluation against gold, the only REAL money out there. So far, the dollar's devaluation against gold amounts to slightly less than 97% over a span of 73 years, and we have absolutely no reason to expect it not to give those final 3 percent up as well. Every fiat currency is ultimately on its way to utter worthlessness, it is only the speed at which this happens that is occasionally in question. Those final three percent, the last lap in the fall into the black hole that awaits every fiat currency at the end of its life are going to be a sight to see IMO.

[Mish note: It was "The Incredible Shrinking Dollar" cover of Newsweek that marked the bottom of the US dollar in 2005 to within a week or so. Nonetheless Trotsky is correct that Economist covers have a nasty habit of marking major turning points. Other recent notables include Time Magazine's cover in the summer of 2005 "Home $weet Home - Why We're Going Gaga over Real Estate" marking the tip top of the real estate bubble within a month. Yes, they did say "gaga" right on the cover.]

General Comments on Junior Miners
Mish and Trotsky:
At the present time, the junior sub-sector of the gold stock universe is ironically the one offering the best value. Most (but not all) of the senior and mid tier producer shares are overvalued by traditional valuation criteria and presumably profit mostly from their scarcity value (the gold sector's total market capitalization is very small). At the same time, however, it should be clear that the prospective higher reward from investing in juniors also entails high risk. It is usually best to buy them when the mood is bleak, and their prices break down due to disinterest.

A cardinal rule that investors should heed is to diversify. Holding fewer than 10 junior companies in a heavily weighted miners portfolio entails increased risk. Concentrated bets will of course provide the biggest bang for the buck when they pan out, but in the junior miner’s universe one must always count on something NOT panning out according to expectations. The only way to mitigate that risk is by means of diversification. In a diversified portfolio it will not matter much if 2 or 3 of your 10 stocks go to zero provided you have 2 or 3 multi-baggers as well.

Sometimes properties are confiscated by an unfriendly government (this recently happened in Uzbekistan to NEM and others), sometimes the initial assessment of a property's potential turns out to have been overly optimistic, and sometimes an individual stock falls out of favor for unknown reasons while everything else marches ahead. Careful study may weed out some losers but it is too much to expect that every pitfall can or will be avoided. Eventually some picks will turn out to be the silk purses and others will be the sow’s ears, so one simply MUST diversify within this sub sector. The companies presented in this write-up all seem to have better potential than most, but they are subject to the above mentioned risk factors, and one should always keep that in mind.

Whether or not one wants to invest in such companies at all depends on one's personal risk tolerance. Those willing to invest in this sector simply must count on the share prices of the juniors to be extremely volatile and subject to extraneous factors including future movements in the price of gold, seasonal factors, currency effects, and the risk appetite of investors.
Disclosures:

I do own shares of Douglas Lake Minerals and have ever since the Monday following the Chicago Natural Resources Conference. I have added on weakness since then. I consider those shares to be a "core position" unless and until drill results or other factors dictate otherwise. Those factors can change at any time and I reserve the right to make portfolio changes at any time, without notice, based on such factors. At the time of this writing I have no current position in any of the other picks mentioned above but that is very likely to change, and when it does it will be without notice.

Neither I nor Trotsky are being paid to write about any company listed above but I do receive ad revenue as previously disclosed.

The above post represents the opinions of the authors and should not be taken as investment advice. Any investment decisions undertaken after reading this (or any public post from anywhere) must in all cases be made by the reader. Please consult your investment adviser before taking action on the analysis and opinions presented above.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Tuesday, 5 December 2006

Kool-Aid at Toll Brothers

On December 5th Toll Brothers reported 4th Quarter Earnings and the results were not exactly pretty.

Highlights
  • 2006 4th Q net income declined 44% vs. 2005 from $310.3 million to $173.8 million.
  • 2006 4th Q earnings per share declined 42% versus 2005.
  • 2006 4th Q revenues declined 10.4% vs. 2005 from $2.02 billion to $1.81 billion.
  • 2006 4th Q backlog declined 25.3% vs. 2005 from $6.01 billion to $4.49 billion.
  • 2006 4th Q signed contracts declined 55.6% vs. 2005 from $1.59 billion to $706 million.
  • 2006 4th Q cancellations came in at 585.
  • 2007 Deliveries are expected to be between 6,300 and 7,300 homes.
  • 2007 Land write-offs are expected to rise 375% from $16 million to $60 million.
Robert I. Toll, chairman and chief executive officer, stated:
"In tough times, our team produced our fifteenth consecutive year of record revenues and our second highest annual profits. These accomplishments are exceptional, considering the significant rise in cancellations, and are a tribute to our associates' commitment and hard work.

Fifteen months into the current slowdown, we may be seeing a floor in some markets where deposits and traffic, although erratic from week to week, seem to be dancing on the bottom or slightly above.

As we previously announced, this quarter's results were negatively impacted by our higher than normal 585 cancellations. With these cancellations creating unintended specs, we could face increasing margin pressure as we seek to move these homes.

Right now is a great time to buy a new luxury home. Builders are motivated to sell their specs and the fundamentals that typically lead our industry out of a slowdown are already in place. Interest rates are near historic lows, unemployment is near an all-time low and the stock market is setting records."
The Conference Call

The Conference Call was even more interesting (and entertaining) than the earnings report. Here are the highlights with Ivy Zellman at Credit Suisse questioning Robert Toll.

Ivy Zellman: "Which Kool-Aid are you drinking because I want some ... It's not what we are hearing from a lot of the other builders. ...What do you see in the data because your numbers certainly don't show it today and there is clearly a lot of risk that 2007 won't bring the optimism to reality that you are seeing, so why put your neck out Bob?"

Robert Toll: "I don't think I put my neck out. I think I made a statement in regard to what I witnessed. ... But I don't think I've made a statement with respect to the future ... I've just told what I have witnessed."

Ivy Zellman: "I'm sorry. I thought you said pent up demand...."

Robert Toll: "I think the pent up demand statement falls logically..... Taking the DC market as an example .... It would logically follow that demand is increasing in the DC market"

Ivy Zellman: "I guess that's fair but why, to be a little more pointed, if you are as optimistic as you seem//"

Robert Toll: (cutting off Ivy) "I didn't mean to project optimism, I only meant to project what I've seen in the past"

Ivy Zellman: "Ok well let's just say that you read a report that stocks will continue to surge why only buy 12 thousand shares of your stock why not buy a boatload of your stock if you really believe stocks were headed north here?"

Robert Toll: (cutting off Ivy at one point but she finishes anyway this time) "Well I referred to somebody else's belief but let us say that I believe, which I am unwilling to make a statement on, to assume your proposition that I believe, which I don't necessarily, but let us assume that I do, your question why wouldn't I buy stock ... and the answer is I believe I can make more money with my powder cash buying land and expanding the business than I believe I could make by buying my stock" [Mish note: Yes as silly as it might look in print, that is what Toll said.]

Ivy Zellman: "I think a lot of people if they ever follow you Bob, in your buying and selling personally, they made a lot of money, and I'll leave it at that". [Mish note: This is clearly in reference to insider sales.]

Comments on Silicon Investor

Also entertaining were these comments posted on Silicon Investor.

Ramsey Su
summary of what Ivy said:
Bob, You are full of sh*t!!!!!

GT
LOL, IVY just insulted Bob and he said, "THANK YOU"
The guy is so dumb he does not understand what she is saying.

Ramsey Su
Seriously, when questioned, Bob Toll is pretty admitting that he was just pumping. NO areas are improving. He based his entire dancing at bottom on a couple of refundable deposits.

CalculatedRisk
OK, I listened to the recorded call. I've been on both sides of calls, and these guys seemed very unprofessional to me. "I didn't mean to project optimism."
Amazing.

Spec Homes

Toll Brothers has a website that lists "Quick Delivery" Homes.
Quick Delivery Homes are new homes in Toll Brothers communities that are already under construction and are ready to move into in a matter of weeks or months. Our Quick Delivery Homes (often called Inventory Homes or Spec Homes) reduce the time it takes to build a custom luxury home while still allowing you to select many of the custom features available from our extensive 500+ catalog of possibilities.
Ramsey Su totaled them all up, came up with 612, and noted "That seems to be a lot for a builder who says they do not build specs." Here are the totals by state.

AZ 42, CA 42, CO 9, CT 5, DE 7, FL 114, IL 18, MA 9, MD 24, MI 32
MN 3, NC 29, NJ 38, NV 63, NY 13, PA 37, RI 2, SC 12, TX 35, VA 78
612

Ignoring the current cancellation rate, ignoring the spec homes, and assuming the optimistic projection of 7,300 home sales comes in, Toll is still sitting on a 10 year's supply of land with 74,000 lots. That makes his comment to Ivy about buying more land seem more than a bit disingenuous. All things considered, the odds of Toll "dancing on the bottom" seem rather remote.

Disclosure.
I have no current position in TOLL (but I may take one).

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Monday, 4 December 2006

Floors, Ceilings, Camels, Straw

There was a very interesting article in the Pimco Investment Outlook for December 2006 by Bill Gross entitled Reality Check. Gross talks about a new derivative credit product retailed to institutional buyers under the sticker known as a CPDO or "constant proportion debt obligation." It is a very interesting conversations so let's tune in.
Things are seldom what they seem. Skim milk masquerades as cream.

........ I write today not to expound on the cyclical economic outlook nor to unnecessarily repeat observations of prior Investment Outlooks conceding that risk spreads are compressed and potential alpha generation likely “anemic.” .... What I would like to speak to now is the current pricing (overpricing) of certain risk assets even under the idyllic conditions of continued Fed transparency and globalization and all of the other components which may have seemingly produced cream out of skim milk.

Volatility and growth rate assumptions dominate risk asset prices as do presumption of future real interest rates, liquidity, etc. The list of variables, if not endless, is certainly long and therefore more and more subjective the further one ventures out on the pricing limb. I, and I’m sure you as well, am always amazed at the pundits who claim that certain just released information is already “priced in” to the markets. How do they know and who did they ask?

But there are certain points in more definable, less “BS-able” asset markets that approach certainty if only because they are more mathematically based. When the Fed cut interest rates to 1% in June of 2003, I could guarantee you that they could only cut them 100 basis points more. When 10-year yields on Japanese JGBs hit .35% at the same time, I could almost guarantee you that their incredible bull market run was coming to an end. NASDAQ 5,000? Easy in retrospect, but harder at the time, if only because the mathematics of value were being biased by the phantasms of hope. The floor was 5,000 points below, but the ceiling somewhere in the wild blue yonder.

Because the bond market is more mathematically oriented than riskier asset markets, it stands to reason that a quest for certainty and reality in financial markets would begin there. Fed Funds at 1%, JGBs at .35%, and ?. Where is the present day counterpart where one could claim that prices could go no higher or risk spreads compress no further? We are beginning to find such evidence in the investment grade corporate bond market, the narrowing spreads of which are displayed in Chart 1.



While a rather obvious 25 or 35 basis points to 0 analogy could quickly be advanced here, a finer, more precise analysis emanates from the quantitative dissection of a new derivative credit product retailed to institutional buyers under the sticker known as a CPDO or “constant proportion debt obligation.”

Without too much explanation, these multibillion-dollar instruments lever investment grade indices up to 15 times the amount invested and offer or have offered a spread of 200 basis points over LIBOR with a AAA rating. Hard to pass up I suppose, recognizing that AAA securities are by definition blue chip with rare, only infinitesimally small annual default rates. But this AAA rating is subject to numerous (more numerous than usual) subjective assumptions on the part of the rating services and in turn vulnerable to quicker downgrades than your normal AAA GE credit rating (there GE, I’ve paid you back.)

My purpose in bringing up the CPDO, however is not to denigrate the rating sources or to praise GE, but to state that under PIMCO quantitative modeling, current investment grade CDX spreads, shown in Chart 1, can only narrow by 3 or 4 more basis points before these CPDO instruments can no longer earn a AAA rating or offer such an attractive 200 basis point spread. More importantly, increasing multiples of leverage beyond 15x near current yields spreads cannot maintain either a AAA rating and/or the 200 basis points in yield spread that have made this derivative so attractive and in turn helped to reinforce a declining trend in all credit spreads over the past few months. The increasing use of leverage, in other words, at least as applied to this particular area, appears to have run out of its magical ability to increase returns. Investment grade corporate spreads therefore are not likely to narrow further. The perceived fat content in this supposed AAA “cream,” is as high as it’s going to get, and skim milk may eventually be the reality.
Summary of Key Observations.
  • CPDOs have reinforced a declining trend all credit spreads.
  • Increasing leverage appears to have run out of its magical ability to increase returns.
  • Volatility and growth rate assumptions dominate risk asset prices as do presumption of future real interest rates, liquidity, etc. Those assumptions just may not be correctly “priced in”.
  • We are much closer to the floor than the ceiling when it comes to corporate spreads.
  • Investment grade corporate spreads therefore are not likely to narrow further.
  • The ability to lever any or all asset returns via increasing leverage is reaching a climax.
Gross goes on to say "No gloom and doom message here" (refer to the article for context) but I think the implications are obvious and can hardly mean anything but doom and gloom when this mess starts to unwind. I encourage everyone to read the entire article.

Default Insurance

John Rubino on DollarCollapse asserts Everyone is writing default insurance!
  • The stocks that make up Bearing's credit bubble index (banks, brokers, homebuilders) didn’t miss a beat when tech crashed in 2000; they kept on rising and have now, despite the homebuilders’ recent weakness, hit levels comparable to the NASDAQ before its crash.
  • Subprime lending has driven the latest stage of the credit bubble, which puts it on very shaky ground indeed. From Bearing: “32.6% of new mortgages and home-equity loans in 2005 were interest only, up from 0.6% in 2000; 43% of first-time home buyers in 2005 put no money down; 15.2% of 2005 buyers owe at least 10% more than their home is worth (negative equity); 10% of all home owners with mortgages have no equity in their homes (zero equity); $2.7 trillion dollars in loans will adjust to higher rates in 2006 and 2007.”
  • Instead of a single isolated bubble, there has been a series of rolling bubbles, with new ones forming to replace those that burst. Each, in other words, is part of one mega-bubble that’s fueled by an ongoing flood of new dollars.
Click on the above link to see some interesting charts with thanks to John Rubino and Bearing Asset Management. Even as some components of subprime lending are now blowing up, expanded leverage in CPDOs was ready and waiting in the wings. One can only wonder "What the BLEEP is next?"

Fannie Mae & Freddie Mac

I find it interesting that the Treasury Drops Demand That Fannie, Freddie Cut Their Portfolios.
Dec. 1 (Bloomberg) -- The U.S. Treasury is no longer demanding that Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac reduce their combined $1.4 trillion mortgage portfolios as part of legislation creating a new regulator for the government chartered companies, according to a document the Treasury gave to Democrats in Congress.

Treasury officials in July backed legislation that passed the Senate Banking Committee requiring a new regulator to cut the mortgage assets rather than just giving it authority to do so. Fannie Mae says such constraints could reduce its portfolio to less than $100 billion from $720.9 billion. The bill hasn't moved to a Senate vote because of opposition from Democrats.
Inquiring minds are probably wondering what happened to that systemic risk at Fannie Mae that the Fed and the Treasury department had both been harping about for several years now. Bear in mind that Fannie Mae also has a derivative mess so big that it still has not filed is annual report for 2004 or any quarterly reports since then Forbes talked about the filing problems of Fannie Mae on November 8, 2006.
Fannie Mae said it determined financial statements from January 2001 through the second quarter of 2004 should no longer be relied upon, due to issues with accounting practices and material weaknesses in internal controls over financial reporting.

The company plans to restate earnings for fiscal years 2002 and 2003, as well as the first and second quarters of 2004.

The company plans to file restatements, its quarterly report and annual report for 2004 by the end of this year. In the meantime, because of the late filing, Fannie Mae will need to request extensions from the NYSE in order for its shares to remain listed on the exchange.
Let's review the Testimony of Secretary John W. Snow before the U.S. House Financial Services Committee on Proposals for Housing GSE Reform.

In order to protect against the systemic risks posed by the GSEs' mortgage investment business, the Administration recommends that limitations be placed on the size of the GSEs' retained mortgage investment portfolios. An appropriate phase-in period for the reduction of the existing portfolios would be needed so as not to disrupt mortgage or financial markets.

In addition to Snow's testimony, various Fed members have also talked about systemic risk at Fannie Mae numerous times. I am the only one that finds it odd that the Fed is no longer concerned about the systemic risk at Fannie Mae or the derivative mess they are in even though Fannie Mae has not filed a quarterly report since 2004? Did systemic risk vanish overnight? Or is the Fed now more fearful of the housing implosion than the systemic risk it was previously worried about? If Bernanke sends me an email answering those questions I will be more than happy to post it.

Harvesting Currencies

I am wondering how long it takes before this "harvesting operation" blows sky high.
PowerShares DB G10 Currency Harvest Fund
Description
Seeks to track the Deutsche Bank G10 Currency Future Harvest Index™ by (1) entering into long futures contracts on the three G10 currencies associated with the highest interest rates, (2) entering into short futures contracts on the three G10 currencies associated with the lowest interest rates, and (3) collateralizing the futures contracts with United States 3-month Treasury bills.
Derivatives Trading

Bloomberg is reporting Derivatives Trading Soars to $370 Trillion.
Nov. 17 (Bloomberg) -- The use of derivatives grew at the fastest pace in eight years during the first half of 2006, boosting earnings at securities firms and reducing costs for investors.

The face value of derivatives based on corporate bonds, currencies, interest rates, commodities and stocks jumped 24 percent to $370 trillion, according to the Bank for International Settlements. It was the biggest percentage rise since the bank began keeping records in 1998.

Trading in credit-default swaps, the fastest-growing derivatives market, helped spur record earnings for banks including New York-based Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs Group Inc. At London-based Barclays Capital derivatives accounted for more than 60 percent of revenue and profit, Chief Executive Officer Bob Diamond said in May.

"The pace of growth is going to have continued unabated in the second half of the year," said Kit Juckes, head of fixed-income research in London at Royal Bank of Scotland Group Plc.

The amount of outstanding credit-default swap contracts jumped to $20.3 trillion from $13.9 trillion at the end of last year, the Basel, Switzerland-based bank said on its Web site today. The securities are financial instruments based on bonds and loans that are used to bet on an increase or decrease in indebtedness.

Alan Greenspan, the former chairman of the Federal Reserve, has been saying since 2002 that derivatives reduce risks by making financial markets resilient to shocks. In May he told a Bond Market Association gathering in New York that derivatives are the most significant change on Wall Street "in decades."
Modern Financial Wizardry

In other news, a spokesman claiming to represent Greenspan reported that the entire risk of all derivatives trading to date has now officially been offloaded to Mars. A Martian spokesman verified that claim and went on to state that Martian risk has been offloaded to France. France in turn claims to have offloaded the risk to the MMMM corporation better known as Madame Merriweather's Mudhut Malaysia, the ultimate guarantor of $370 trillion in derivatives.

Leverage on the trade has not yet been calculated but Madame Tandalayo Merriweather of Kuala Lumpur has emailed me personally stating "Don't Worry, My Mudhut is Priceless". The key point here is the priceless nature of the Malaysia Mudhut which is a good thing given that it has taken two years and counting to straighten out the derivatives mess at Fannie Mae alone. In a miracle of modern financial wizardry, no one it seems has any risk associated with these derivatives, given they are all backed by something priceless.

Citadel

It is staggering the amount of credit that is sloshing around on totally unproductive activities. As proof I offer Citadel trading costs hit $5.5bn.
The importance to Wall Street of a handful of large hedge funds was starkly illustrated by the disclosure that Citadel Investment Group paid more than $5.5bn in interest, fees and other investment costs last year. Although the net asset value of Citadel's two funds is only about $13bn, its costs are high because its managers trade frequently and take on huge leverage.

Citadel is raising $2bn in a debt issue managed by Lehman Brothers and Goldman Sachs. Fortress Investment Group, which has $26bn in hedge fund and private equity assets, last month filed for an initial public offering that is expected to value it at about $7.5bn. But the banks are expected to fight hard to retain hedge fund business. Sylvie Durham, a lawyer at Greenberg, Traurig who represents hedge funds, said: "They will cut spreads on deals and loosen restrictions they have on how money they lend can be used."
"They [banks] will cut spreads on deals and loosen restrictions they have on how money they lend can be used" in order to retain business. Well isn't that special.

GDP vs. M3

Credit is soaring in every which way but none of it is benefiting the real economy. One can look at the plunging GDP and increasing inventories as proof. No additional production capacity has been added by any of this financial activity and none is needed anywhere in anything anyway as I pointed out in Bernanke's Box. Thus we have finally reached the point where all credit expansion is now nothing but pure speculation. This is an extremely dangerous limbo of sorts where monetary policy is actually restrictive on real world productive activities and also restrictive on individuals overleveraged in debt but nowhere near restrictive enough (for the time being) to stop further speculation by financial wizards seeking profit. See An email from Bernanke for the problems facing Bernanke.

Let's now return to Floors and Ceilings for a bit.

Floors
  • Credit Standards
  • Corporate Spreads
  • Volatility
  • Interest Rates
Interest rates are closer to the floor than the ceiling but still are quite far above where they are in Japan. One difference now is the fact that the U.S. dollar index was at 120 when the Fed started its last slash and burn operation but is now sitting at 82.5.

Ceilings
  • Leverage
  • Risk Taking
  • Bullishness
  • Housing Starts
  • Housing Permits
  • Credit Default Swaps
  • Derivatives in General
As Bill Gross points out it is easier to estimate the bottom than the top, but if credit standards and credit spreads are at the bottom, it is likely to imply the top is near at hand on all kinds of things. The top is clearly in on Housing Starts and Housing Permits and in spite of a significant plunge in both, they remain much closer to the ceiling than the floor on a historic basis.

It has been amazing to say the least to see the progression that has taken place. Anything and everything was done to keep the credit bubble expanding.

Credit Bubble Expansion History
  1. In the wake of a dotcom bust that Greenspan refused to let play out, interest rates were slashed to 1%.
  2. Low rates fueled massive overinvestment in housing.
  3. The Fed started hiking.
  4. To keep the housing bubble going, credit lending standards dropped with each rate hike.
  5. Housing prices soared and pay option arms and other products were invented to keep housing affordable.
  6. Stock funds resorted to selling options to "gain income".
  7. Speculation in credit default swaps soared.
  8. With each rate hike in the U.S., the carry trade in Yen became more and more attractive. Speculation in various carry trades soared.
  9. Carry trade speculation compressed yields across the board in all kinds of things.
  10. The housing bubble eventually burst due to pure exhaustion but CPDO speculation came to the forefront to keep things humming. This further suppressed credit spreads.
  11. Hedge funds unhappy with gains on CPDOs resorted to increased leverage.
  12. Derivatives trading soared to $370 Trillion.
  13. Running out of room on CPDOs, money started pouring into leveraged buyouts.
  14. End of the line?
Leveraged Buyouts

Leveraged buyouts appear to be the latest toy for the speculative crowd. Leveraged buyouts are not a new concept. Can this rehash be the end of the line?

The Atlanta Business Chronical is reporting Texas Pacific eyeing Home Depot.
According to a New York Post report Thursday, Fort Worth, Texas-based Texas Pacific and New York-based Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co. are among the buyout firms considering a buyout deal that could be worth $100 billion.

The buyout, if it occurs, would be the largest leveraged buyout in history, according to the news reports.
On Friday December 1st, John Succo, one of my favorite Minyanville professors wrote about The H boys...
Home Depot (HD) is up over a dollar pre-open on LBO rumors. My firm's thoughts are that an LBO for HD (or any retailer) makes little financial sense. Most of these rumored and actual transactions these days are making little sense, but companies like this it is especially the case. The only positive factor going for such a deal is that HD has virtually no debt. But it has little in the way of hard assets and thin margins, which makes an LBO very dangerous.

But crazier things have happened. After all that de-levering by companies in 2002 they are now all in a rush to re-lever. Lessons not learned.

If the US's new Treasury secretary wants to worry about financial melt-downs as a function of risk taking by hedge funds, he needs to call up Mr. Bernanke and talk about the real source of risk: super easy money finding its way into pure speculation. Today's LBO funds are a form of hyper-speculation as they are forcing too much risk into the system.
Although $100 billion is clearly not what it used to be, the proposed leveraged buyout of Home Depot is still the largest in history. Can this be the proverbial camel that breaks the straw's back?

Mish Notes:
1) The above post originally appeared in Whiskey&Gunpowder.
Click on the link for a free subscription.
2) Home Depot has since Quashed Buyout Rumors but the idea that the market will eventually choke over one of these leveraged buyouts remains valid.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Sunday, 3 December 2006

Maxed Out

Are we about to see a trend reversal in reality television shows from the likes of Flip This House to Maxed Out? I have not seen Maxed Out but I am positive it will be a welcome change over the current financial wizardry garbage telling everyone years too late how to make a fortune off a trend well past its peak and now dieing. Face the facts: flipping and flippers are now "burnt toast".


Meet Aurora--she's 21 and already $80,000 in debt. Can she put the manicures on hold and give herself a fresh financial start?

Kathleen is a single mother earning $37,000 a year. Can she dig herself out of debt and give her children the security they deserve?

In each episode of Maxed Out, finance coach Ayse Hogan gets to the root of what is causing one woman's unhealthy relationship with money. Observing the subject's behavior and putting her on a strict budget, Hogan helps the cash-stressed gal by demonstrating the basic tenets of wealth-building: debt reduction, savings and investment.
If Maxed Out takes off, especially if other similar television shows follow, just might mark a significant turning point in consumer credit aversion. Consumer psychology does not turn on a dime and this is a start. Every trend change starts somewhere and it is high time consumers tell credit card companies exactly where to go. You know it, I know it, and everyone in debt knows it.

This show is yet another small sign of the change away from consumption and risk towards savings an risk aversion. The signs are adding up. Can it be that sometime soon individuals will no longer be bragging about how much their house is worth or how many condos they have to how much of their income they are putting away in T-Bills?

No doubt some (many) of you will find the idea preposterous, but the supertanker of risk (at least from the consumer side) has already turned. Once turned, supertankers are very difficult to turn again. The fat cats on Wall Street with their leveraged buyouts and stock buybacks and enormous bonuses are simply too busy giving each other high fives to have noticed the change in direction. The combination of those last two sentences will turn out to be Bernanke's worst nightmare.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

A Lit Fuse in Key West

I have a new set of posts from a friend living (and renting) in Key West who posts on my board on the Motley Fool under the name "FreeThinkerKW". The first post is from a week or two ago, and the update to that post is from December 1.

A Lit Fuse
Every Friday in the Key West Citizen, Good Deeds (sales of homes and land in the Florida Keys) are listed. Last week, just one home sold in all of Key West.

Here is an interesting thing which just happened in the latest listings. The Good Deeds used to show you how much the previous owner of a property paid for it before he recently sold it to Buyer XYZ for a new price. [It no longer does.] I believe the local Real Estate cartel has put pressure on the Key West Citizen to stop showing the previous sale price.

When business was booming just two years ago, it was common to see eye popping returns such as a Home bought in 1991 for $90,000 selling for $1 million in 2004. You couldn't buy advertising that good for the Real Estate business in this town.

However, the last two years have not been good for those who bought. And many of those who've recently bought in the past three years when the lead car of the Real Estate Roller Coaster was just tipping over the tallest pricing peak have got to face reality i.e., the ARM resets are just about to kick in for many of the people sitting in the rear cars of that roller coaster.

To use another metaphor: many more homes are about to flood a market already saturated with homes for sale. A lot of homeowners are going to drown in their debt.

I say, it's easy to figure out inventory will continue to grow? Well, as I stated in my post about the auction [Mish note: See Shell Shocked in Key West], I'm only seeing one or two homes sell weekly in Key West. Just a few years ago, you'd see 30, 40, 50, 100 homes turn hands in a week. At the rate we are moving homes now, one or two a week, we have more home owners dying and their properties go on the market For Sale, adding more inventory than is being sold.

Inventory is growing like an Red Algae bloom in the Florida Bay. It expands by another 100 homes every 2 or 3 months now.

The new talking point from David Lereah and the NAR is leaking into local realtor's ads: "This is a Great Time to Buy Real Estate!" The "Easy Math" suggests otherwise. The easy math simply comes from observation and writing down figures. And then you paint in those numbers you collect and you get this Technicolor look at what is really going on.

Here we are in the Lower Keys: 1600 homes on the market. We just had 22 homes go to auction and not one minimum bid was met. Not one!

Interestingly enough, one house sold below the minimum bid. The person selling his home below his minimum bid was a Realtor. That's like an insider at Enron selling stock while he and all his boardroom buddies are emailing employees to keep loading up on Enron in their 401s and telegraphing "BUY ENRON" to analysts and investors in glowing press releases.

I can't see how any rational person with a modicum of math ability can agree to put their real money into a Key West home at this time. Even if you can't do an Excel spreadsheet, all you need is a pen and a legal pad. Buy a Key West Citizen. Write down some addresses of Homes for Sale with asking prices. Take 30 to 50 addresses. Come back every 6 weeks and watch how many thousands and tens of thousands are shaved away from the asking price.

Real Estate in this town is no longer escalating in price. No one can deny that. However, hundreds of homeowners still refuse to come down off their asking prices. And as more and more home prices drop below the $500k mark . . . I wonder . . . what in the world are these last people still sitting in their seats in a burning theater going to do when the market sees $250,000 homes again and incinerates their wishful thinking? Where will they be? Upside down on a mortgage, boat in the yard paid for by a refi-loan and they can't use the boat because everybody in the house is working a 2nd or 3rd job? I don't know. Everybody's got a different story. But so so many of the good people I know who got suckered by "Real Estate always goes UP," theory are living those lives of quiet desperation right now which Thoreau warned us about. I can see it in their eyes.

When the wave of ARM resets come, and the foreclosures roll, that's when the real estate selling panic will reach the epoch proportions of the real estate buying panic of just a few years ago.

The fuses are already lit. I feel 2007 will be the year that those who didn't run away from the Debt Bomb and Housing Bubble Bomb will realize they are trapped and will be in the blast zone come 2008. I think 2008 will be the mass carnage year for home prices drops in Key West. Yet, I think that's just the beginning. I think real estate will suffer into the middle of the next decade. I don't see a bottom happening in 2008. No way.

Keep an eye on housing inventory in your hometown, folks. If you can find the Good Deeds for your county, see if you can also find the data now missing from ours: how much the seller paid for the property. Sellers who are selling for less than what they paid and Real Estate Cartel members do not want to share that info in Key West any longer. For the blue collar seller who sells at a loss, it's embarrassing. Having that kind of loss printed in the local mullet wrapper is akin to saying, "Here's this week's sucker at Real Estate lotto."

This is a small town. We know you bought a place for $600,000 three years ago and just unloaded it today for $450,000. That's the kind of loss among blue collar workers which fires up the Coconut Telegraph for days. And that's not good because those who never bought are not going to buy anytime soon now that one of their own got burned so badly.

Still, the powers that be haven't covered up the asking price and selling price in the Florida Keys Good Deeds. That is an eye opening exercise in itself for anyone with an ability to see through the B.S.

The few properties selling are in 95% of the cases selling below the asking price. And some of the drops from asking prices are staggering. A $750,000 home recently sold for $625,000. And this is a home which easily could have commanded more than $1 million 18 months ago. Can you imagine sitting in on that negotiation and the seller keeps giving, giving, giving, because it's the first nibble he's had in a year?

My view: real estate will continue to decline in Key West next year. In 2008 the roller coaster will jump the tracks, and the old wooden rails will catch fire and burn to the ground.

This sounds crazy, but the more I observe, the more I believe this is going to take 10 years or more to squeeze out the excess. What Key West Real Estate went through is akin to NASDAQ at 5000. And instead of Mark Meeker and Henry Blodgett on the sidelines screaming for Amazon 600, Qualcomm 1000, and so on, we've now got David Lereah and $40 million worth of National Realtor ads and talking points telling us, "There's Never Been a Better Time to Buy Real Estate!"

I think 2008 will see everybody accepting a brutal new reality. And then I see everyone lowering their asking prices for years to come. But then again, all bets are off if we have some unseen event like a Category 5 Hurricane that wipes most of this town off the map. And then again, a good old fashioned recession would kill tourism and then we'd see the last linchpin of real estate . . . commercial real estate . . . begin the decline which housing is seeing now. Yes, a lot of things could happen to explode the bomb earlier than 2008.

Years ago, in the 1970s, the military left Key West in a big way. That took thousands of jobs in one fell swoop. Back then, back in the days of Jimmy Buffet living and dying in 3/4 time in Key West, you could rent a decent size apartment for $75.00 a month. Beers were .50 cents a bottle at happy hours. Square groupers (bales of pot) washed ashore regularly, and smuggling became our No. 1 big business in Key West.

I think we could go back to a time when this town is beat again. It has happened 4 or 5 times in our history. And that's something most people don't pay any attention to: history. Hell, Hemingway wrote off Key West and moved to Cuba in the late 30s. That was after the great Hurricane of 1935 knocked out Henry Flagler's railroad all the way to Key West. Thirty years before Hemingway left, another hurricane chased the Cigar business out of Key West and up to Tampa. Each time, this town suffered, real estate prices dropped, and people lost small fortunes by buying at the top when they should have been selling.

Here's my synopsis, my shot in the dark prediction for Key West Real Estate.
  • 2007: last alarms for "Run, Forrest, Run," as first of the ARMS reset. Meaning some of these loans at $3000 a month will adjust to an ARM which takes the loan payment to $4500, $5500, and higher. A lot of people I know are not going to be able to do it, even with a 3rd job. I expect many people to "disappear" from social scenes simply because they are too exhausted or broke to show their faces.
  • 2008: ARM reset time bomb goes off with a big bang and takes out all unreal asking prices on Key West real estate.
  • 2009-?: Key West veterans who left town start sauntering back into town after hearing the speculators and rude Northerners who stopped us from having fun and relaxation are moving out in droves like frightened wild dogs running from a T Rex. Key West veterans who lost it all in Real Estate toss in the Keys and run away in shame.
Is this the way it will turn out? Stay tuned. I may stick around. I may leave myself with my cushion of cash, gold, and good investments. We shall see what we shall see. Meanwhile, I'm taking my time finding work I want to do with love and passion. Wish me luck in that quest to "follow my bliss."

December 1 A Lit Fuse Continued

Here is an update to last week's post about the Good Deeds in the Monroe County Property Transfers. I am looking at last week's property transfers: Three houses sold in all the Florida Keys. Zero homes sold in Key West.

Just to be absolutely clear about this, I called Brian at Investor Title Service) which lists these good deeds and sells Realtor banner ads above the deeds.

He confirmed that For Sale By Owner sales . . . if there were any last week . . . would not be covered by the Good Deeds he lists as his listing is associated with the MLS. So, that skews the sales of homes in Key West and the Keys as I would need to go to the county and get the exact amount of property transfered.

Still, using what I've got, here are the three homes sold with asking price and what they fetched:

1.List Price: $4,500,000
Sold Price: $3,800,000
15.6% difference between list and selling price

2.List Price: $599,000
Sold Price: $525,000
12.4% difference between list and selling price

3. List Price: $399,000
Sold Price: $365,000
8.5% difference between list and selling price

I also would like to print an outstanding article in the Solares Hill Weekly Newspaper. Unfortunately, the paper is not online. The article would shed a great deal of insight as to what insurance rates are doing to people in this town.

A representative for Citizens Insurance, the last insurer of choice in the state of Florida . . . and whose rates are set by the government, not by their quasi-governmental agency . . . got verbally jumped by a group of angry politicians and citizens from the Lower Keys in a meeting a few nights ago.

To show you what some of these folks are going through 14 months after Wilma, one representative of a Condo down here whose roof was blown off and which has now been replaced for $3.5 million, has yet to receive its first check.

Another man stood up and told the audience about his ancient house constructed by shipbuilders and which has withstood every hurricane since it was built years and years ago. His wind insurance payments to Citizens this year jumped from $3,900 to $18,000.

Mind you that Citizens is bragging to the governor that "average" rates have only gone up 57%. And that last story is not a lie. My old roommate is paying $20,000 premium for wind with a $30,000 deductible. He wants out of the Keys so bad he's losing his mind.

Again, if you want to live in the Keys, rent. DO NOT BUY.

This is only going to get much, much worse.
Thanks FreeThinker!

Almost no one living in Key West thought this could possibly happen. Even after reading this most will discard this story as "Florida Thing" thinking it can't possibly happen to them. Well it can and it will happen in many other places (and the entire state of California is pretty much one of my prime targets). The worst is clearly yet to come.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Saturday, 2 December 2006

World Trade Progress

Reuters is reporting Brown, Paulson call for WTO progress.

I must note that Mish has been calling for world peace for years but no reportable progress has been sighted. Is this a chicken/egg which comes first kind of thing (no free trade without world peace/no world peace without free trade)? While pondering that question here are the article highlights lowlights.
Ahead of their meeting in London on Tuesday, Paulson and Brown said in a joint article that urgent action was needed to restart global trade talks, in a sign that the United States may be preparing to cede some ground in order to reach a deal.

"With the fate of Doha in the balance and multilateral trade rules a possible casualty, we urgently need people on both sides of the Atlantic who are prepared to make the case for trade and commit to policies that make it work," the two finance ministers wrote.

"North America and Europe are the two largest free-trade areas in the world. We are also the two largest economies. Further trade liberalisation led by our continents could encourage others to follow."

World Trade Organisation chief Pascal Lamy suspended the so-called Doha round of talks in July after trade ministers failed to break a long-standing impasse over farm subsidies and tariffs.The round has been billed as a once-in-a-generation chance to inject up to $300 billion (155 billion pounds) a year into the world economy and lift millions out of poverty."

Current talks are focussed on the agriculture sector, a vital part of economies across the globe. We should recognise, though, that expanding trade in manufacturing and services is also critical to economic progress everywhere," the two men wrote.
The reason I said "lowlights" is because all anyone does is talk. There is never any action. Time after time there is an agreement to agree without ever doing a thing. I see that current talks are focused on agriculture, which is where they were focused last year, two years ago, three years ago, 5 years ago, and (I am guessing at this) 10 years ago.

Let's look at a few previous links on trade.
The US and EU are the two single biggest block to free trade in the entire world, largely due to insistence on agricultural tariffs so it was ironic if not outright Orwellian to see Paulson claim "North America and Europe are the two largest free-trade areas in the world. We are also the two largest economies. Further trade liberalisation led by our continents could encourage others to follow."

The first major country that has the intestinal fortitude to really PRACTICE free trade, regardless of what any other country does or says will be an enormous winner. Instead the EU is putting tariffs on shoes, underwear, and other goods, and both the US and EU have massive subsidies on agricultural goods.

Height of Ridiculousness

The height of ridiculousness has to be trade agreements that force Japan to import rice even though its protectionist measures enable Japan to grow all the rice it needs. I talked about the absurdity of mandatory Japanese rice imports in How NOT to fix the Global Economy.
Mandatory rice imports pile up in Japan, raising storage costs.
Tuesday, October 10, 2006 at 13:20 EDT
TOKYO — The inventory of rice Japan has imported to fulfill a requirement under an international trade accord reached 1.8 million tons by the end of this August, entailing storage costs of 17 billion yen in fiscal 2005, agriculture minister Toshikatsu Matsuoka said Tuesday.

"How to draw down the inventory and reduce the storage cost is a major challenge for us so we hope to come up with some measures to whet demand for foreign rice," the minister of agriculture, forestry and fisheries told a news conference. The government has been encouraging use of imported rice in processed food so as not to dampen demand for domestically grown rice people eat as their staple food.
Storage costs are 17 billion YEN for rice in Japan, rice they will not even eat!

Paulson Warns on Protectionism

Echoing a headline opinion I 100% endorse, Paulson warns on trade protectionism.
U.S. Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson said on Tuesday trade protectionism was on the rise despite strong global prosperity and warned it was a potentially dangerous trend.

"We cannot allow protectionist elements to stifle our growth, limit our opportunities, and dictate the terms of our engagement with the world," Paulson said in prepared remarks for delivery to the Confederation of British Industry's annual conference.

"Giving in to protectionist sentiment would send a terrible signal," Paulson said during a joint appearance with British Chancellor of the Exchequer Gordon Brown.

Paulson said while reducing agricultural subsidies was important, it was just as vital to find ways to boost trade in manufacturing and services. Paulson said countries that opened their borders to trade almost invariably achieved increased prosperity.

"Despite the known benefits of trade, the protectionist sentiment that is rising in our two nations and elsewhere around the world is predicated on a false assumption that trade harms our economies," Paulson said.
If countries that open their borders to free trade "invariably achieve increased prosperity" then why don't we do it? In other words why don't we practice what we preach?

Here is the key hypocrisy "Paulson said while reducing agricultural subsidies was important, it was just as vital to find ways to boost trade in manufacturing and services." No, it is NOT just as important, at least not to third world countries. The US still has a manufacturing base (even if it is shrinking) and huge agricultural output as well. Many emerging markets only have an agricultural base. The US and EU both want something for nothing. That is, the US and EU want "free trade" when it comes to airplanes but not corn. The US claims to be willing to give up agricultural subsidies, but only if the EU does. Waiting for the EU to give in on that concept is like waiting for Godot.

Europe

In yet another irony I see that Europe Surpasses U.S., Japan in Gains From Trade.
Nov. 27 (Bloomberg) -- Europe, where worker anger over globalization sparks street protests, is surpassing the U.S. and Japan in the race to reap benefits from the explosion in world trade and investment.

The continent is claiming a bigger share than the U.S. of the increased trade with fast-emerging markets such as Brazil, Russia, India and China, say economists at Goldman Sachs Group Inc. Companies such as French retailer Carrefour SA and German software maker SAP AG are winning customers in emerging markets at the expense of rivals based in other regions.

"It raises eyebrows when people hear it, but Europe is doing well from globalization and greater trade," says Erik Nielsen, chief European economist with Goldman Sachs in London. "It stands to benefit much more in the future."

"Some politicians in Europe have been using the threat of globalization as a way of saying we have to protect ourselves, so it's become part of the political agenda," says [Martin] Baily, who was chairman of the White House Council of Economic Advisers under President Bill Clinton.

A European Commission poll of 24,750 residents this year found 47 percent regard globalization as a threat. Just 37 percent view globalization as a "good opportunity," compared with 56 percent three years ago. Opposition ran as high as 72 percent in France, where discontent played a part in the rejection of a new European treaty and the defeat of revamped labor market laws. France will elect a new president next year and globalization is the hottest issue in the campaigning.

"You can be scared of globalization, but only openness and the dismantling of trade barriers will create prosperity," German Chancellor Angela Merkel said in a speech in Frankfurt on Nov. 17.

French Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy, a likely 2007 presidential candidate, this month lauded the "unprecedented possibilities" of globalization. "The question is not whether globalization is good or bad," Sarkozy said Nov. 9. "It is whether we are prepared for it."
It is ironic that the EU is gaining on account of small pockets of free trade but workers are angered over it. Even though French Interior Minister Nicolas Sarkozy and German Chancellor Angela Merkel are strong proponents of free trade, only 37% of EU respondents think it is a good opportunity. Will French voters support Nicolas Sarkozy or will there be a backlash of protectionism?

One way of looking at free trade is "That Giant Sucking Sound". Another way of looking at free trade is cheaper underwear at Sears and cheaper goods in general at Wal-Mart. The third way of looking at things is that Australia, Canada, New Zealand, Brazil, India, China and other countries are forging economic alliances and the US and EU are increasingly on the sidelines over agricultural subsidies.

This is yet another short term pain, long term gain thing but few countries are willing to suffer through the short term pain. With every passing day the US and EU are less relevant. It may be a long long time before "less relevant" becomes "irrelevant" but we are clearly headed that direction. Like it or not, Asia is embracing free trade and the US and EU better hop on board or they will be left behind. "The question is not whether globalization is good or bad. It is whether we are prepared for it." Clearly the US and EU are not prepared for it.

Fair Trade

I know the counter arguments already. "It's not free trade we want. It's fair trade we want". Of course the US and EU want to decide exactly what "fair" means. Fair Trade is really a euphemism for protectionism (typically fostered by some group demanding protection). What people don't realize is that even if a country removes all barriers to trade UNILATERALLY (meaning, the trade situation will be "unfair") it will garner more prosperity than its protectionist competition. It works every time and Hong Kong is a good example. Free trade encourages competition, lowers prices and spurs innovation. In spite of those benefits, protectionist sentiment seems to be rising.

Living Wages

The second argument is "We need a living wage". As plausible as that argument may sound, the problem just may rest with reckless spending (such as the war in Iraq), stupid government policies promoting housing (GSEs and the Ownership Society), other horrid governmental waste most notably in Medicaid/Medicare policy, a negative savings rate, and prices that are simply too high, as opposed to wages that are too low. If prices are too high it is because of government intervention, government policies, and excessive monetary printing. The solution is not more government intervention, more government policies, and it certainly is not more misguided stimulus in the belief it will create more jobs.

Currency Controls

The Telegraph has an interesting article out called Airbus could trigger 'nuclear option' of currency controls.
If you have funds across the Channel, or a ferme in Acquitaine, be vigilant. Keep a close eye on Europe's press, because you might one day find your money is nailed more immovably to its Continental home than you had thought.

Four years ago, a small "cellule" inside the European Commission was ordered to draft a report, instigated by Paris, examining the legal basis under EU treaty law for 1970s-style exchange controls. It concluded that Brussels may lawfully freeze capital flows in and out of the EU, and within it, and that this could be done by a "qualified majority" of EU finance ministers, leaving Britain with no veto.

One of its authors told me this was not an abstract exercise. It was to enable Europe to stem the rise of the euro if the dollar goes into free fall, the underlying argument being that Washington should not be allowed export the consequences of its own reckless spending policies through a "beggar-thy-neighbour" devaluation.

The idea was to stop money coming in, though it could equally be used to stop money leaving.

I thought of this study when French premier Dominique de Villepin lashed out this month at the over-mighty euro. "We can't let the European Central Bank act alone on the exchange rate," he said. Ségolène Royal, the new Socialist leader, upped the ante a week later, accusing the ECB of "shattering growth".

My hunch is that Airbus will bring matters to a head. I was told by an Airbus official last year that if the euro exchange rate went above $1.30 for long, the company was "cooked". He said the chances of this happening were almost nil.

Well, "nil" may be here. While Airbus has an order backlog of 2,177 aircraft worth $220.3bn, these delivery contracts are in dollars while costs are in euros. "This is the nub of the problem," said Louis Gallois, the Airbus chief.

In 2004, the group was shielded by currency hedges at an average rate of $0.98. This year the rate is $1.12, and the hedges are expiring fast. Soon Airbus will face the full violence of the spot market. The aerospace champion is so deeply tied up with Europe's sense of industrial self-worth that it will not be sacrificed lightly on the altar of free currency flows. When the French premier vowed to do whatever it takes to save Airbus, I believed him.
It is important to note that currency manipulation is just another way of protecting home grown industries. There is not a country around it seems that wants a strong currency. Everyone wants to debase their currency to provide export jobs to the US, apparently in the mistaken belief that the US consumer is a bottomless pit of consumption. Those destructive policies are about ready to backfire.

Given that trade disputes are hallmarks of deflationary times, do not look for much world trade progress with the US/EU (and the rest of the world), and do not look for world peace either.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Friday, 1 December 2006

An email from Bernanke

I was quite surprised to wake up this morning and find an Email from Ben Bernanke sitting in my inbox. It was in response to Bernanke's Box. I wanted to share it with everyone. It seems the Fed is about to initiate a new policy of speaking exactly what is on their minds. The following Email from chairman Bernanke is a kickoff for that campaign. It goes a long way towards speaking openly and honestly about the problems the US is facing and how the Fed intends to deal with them. From Ben Bernanke:
Speaking on behalf of all the Fed members we thought it was time to honestly address the situation the country is facing. This is part of our new policy to be as candid and honest as possible. Quite frankly we are frightened by the rapid falloff in housing permits, the rise in jobless claims, the rise in inventories, and the slowdown in consumer spending. It now appears the landing is not going to be soft and it is also doubtful the financial markets are fully prepared for it.

This slowdown in jobs and wages could not have come at a worse time because consumers are cash strapped already. We now forecast a downward spiral in construction jobs that will spill over into other segments of the economy resulting in additional losses in wages and jobs. Compounding the problem is the fact that many home buyers took the advice of former chairman Greenspan by taking out adjustable rate mortgages with teaser rates that are now about ready to be reset.

Unfortunately we can’t start cutting interest rates just yet because we are also frightened by the massive speculation in the financial markets with stock buybacks, mergers, leveraged buyouts, and trillions of dollars in derivatives floating around some of which we do not even know who the ultimate guarantor is. We are hoping but do not know that the ultimate guarantor of these derivatives is not Madame Merriweather's Mud Hut in Malaysia.

We do not want to fuel further speculation in the equity markets so we have decided to do nothing for as long as possible. Another reason for doing nothing right now is the rapid fall in the US dollar. This frightens us too. All in all, we have decided the best policy decision is to do nothing while hoping that things get better. Please bear in mind, however, that hope is unlikely to work.

Many financial analysts have suggested that corporate spending will take the place of consumer spending when the consumer is finally tapped out. That can’t and won’t happen. Businesses have no reason to expand headed into a consumer led recession. But instead of wisely holding cash for the rough times ahead, businesses have been spending it on stock buybacks at an all time record pace. As you might guess, this further frightens us.

That we are frightened by so many things is clearly visible in the price of gold. In fact, we really have been trying to figure out why the price of gold isn't much higher given how frightened we are. This is indeed our latest conundrum.

In the past we have avoided talking about such issues because of fear that we might simultaneously prick the bubble in houses and the bubble in the equity markets. Careful analysis, however, shows that the average consumer is benefiting from the rise in equity markets as much as he benefited from the $34 billion in bonuses that Wall Street just handed out (which is another way of saying not at all). Real wages have been falling for the average guy on the street and that is shown by 19 consecutive months of negative savings rates, which is of course still another thing we are frightened by.

Make no mistake about it, a recession is where we are headed. We admit our role in fueling these bubbles by holding interest rates too low too long. Rather that attempt to cover up past mistakes our new policy at the Fed is honesty, and honestly we really do not know what to do. When we do decide what to do, we will tip off the banks first (just as we always have) because our biggest fear of all is a collapse of the banking system.

Ben Bernanke
Of all the financial blogs and media outlets, I am pleased and honored to be the one to receive that Email from Ben Bernanke. I am sure he feels much better too after getting all that baggage off his chest. I look forward to receiving more Emails from the Fed and promise to share them as soon as they come across my desk.

Mish addendum:
Judging from email responses as well as replies to this post it seems that some people believed this. Others thought I would be dumb enough to be taken in by an email from someone pretending to be Bernanke.
It is neither. I wrote that piece. I thought it was obvious.
Even if it wasn't initially, by the time one got to "Madame Merriweather's Mud Hut in Malaysia" it should have been exposed as a spoof right then.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/