Thursday, 14 December 2006

Pennies, Nickels, and Dollars

The USA Today is reporting New rules outlaw melting pennies, nickels for profit.
12/14/2006 WASHINGTON — People who melt pennies or nickels to profit from the jump in metals prices could face jail time and pay thousands of dollars in fines, according to new rules out Thursday.

Soaring metals prices mean that the value of the metal in pennies and nickels exceeds the face value of the coins. Based on current metals prices, the value of the metal in a nickel is now 6.99 cents, while the penny's metal is worth 1.12 cents, according to the U.S. Mint.

That has piqued concern among government officials that people will melt the coins to sell the metal, leading to potential shortages of pennies and nickels.

"The nation needs its coinage for commerce," U.S. Mint director Ed Moy said in a statement. "We don't want to see our pennies and nickels melted down so a few individuals can take advantage of the American taxpayer. Replacing these coins would be an enormous cost to taxpayers."

Under the new rules, it is illegal to melt pennies and nickels. It is also illegal to export the coins for melting. Travelers may legally carry up to $5 in 1- and 5-cent coins out of the USA or ship $100 of the coins abroad "for legitimate coinage and numismatic purposes."

Violators could spend up to five years in prison and pay as much as $10,000 in fines. Plus, the government will confiscate any coins or metal used in melting schemes.

The rules are similar to those enacted in the 1960s and 1970s, when metals prices also rose, the Mint said. Ongoing regulations make it illegal to alter coins with an intent to commit fraud. Before today's new regulations, it was not illegal to melt coins.

Metals prices have skyrocketed worldwide in recent years in response to rising demand, particularly in rapidly growing China and India. Prices for zinc, which accounts for nearly all of the metal in the penny, have risen 134% this year, according to the London Metal Exchange. Even accounting for a recent decline, the price of copper is up 50% since the start of 2006. Nickels are produced from 75% copper and 25% nickel.

Although the Mint's new rules are immediately going into effect, the Mint will take comments from the public for a month.

The government has changed the composition of coins in response to rising metal prices. The penny, which was pure copper when it was introduced in 1793, was last changed in 1982.
Shortly after I posted the above on Silicon Investor, "Bucky" responded with:
Twice in our nation's history, gold coins were melted by the government.

The first melting occurred in 1834 when the gold content of U.S. coins was reduced and nearly all gold coins minted from the period 1795 to 1834 were melted because their intrinsic value exceeded their face value.

The second melting resulted from the great Gold Confiscation of 1933, when 90% to 95% of all U.S. gold coins held by individuals, banks, and the Treasury were recalled, thrown into huge melting pots, and poured into lifeless 100-ounce and 400-ounce gold bars. Franklin Roosevelt's gold confiscation order of 1933 saw the end of regular issue, legal tender U.S. gold coinage.
Part III of Honest Money Douglas V. Gnazzo discusses Coinage Acts From 1834 to 1900. Gnazzo's article is a good read on the history of various coin acts.

While on the subject of good reads I can point out The Monetary Elite Vs. Gold's Honest Discipline by Vincent R. Locascio, Demise of the Dollar by Addison Wiggin, The Dollar Crisis by Richard Duncan, and The Coming Collapse of the Dollar by James Turk and John Rubino.

Disclosure: If you order any of those books via the above supplied Amazon links I will make about 20 cents or so a copy. If that bothers anyone go straight to Amazon and do a search.

Answers.com has this to say about the Coinage Act of 1834.
By 1834, the gold in the half eagle was worth more than its face value. The Act of June 28, 1834 called for a reduction in the gold used. The weight of the coin was reduced to 8.36 grams, the diameter reduced to 22.5 mm, and the composition changed to .8992 gold and .1008 silver and copper.
In 1933, with the Executive Order 6102, President Roosevelt confiscated the nation's gold.
Executive Order 6102 was signed on April 5, 1933 by U.S. President Franklin D. Roosevelt to prohibit the "hoarding" of privately held gold coins and bullion in the United States, in an attempt to address the causes and effects of the Great Depression. This Order was given under the auspices of the Trading with the Enemy Act of 1917. The government required holders of significant quantities of gold to sell their gold at the prevailing price of $20.67 per ounce. Shortly after this forced sale, the price of gold from the treasury for international transactions was raised to $35 an ounce. The U.S. government thereby devalued the dollar to 69.3% of its former value.

The order specifically exempted "customary use in industry, profession or art"--a provision that covered artists, jewelers, dentists, and electricians among others. The order further permitted any person to own up to $100 in gold coins (equivalent to about $1,550 as of 2006).

Section 9 of the Order noted the punishment for failure to comply could include a fine of up to $10,000 or up to ten years in prison. Nevertheless, anecdotal accounts later related that many persons who possessed large amounts of gold simply ignored the order and hid their gold until the Order ceased to be in effect.

The government held the $35 per ounce price until August 15, 1971 when President Richard Nixon announced that the United States would no longer convert dollars to gold at a fixed value, thus abandoning the gold standard.

The limitation on private gold ownership in the U.S. was repealed by an act of Congress codified in Public Law 93-373 which went into effect December 31, 1974. P.L. 93-373 does not repeal the Gold Clause Resolution of 1933, which makes unlawful any contracts which specify payment in a fixed amount of money or a fixed amount of gold. That is, contracts are unenforceable if they use gold monetarily rather than as a commodity of trade.
Right now, a nickel is the closest thing to "Honest Money" we have. We are in the ironic situation where the value of the dollar is falling but the value of a nickel is rising. In what time frame will the current (and probably soon to be confiscated) nickel be worth more than a dollar?

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Wednesday, 13 December 2006

Auctioneer's Perspective

I spoke with Carl Carter, public relations manager for J.P. King following the auction of 40 condos at the Hamptons at Tampa Palms. 171 bidders from 15 states arrived and 40 units were sold. The planned sale was 40 absolute with another 60 units with a minimum bid. In addition there were another 160 the developer still owned and wanted to sell. What follows are excerpts from that interview.

Mish: Can you describe the auction.
Carter: The auction was in a format called "High Bidders Choice". The winning bidder had a choice of condos in pool of similar picks, typically by unit size. There were 1 BR, 2 BR and 3 BR pools being auctioned and the high bidder had his choice of units remaining in the pool.

Mish: How many units of each type were sold?
Carter: 20 2-bedrooms units, 15 3-bedrooms units, 5 1-bedrooms units.

Mish: What was the price range on the units sold?
Carter: $130,000 to $200,000. Total auction proceeds were $5,900,000.

Mish: Does that include auction fees?
Carter: Yes

Mish: What is the primary reason developers are resorting to auctions right now?
Carter: Condo sales by normal methods are practically dead and carrying costs are eroding the developers’ anticipated profits. Sellers are looking for a way to preserve profits or minimize their losses.

Mish: What happened?
Carter: In short, developers overbuilt. The market was distorted by speculators who were flipping units for a quick profit, and that made it look like demand was higher than it was. When the speculators disappeared, reality set in. That reality is coming as a huge shock to many developers and flippers alike: Units are just not going to be sold for prices anywhere close to what was being offered a year ago — no matter what marketing method is used. In many instances flippers are competing with developers to sell units. This is pushing prices down.

Mish: Is this a Florida thing only?
Carter: No, but Florida probably has the biggest oversupply. We are getting calls from developers every day, and several attended the Tampa auction just to see how it works. Some developers who last year had never even thought about an auction are seriously considering it. We have done condo auctions recently in Door County Wisconsin, Austin Texas, Florida, Alabama and Michigan.

Mish: What about supply and demand issues?
Carter: Demand is still very weak, and supply is still increasing.
From that perspective it just seems very unlikely that we are close to a market bottom.

Mish: Are you speaking nationally or just Florida.
Carter: I am speaking nationally, but when it comes to the oversupply, Florida’s the national situation on steroids.

Mish: Was the auction a success?
Carter: Definitely. We had 171 bidders from 15 states -- more than four bidders there for every unit we sold. That’s a good turnout, which tells us we got the current market value. The developer would have offered 60 more units if the prices had been running higher. This is simply a weak market. Still 40 units is a lot of units to move in a weekend and the developer is happy to have reduced his carrying costs significantly. From the point of view of the buyers, many are pleased with the bargains they received.

In a response to a question as to "developer interest" Carl Carter informed me that approximately a half dozen developers showed up to witness the auction. Obviously those developers wanted to see how things went.

Previous Listing Prices

Carter noted that previous asking prices on the condos were in the neighborhood of $181K for the one-bedroom units, $239-289K for the two-bedroom units and $309-340K for the 3-bedroom units. He believed those to be average prices.

A link from NewCondoReality showed prices and numbers of units to be as follows:
1 Bed - from $169K
2 Bed - from $220K
3 Bed - from $299K
As of Nov 4th - there are 70 units out of 300 units already under contract.
The above link may no longer be working although it was working on December 10th 2006.

Let's do the math

Giving everyone the benefit of the doubt, let's assume the original prices offered/paid were at the low end of the range as opposed to the average prices that Carter quoted.

20 2-bedrooms: $220,000 * 20 = $4.4 million
15 3-bedrooms: $299,000 * 15 = $4.485 million
05 1-bedrooms: $169,000 * 05 = $845,000
Total: $9,730,000

Auction total: $5,900,000
Subtracting a 10% auction fee the revised auction total was net $5,310,000 to the seller.

Quick math shows that any investor who bought at last year's prices is now on average 45% underwater, not counting maintenance fees, property taxes, insurance, interest payments, etc. Note too that the developer is still holding 60 additional units he was hoping to unload at the auction but failed to do so. The developer also has another 160 units waiting in the wings. Pent up supply?

The only units sold at the auction were units offered on an unconditional basis (no minimum bid). Inquiring minds might be wondering if this auction was really a "success".

Shell Shocked Comparison

Please consider Shell Shocked in Key West for comparison purposes.
Before the start of the auction, Slokumb had estimated 100 people would attend the event, but more than 200 showed up, with 58 registering to bid. Many chose to hang on to their bidding cards, and those who did bid were cautious. Absent were "bidding wars" with people vying back and forth for the highest bid while the price climbs higher and higher. Instead, most were content to let the property go to someone else for a lesser "bargain."

None of the asking prices were met. The closest bid fell $149,000 short, while bidding on the most expensive property, located at South St., fell more than $2.5 million shy of the almost $6 million asking price.
Not a single home sold at that Key West auction. By comparison, the 40 units sold at the Tampa auction has to be considered a rousing success. How else can one look at it? What was the difference? The difference is "unconditional" vs. "conditional". There was no minimum bid required on the 40 units J.P. King Tampa auction. There was a minimum bid on the Key West units.

Please note that I am not attempting to make a hero or a goat out of any auctioneer. Some of the terms and conditions of the auction are set by the sellers, not the auctioneer.

Pent Up Supply

Let's now return to a question I asked Carter.

Mish: What about supply and demand issues?
Carter: Demand is still very weak, and supply is still increasing.
From that perspective it just seems very unlikely that we are close to a market bottom.

Can anyone doubt Carter's reply? Indeed, 40 units sold but how many of those were to the next flipper hoping to unload at a higher price? Did this auction, no matter how successful reduce any supply? Even if it did (which is debatable), what about the condos still under construction in Miami, Tampa, Las Vegas, San Diego, Chicago, Boston, DC, Seattle and countless other places?

What have we learned from this?
  • Units will sell at an unconditional vs. a conditional auction
  • Conditional sellers are still too stubborn about price
  • Anyone "needing" a particular price likely can not get it
  • Condo prices have declined 40% in some locations and we still are not at the bottom
  • Carry costs are mounting
  • There is still pent up supply
Final Thoughts

Panic has still not set in, but it will eventually.
That event could be years off.

Note: This post originally appeared in WhiskeyAndGunpowder.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Inexplicable Numbers

MarketWatch is reporting Retail sales show surprising strength with 1% gain
Sales of durable goods, gasoline lead broad-based rise.

The report was "inexplicable," said Ian Shepherdson, chief U.S. economist for High Frequency Economics, in an email. He noted that government data show a cumulative 3.1% rise in auto sales over the past three months, while the automakers report sales volumes are down 1.2%.

Another economist said the consumer is resilient. "Do not ever EVER count out the U.S. consumer," wrote Robert Brusca, chief economist for FAO Economics, in an email.
The differences between the automaker's numbers and the government's numbers are so staggering there simply must be questions. So before anyone gets hyped up about retail sales that are indeed "inexplicable", let’s see what Christmas sales look like.

After initial hype over Black Friday fizzled out, data has not exactly been robust. "Do not ever EVER count out the U.S. consumer". Hmmm. If that opinion was not nearly unanimous before, I bet it is now.

There are similar worries in the UK right now.

U.K. Inflation Rate Increases to Highest Since 1997

Consumer prices rose 2.7 percent from a year earlier, the most since the index was introduced in January 1997, after a 2.4 percent gain in October. Economists had expected an increase to 2.6 percent. Consumer prices rose 0.3 percent in the month, led by gains in utility bills and transport costs.

I find it amazing that people think that a blunt instrument like interest rates can cure rising energy prices or utility bills.

CPI is a lagging indicator.
Wages are a lagging indicator.
Energy demand is relatively inelastic.

The Fed being enormously wrong at major turns is legendary.
Here are some numbers that are very explicable.

Late Mortgage Payments Rose Sharply in Late Summer.
Late mortgage payments shot up in the third quarter as higher interest rates squeezed budgets and made it harder for homeowners -- especially those with weaker credit records -- to keep up with their monthly obligations.

The Mortgage Bankers Association, in its quarterly snapshot of the mortgage market released Wednesday, reported that the percentage of mortgage payments that were 30 or more days past due for all loans tracked jumped to 4.67 percent in the July-to-September quarter.

Subprime borrowers had a delinquency rate of 12.56 percent in the third quarter, the highest in more than three years. The delinquency rate for these borrowers holding adjustable-rate mortgages was even higher -- at 13.22 percent in the third quarter, also the worst reading in more than three years.

For those financially strapped homeowners, the combination of slumping prices and rising interest rates can be painful. If the value of their homes drops, their loans could be worth more than their property. If their interest rates rise, their loans would become more expensive to pay off.
I think the question is not how fast they hike next year but when the downturn gets going how fast they start cutting.

What Year Is It?

That is the big question that seems to be on everyone's mind. I have heard all kinds of years (1994, 1984, 1999, 1987). Eric Janszen at ITULIP addresses the question in a very well written article Is it 1999 again? Yes and no.

On the other hand I am wondering if it is more like 1929 again pointing to Floors, Ceilings, Camels, Straw and Interview with Paul Kasriel. Just to be clear, Kasriel did not say it was 1929 again, he merely outlined the conditions in which deflation can happen in the U.S. and I believe those conditions are present now.

"What Year Is It?" will be the subject of a podcast discussion with Eric Janzen and myself, with Tom Jeffries moderating. Details are now in the works. I will post a link to it as soon as it is available. In the meantime, you may wish to read Eric's point of view in the above link.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Monday, 11 December 2006

November Jobs Report

On December 6th ADP said Private-sector jobs rise 158,000 in November.
Hiring pace is consistent with 'modestly below-trend' economic growth

Based on a string of huge misses by ADP, I predicted the official November numbers would badly miss as well, coming in at 88,000. Bart at NowAndFutures predicted 116,500. I offered to wager a box of Omaha Steaks (10-oz ribeyes) on the outcome. Fortunately for me Bart declined. ADP was indeed high but I would have lost the bet.

Here are the official employment numbers for November 2006.
Nonfarm payroll employment rose by 132,000 in November, and the unemployment rate was essentially unchanged at 4.5 percent, the Bureau of Labor Statistics of the U.S. Department of Labor reported December 8th. Job gains continued in several service-providing industries, including professional and business services, food services, and health care. Employment declined in construction and manufacturing.

Industry Payroll Employment (Establishment Survey Data)
Total nonfarm payroll employment rose by 132,000 in November to 136.0 million. This followed increases of 203,000 in September and 79,000 in October (as revised). Thus far this year, payroll employment has grown by an average of 149,000 per month. In November, employment rose in several service-providing industries and in mining; employment declined in construction and continued to trend downward in manufacturing.

Professional and business services employment increased by 43,000 in November and has risen by 426,000 over the year. Job growth has occurred in a number of industries, including architectural and engineering services, management consulting, and computer systems design.

Employment in temporary help services was flat over the month and has changed little since January.

Health care employment rose by 28,000 in November. Hospitals and doctors’ offices each added 6,000 jobs. Over the year, health care employment has increased by 309,000.

In leisure and hospitality, employment growth continued in food services and drinking places. This industry added 34,000 jobs in November, raising total job gains over the last 12 months to 295,000.

Employment in wholesale trade continued to trend up in November. Employment in this industry has risen by 288,000 since its most recent low in August 2003. Within retail trade, employment grew over the month in clothing and accessory stores; health and personal care stores; sporting goods, hobby, book, and
music stores; and nonstore retailers (which include catalog and internet retailers). General merchandise stores continued to lose jobs (-12,000 after seasonal adjustment); since August 2005, employment in this industry has decreased by 107,000.

In the goods-producing sector, mining employment grew by 4,000 in November with gains in support activities for oil and gas. Employment in mining has grown by 136,000 since its most recent low in April 2003.

Construction employment declined by 29,000 in November, following a loss of similar size in October. The November decline was spread across all component industries. Since peaking in February of this year, employment in residential specialty trades was down by 109,000.

Employment in nonresidential specialty trades edged down in November, after trending up during the first 10 months of the year.

Manufacturing employment continued to trend down (-15,000) in November. Motor vehicles and parts lost 7,000 jobs. Employment continued to fall in two construction-related industries: wood products (-6,000) and furniture and related products (-5,000). Computer and electronic products manufacturing added 5,000 jobs over the month.
The report shows that health care remains strong although it is very difficult to say what percentage of those jobs are in a high paying category. Doctors and nurses would generally be high paying positions but employment in nursing homes and social services may not be. Leisure and hospitality jobs were also strong but it is safe to assume that most of those are not high paying jobs. Professional and business services expanded very nicely and those indeed may be better than average jobs but manufacturing and construction jobs contracted and those are also better than average paying jobs.

Given that it takes about 150,000 jobs just to break even with immigration and population increases this was not really a good showing but arguably not a disaster.

Birth Death Assumptions


Following are the latest business birth/death assumptions.
Click on chart for a much easier to read view.



The above chart shows 29,000 new jobs were assumed by the government to have been created in November. Click on the above link for an explanation of how business births and deaths figure in to jobs numbers.

Construction Jobs

One of the more interesting things in the report was that "Employment in nonresidential specialty trades edged down in November, after trending up during the first 10 months of the year."

Following is a chart of construction jobs (both residential and non-residential) for November 2006. Click on chart for an easier to read view.



Before discussing construction please note the red vertical oval. It shows that 40,000 goods producing jobs were lost. It also shows that of the 132,000 jobs that were created, 13.6% (18,000) jobs were government jobs. The last thing we need is more unproductive government jobs. Taking those two numbers into consideration, this was a fairly weak set of jobs numbers and supportive of the idea we are in an economic slowdown. The massively inverted yield curve also suggests that not only is a slowdown coming, but an out and out recession is coming.

It is simply illogical to assume that businesses would even want to keep expanding in the face of a consumer led recession. Even if they did, it is important to remember that consumer spending is 70-75% of the economy (and possibly higher in THIS economy). With that as a backdrop it is also illogical to expect that corporate spending can possibly pick up the slack even IF businesses were to keep expanding in the face of a consumer slowdown.

Nonresidential building has now shown a 4 month steady decline in jobs even as non-residential trade jobs are holding up over the same 4 month period. This divergence between trade jobs and building jobs is unlikely to hold. With an October to November decline in non-construction trade jobs it is possible that this divergence is now being resolved but we must wait and see if the data point on trade jobs is an outlier.

What we can see for sure is that huge cracks are starting to appear in the myth that "corporate expansion is likely to pick up where consumer spending left off". In the dotcom bust of 2000 strength in consumer spending did pick up when corporate spending was slashed, but it is simply illogical to expect the opposite to be possible.

When corporate expansion does crack it will be part of a "Second Wave Down" in construction and jobs and will have a far greater economic impact than the decline so far in residential construction.

Bernanke's Box

In Bernanke's Box I asked
Can someone please tell me what we need more of?

Home Depots?
Lowes?
Pizza Huts?
Restaurants of any kind?
Strip Malls?
Furniture Stores?
Nail Salons?
Wal-Marts?
Office Supply Stores?
Grocery Stores?
Appliance Stores?
Auto Dealers?
Banks?
What? What? What?

Nothing is what. There is a veritable glut of every kind of store imaginable. The construction of all those places provided jobs. The staffing of all those stores provided jobs.
The bottom line is there is simply no need for businesses to expand into a consumer slowdown. It would not make economic sense to do so and that is arguably why corporate insiders are bailing at a record pace (an 18 year high), even as stock buybacks continue unabated.

Commercial construction always lags residential construction simply because Walmart's, Pizza Huts, Home Depot's, Nail Salons, etc, finish their buildout after residential areas are built. This is only logical, but the mantra being sung by Wall Street pundits is that somehow corporate spending will save the day.

Mergers and Cutbacks

Watch what insiders and corporations are doing not what they are saying. What corporations are doing is wasting money at an amazing pace on stock buybacks, while cutting back on existing expansion plans.

Yes we are seeing mergers and proposed mergers especially in the banking industry as noted by the headline Bank of America may bid for U.K. bank Barclays.
Biggest financial-services deal ever would create top global bank
Bank of America could be about to make a bid for U.K. retail and investment-banking group Barclays in a deal that would create the world's biggest bank, according to analysts at Merrill Lynch.

"Bank of America has previously indicated that the next phase of its expansion is to become a leading global commercial and investment bank. In order to achieve that goal, we believe Bank of America is very interested in acquiring Barclays," the broker said in a note to clients.
The important point to remember about these mergers and consolidations is that they cost jobs. There have been no estimates so far but 10,000 would not surprise me at all. We are seeing all kinds of consolidations right now in financial services and sub-prime mortgage businesses, with some of them not consolidations but outright job destructions due to bankruptcy.

In Bernanke's Box I also noted Home Depot Sales Falloff Kills Staff Increase Plan.
November 30, 2006 -- Home Depot abruptly shelved a much-touted plan to improve customer service by hiring more store-level employees - just a month after rolling it out.

The about-face appears to be the result of a sales slowdown that is far more severe than the company anticipated, sources said. Rather than hiring additional employees, all stores - even those $40-million-plus high-volume locations - were told to cut staff hours by 200 per week because of falling sales.

The reason? Sales were falling short of internal projections, the result of a housing market that had stopped booming.
For Home Depot to go from hiring plans to firing plans in a single month, things must have gone to hell in a handbasket in a hurry. There is no other rational explanation.

In summation there is not a shred of evidence that suggests corporate spending is about to pick up. There is also not a shred of evidence that suggests that even if it did, it could possibly "take over where consumer spending left off". The idea is not only illogical it is unsupported by what is actually happening.

What is happening however, is subprime lenders are blowing up throwing more people out of work, furniture stores are blowing up throwing more people out of work, proposed financial mega-mergers (if they happen) will throw more people out of work, Walmart has recently cut back on expansion plans, Home Depot did an immediate reversal of expansion plans, and now we see a 4 month straight decline in nonresidential building.

The Second Wave Down is coming, and this one will have far more serious consequences.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Interview with Paul Kasriel

There has been a raging debate on Silicon Investor, the Motley Fool, Minyanville, and nearly everywhere else too about whether or not it is possible for a Japanese style deflation to happen in the United States. Almost everyone denies the possibility outright.

Because most people writing about or discussing this issue do not have a background in economics (myself included), I asked Paul Kasriel Sr. V.P. and Director of Economic Research at The Northern Trust Company for his thoughts on deflation in Japan vs. deflation in the US. We also had a brief follow up phone conversation after I received his email response. What follows is an email from Kasriel as well as a synopsis of our phone interview. These conversations took place on December 7th and 8th 2006 with one followup question over the weekend.

No, this is NOT a spoof as was An email from Bernanke.
This is the real deal.

Email from Paul Kasriel
Japan experienced a deflation in recent years because the bursting of its asset-price bubble in the early 1990s created huge losses in its banking system. The Japanese banks had financed the asset-price bubble. When it burst, the debtors could not keep current on their loans to the banks and therefore were forced to turn back the collateral to the banks. The market value of the collateral, of course, was less than the amount of the loans outstanding, thereby inflicting huge losses of capital to the Japanese banks. With the decline in bank capital, the Japanese banks could not extend new credit to the private sector even though the Bank of Japan was offering credit to the banks at very low nominal rates of interest.

Banks are an important transmission mechanism between the central bank and the private economy. If the banks are unable or unwilling to extend the cheap credit being offered to them by the central bank, then the economy grows very slowly, if at all. This happened in the U.S. during the early 1930s.

U.S. banks currently hold record amounts of mortgage-related assets on their books. If the housing market were to go into a deep recession resulting in massive mortgage defaults, the U.S. banking system could sustain huge losses similar to what the Japanese banks experienced in the 1990s. If this were to occur, the Fed could cut interest rates to zero but it would have little positive effect on economic activity or inflation.

Short of the Fed depositing newly-created money directly into private sector accounts, I suspect that a deflation would occur under these circumstances. Again, crippled banking systems tend to bring on deflations. And crippled banking systems seem to result from the bursting of asset bubbles because of the sharp decline in the value of the collateral backing bank loans.

Hope this helps,
Paul

Paul L. Kasriel
Sr. V.P. and Director of Economic Research
The Northern Trust Company
50 South LaSalle Street
Chicago, IL 60603
Followup Interview

I was fortunate to catch Paul for a brief phone interview after I received that email. Here it is.

Mish: Would you say that consumer debt in the US as opposed to the lack of consumer debt in Japan increases the deflationary pressures on the US economy?
Kasriel: Yes, absolutely. The latest figures that I have show that banks' exposure to the mortgage market is at 62% of their total earnings assets, an all time high. If a prolonged housing bust ensues, banks could be in big trouble.

Mish: What if Bernanke cuts interest rates to 1 percent?
Kasriel: In a sustained housing bust that causes banks to take a big hit to their capital it simply will not matter. This is essentially what happened recently in Japan and also in the US during the great depression.

Mish: Can you elaborate?
Kasriel: Most people are not aware of actions the Fed took during the great depression. Bernanke claims that the Fed did not act strong enough during the great depression. This is simply not true. The Fed slashed interest rates and injected huge sums of base money but it did no good. More recently, Japan did the same thing. It also did no good. If default rates get high enough, banks will simply be unwilling to lend which will severely limit money and credit creation.

Mish: Do you have any comments regarding Greenspan?
Kasriel: Greenspan is a fascinating study. Some day I hope to write a book about him. Right now I willing to say he is the luckiest Fed chairman in history.

Mish: Greenspan is the luckiest Fed chair in history? How so?
Kasriel: He was fortunate in two very big ways. First off, he was fortunate to preside over the economy at a time when productivity was soaring and the global supply of goods was expanding rapidly because China had entered the world trading arena. In that environment the Fed could create large amounts of money and credit without causing inflation other than in asset prices.

Mish: Does that mean you believe that inflation is a monetary phenomenon related to increases in money supply and credit as opposed to rising prices?
Kasriel: Yes, and that is exactly why Greenspan was so lucky. Inflation was masked by the factors we just mentioned.

Mish: I am very glad you said the word "masked". I have used that word for quite some time but most just do not get it. What is the second way Greenspan was fortunate?
Kasriel: When the Fed slashed interest rates to 1%, the U.S. banking system was capitalized well enough to be willing and able to relend the cheap credit it was being offered by the Fed. This stimulated housing. Housing provided jobs. With jobs and with rising real estate prices people felt confident to borrow and banks felt comfortable to lend.

Mish: How does inflation start and end?
Kasriel: Inflation starts with expansion of money and credit.
Inflation ends when the central bank is no longer able or willing to extend credit and/or when consumers and businesses are no longer willing to borrow because further expansion and /or speculation no longer makes any economic sense.

Mish: So when does it all end?
Kasriel: That is extremely difficult to project. If the current housing recession were to turn into a housing depression, leading to massive mortgage defaults, it could end. Alternatively, if there were a run on the dollar in the foreign exchange market, price inflation could spike up and the Fed would have no choice but to raise interest rates aggressively. Given the record leverage in the U.S. economy, the rise in interest rates would prompt large scale bankruptcies. These are the two "checkmate" scenarios that come to mind.

Mish: Thanks Paul. When you do your book on "The Luckiest Fed Chairman in History" please send me a copy. I am sure it will be a best seller.
Kasriel: Will do.

Well I hope that puts to bed two ideas
  • That it is impossible or nearly impossible for the US to suffer Japanese style deflation
  • That slashing interest rates to 1% will matter one iota if it happens.
It should also put to bed (but probably won't) the distinction between inflation (a monetary event) and prices.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Saturday, 9 December 2006

Where is the US$ Headed?

The following chart shows that the US dollar is once again approaching long term support. And once again bearish sentiment against the US dollar is rising. Here is a chart of the US$ index as of December 6th 2006.



Click on the chart for a much enhanced image.

The Economist - Dec 2nd 2006

A Recent cover of the Economist highlights the renewed bearish sentiment. Magazine covers in general and Economist covers in particular have a nasty habit of marking major turning points.

Remember that it was "The Incredible Shrinking Dollar" cover of Newsweek that marked the bottom of the US dollar in 2005 to within a week or so.

We also see big specs plowing heavily into both the British pound and the Euro, and the unwinding of those trades (which I think will happen) would be supportive of the dollar.

On the other hand, we still see a carry trade in the Yen and Swiss Frank which has negative implication for both the US$ and US equities if and when that trade unwinds.

Dollar Weakness vs. Interest Rates

In an extremely misleading report I see the following headline:
Dollar weakness poses growth risk.
Excessive weakening of the U.S. dollar could lead to interest rate hikes in the United States, Europe and Japan and hurt global economic growth, OECD Secretary General Angel Gurria said on Monday.

The imbalance between a huge current account deficit in the United States and surpluses in Asian countries and oil exporting states is prompting investors to move out of the dollar, Gurria said.

"What is happening now is a manifestation of this process," Gurria told reporters in Madrid after meeting Spain's Foreign Minister in Madrid.

"If the dollar falls in a disorderly or excessive fashion, it will trigger rate hikes in the United States and this could be reflected by rate hikes in Europe and/or Japan, and growth could slow," he added.

Gurria said the United States was not doing enough to lower its current account deficit, even though strong U.S. growth had allowed the country to cut its fiscal deficit. "You've got to ask the question whether anyone is worried or not, if the issue is being resolved," said Gurria. "The current account deficit continues."
It is NOT a weakness in the US dollar that may cause interest rates to go up, it is excessive expansion of money and credit within the US that is causing the US dollar to drop. It is imperative for people to put the horse before the cart but as simple as that may seem nearly everyone puts the cart before the horse.

If and when the US stops blowing trillions it does not have in Iraq and other places (god knows when), and if and when US consumers toss in the towel and stop buying more junk than they need (likely right now), the situation will change.

Even still, the biggest factors on whether or not a currency rises or falls are:
  1. Relative expansion of money and credit vs. other countries
  2. Interest rates differentials vs. other countries
Notice that the trade deficit is not on that short list. And as difficult as this may seem, credit is expanding as fast if not faster in the EU than in the US. Furthermore, interest rates are still sitting at .25% in Japan vs. 5.25% in the US. This is hugely supportive of the US dollar (at least until the carry trade blows up).

Once again let's turn to John Succo one of my favorite professors on Minyanville to see if we can shed some additional light on this situation. On December 5th addressing a reader question on dollar weakness vs. deflation professor Succo wrote:
I am wrestling with “can central banks induce a round of hyper-inflation or has it already passed?” My conclusion, however, is the same: every hyper-inflationary period (rising nominal asset prices) eventually is followed by a deflationary bust (the last bottle of booze). We are all trying to figure out where we are. But make no mistake: the weight of all that debt created by central banks will at some point be too much to bear.

All this credit has created a series of “bubbles” in asset prices. The Fed is disingenuous when they say they don’t try to prevent them, but manage the aftermath. They actually consciously create them as a means to continue speculation and debt growth. The last was supposedly the real estate bubble because it is the largest asset market. But it turns out that the last one might not need one large asset class to “get liquidity into consumers’ pockets.” It may not even be based on generating consumption.

Perhaps the last bubble involves all asset classes and is being accomplished through monetization. The Fed creates credit and then borrowers take that credit and buy Asian goods. They need an asset class, like real estate, as collateral for that borrowing. Then they spend any excess liquidity driven by higher asset prices and spend it.

Those created dollars are being sterilized by foreign central banks accomplished by their creating more credit and then buying U.S. securities. Perhaps we are now seeing that last bubble: foreign central banks buying all kinds of private assets like corporate bonds, mortgages, and yes even stocks with that credit.

So the last bubble morphs from a consumption bubble to a speculation bubble.

This does not seem to bother some as it does me. What happens when governments buy private assets and crowds out private investment? You get excessive risk taking of course; everyone goes into debt even more.

I paraphrase Mr. Steve Galbraith when he said “investors have reacted rationally to free money (negative real interest rates). They borrow it. Debt is good when rates are negative.” I still wrestle with this comment. It sounds right, but in the end I do not think it is. It sounds right when you look only at return. Of course it is rational to take money at a negative interest rate and lend it back out at a positive one. I have described the yen carry trade as this, but there are ever increasing risks associated with it. In order to get that free money there is currency risk: long dollars and short yen. There is no free lunch. So when investors take that “free money” they risk default when rates return to normal. So when risk is factored in, the risk of losing all, taking free money may not be so rational.

And so when governments buy risky assets they in a way force private investors to take risks that are not rational. LBOs are done that make little economic sense and redistribute wealth by destroying it in the future. Hedge funds are given so much liquidity they speculate.

The bottom line is as credit expands, nominal asset prices rise. But as credit expands because it is created and not generated by normal economic activity, the debt reaches a point where it can no longer be supported. Central banks are just finding more creative and dangerous ways to cajole markets into taking more credit.

I do not know when this point will be reached (deflation). There are signs now of excessive speculation, but I saw that a while ago too. But it is cumulative so we know from deduction that we are getting closer and closer. When deflation does kick in the dollar will rally, yes. But that may be from much lower levels.

The only thing we can be sure of is the degree to which this situation has risen. The imbalances are immense.

Succo
Hmmm. Are the imbalances immense or are they insane?

In regards to the US dollar, one must remember that all fiat currencies are eventually doomed. That of course does not preclude a massive deflationary collapse first. In the meantime one needs to remember that interest rate differentials and credit expansion matter most and the odds of additional rate hikes by both the UK and Europe may be overstated.

The Herald Times is reporting ECB raises its key interest rate to 3.5 percent.
FRANKFURT, Germany: The European Central Bank raised its key interest rate by a quarter of a percentage point to 3.5 percent on Thursday, despite strength in the euro that some analysts have feared could stunt economic growth and hurt exports.

But if some are worried, ECB President Jean-Claude Trichet was not.

Trichet, who oversees economic policy for the region that accounts for nearly 15 percent of the global economy, promised to keep a close eye on inflation but resisted any temptation to try to talk the euro down.

While calling "disorderly" currency movements undesirable, he did not say how the euro's level near 20-month highs against the dollar might affect monetary policy and said people should let the markets judge the euro's exchange levels.

The Bank of England, meanwhile, held its key interest rate steady at 5 percent on Thursday, a decision that was widely expected after increases in August and November took rates to the current five-year high.

Speaking after the ECB announced its sixth quarter-point increase in 12 months, Trichet said the bank will monitor inflation "very closely" — a signal that another increase next month was unlikely, but leaving the way open for an increase in February or March.
The reason another rate hike in the EU is unlikely is that Trichet did not use the word "vigilant" which has been his signal that he intends to tighten further. Note too that the UK passed on the chance to hike yet again. The key question here is "what is the market expecting?"

If the expectation is for more hikes in Europe and the UK and for cuts to occur in the US, and that expectation does not happen, look for the US$ to rally. It may rally anyway based on current sentiment. To put my neck on the line I suspect the US$ will hold the 80 level (or perhaps do a headfake below then reverse). Longer term, the US$ is indeed toast but that can be quite a ways off from here.

In regards to a deflationary collapse of the stock market, once again the question here is timing, and of course timing is nearly everything. That said, the amazing thing to me is that most do not even see the risks, let alone are they concerned about the timing of the upcoming debacle.

Yes, I have been raising the caution flag for some time and the taunts are now getting shrill. "When Mish When When When When? How long have you been calling for this now? Two years? When is it coming Mish When?" I received a post almost exactly like that on Silicon Investor last week.

Shrill taunts out of the blue often accompany major market tops or bottoms. Let's see if history repeats. In the meantime one has to decide whether or not to play the "greater fool" game or not. Many that played the game with Florida condos are now facing bankruptcy. Others still haven't the faintest clue as to what the risks even are.

It's one thing to knowingly play the "greater fool" game, it is of course another matter to be playing the game and not even know it.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Thursday, 7 December 2006

Demise Comes Quickly

MarketWatch is reporting Subprime lender Ownit Mortgage shuts down.
Ownit Mortgage Solutions, a California company that described itself as one of the top 15 lenders to homeowners with weak or no credit histories, has shut down, citing "the current unfavorable conditions of the mortgage industry."
Merrill Lynch & Co. (MER) and private equity firm CIVC Partners hold stakes in Ownit, which built its book of new loans to $8.3 billion in 2005 from $1.1 billion in 2003, in part by introducing products like 45-year mortgages, according to its Web site. Ownit's demise comes as subprime mortgage lenders are being squeezed by higher funding costs, weakening loan demand and rising delinquencies.

"Effective Dec. 5, Ownit closed its doors, and we are no longer able to fund or process your loans," the company said on a recorded telephone message. "We apologize for any inconvenience."

Ownit ran out of cash needed to meet its obligations to repurchase loans from investment banks and others who bought them in the secondary market, people in the industry said. The banks, which convert the loan payments into mortgage-backed securities for sale to investors, can force the original lenders to repurchase loans if the mortgage borrowers default.
.....
.....

The end came quickly for Ownit.

"We were all working yesterday, assuming we were fine," Dave Hanthorn, a New Jersey-based employee who sells the firm's loans to mortgage brokers, said Wednesday evening. "At 5:15 last night we got the call that we were ceasing operations." He said the company gave no explanation for its funding problems.
The LA Times is reporting Ownit a victim of sub-prime shakeout.
One employee, among 300 to lose their jobs in California, said he learned of the company's demise Tuesday while manning the Ownit booth at a mortgage conference in Las Vegas.

"Suddenly, people were all rushing over and practically throwing their BlackBerries at me," said Kevin Panet, a marketing and training manager. "The messages they were getting from people at the company said things like, 'Thanks for the memories'."

In its statement, Ownit blamed Merrill Lynch & Co. for the closure, saying the company was one of its primary lenders and had cut off its funding Tuesday. Merrill Lynch holds about 20% of Ownit. Merrill Lynch spokesman Bill Halldin said Ownit's statement was misleading, but he declined to comment further.

Two people with knowledge of the funding arrangement said JPMorgan Chase & Co. cut off Ownit's funding Monday, leaving the lender unable to issue loans. JPMorgan couldn't be reached for comment.

According to trade publication Origination News, Ownit ranked 11th among sub-prime wholesale lenders in the first half of 2006 with $5.5 billion in loans.

Panet said he didn't know how much pay would be coming to employees. "I've been told not to expect anything as far as severance goes," he said. "It's not sure we will be getting a last paycheck on the 15th."

Ownit executives wouldn't discuss the shutdown beyond the company's brief statement. It was also unclear what would happen to loans that were in process. On Wednesday, the company's website was taken down.
This should be a huge wake up call to individuals playing the "Greater Fool" game and even more so to hedge funds leveraged up 15 times in derivative plays thinking there will be time for an orderly exit. Well there won't. One day out of the blue we are going to go from record low volatilities to lock limit down three days in a row. The carnage is going to stun even bears like myself.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/