Saturday, 17 February 2007

Robber Barons or Communist Central Planning

Imagine for a minute that you own a fruit stand. You sell oranges, grapefruit, lemons and limes. Perhaps in season you sell apples, peaches, and strawberries. What would you think if the government came in and forced you to sell broccoli, asparagus, and pecans? Hopefully you would be horrified. After all, wouldn't that smack of failed Soviet command economics?

Well sad to say that is exactly the proposal made by the attorney general of Mississippi, Saturday February 17, 2007. Please consider Miss. AG Seeks Legislation on State Farm.
Mississippi Attorney General Jim Hood said Friday he will seek legislation aimed at blocking State Farm Insurance Cos. from refusing to write new homeowners and commercial policies in the hurricane-battered state.

Hood's plan would require any company that writes automobile insurance in Mississippi and also writes homeowners policies in other states to offer homeowners and commercial properties throughout Mississippi.

Hood said his plan is modeled after actions taken by Florida. Florida's legislation primarily deals with preventing policy cancelations and non-renewals, but Hood said a model could be crafted to force companies to write new policies.

"We're looking at a robber baron in the face that is trying to make an example of Mississippi," Hood said of State Farm.

State Farm, Mississippi's largest homeowner insurer, said Wednesday it has had enough of the "untenable" legal and political climate in the state and is suspending writing new homeowners and commercial policies. The company said the suspension would begin Friday and continue until the business climate in the state is more palatable.

In a statement Friday, U.S. Rep. Bennie Thompson, D-Miss., said he was "deeply disturbed" by the decision and said Congress would hold hearings on the insurer's conduct.

State Farm spokesman Phil Supple said Friday that Hood's rhetoric, including his comparison of State Farm to a "robber baron," is a "remarkable response to what was purely a business decision."

Hood's plan prompted criticism from other Mississippi officials, who say the Florida legislation it's based on is driving insurers out of that state. "Florida did something similar and we're seeing companies leave Florida daily," said Lee Harrell, Mississippi's deputy insurance commissioner.

Robert Hartwig, vice president and chief economist for the Insurance Information Institute in New York, an industry-funded group, said Hood's proposal isn't likely to succeed in compelling State Farm to continue writing new homeowner policies.

Automobile insurance isn't profitable enough to offset losses in the sale of homeowner insurance in a hurricane-vulnerable region so the company may be inclined to stop selling auto policies if they also must sell homeowner policies there, Hartwig said. "The only losers in this situation are consumers facing fewer options for automobile insurance," Hartwig said.
Should Mississippi be stupid enough to pass legislation forcing "the farm" to sell asparagus when "the farm" only wants to sell grapefruit and oranges, what will happen should be obvious: The price of grapefruit, oranges, and asparagus will all rise when "the farm" rightfully tells Mississippi to shove it and takes its produce stand elsewhere.

The government has no business telling "farms" of any sort what kind of fruits and vegetables they can sell, nor does the government have any business setting prices for "produce". Wasn't Soviet command style economics discredited long ago?

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Every Picture Tells a Story

In the past few months we have seen repeated bottom calls by David Lereah at the NAR. We have also heard Robert Toll proclaim to be "dancing above the bottom", and just this past week Greenspan himself said "The housing slump was all but over."

Following is a a graphical presentation to see if we can determine just how likely those statements are to be true. The pictures speak for themselves.

Hew Home Inventory



Is the Bottom In?

California Default Notices
(click on chart for a much better view)



Is the bottom in?

San Diego Defaults



Is the Bottom In?

Subprime Market Share



With credit standards tightening.....
where is the pool of new buyers going to come from?

Piggyback Loans



With credit standards tightening.....
where is the pool of new buyers going to come from?
Just a reminder, take a look at that first chart again of inventory.

Housing Starts 1965-2007
(click on chart for a much better view)



Is the bottom in?
In time or price or starts?

XHB - Hombuilders ETF
(click on chart for a much better view)



Is the top of this retrace in?

Thanks to....
Economagic, Calculated Risk, Professor Piggington, Immobilienblasen, B.C. Anonymous, Foreclosure Forum, and Inside Mortgage Finance for the images used in this post.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Friday, 16 February 2007

Ford North America Report Card

Detroit News is reporting Ford fix-it plan off track.
Report: Sales goals missed, morale low
Ford Motor Co. is failing to meet key goals in its turnaround plan and employees are losing confidence in the company's ability to save itself, according to an internal report released to employees and obtained by The Detroit News on Thursday.

Titled "Report Card: Ford North America," the report paints a grim picture of a company unable to stop its downward spiral.

Ford missed its retail sales goal in the United States for January by 10,600 vehicles -- or nearly 1 percentage point of market share -- and now expects to miss its retail market share goals for February and March, the report shows.

The company hit its material cost reduction target for January, but will miss its targets for February and March by a wide margin, according to the current forecast.

Ford's problems are not lost on employees, only 47 percent of whom say they have confidence in Ford's long-term success. And less than 45 percent believe the automaker's "Way Forward" plan is working, according to the results of an employee survey included in the report.

The failure to meet the plan goals is the first sign of real trouble for CEO Alan Mulally's new regime. While Ford lost more money in 2006 than ever before -- $12.7 billion -- most of that damage was done before the former Boeing Co. executive was tapped to lead Ford last fall.

Since then, Mulally has stressed the need for unblushing honesty and rigorous accountability, urging his executives to set realistic goals for 2007. However, Ford's Americas team failed to meet these supposedly more realistic targets.

That is bound to put more pressure on Ford Americas President Mark Fields and his team. Wall Street is likely to be more indulgent with Mulally, according to Bradley Rubin, who follows Ford for BNP Paribas. "He's already done the hard thing, which is raising the capital and getting enough cash in there to fix Ford's problems," Rubin said. "It's not about how much they lose in '07. Earnings have taken a back seat to whether or not they have enough cash and financial flexibility."

In December, Ford put up all of its U.S. assets to secure more than $23 billion in financing to fund the turnaround plan.

Fields went over the report with employees Wednesday as part of his regular weekly Webcast, but acknowledged that he is having a hard time convincing them to keep the faith.

According to a quarterly survey of employee morale, results of which were included in the report, most employees have a dim view of Ford's future. Just more than 50 percent were optimistic about the future a year ago, and Ford set a goal of increasing that number to 60 percent this year. But it has already fallen to below 50 percent.

Product -- or the lack thereof -- is a major cause for this pessimism. Only 38 percent of workers surveyed said they believe Ford has "the right products to move the company forward."

According to the report released to employees this week, the shortfall in retail sales was "due to greater-than-expected segment shift out of pickups, unfavorable share performance related to SUVs and lower-than-planned availability of (Ford's) new products."

Ford is well on its way to meeting its goal of cutting some 44,000 jobs in the United States by 2008. The company also plans to idle 16 factories by 2012.
Product -- or the lack thereof -- is a major cause for this pessimism. Only 38 percent of workers surveyed said they believe Ford has "the right products to move the company forward."

Wow. I guess that says it all. 62% of the work force does not believe in the company. In the just wondering department: After Ford gets rid of 44,000 employees and shuts down 16 plants, exactly how much of Ford's US operations will be left?

Ford Monthly Chart
Click on chart for a better view.



In December, Ford put up all of its U.S. assets to secure more than $23 billion in financing to fund the turnaround plan. Near term that staved off bankruptcy, at least for a while. The questions now are: How fast will Ford burn through that cash? What is going to happen to car and truck sales heading into a consumer led recession? I suspect the burn rate will be a lot higher than anyone thinks once this recession gets going.

Technically Ford is challenging a brutal monthly down trend line that has capped every rally since 1999. It is also sitting modestly above a long term support line dating all the way back to 1993. If that support breaks, Ford will be following the airlines and auto parts manufacturers into bankruptcy.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Thursday, 15 February 2007

The "R" Word

A series of economic reports came out on February 15th that can best be described as "dismal". Recession is now knocking on the door. In the weeks and months to come expect to hear the "R" word much more frequently. Let's take a look at some of the reports.

Economic Reports
  • Industrial Output
  • Capital Flows
  • Weekly Jobless Claims
  • Factory Sector ISM
Industrial Output
Industrial output falls sharply in January
U.S. industrial production fell in January by the largest amount since Hurricane Katrina devastated the Gulf Coast in September 2005, the Federal Reserve reported Thursday.

Industrial output of the nation's factories, mines and utilities fell 0.5% in January, the fourth decline in the past five months. Automakers and other producers are slashing production to bring down their inventories of unsold goods.

The decline in factory output was even steeper, with production down 0.7%. Production of motor vehicles and parts fell 6%. Vehicle assemblies fell to their lowest level in nearly a decade. The decline in factory output was broad based. Factory output excluding vehicles fell 0.4%.

The report was "dismal," wrote Stephen Stanley, chief economist for RBS Greenwich Capital, although he judged that the January downturn was a "temporary weather-related bump in the road," not a fundamental shift in the economy.

"The sector is in recession," wrote Ian Shepherdson, chief U.S. economist for High Frequency Economics, noting that output fell 1.7% annualized in the fourth quarter and is heading for a decline in this quarter as well.

Capacity utilization fell to 81.2% in January from 81.8% in December. This is the lowest level since last February. The Fed had been worrying about high rates of capacity utilization feeding into inflation.
"The sector is in recession," wrote Ian Shepherdson, chief U.S. economist for High Frequency Economics. Indeed it is. That is in addition to the housing sector which is also clearly in recession. It should not be long before the word "sector" is replaced by the words "United States".

Capital Flows
December sees $11 billion net capital outflow
U.S. monthly capital flows reversed in December to an outflow for the first time since June 2005, the Treasury Department reported Thursday. The U.S. recorded an outflow of $11 billion in December, compared with an inflow of $70.5 billion in November, the Treasury said.

The U.S. economy has required big inflows of capital of about $70 billion every month to fund its large current account deficit, which totaled $225.6 billion in the third quarter -- about 6.8% of gross domestic product. The large inflows of foreign capital have kept U.S. interest rates lower than they would otherwise be, boosting the real-estate sector and other asset markets with cheap money.

The dollar fell against yen and the euro following the report, which, according to Action Economics, "didn't sit too well" with the markets after Tuesday's report on the nation's growing trade gap and a Wall Street Journal report that China is considering shifting some of its $1 trillion in foreign reserves into riskier assets, such as corporate bonds, stocks and even commodities.

Net long-term capital inflows, meanwhile, fell to $15.6 billion in December from $84.9 billion in November. This marked the lowest inflow since January 2002.

Foreign private investors sold stocks in December, and they bought fewer Treasury bonds and corporate bonds. Foreign central banks bought a record amount of government agency bonds to close out 2006.

Overall, foreign private investors bought $39 billion in long-term securities in December, compared with $115.7 billion in November. They purchased only $4.5 billion in Treasury bonds and notes in December, compared with $33.1 in the previous month, according to the data.

A senior Treasury official noted that the monthly data are volatile and should be viewed over longer terms.
The article reported "A Wall Street Journal report that China is considering shifting some of its $1 trillion in foreign reserves into riskier assets, such as corporate bonds, stocks and even commodities." Just what are they thinking? Sorry, that's the wrong question. Here's the right question: Are they thinking at all? There's nothing quite like a rush into riskier assets such as corporate bonds and stocks headed smack into a recession when those asset classes have not seen any kind of significant decline for four years. Didn't Japan try that once or twice too? The Bank of England sold gold after it fell from 800 to 250. This is simply what central banks do all the time, whether they are thinking about anything or not.

Weekly Claims
Jobless claims jump 44,000 to 357,000
The unemployment lines grew longer last week, in part because of bad weather in the Midwest and Northeast, the government reported Thursday. The number of people collecting unemployment benefits rose to the highest level in a year.

Seasonally adjusted initial jobless claims increased by 44,000 to 357,000 in the week ending Feb. 10, the Labor Department said. It's the highest level since late November. And it's the largest weekly increase since September 2005, just after Hurricane Katrina devastated New Orleans.

The four-week average of new claims - which smoothes out one-time events such as holidays or weather - rose by 17,500 to 326,250, the highest since December.
Meanwhile, the number of people collecting unemployment benefits in the week ending Feb. 3 rose by 71,000 to 2.56 million, the most in 13 months. The four-week average of continuing claims rose by 18,000 to 2.52 million, the most in 12 months.

Long-term unemployment has been stubbornly high during this expansion, despite the decrease in the unemployment rate to 4.5%. In January, about 30% of the 7 million official unemployed people had been out of work longer than 15 weeks, while 16%, or 1.1 million, had been out of work longer than 27 weeks.

Typically, unemployment benefits run out after 26 weeks for those who are eligible. Those who exhaust their unemployment benefits are still counted as unemployed if they are looking for work.
Are they really attempting to blame this on the weather? Of course. Was there any mention that construction jobs were way up in November and December because of unseasonably warm weather? Of course not.



Jobs are where the rubber meets the road in this expansion. It remains to be seen if this weekly claims number is an outlier, but in conjunction with the other economic reports I find that unlikely. As an aside, it is now taking enormous increases in M3 just to stand still. In 1980 it took $1 of new debt to create $1 of GDP; in 2000 it took $4 and today it takes $7. We seem to be pushing on a string and the expected revisions to the 4th quarter GDP shows it.

Factory ISM
Factory gauges point different directions
The New York Fed's Empire State index jumped to a healthy 22.4 in February after two soft months, but the Philly Fed index fell to 0.6, pointing to a barely growing manufacturing sector in the Philadelphia region.

The two gauges are of interest primarily because they are seen as clues to the national Institute for Supply Management survey for February due out in two weeks. In January, the ISM index fell unexpectedly below 50% for the second time in three months. In the ISM, readings under 50% indicate the factory sector is contracting.

The Philly Fed new orders index fell to negative 0.5, while the shipments index dropped by more than 22 points to 1.7. The unfilled orders index improved to negative 10.5, indicating that manufacturers are working off their backlogs. The prices-paid and prices-received indexes showed little change. The employment indexes contracted.

In Empire State report, the headline index rose to 24.4 from 9.1, confounding expectations of a drop to 8.7. New orders and shipments increased and unfilled orders moved out of negative territory. The employment indexes improved. The Empire State new orders index rose to 18.9 from 10.3. Shipments rose to 27.1 in February from 16.1. The inventory index improved to negative 7.5 from negative 19.2.
If one is looking for outliers, the Empire State report is likely it. Still, In January, the ISM index fell unexpectedly below 50% for the second time in three months. In the ISM, readings under 50% indicate the factory sector is contracting. The Fed has never in history hiked with a negative ISM reading.

Rate Cuts Coming?
Odds of first-half '07 rate cut more than double after data
The odds of an interest rate cut through the first half of 2007 more than doubled, after weaker-than-expected industrials production data, lower-than-anticipated import price growth and a sharp rise in weekly jobless claims offset a surprise rise in manufacturing activity in the New York region. July fed funds futures were last up 0.02 at 94.785, which implies a 14% chance that the Federal Reserve will lower its target on overnight rates to 5% from 5.25% by its policy setting meeting in late June. At the intraday high of 94.79, the highest price seen since Jan. 22, the odds of a cut stood at 16%. Late Wednesday, the odds of a cut were at 6%.
At the time of this writing the odds were not yet reflected on the Fed Funds Rate Predictions Chart. Here is a chart showing the June FOMC meeting expected outcome as of February 13.



Click on the above link to refresh the chart. Within a day or two the chart should show some significant differences. Right now the chart shows that odds of a June hike are greater than the odds of a cut. That will change.

$TNX
Treasury Bears (and they seem to be damn near everywhere) have been salivating over the latest uptick in yields. Let's step back and look at the big picture. Following is a monthly chart.



Daily Chart



From a seasonality standpoint, treasuries are generally bearish from the beginning of the year through tax season (April-May) timeframe, and if that upper trendline on the monthly chart is going to break, now would be the time. In light of economic data, I doubt we see that happen although there could potentially be one last blast higher in a bond revolt when the Fed is forced to start cutting.

The pent up domestic demand for treasuries is in my estimation enormous. Nearly every hedge fund, mutual fund, and investor has been chasing stocks for a long time. Treasuries are generally despised except by foreign central banks. But when the US equity markets finally die of speculative exhaustion, I expect to see a massive repricing of risk with junk yields moving substantially higher and US treasuries yields, substantially lower, in a flight to safety construct.

Bernanke's Box

Bernanke has to be suffocating in that box he is in. Interest rates are no longer accommodating for the real economy and the rising bankruptcy and foreclosure data in conjunction with a sinking jobs picture and anemic GDP proves it. On the other hand the FF rate is not high enough to kill financial speculation. Proof of the latter is collapsing yield spreads on junk and foreign bonds, rising NYSE margin levels, what seems to be insatiable demand for credit swaps, and a stock market where all news (good or bad) is generally cheered.

There is also the carry trade fuel to consider. The carry trade is attractive as long as money borrowed in Yen finds sufficient returns elsewhere and/or the Yen itself continues to sink. The greater the interest rate differential between the US and Japan the more attractive the carry trade is. Could it be a collapse in treasury yields in the US as opposed to a rise in interest rates in Japan that sinks the carry trade boat?

Regardless of what the triggers are, a recession and a repricing of risk are both baked in the cake.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Largest Home Price Drop on Record

Housing is Local (Except when it's National).
The NAR is reporting a record slump in home prices.
Fourth-quarter report from National Association of Realtors shows largest price drop on record as markets with price declines now outpace those with gains.

Prices slumped 2.7 percent in the fourth quarter compared to the fourth quarter a year earlier, according to the report from the National Association of Realtors (NAR). That's the biggest year-over-year drop on record and follows a 1.0 percent year-over-year decline in the third quarter.

In addition, 73 metropolitan areas reported a decline in the fourth quarter, compared to a year earlier. That outpaced the 71 that saw a gain. It was both a record number and percentage of markets showing a decline in the group's quarterly report. Five markets saw prices unchanged.

The most recent median prices are down even more: 3.4 percent since hitting record highs in the second quarter. Almost three-quarters of the markets, reported on by the group, saw declines in median prices over the past six months, with eight reporting double-digit declines.

But the weakness in prices wasn't restricted to those kinds of markets. Springfield, Illinois, reported a 16.2 percent drop in the fourth quarter compared to the third quarter, the biggest decline during that time frame, along with a 10.4 percent decline compared to a year earlier.

Still, the trade group statement said it believed that the worst was over for the drop in prices.

"Examination of data within the quarter shows home prices stabilizing toward the end," said a statement from David Lereah, the NAR's chief economist. "When we get the figures for this spring, I expect to see a discernable improvement in both sales and prices."
Here is a chart of nationwide prices.



Click here for the latest home prices in 149 markets tracked for the fourth quarter of 2006.

"Examination of data within the quarter shows home prices stabilizing toward the end," said a statement from David Lereah, the NAR's chief economist. "When we get the figures for this spring, I expect to see a discernable improvement in both sales and prices."

David Lereah is a paid cheerleader. On that basis I expect to see David Lereah cheerleading regardless of what the facts are. As for me, I will take the other side of the bet: I expect to see an economy heading into recession, with increasing foreclosures, more distress auctions, more bankruptcies, and weakening prices. One of us will be right and one of us wrong. I will say in advance that at some point there will be a fake rally of sorts, from what level I do not know but my inclinations are that such a rally will occur after a deeper slump than this one. The foreclosure party has really just started.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Wednesday, 14 February 2007

US GDP Flunks Smell Test

Flashback January 31, 2007 - Bloomberg reported: U.S. Economy: Growth Quickens, Propelled by Spending.
The U.S. economy grew at the fastest pace in a year last quarter as declining energy costs helped power consumer spending and contain inflation, enhancing Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke's stature at the start of his second year.

Gross domestic product increased at an annual pace of 3.5 percent, the Commerce Department said in Washington today. That was more than forecast and up from a 2 percent pace in the prior three months. Other figures today showed manufacturing and construction still struggling to shake off a slowdown.

Stocks rose after the Fed, which left its benchmark interest rate at 5.25 percent today, said inflation has "improved" at the same time data have shown "somewhat firmer economic growth."

Central bankers, in a statement accompanying the rate decision, said that "readings on core inflation have improved modestly in recent months'' and that price pressures would likely "moderate over time."

Higher Stock Prices

The Dow Jones Industrial Average increased 106 points, or 0.8 percent, at 2:40 p.m. in New York. The Standard & Poor's 500 Index rose 9.4 points, or 0.7 percent.
In less than two weeks the 4th quarter US GDP was revised lower from +3.5% or so to something closer to +2.0 to +2.5%. I remember all the fanfare from everywhere touting US 4th quarter growth. The odd thing is, today I am scrambling to find much of anything on the revised lower estimates. This is the best mainstream media report I can find. It happens to be from Australia.

The Sydney Morning Herald is reporting US trade gap drags down GDP.
An unexpectedly wide December trade gap and pared down business inventories are certain to slice a big chunk off the government's gauge of fourth-quarter economic growth, showing the year ended on a subdued note.

In fresh data on a key piece of the economic pie, the government on Tuesday reported that the US trade deficit widened 5.3 per cent to $US61.2 billion ($A79.43 billion) in December, pushing the full year's shortfall to a record $US763.6 billion ($A991.11 billion).

The latest trade numbers, which reflected surges in oil imports and goods from China, showed US consumers were buying more goods from overseas, which acts as a drag on US producers and ultimately economic growth.

The government reported two weeks ago that gross domestic product, the broadest measure of overall economic activity within US borders, expanded at a 3.5 per cent annual rate during the October-through-December quarter.

Now economists are expecting a revision in the GDP data due on February 28 to show a leaner reading for the quarter, after the bigger trade deficit and data showing wholesalers pared their inventories at the end of the year. When businesses meet demand by unloading stockpiles it detracts from growth because there is less need to ramp up production.

"Q4 GDP will be revised down; it didn't really pass the smell test in the first place," said Keith Hembre, chief economist at FAF Advisors in Minneapolis.
It is much easier to find decent news reporting outside the US mainstream media, especially when it comes to the US economy.

In the US, Nouriel Roubini was on top of this story with his blog entry US Q4 GDP Growth Likely to be Revised Down to 2.0-2.2% from Initial 3.5% Estimate.
It now looks like the alleged growth rebound in Q4, from the 2.0% of Q3 to the 3.5% of Q4 was an illusion based on incomplete data. Based on recent data on inventories for December (much lower than initially predicted by BEA) and today’s December trade balance figures (much worse than initially forecasted by BEA) the initial estimate for Q4 growth will be revised downward to 2.0% or at best 2.2%. Indeed 2.2% is today’s revised estimate by JP Morgan, one of the most bullish – on US growth - investment houses. In a research note today they said: “A wider than expected December trade deficit leaves fourth quarter GDP growth tracking 2.2%, down from the advance estimate of 3.5%.”.

So, the alleged growth rebound in Q4 actually did not occur. Indeed, as BEA had estimated strong consumption in Q4 and in December, it was odd that one would expect an improved trade balance in December: all those plasma and LCD TVs and consumer electronics - that were at the center of the holiday consumption binge - are imported. And indeed the December trade figures today showed the obvious: a large chunk of the consumption boom during the holidays went into imports.
One of the more interesting things I suppose is the fact that stocks rose on the report of a higher GDP and stocks rose on a revised lower GDP. Does any one care about anything or is there simply a mad panic to get into stocks before it's too late? I recall a similar panic to get into housing in the summer of 2005 "before it's too late". Here's a free tip: When everyone is rushing to get in to something "before it's too late", it is already way too late.

For a very timely (in advance) article on that concept I refer you to this short article: It's Too Late. Mish readers may wish to check the date on that article.

Let's now return to the GDP. I consider +2% to be the stall rate. I say that because the first 2% of the GDP is total nonsense (hedonics and imputations) that simply do not reflect any real economic activity. I have reported on this before but imputations include the concept of "paying oneself rent" and the GDP value of "free checking accounts".

If there was value delivered in "free checking accounts" banks would be charging for those services. In essence they already are. When you deposit money into your checking account, a "sweep" process takes that money and on a nightly basis "sweeps it from your account" into a general lending pool so that banks can lend that money out. In the meantime banks pay you 0% interest while lending it out for profitable returns. To top that off some bureaucrat comes along and decides that GDP should be higher because of the "value" you receive for that "free" checking account.

Believe it or not, there is similar nonsense in the GDP that says that if you do not own your own home, then you would be renting it from someone else. In those cases the GDP is revised upwards as if you rented your house from yourself. Given that close to 69% of the US owns their own home, the concept of paying oneself rent adds a decent chuck to the GDP. Unfortunately there are delays of close to two years on reporting of these distortions. I hope to have the next report on this, with actual figures, sometime in April.

So what does this mean? It means that a recession that seemed very unlikely a mere two weeks ago is now very much in the limelight. I am waiting to see the revision to the revision of the revision but if the next revision comes in at or below +2.5% then the first sub +2.0% will likely have me declaring the start of an "unofficial recession".

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Tuesday, 13 February 2007

Focus on Currencies (part 2 of 2)

This is part 2 of Focus on Currencies. Focus on Currencies (part 1) covered Technical Analysis, Politics, and the Commitment of Traders report (speculation vs. hedging) of futures. Part two covers the carry trade and currency fundamentals.

The Carry Trade

Let's kick this section off with the question: What is the carry trade?
The answer comes from the San Francisco Fed in an article entitled Interest Rates, Carry Trades, and Exchange Rate Movements.
What is the carry trade?
In the most common version of this strategy, an investor borrows a given amount in a low-interest rate currency (the “funding” currency), converts the funds into a high-interest-rate currency (the “target” currency) and lends the resulting amount in the target currency at the higher interest rate.

According to economic theory, an investment strategy based on exploiting differences in interest rates across countries should yield no predictable profits. Consider two countries, one with a high interest rate, and the other with a low interest rate. According to another equilibrium condition of international financial markets called the “uncovered interest parity,” the difference in interest rates between the two countries simply reflects the rate at which investors expect the high-interest-rate currency to depreciate against the low-interest-rate currency. When this depreciation occurs, investors who borrowed a given amount in the low-interest rate currency and then lent it in the high-interest rate currency will find that their return is worth less. The uncovered interest parity condition implies, indeed, that investors should expect to receive no profits, as they should expect the return from lending in the high-interest-rate currency to be worth ultimately as much as the cost of borrowing in the low-interest-rate currency.

In practice, however, investors in international financial markets do seem able to make profits through such strategies.

Empirical evidence shows that currencies that are at a forward premium and that, correspondingly, have a low interest rate, actually tend, on average, to depreciate, not appreciate, as the theory of interest parity conditions predicts. Similarly, currencies that are at a forward discount and that, correspondingly, have a high interest rate, tend, on average, to appreciate, not depreciate.This anomaly, then, implies that an investor who enters a carry trade is quite likely to make predictable profits from two sources: the interest rate differential between two currencies and the appreciation of the high-interest rate currency that was originally bought at a forward discount.
In reference to the COT numbers on the Yen from part 1 ... The numbers might seem huge, after all $13,212,986,904 bet on shorting Yen futures sure looks like a big number, but in all likelihood is peanuts in the grand scheme of things. Expressed as $13.2 billion, it seems much smaller. Please consider Brad Sester's excellent article A trillion dollars gets my attention, whether it comes from the PBoC or the yen carry trade.
Tim Lee, of Pi Economics, reckons as much as $1 trillion may be staked on the yen carry trade. Were the yen ever to rise sharply (making the trade unprofitable), there could be hell to pay in the markets.

I suspect Gillian Tett would be far better positioned to guess the actual size of the yen carry trade than most. Her excellent FT article spells out the various ways cheap yen have influenced global markets -- and not just the obvious ones.

Just how large the carry trade is, nobody really knows ... But whatever the precise number, what is clear is that carry trades have been fueling the dash into risky assets in the past couple of years.

After all, with Japanese interest rates at rock bottom and the yen on a downward path, it has been frighteningly easy for any hedge fund to borrow in yen, invest in something yielding, say, 5 per cent a year, apply a bit of leverage and – hey presto – produce returns of 20 per cent, or more. Conversely, if an investment bank wants to create a collateralised debt obligation but cannot sell the riskiest debt tranche, it can put this on its own books – funded by ultra cheap yen. The yen has thus been tantamount to the ATM of the global credit world – spewing out (almost) free cash.


There is nothing like borrowing in a depreciating currency to buy the equity tranche of a CDO in a world where there are virtually no defaults. No wonder investment banks have been so profitable.

Of course, the biggest carry trader of them all is the Japanese government. It borrowed a lot of yen to buy something that yielded a bit under 5% a few years back.
That trade has paid off. Big Time. The MoF borrowed in depreciating yen to buy appreciating dollars -- and got a bit of carry in the process. And the MoF did it on a truly enormous scale.

A private investor might even want to start to take some profits ....

Bottom line: a ton of people -- the Japanese government and Japanese "real money" as well as the leveraged community -- are short yen and long higher carry currencies at a time when the yen is very, very weak by most historical standards.
In September of 2006 MarketThoughts.com had an interesting article called The Yen Carry Trade Revisited.
......The second great Yen carry trade began in the summer of 1995 and it did not end until October 1998 – when the Yen ended its decline by rising 15% in a week!

As for the current Yen carry trade, there is little evidence to believe that much of the borrowed Yen went into commodity speculation – as the decline of commodity prices in the last four months has generally not led to a higher Yen. More likely, the typical profile of the latest Yen carry trade participant is as follows:

1. A speculator who borrows or shorts Yen and use the money to invest in a higher-yielding asset (usually government bonds or CDs) in the U.S., UK, or countries in the Euro Zone. The days of using this money to invest in higher-yielding countries in “peripheral” developed countries like Iceland and New Zealand has definitely ended – given the crash in both of these currencies earlier this year.

2. A Japanese investor (e.g. a pension fund, a life insurer, or an individual investor) who converts his money from Yen to U.S. dollars (or the Euro or the Pound, etc.) in order to invest in Treasuries or overseas real estate. Note that this position is usually unhedged – which again puts further pressure on the Yen.

Quoting the IMF's “Financial Stability Report”:

The evidence that Japanese domestic investors conducted a form of the carry trade by seeking higher returns overseas is quite strong. Domestic institutions, such as life insurers, effectively engaged in the carry trade by purchasing foreign bonds to support yen-denominated liabilities, often on an unhedged basis. Net purchases of foreign bonds by life insurers totaled 848 billion yen ($7.4 billion) in 2005. Individual investors—particularly wealthier retired households — shifted a share of wealth away from bank deposits or other low-yielding yen investments, toward foreign bonds or investment trusts explicitly tied to foreign bonds (see the first figure). At its peak in late 2005, the money flowing into foreign bond funds exceeded 5 trillion yen over the trailing 12-month period, equivalent to about 1 percent of GDP.

Positioning on yen futures contracts also points to the existence of an offshore yen carry trade. Data from the Chicago Mercantile Exchange show noncommercial traders (predominantly financial players) moving from net long to net short yen positions in early 2005, and staying net short until the end of April 2006.
(Mish note: Speculators are hugely short Yen futures again as discussed above)

So the $64 trillion question is this: When will the Yen carry trade end? On a purchasing power parity basis, the Yen is undervalued against the U.S. Dollar, but massively undervalued against the Euro. That being said, things can always get more extreme before reversing – especially when it comes to the financial markets. Drawing a tentative up trend line from the previous lows in the Yen in early 1990, October 1998, and early 2002, and one gets a target range of approximately US$0.78 to US$0.82 (for every 100 Yen) before we see the Yen bottoming. But in all likelihood, it will need some kind of trigger. Just what is that trigger? I will discuss more about this as we approach the US$0.78 to US$0.82 range and my preferred timeframe (later this year), but for now, I am guessing lower-than-expected economic growth in Western Europe as the revision of the German VAT comes into play starting January 1, 2007. Historically, a goods & services tax has always meant a stronger-than-expected economic slowdown, and the German economy will be no different – despite the prevalent optimism among the German government at this point.
So now we have Japanese life insurers speculating in the carry trade. Isn't that special? One possible answer to the "$64 trillion question: When will the Yen carry trade end?" is that these things always seem to go on much longer and get more insane than any rational person deems likely. Such thinking suggests a possibility that the trendline break in the Yen (as noted in part one and repeated below) is a real one. Those following along carefully will note that is the opposite of what I suggested in part 1 in reference to the COT data (i.e. an unwinding of the futures positions is dollar negative on balance).

Yen / US Dollar (Monthly)



Fundamentals
  • All fiat currencies eventually head to zero. The only difference is the length of time it takes to get there.
  • Gold has never gone to zero and barring a star trek like replication device, or nanotechnology that can easily combine atoms to make elements, gold is not likely to head to zero either.
  • In the meantime the biggest factors that determine relative worth of currencies seem to be interest rate differentials, expansion of money and credit, and Foreign Direct Investment. The much ballyhooed trade deficit is far down the list.
  • When it comes to the Yen, the interest rate differential between Japan and the US or Japan and Great Britain is substantial.
  • Japan is also sitting on a national debt over150% of GDP. What that will eventually do to interest payments when rates rise should be obvious. The implication is Japan may have to raise taxes substantially smack in the face of poor demographics (shrinking population). Japan has lots of reasons to resist hiking rates. That is Yen negative.
  • Europe has demographic problems of its own. Europe also has a very rapid expansion of M3 but a much lower interest rate than the US. That is Euro negative vs. the US dollar.
  • Great Britain has a housing bubble of its own and will undoubtedly burst at some point. This should put pressure on the pound as expected rate hikes in the UK may not occur.
Everyone has a tendency to look at problems in the US in isolation. As you can see the issues are both many and complex. There is a lot more to currencies than the one sided view often heard "The US dollar sucks". This post is an attempt to look at things from as many angles as possible.

From a purely technical standpoint I would have to suggest "Trust the trendline breaks on the charts". From the standpoint of things almost always get crazier than anyone thinks, I am inclined to believe the Yen is likely to sink further then whipsaw massively. I suggested this quite some time ago and so far have been correct. From the explosive potential of the unwinding of the carry trade one should be watching those charts carefully.

From a political standpoint I am rather unimpressed with Paulson even as others seem to be going gaga just because he is "watching very, very carefully". From the standpoint of the US dollar in and of itself, things do not seem as bad on many standpoints as most seem to think, especially in relation to the Euro. Ultimately however, the fate of the dollar may depend on the timing, magnitude, and swiftness of the unwinding of the carry trade, and from what level that unwinding occurs. Taking quick action should something go wrong with whatever you are doing (in whatever direction you are doing it) seems like the best advice at this juncture given that the situation is potentially explosive in both directions.

Two Quick Notes:
  1. This post originally appeared in Whiskey & Gunpowder.
  2. Some of you have had trouble logging in to The Market Traders. If you signed up but could not get logged in, please try one more time. Click here to Email Mish about The Market Traders if you are still having problems getting on.
Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/