Thursday, 21 December 2006

Changing Priorities

The Washington Post is reporting Harrah's Debt Load Will Nearly Double
LAS VEGAS -- Casino giant Harrah's Entertainment Inc.'s debt load will nearly double and its priority will shift to paying it down instead of reinvesting in growth after one of the biggest leveraged buyouts ever, according to SEC documents filed Wednesday.

Harrah's Chief Executive Gary Loveman told key employees that the company's debt would rise to $21 billion, or eight times operating profit, from the current multiple of 4.7, after being bought by Apollo Management Group and Texas Pacific Group, according to a presentation he made Tuesday after the deal was announced. Other Securities and Exchange Commission filings show Harrah's current debt is $10.7 billion.

Equity in the company will shrink from more than $14 billion to $7 billion, SEC documents show. One slide from Loveman's presentation was titled: "With high initial debt levels, capital allocation priorities will likely change."

Harrah's historical priorities show two check marks beside "reinvest for growth" and "mergers and acquisitions," but only one beside "share repurchases" and "reduce debt." Under the new structure, only one check mark goes toward reinvestment and acquisitions, while two appear beside reducing debt.
...
The transaction for Harrah's, excluding debt, ranks as the seventh-largest leveraged buyout ever, according to Thomson Financial. The largest was RJR Nabisco Inc.'s $25 billion acquisition by Kohlberg Kravis Roberts & Co. in 1998.
Nearly lost in the excitement of this enormous deal is number of check marks and where they are. Everyone has been focused on rising share prices of these deals and the credit expansion that is taking to get them done, while ignoring the other side of the equation: massive debt, over leverage, and diminishing prospects of future expansion.

Once the deals are all signed sealed and delivered, someone is going to have to figure out how to pay back that debt. In other words: "credit contraction".

On Minyanville today Professor Bennet Sedacca citing Ned Davis research reported: Credit exposure relative to risk based capital by the top 5 banks rose to a record 433.5%. Am I the only one that senses a future changing priority of banks away from ever increasing credit exposure?

What about consumers? You can already see a shift away from buying condos, second homes, furniture, appliances, remodeling, etc. Consumers are cutting back. Willingness to take on more debt and ability to take on more debt have changed. Those problems are highlighted in decreasing profits at Circuit City, cutbacks at Home Depot, and UPS. Where is the need to expand?

Bankruptcies and foreclosures are massively rising, in some states as much as 300%. That is forced credit contraction. And as priorities of consumers and businesses shift away from expansion and risk towards risk avoidance and debt paybacks, we are of course talking about a shift from inflation to deflation. We are right there right on the cusp and "changing priorities" will seal the fate.

Note: Changing priorities will be one of the subject of tonight's podcast on Howe Street. Ironically enough, it was changing priorities that caused this delay from our normal Wednesday schedule. Tune in and find out.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Monetary Shock Therapy

Today's post is on Thailand and Scotland. The former is on virtually everyone's radar while the latter is on almost no one's. Let's take a look at Scotland first.

The Financial Times is reporting Scotland weighs chance to go it alone.
Just under three centuries ago – in 1707 – the parliaments of England and Scotland united after centuries of conflict, signing a treaty called the Act of Union. Today, both nations – along with Wales and Northern Ireland – comprise the UK.

Next May the Scottish National party (SNP), a movement committed to taking Scotland out of the UK, could become the largest party in the Edinburgh parliament. If that happens – and latest opinion polls suggest it is a real possibility – then the struggle for Scottish independence could start to dominate the UK political landscape in a manner few could have imagined.

In recent weeks, Mr Blair has expressed mounting concern about the sudden surge in support for the SNP, saying victory for that party could “plunge us into constitutional nightmare”. He told a Labour audience on November 26 that it should not take the SNP’s ambition for independence lightly. “I hear you scoff: ‘They say it, but they’re not serious. They wouldn’t do it.’ But they are deadly serious and they would do it.”

Alex Salmond, the SNP’s combative leader, says that if his party forms a government, it would within 100 days publish proposals for a referendum on independence. The prospect of such a referendum has resonance with Scots. An ICM poll for the Sunday Telegraph last month found that 52 per cent of Scots favoured the idea of independence against 32 per cent against.

What is pushing the SNP forward? Two forces are key. First, there is the natural pendulum of politics. Labour is deflated after nearly a decade in power both in London and Edinburgh.

Another factor is the rise in world oil prices. The SNP has always argued that 90 per cent of North Sea oil in the UK sector belongs to Scotland. High energy prices have therefore given a mark of respectability to the party’s economic plans, although these are contested by Labour. If the SNP proved victorious next year, oil would be a main point of friction between London and Edinburgh. Mr Salmond argues that, within 10 years and using only half Scotland’s oil income, the country could have a £90bn ($177bn, €134bn) trust fund. “The choice for Scotland is clear,” he says. “Those revenues either flow south to London or they can be invested for the people of Scotland.”

Another area of potential discord concerns Trident, the nuclear weapons system based on submarines that operate from the Firth of Clyde west of Glasgow, Scotland’s second city. The SNP says an independent Scotland would be non-nuclear. It therefore pledges that Trident – which the Blair government has just decided to renew – would have to move south of the border.

Mr Blair understands this demand by the Scots for economic betterment. One of his central arguments against the SNP is that the Union is economically good for the Scottish economy. Though the SNP disputes the calculation, official figures for, the latest available, show Scots receive £11bn more in total government expenditure than they give back in revenue.

This argument creates a problem on another front, however. While the £11bn of net receipts may persuade some Scots to remain part of the Union, this cash benefit is increasingly resented in England. Indeed, one of the new difficulties facing the UK is growing English irritation about the freedom devolution offers Scotland. This means the Scots, unlike the English, promise free care for the elderly and have rejected university tuition fees.
Hmmm. A fued over oil and WMDs, now where have we seen that before? It is ironic that Blair telling Scotland how good the Scottish have it led to resentment from some of the British who respond "just let them go". Is anyone happy?

Thailand

In Thailand we have a different situation known as EDAA (Every Day Another Adventure).
Let's have a recap.

Mon Dec 18
Annoyed over a currency up 16% this year vs. the U.S. dollar, the Thailand central bank said that investors based abroad would be able to invest just 70 percent of funds transferred to Thailand, and recoup all of their funds only if they kept the money in the country for more than a year. The rule said any withdrawals within a year would be penalized 10 percent of the original investment. The stock market plunged 15% in response.
Tue Dec 19
Thailand will not reconsider measure to halt baht rise
The Thai government will not reconsider draconian measures introduced to halt the baht's rise, the finance minister said, despite stocks plummetting to record losses on the news.

"The government will not reconsider the policy; let the market take (its) course and it will adjust itself," Pridiyathorn Devakula told Agence France-Presse, adding that the move would only affect brokers and short-term currency speculators.

"The Bank of Thailand had no choice since we found that there was speculation in short-term debt instruments," he said.

In the face of the unprecedented losses, dealers and the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) had asked the central bank to reconsider the new currency control measures announced yesterday.

The Stock Exchange of Thailand composite index plummeted 108.41 points, the biggest one day drop in the 31-year history of the bourse, shedding 14.84 pct to close at 622.14 after being down nearly 20 pct at one stage.
Tue Dec 19
Thailand Abandons Limits on Foreign Stock Investments
Thailand scrapped currency controls on international stock investors one day after their imposition by the central bank prompted the biggest stock market plunge in 16 years.

Thailand's government exempted stocks from the central bank rule that international investors must pay a 10 percent penalty unless they keep funds in the country for a year. The policy reversal illustrates Thailand's dependence on foreign investment and the degree to which investors resent restrictions on their investment decisions.

"The stock market has fallen too much today," Pridiyathorn told reporters at a press conference. "This is the side effect of the central bank's measure, but we have fixed it already."

The currency controls triggered declines in other emerging stock markets by highlighting the risks of investing in developing economies.

Thailand in 1997 untied the baht from a U.S. dollar peg, triggering currency collapses in South Korea and Indonesia and leaving much of Asia in a financial crisis that required an international bailout.
Wed Dec 20
Thailand Discovers Fury of Investors Scorned
In a span of 24 hours, the Bank of Thailand first outraged investors by slapping a Chilean-type tax on capital inflows and then tried to placate them by taking equity investments outside the purview of the levy.

The capital lockup rules revived memories of what Malaysia had done in 1998, although curbing the profit potential of new money entering Thailand is nowhere near as draconian as Mahathir Mohamad's trapping of existing foreign investment by fiat.

Nevertheless, the Bank of Thailand's actions have raised the specter of more widespread use of monetary shock therapy in Asia. The Thai authorities' flip-flop shows the level of desperation with a world awash with money.

Monetary-Policy Challenge

Consider the overwhelming challenge for the Bank of Thailand in controlling the growth of domestic money supply in the face of ever-increasing sums of incoming capital.

From May to October this year, the expansion in the monetary base -- currency in circulation and bank reserves -- remained restricted at about half a percent even as net foreign assets in the banking system grew 6.5 percent.

Central bank Governor Tarisa Watanagase couldn't possibly have kept her foot on the money brakes forever. One option was to let the currency keep rising. That would have eventually shut down exports, the only economic engine that's still firing. Or, the authorities could let the monetary base expand to a point where they lost control over inflation.

The Bank of Thailand's move, thus, is a desperate attempt to prevent its monetary policy from being compromised by capital inflows that had, until last week, caused an intolerable 16 percent surge in the baht, making it this year's best-performing Asian currency.
Wed Dec 20
Thai market rebounds 11%
Shares on the battered Bangkok market staged a recovery this morning after Tuesday's 15% plunge, but dealers said confidence remains fragile amid fears of a re-run of the Asian financial crisis a decade ago.

By the close local time, the Thai SET Index had jumped 11% to 691, its biggest gain in almost eight years. The market crashed by 15% on Tuesday as the Bank of Thailand and the finance ministry imposed currency controls in an attempt to curb the strength of the Thai baht.
Wed Dec 20
Tarisa Watanagase, governor of the Thai central bank, Defends actions.
Speaking as the Thai stock market rebounded from its record-setting plunge of 15 percent on Tuesday, Ms. Tarisa defended event that seemed to touch off the plunge, an attempt by the government to cut off short-term foreign investment in the country, sometimes called hot money.

Ms. Tarisa dismissed criticism that the move had tarnished Thailand’s reputation among international investors. Rather, she said Thailand was a victim of the huge imbalances in trade and savings that send trillions of dollars sloshing in and out of developing economies.

“This is not a problem unique to Thailand,” Ms. Tarisa said during an interview. “I’m sure that if this sort of problem is not cured in a cooperative manner, we could see similar measures elsewhere. Each country will have to find a way to take matters into its own hands.”

The goal of the bank’s policy was to slow the upward trend in the baht to give Thai exporters, particularly in the agricultural sector, time to adjust. Money had been pouring into the Thai bond market at a rate of $1 billion a week, Ms. Tarisa said, compared with $300 million a week last year. It remains to be seen whether the country can succeed in stemming that tide.
Thu Dec 21
Thai Stocks Drop as Baht Slumps
The baht today posted its biggest decline in more than seven years after the Bank of Thailand this week introduced curbs on the purchase of local assets. International investors yesterday sold more Thai shares than they bought for a ninth straight day.

"The baht has dropped sharply today and that reflects the declining confidence among investors in the Bank of Thailand's measure," said Visit Ongpipattanakul, a strategist at Trinity Securities Co. in Bangkok. "We could see overseas investors continue to sell Thai stocks for a while."

The SET Index fell 19.66, or 2.8 percent, to 671.89 as of 11:14 a.m. in Bangkok. The gauge yesterday surged 11 percent, the biggest advance since February 1998, after the government rescinded its restrictions on the purchases of stocks by foreign investors. It had slumped by the most in 16 years a day earlier.

The baht lost 1.9 percent to 36.49 per dollar today, its biggest drop in more than seven years and the weakest since Nov. 24. The decline reduced its gains this year to 12 percent. A weaker currency makes baht-denominated assets less attractive to international funds.

Overseas investors yesterday sold 2.87 billion baht ($78.7 million) more of Thai stocks than they purchased, the ninth straight day of net sales. A day earlier, they sold 25.13 billion baht more of Thai stocks than they bought, according to data from the Stock Exchange of Thailand.
Lost in the shuffle of these gyrations is the fact that curbs on foreign investments in bonds and other debt instruments remain. Can a policy that allows one set of capital inflow rules for the stock market but another set of rules for the bond market possibly work?

Thailand proved over the past few days what can happen to a country where there are enormous capital inflows followed by sudden capital outflows. That is exactly one of the things China has been fearing with all the hot money flowing into that country. It is also one of the reasons that China simply must keep a lot of U.S. dollar reserves until it first floats the RMB and thing stabilize.

Yet every Tom, Dick, and Harry keeps telling China to move it's reserves to the Euro and float the RMB. This little exercise just might show why that might not be such great advice. Imagine what might happen if China dumped the dollar for Euros and then later floated the RMB. Would that hot money exit without China having enough dollar reserves?

Yes China does need to do something. China can not stay pegged to the dollar forever. But as long as the RMB is pegged to the dollar China needs to keep sufficient dollar reserves.

Let's flashback to the 1997 East Asian financial crisis.
From 1985 to 1995, Thailand's economy grew at an average of 9%. On 14 May and 15 May 1997, the baht, the local currency, was hit by massive speculative attacks. On 30 June, Prime Minister Chavalit Yongchaiyudh said that he would not devalue the baht, but Thailand's administration eventually floated the local currency, on 2 July. The baht dropped very swiftly and lost half of its value. The baht reached its lowest point of 56 to the dollar in January 1998. The Thai stock market dropped 75% in 1997. Finance One, the largest Thai finance company collapsed. On 11 August, the IMF unveiled a rescue package for Thailand with more than 16 billion dollars. The IMF approved on 20 August, another bailout package of 3.9 billion dollars. The baht has only recently in November 2006 reached pre-crisis highs of 36.5 to the dollar.
This appears to be the reverse of 1997. Note that the Baht now floats but in 1997 was pegged to the dollar. In 1997 hedge funds were shorting the Baht. Recently hedge funds were plowing into the Baht and it is the U.S. dollar is that is perilously perched just above its multi-decade support levels. Still, the high probability bet is that support for the US dollar will hold (for now), but if it does break hard, the consequences could be momentous. EDAA (Every Day Another Adventure) and one of them will eventually matter.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Tuesday, 19 December 2006

November PPI, CPI

MarketWatch is reporting U.S. Nov. PPI 2.0% vs. 0.7% expected.
Producer prices rose by much more than expected in November, with the core producer price index rising by the most since July 1980, the Labor Department said. The November producer price index climbed by 2%, the biggest rise since November 1974, statistics show. Most of the gain in the headline producer price number was in energy prices, which rose by 6.1%. Of that, 17.9% was gasoline prices, while 14.6% was diesel fuel. Economists surveyed by MarketWatch were expecting the PPI to rise by 0.7%. They also forecast a 0.3% rise in the core PPI.
Following are a set of charts on the PPI for November 2006 from the BLS.

Finished Goods PPI



That was a pretty massive bounce in the finished goods PPI.
Is it sustainable?
Let's start with a look at core PPI coming in at +1.3%.
From the BLS report:
The index for finished consumer goods excluding foods and energy climbed 1.1 percent in November following a 0.8-percent decrease in October. Accounting for the majority of this upturn, prices for light motor trucks increased 13.7 percent after moving down 9.7 percent in the previous month. The indexes for passenger cars and alcoholic beverages also turned up after October declines. By contrast, the index for pharmaceutical preparations declined 0.4 percent following a 0.5-percent advance in October. Prices for household appliances, sporting and athletic goods, and tires also moved down in November after rising in the prior month.
Prices for light motor trucks were up 13.7% accounting for a majority of the upturn?! Is that likely to happen again? In fact, did that really happen at all?

Intermediate Goods PPI



At the intermediate goods level there is an unmistakable trend in the core PPI.

Of course many will object to energy being stripped out of these comparisons so let's take a look at the weekly chart of crude prices to see if we can shed any light on the situation.



Notice that we had a decent bounce off strong support at 55. Cynics everywhere expected a bounce after the election and sure enough we got one. Was it an election manipulation bounce, or a technical bounce or both? Whatever it was, the chart still shows a busted weekly trendline.

MarketWatch is reporting Crude futures fall under $62; natural gas near two-year low
January crude fell 31 cents to $61.90 a barrel in early trading, ahead of the contract's expiration at the end of the session. February crude was down 31 cents at $62.48. January natural gas fell 10 cents to $6.975 per million British thermal units, trading under the $7 level for the first time since February of 2005 on forecasts for milder weather in parts of the U.S.
No doubt inflation alarmists will be sounding the bells over the raw PPI numbers while ignoring both the details and previous drops in the PPI. With natural gas futures near a two year low, with crude really not doing much more than putting in what appears to be a technical bounce, and with a huge portion of this PPI increase being based on a 13.7% increase in light truck prices, the November PPI is more likely to be an outlier than the start of a strong trend reversal back up.

Dr. Copper and lumber would seem to agree.

Copper



Click on the above chart for a better view.

Lumber



The treasury market did not have a strong reaction to the PPI report but to be fair it has taken a decent sized hit in the preceding week. It can now look for a much easier comparison next month just as it had a very difficult comparison this month.

CPI



So where was the passthru? OK. OK. So you don't believe the CPI, and for valid reasons I don't either.

Reasons to be skeptical about the CPI
  1. It is not possible to pick a representative basket of goods and services in the first place.
  2. Quality improvements and new products make it impossible to measure price changes in that basket with any reliability.
  3. Government manipulation.
Along with many others, I believe the CPI seriously understated both energy price increases and home price increases between 2001 and 2005. Since 2005 the CPI has overstated housing prices from my point of view.

Nonetheless the CPI provides one point of reference and in conjunction with the PPI, raw materials charts, housing, and retail stores data it is possible to have some degree of confidence in what is happening. In this case housing demand is still falling as are housing prices, lumber and copper have broken down, natural gas is close to two year lows, the weekly trendline on crude is solidly busted, Walmart is struggling and UPS is cutting back work force at Christmas as is Home Depot. Overcapacity is abundant in nearly all goods and services and consumer demand is clearly weakening.

With that backdrop a flat or even negative CPI makes sense. Thus the rising PPI is most likely a bounceback effect with a drop that was perhaps a bit overstated the previous few months. Looking ahead I see continued negative price pressures on account of weakening housing and weakening consumer demand.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Monday, 18 December 2006

Nickels, Copper, Lumber

This post is a continuation of Pennies, Nickels, and Dollars with an additional look at copper and lumber. For those who missed it here is a brief recap:
People who melt pennies or nickels to profit from the jump in metals prices could face jail time and pay thousands of dollars in fines, according to new rules out Thursday.

Soaring metals prices mean that the value of the metal in pennies and nickels exceeds the face value of the coins. Based on current metals prices, the value of the metal in a nickel is now 6.99 cents, while the penny's metal is worth 1.12 cents, according to the U.S. Mint.

"The nation needs its coinage for commerce," U.S. Mint director Ed Moy said in a statement. "We don't want to see our pennies and nickels melted down so a few individuals can take advantage of the American taxpayer. Replacing these coins would be an enormous cost to taxpayers."

Under the new rules, it is illegal to melt pennies and nickels. It is also illegal to export the coins for melting. Travelers may legally carry up to $5 in 1- and 5-cent coins out of the USA or ship $100 of the coins abroad "for legitimate coinage and numismatic purposes."
Note the irony in the mint for being concerned about those who would "take advantage of the American taxpayer" when the actual production cost for each penny is now up to 1.73 cents according to the Houston Chronical. Year in and year out the mint wastes money by coining pennies.

2006 Coin Production Figures
Click on chart for a better view.



The above chart thanks to the US Mint.

Notice that the Mint produced $78,612,000 worth of pennies at a cost of $135,998,760 thereby wasting $57,386,760 of taxpayer money through November of 2006. Worse yet are the continued handling charges (and time wasted) by merchants and banks sorting and counting the damn things.

Click on the above link if you wish to calculate how much the mint wasted in 2004 and 2005 coining pennies.

Following is an email conversation I had with John Rubino at DollarCollapse.com shortly after I wrote Pennies, Nickels, and Dollars.
Mish:
Oddly enough it is quite likely that the Mint will bring upon the very conditions they hope to prevent! Telling people 20 nickels are worth 40% more than a dollar can only invite hoarding.

Rubino:
Exactly! I told my 9-year-old about the nickel thing today (he's home from school with a cold) and he immediately got our change jars out and started picking out the nickels.
The mint had to be crazy to announce that a nickel is worth 7 cents. I got to thinking about this a bit more and a nickel is really .05 dollars plus a call option on the price of copper and nickel (the metals) in the nickel. If that option is ITM enough (in the money) the mint can not prevent people from hoarding them which will in turn drive up the cost of producing them. In fact, the actual price does not even have to get high enough, the mere expectation that metal prices will get high enough could cause hoarding. Of course the mint tried to negate that call option by making it illegal to melt the coins but that will not stop hoarding if the expected or actual price of copper and nickel gets high enough.

All the mint really accomplished was telling everyone that a nickel is backed up by something useful even if a dollar is not. Eventually this is likely to force the mint to debase the nickel by replacing the copper and nickel in the nickel with steel or aluminum.

I concluded Pennies, Nickels, and Dollars with the following:
Right now, a nickel is the closest thing to "Honest Money" we have. We are in the ironic situation where the value of the dollar is falling but the value of a nickel is rising. In what time frame will the current (and probably soon to be confiscated) nickel be worth more than a dollar?
Copper

Recall that the mint long ago replaced much of the nickel in nickels with copper, just as they removed the silver in silver dollars and replaced the copper in pennies with zinc. That is actually the process I was referring to when I suggested nickels would soon be confiscated.

In the short term it is likely the value of a nickel drops to a nickel or less because of the falling price of copper. If there was as much nickel in nickels as there used to be, then nickels would be worth even more than today's copper nickels.

If you are still with me, here is a weekly chart of copper (now the primary value in holding nickels).



Click on the above chart for a better view.

Many of you know that I have been bearish on copper for quite some time. I have been bearish on copper simply because so much of it is used in housing. I expected that Symmetrical triangle to break down and it did. Also note that I was lenient in how I redrew that triangle. The lighter blue line at the base was the lower edge of the previous triangle I was looking at.

We have since then seen a retest of support at the 320 level that seems to have failed as well as multiple failed tests of the triangle (using previous lines). My target remains the 220 level but 160-180 is not out of the question. Technically copper is broken. Can it blast higher anyway? Yes it can. I just do not think it is likely.

Lumber

For grins here is a chart of lumber prices.



Exactly what is Dr. Copper and Lumber telling us?
To me it is obvious.
This economy is in trouble.

The Future Worth of a Nickel

Let's now return to my previous question "In what time frame will the current (and probably soon to be confiscated) nickel be worth more than a dollar?"

Aaron Krowne gave a couple of possible answers to that question on AutoDogmatic.com.
If base metal values continue to increase by 5% per year on average, and the dollar continues to depreciate by about the same, then in about 26 and a half years, a nickel will be worth a dollar in inherent value. If the rates are 10% per year, then in a bit over 13 years this milestone will be reached.
Some might think Aaron is asking too much, others too little, and in the short term I am still calling for a pullback in copper prices. But what's to lose by hoarding nickels? Oddly enough hoarding nickels is a hedge against both hyperinflation and deflation. If hyperinflation kicks in, a nickel might be worth more than a quarter (in metals content) in no time flat. If deflation kicks in as I suspect, cash will be a good thing to have. If you are going to hold cash (change) it may as well be in nickels.

This post originally appeared in WhiskeyAndGunpowder.
Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

1929 Revisited

Many people asked for a transcript of Contrarian Debate: Janszen vs Mish the discussion between Eric Janszen and myself on housing, a possible recession, and the terminal state of the asset bubble cycle: inflation or deflation.

Others wondered why the "&*%@$!" format was streaming audio instead of MP3. I can not answer that question but I will pass that thought along to the person recording and we will attempt to have a different format next time if at all possible. Finally others questioned calling what took place a "debate". Well it was never intended to be a debate in the classic sense but rather a discussion of ideas and topics that each of us agreed to talk about in advance. Indeed there was far more agreement than disagreement.

In the discussion each of us presented a "What year is it?" scenario. Eric Janszen chose 1999 as outlined in Is it 1999 again? Yes and no. I chose 1929. I think it is fair to say we both agree that history rhymes but does not repeat, and those looking for "fireworks" as opposed to a discussion of ideas may have been disappointed.

There is no transcript available but following are my views on the parallels between now and 1929 and why this is not a repeat of the 70's. Let's discuss the 70's first.

70’s Rerun

Similarities
  1. War in Vietnam war then vs. the war in Iraq now
  2. Rising oil and commodity prices
Differences
  1. Rising Oil prices [demand side shock vs. supply side shock]
  2. Spiraling wages then vs. declining wages now
  3. Wage and price controls then
  4. Consumer Debt levels – Significant ability to take on more debt in the 70's
  5. Housing down payments – 20% then 0% now
  6. Two family incomes now vs. one family income then
  7. The power of unions - then
  8. Globalization & Global wage arbitrage - now
  9. Outsourcing - now
  10. Productivity improvements - The internet and other innovations - now
  11. Declining credit standards - now
  12. Downfall of communism
  13. Long term interest rates under 5% - now
  14. New creative financing ideas running rampant - now
  15. Massive use of derivatives - now
  16. China, India, and Emerging Markets
The differences noted above are staggering and Eric agreed.

20's Rerun
  1. Throughout the 1920s, the Fed deliberately and unwisely stimulated the stock market by keeping the “call rate,” that is, the interest rate on bank loans to the stock market, artificially low. – Margin rates were just lowered here and the FF rate which was lowered to 1% supported a big housing boom.
  2. In the late 1920s, bank credit propelled a massive real estate boom in New York City, in Florida, and throughout the country. We now have the biggest housing bubble in history.
  3. In the 1920’s there was a massive infusion of money (gold) from war torn Europe stimulating our economy. We currently have a massive stimulus of cheap money from Japan and China via and various carry trades and cheap credit supporting our economy.
  4. In the 20’s we intervened in foreign exchange markets to enhance or stabilize Europe’s power to buy our exports. We currently are involved in disputes with China over currency issues attempting to get China to buy more of our goods.
  5. There were massive productivity improvements in the 20’s along with the industrial revolution and assembly line processing. The 90’s – 2000’s productivity miracle was the internet. Huge boom periods on account of disruptive innovation. By contrast there was no such innovative disruptions in the 70’s.
  6. In late 20’s credit was expanding at a rapid pace but there was no need for additional productive capacity. Today GDP is rapidly falling but credit is still rising. There is no pent up demand for homes, restaurants, retail stores, strip malls, autos, truck, etc, just as there was no need for additional assembly line production in 1929. Speculation replaced productive capacity just as it is today.
  7. In 1929 leverage was extreme via stock margin. In 2006 credit derivatives leverage is extreme to the tune of 340 trillion dollars worth with no one really understand exactly what the counterparty risk is.
  8. A few days before leaving office in March 1929, Coolidge called American prosperity “absolutely sound” and assured everyone that stocks were “cheap at current prices.” Based on the “Treasury Model” and unsustainable earnings growth due to financing activities, we are once again told time and time again that “the economy is sound” and stocks are cheap at current prices.
  9. "Keynesian Folly", along with other massive government interventions managed to convert what would likely have been a short, sharp recession into a chronic, permanent, stagnation with an unprecedented high unemployment that only ended with World War II. Massive government interventions between 2002 and 2005 prevented a badly needed recession and instead created the biggest asset bubble in history.
  10. In 1933 gold coins were confiscated – now we have a threat of nickels being confiscated.
  11. At the time, the stock market of 1929 was the biggest asset bubbles in history. We have now vastly exceeded all previous credit bubbles.
  12. The Smoot-Hawley Tariff was signed into law on June 17, 1930. There are renewed threats of tariffs in the U.S. Congress right now.
Oddly enough I found one more similarity just today. In More Cream for the Fat Cats I see that "Corporate profits are at their highest level since 1929."

The above 12 points were the similarities I mentioned in the discussion and Eric chimed in with an additional one: Buying goods on credit. Buying on credit first became widely practiced in the 20's. It was done to "make things affordable". Now nearly everything is made affordable by stretching payments to lengths that certainly never would have been allowed in the 70's but are commonplace today.

That is where we parted ways. While agreeing on the similarities Eric also cautioned there were parallels to 1937 and presented his "Ka-Poom Theory" which you can also see in Is it 1999 again? Yes and no. On the other hand I am sticking to a simple "It’s not different this time" approach and that all asset bubbles collapse in a deflationary credit bust. Previous credit busting deflationary collapses include Japan, the Great Depression, the railroad bust of the 1880's, the South Sea Trading Bubble, the John Law Mississippi Bubble, and the Tulip Mania Bubble.

In an Interview with Paul Kasriel we had the following discussion on how inflation starts and ends.
Mish: How does inflation start and end?
Kasriel: Inflation starts with expansion of money and credit.
Inflation ends when the central bank is no longer able or willing to extend credit and/or when consumers and businesses are no longer willing to borrow because further expansion and /or speculation no longer makes any economic sense.
It is pure speculation now (corporate buybacks, leveraged buyouts, collapsing volatilities) along with foreign central bank asset buying that is driving stocks higher. None of it is getting into the average guy's pocket and none of it has anything to do with the real economy. Meanwhile real wages are falling, home prices are collapsing, and if I am correct job growth is about ready to fall off the cliff in a second wave down of reduced corporate spending. That combination will increase foreclosures, defaults, and bankruptcies (the latter of which obviously destroys credit).

There is little central banks can do about it either, just as they could not do much when all of the other massive bubbles throughout history collapsed. Nonetheless, “Keynesian Folly" will likely be attempted once again. The last execution by Greenspan produced the housing bubble and with it jobs. If the next attempt does not put money into consumers pockets and have them spend it on increased consumption (as opposed to paying off debts), the party is over regardless of what year this is.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Saturday, 16 December 2006

Paulson, Bernanke Strike Out

At the trade summit opening in China on December 14th Paulson Called for More Flexible Yuan.
U.S. Treasury Henry Paulson, facing pressure from Congress for trade sanctions against China, urged the nation to relax currency controls and better protect property rights to help close a record trade gap.

Talks in Beijing must produce "tangible results" to prevent protectionist elements in both nations damaging their trade partnership, Paulson, leading one of the biggest U.S. economic delegations to China, said in the Chinese capital today.

China should move toward a regime where "currency values are determined in a competitive open marketplace based upon economic fundamentals," Paulson said at the inaugural meeting of the so- called Strategic Economic Dialogue between China and the U.S. "In the meantime more currency flexibility is necessary."
China did not take too kindly to Paulson's remarks. Fortune Magazine reported China pushes back against Paulson.
Vice Premier Wu Yi had other ideas. Like an impatient schoolmistress, she opened this historic gathering with a lecture. Her talk was one part history lesson (China has 5,000 years experience as a global citizen) and one part 21st century civics lesson (the goal is a "socialist harmonious society"), with no sign that her regime sees any need for major economic reform.

"We have had the genuine feeling that some American friends are not only having limited knowledge of, but harboring much misunderstanding about, the reality in China," she began, striking a less-than-diplomatic note. "This is not conducive to the sound development of our bilateral relations."

In delivering her 20-page presentation, which included slides to illustrate points on Chinese history, Ms. Wu made clear that the Chinese regime believes it has carved its own responsible global economic path, and isn't especially eager for the Americans' free-market advice.

According to the English translation of her remarks, she repeated six times that China was "sticking to" its "new path of industrialization," and three times that China was "continuing to improve" on reforms already in place. Substantial free-market change wasn't part of the equation. "By following a path of building socialism with Chinese characteristics in an independent and self-reliant manner," she said, "we have scored glorious achievements that attracted worldwide attention."

Ms. Wu's remarks included veiled barbs at the U.S., noting that China had ratified the Kyoto Protocol on global warming and was "fully harnessing world peace" in its global economic development. The United States did not ratify Kyoto, and remains bogged down in an unpopular war in Iraq.

The Chinese also complained about U.S. national security policies that limit sensitive high-tech trade and acquisitions of American firms, according to Gutierrez. The American delegation, he said, was forced to "clarify" a perception that U.S. policy was moving toward protectionism.
One would think that by now the US would get the picture. China does not want or need our advice. How many times does China have to tell the US to butt out? But that did not stop Bernanke from taking a swing the following day.

The Financial Times reported Bernanke calls for renminbi revaluation.
Ben Bernanke stepped into a political minefield on Friday [December 15th] when he released remarks branding China’s undervalued currency an “effective subsidy” for its exporters that was distorting patterns of production and trade.

Although the Federal Reserve chairman dropped the phrase in a speech in Beijing, using instead the less inflammatory term “distortion”, the Fed was standing by the language of the original text.

His comments were welcomed by US manufacturers. Frank Vargo, of the National Association of Manufacturers, said: “This is a very important message. The administration has been talking simply about currency flexibility. But Bernanke has come out and called the currency undervalued and told Beijing it is distorting the Chinese economy. That is significant.”

Hank Paulson, the Treasury secretary who led the delegation and faced pressure to harden his rhetoric, said: “All I can say is that the chairman of the Fed is entitled to his independent comments.”

The incoming Congress took the speech as a cue to launch anti-dumping legislation – which has been looming since Democrats won the midterm elections on a wave of economic populism.

Sander Levin, head of the House committee on trade, on Friday night unveiled a controversial bill to permit the use of anti-subsidy laws in response to “currency manipulation” by Beijing.
Bernanke's remarks should once and for all put to bed the idea that the Fed would be forced to raise interest rates to support the dollar. Previously it was the Treasury Department calling for China to act, now the Fed is in the game too.

The notion that a weaker dollar will help exports and help balance trade deficits is complete silliness. The way to fix the balance of trade is simple. The US needs to stop borrowing money from foreigners to fight a completely stupid war in Iraq, and US consumers need to stop buying junk they do not need and can not afford. With 20-1 wage differentials it is simply impossible to balance the trade deficit on the back of currency devaluations.

The National Association of Manufacturers called Bernanke's speech "significant". The only way it can be significant is if China acts (extremely doubtful as China does not react to pressure) or if Bernanke somehow manages to goad Congress into doing something totally stupid in response such as pass a modern day version of the infamous Smoot Hawley Tariff Act. With a Democratic Congress now in control, protectionist nonsense probably has a greater chance than before, especially with a weakening economy.

What is distorting the world economy is US spending is simply out of control, Japan's interest rates are too low, and carry trades and speculation are running rampant, not just in the US but worldwide. The Greenspan Fed cutting the Fed Fund rate to 1% was certainly a contributing factor leading up to the latest mess.

Vice Premier Wu Yi in no uncertain terms told Paulson exactly where to go, yet Bernanke repeated the same message the following day. So what game is Bernanke playing anyway? Is he that dumb to think he can pressure China? It's not like he is an elected official up for reelection and sending a message the folks back home want to hear.

For unknown reasons Bernanke risked firing up protectionist fears in Congress for close to a zero percent chance China will listen to him and not Paulson. Speaking of Paulson wasn't he supposed to be the great diplomat that Snow wasn't?

My friend Harmy on the Motley FOOL summed up the situation perfectly.
For as long as I can remember any number of small countries have pleaded with the US to modify it's trade policies which caused huge damage to those countries economies. Through it all the US simply adopted a policy of indifference and did exactly as it pleased. Now we have the US trying to force China into doing what the US wants simply because the US cannot control its own economy. The problem the US has is a US one not a Chinese one and I am quite sure that behind the inscrutable Chinese smiles they will do exactly as they please just as the US has done over the years.

When your opponent starts bleating about unfair tactics you know you've got him on the ropes.
This much is clear: The US can no longer call the shots in the global trade arena, the US economy is on the ropes, and whatever game Bernanke is playing smacks of pure desperation.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Friday, 15 December 2006

Contrarian Debate: Janszen vs Mish

The "Contrarian Debate" is a discussion between Eric Janszen and Mish on housing, a possible recession, and the terminal state of the asset bubble cycle: inflation or deflation. As a prelude we also discuss "pocket change" and the rising rate of foreclosures.

Each of us presents and defends a "What year is it?" scenario.
Eric Janszen chose 1999. I chose 1929.

The debate came about as a result of Eric's post Is it 1999 again? Yes and no. Our biggest agreement was that this was NOT a "70's Rerun". For disagreements and other agreements you will simply have to listen for yourself.

Thanks to Tom Jeffries for recording the debate and to Eric Janszen for initially contacting me and proposing this discussion in the first place. Note that this is a long podcast (about 50 minutes). Please play when you have about 50 minutes because that is how long it will take.

On behalf of both of us, we hope you find listening to this debate worth your while. Note that there is a bit of minor static for about 12 minutes or so about half way in, but the discussion finishes clean.

To hear this podcast please click here: Contrarian Debate: Janszen vs Mish and follow the directions.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/