Wednesday, 1 August 2007

Chapter 11 for BZH?

The rumor mill says Beazer Homes is filing for chapter 11.
Here is yesterday's chart.
(click on chart for a sharper image)



At one point today BZH was down 40% to $8.10

Timing Award

I do not know whether the chapter 11 story is a rumor or a fact as BZH is now down a mere 20%. What I do know is that congratulations are in order to BZH insider Ian J. McCarthy who on November 14, 2006 exercised an option to buy 179,535 shares at $8.02 and on the same day unloaded all 179,535 shares for $43.07.

On April 17,2006 Ian J. McCarthy did the same thing with 13,149 shares. Ian J. McCarthy is the president and CEO of Beazer Homes. No doubt this was all part of a broader diversification strategy.

Addendum

Bloomberg is reporting Beazer Shares Plunge; Company Denies Bankruptcy Rumor.
Shares of Beazer Homes USA Inc., the homebuilder facing investigations by the FBI and securities regulators, plunged the most ever on speculation the homebuilder may file for bankruptcy. Beazer said in a statement there was no truth to the rumor.

"We do not know where these scurrilous and unfounded rumors started," Beazer said in a statement distributed by Business Wire.

Atlanta-based Beazer's shares fell $2.53, or 18 percent, to $11.46 as of 11:59 a.m. in New York, after earlier dropping as much as 42 percent to $8.10.

Beazer led shares of U.S. homebuilders lower. The worst housing slump in 16 years has left eight homebuilders nursing losses of $1.97 billion and expenses of more than $3.1 billion as property values fall and land purchases are abandoned. D.R. Horton Chairman Donald Horton said last week the housing market remains "challenging" because of a glut of inventory, higher interest rates and tight lending standards. Beazer last week reported a net loss of $123 million, or $3.20 a share.

"We're hearing Beazer is supposedly going bankrupt," said Michael Nasto, senior trader at U.S. Global Investors Inc., which manages $5 billion in San Antonio. "If in fact that comes to fruition, the market's going to be in a world of hurt."

FBI Probe

The Federal Bureau of Investigation said in March it was investigating Beazer for potential fraud after the Charlotte Observer newspaper reported the company sold homes to low-income buyers who couldn't afford them, financing the purchases with mortgages based on expectations the borrower's income would rise.
Addendum #2

I think a second addendum is a first for this blog but I feel obligated to report that Joe Snider at Moody's says Bankruptcy talk about Beazer is Much Ado About Nothing.
The company said last week it entered into a four-year $500 million revolving credit agreement and it expects to end the year with more than $300 million in cash.

"We're confident that what's going on today is much ado about nothing," said Joseph Snider, a senior credit officer at Moody's Investors Service in New York. "If anything, they're more liquid than they were before and they're coming into their fourth fiscal quarter of the year, where they generate the most cash. So we think it's just a bear raid on the company."

Beazer's $350 million of 8.38 percent notes due 2012 fell 6 cents on the dollar to 78 cents, according to Trace, the bond- price reporting system of the NASD.
Well perhaps this bankruptcy rumor is just that but inquiring mind just might be wondering if this is all "much ado about nothing".

Other inquiring minds might be just be wondering about that "strong fourth quarter" given that inventories are rising, prices are dropping, enormous numbers of ARMs are going to reset, and credit risk on homebuilders is rising. That is not exactly a friendly set of fundamentals.

But the most inquisitive of inquiring minds just might be asking "What was it that Joe Snider himself said about Beazer Homes just 5 days ago on July 26th?"

I am being flooded with telepathic questions. They all go something like this "Ok Mish, just what did Joe Snider say about Beazer Homes on July 26th?"

Let's take a look at an article in CNN Money called US Home Builders Further Darken Housing Outlook.
The picture was equally grim for Beazer, the country's seventh-largest builder, which has recently seen its stock fall because of a Securities and Exchange Commission investigation. The stock fell 8.7% Thursday to $15.56.

Beazer Homes said it cut prices to spur sales and took major charges to write down the value of unsold inventory. The company also announced a new $500 million revolving credit facility that was just half the size of the one it replaced.

Other home builders could see a similar reaction from creditors when they need to refinance existing facilities, said Joe Snider, vice president and senior credit officer for Moody's Investors Service. Companies may need to secure their credit revolvers or accept tighter restrictions.

"This is likely to have pretty significant consequences," he said of the industry's travails.
Joe Snider Recap 2007-08-01
  • "We're confident that what's going on today is much ado about nothing."
  • "If anything, they're more liquid than they were before and they're coming into their fourth fiscal quarter of the year, where they generate the most cash."
Joe Snider Recap 2007-07-26
  • Beazer Homes said it cut prices to spur sales and took major charges to write down the value of unsold inventory.
  • The company also announced a new $500 million revolving credit facility that was just half the size of the one it replaced.
  • Other home builders could see a similar reaction from creditors when they need to refinance existing facilities.
  • "This is likely to have pretty significant consequences," he said of the industry's travails.
Somehow we went from Beazer's being able to only secure half the credit line it originally had "is likely to have pretty significant consequences" to "If anything, they're more liquid than they were before" in the face of widening credit spreads and sinking stock prices, all in the course of the last 5 days. What an amazing turnaround in liquidity.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

one sided coins and unwanted tools

Bloomberg is reporting Italian Shopkeepers Blame Bankers for Losses on Derivatives.

Piera Levo and her husband, who run a 15-employee plumbing supply company in northeastern Italy, bought "insurance" against interest rate increases from UniCredit SpA in 2000.

Six years later, they paid 85,000 euros ($117,000) to extricate themselves from a derivative known as an interest-rate swap that is normally sold to large companies and fund managers. Derivatives are contracts whose value is based on that of another security, index or commodity, or linked to events such as changes in interest rates.

"I had no idea what I was getting into," Levo said.

[Mish comment: There's two more lessons for you. 1) Don't sign anything you don't understand and 2) When brokers offer to sell you insurance on complex debt instruments, run don't just walk away.]

Italian banks, including UniCredit and Banca Italease SpA, have sold swaps to as many as 100,000 small businesses, according to lawyers and industry groups. Concern about the contracts intensified last month, when Milan-based Italease said about 2,200 clients may lose 600 million euros on derivatives. Italy's central bank this week barred Italease from selling its most- profitable derivatives and ordered directors to resign.

The Bank of Italy estimates that non-financial companies had 3 billion euros of liabilities on derivatives at the end of 2006.

[Mish comment: we are coming striking close to finding out that it is indeed Madame Merriweather's Mudhut in Malaysia who the guarantor of those Italian loans. I am sure the same situation exists in the US. For more on the fine Madame, please see An email from Bernanke. Please read that if you haven't already. I believe you will find it very funny.]

Banks sold swaps to clients as insurance against rising rates. They also made lots of money. Commissions from sales of derivatives represented 48 percent of operating revenue at Italease in the fourth quarter, according to John Raymond, an analyst at CreditSights Inc. in London.

"These products are very lucrative," said Jacopo Ceccatelli, a former swaps trader who's now a consultant to two Italease clients who lost money on derivatives. "If a bank's sales force has to make their numbers, then this is a way of doing it."

[Mish question: Is lucrative the right word or is swindle?]

Italease leases everything from digging machinery to cars and real estate. The company's shares rose sixfold from its initial public offering in June 2005 to Feb. 9, 2007, as it increased leasing, and moved into mortgages and factoring. They have since plunged 72 percent.

Italease, controlled by investors led by Banca Popolare di Verona e Novara Scrl, sells derivatives from outside suppliers to clients with mortgages or leasing contracts. It has to cover losses if clients can't pay. The Bank of Italy estimates Italease will lose 500 million euros on derivatives contracts opened with clients, Italease said July 25.

[Mish comment: It seems we have found one "mudhut". There are many more. Q: Why did Italease plunge 72%? A: Because it is increasingly likely that it's guarantee to cover losses is worthless.]

Italease's sales pitch for the derivatives centered on the importance of insuring against changing rates, according to the text of a November 2006 presentation to potential buyers.

The bank also proposes a more complex structure based on the number of days an interest rate is lower than a stated barrier. Italease has an option to close the trade unilaterally and free of cost after the first year, a possibility denied to the client.

[Mish comment: There you have it: the famous one sided gold coin. Clever minds will quickly see this is not the same as a double headed or double tailed coin. This magic coin had one head on it. The other side is blank, in sort of a heads I win scenario, tails I get to cancel the deal. Now why didn't Bear Stearns think of that? Nonetheless Italease is somehow blowing up anyway, no doubt because of leverage or because too many other of its derivative bets are going to hell in a handbasket.]

Unwanted Tools

Meanwhile, back in the states, the Senate panel OKs China currency bill.
The US Senate Finance Committee voted 20-1 on Thursday to give the US government new tools to press China to raise the value of its currency, but the Bush administration said it opposed the bill.

The overwhelming vote shows Congress is headed toward passing legislation by a big enough margin to overcome any presidential veto, said Sen. Charles Schumer, a New York Democrat who helped craft the measure.

The bill's most significant provision requires the Commerce Department to take "currency undervaluation" into account when calculating anti-dumping duties on foreign goods, said Senate Finance Committee Max Baucus, a Montana Democrat.

That could lead to higher duties already in place on many Chinese products, and encourage US companies to seek new duties on additional Chinese goods.

The panel vote came just a few days before US Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson is headed back to Beijing for talks, including quicker action on currency reform.

"(We) do not believe the approaches taken in the bill reported today would strengthen the hand of the United States in achieving essential economic reform," the Treasury Department said in a statement.

[Mish translation: We don't want no stinkin tools.]

The yuan's value wasn't the cause of the deficit, Wu said at a dinner in Washington attended by Paulson and Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke in May. About 85 percent of China's surplus with the US is from foreign companies exporting products no longer made in the US, such as shoes, she added.

[Mish comment: Wu is 100% correct. The source of the deficit is wildcat us financing, a housing bubble, unsupportable consumption patterns by US consumers, etc.]

Sen. Charles Grassley, an Iowa Republican, said the legislation would force the Bush administration to stop "pussyfooting" on the issue by establishing clear criteria to identify countries with fundamentally misaligned currencies, and requiring penalties -- such as increased anti-dumping duties -- if they fail to make reforms within 90 days.

The bill also would require the Bush administration to take action through the International Monetary Fund and eventually the World Trade Organization against targeted countries that refuse to reform their currency policies.

Another provision would let the Federal Reserve intervene in global markets against the misaligned currency if the country has not made appropriate reforms one year after being cited by the United States.
Anyone who thinks a 25% tariff on goods from China will solve trade imbalances is simply nuts. Can consumers afford a 25% tariff on goods from China? The short answer is "no". A longer answer can be found in Price Wars as Wal-Mart recently slashed prices on 16,000 items. Obviously there is overcapacity and lack of demand at existing prices. Think about what would happen if Congress does override a presidential veto of such a bill.

A lesson from history: Smoot Hawley Tariff Act.
The Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act was signed into law on June 17, 1930, and raised U.S. tariffs on over 20,000 imported goods to record levels, and, in the opinion of most economists, worsened the Great Depression. Many countries retaliated, and American exports and imports plunged by more than half. The tariff was replaced by lower bilateral agreements in the mid 1930s.
The cause of the great depression is simple: There was a massive runup in credit, margin, leverage and speculation in the late 1920's. Does that sound familiar? It should. The Smoot Hawley Tariff Act made the great depression worse but it did not cause it as some believe.

Nonetheless, a Smoot Hawley enhanced recession might help clear out the malinvestments that resulted from the fiscal insanity of this administration's policies, policies at the Fed, and the Congressional spending of both parties.

With the right amount of luck (admittedly a massive amount) it could lead to a total revulsion of credit, a complete repudiation of the Fed, the restoration of sound money and sound fiscal policies. The alternative is a serial bubble blowing exhibition of ever larger bubbles that destroys all that is left of the middle class and culminates with a long retrenchment that drags things out for a decade.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Tuesday, 31 July 2007

Totally Discredited S&P

On 2007-07-31 American Home Mortgage went under. After receiving multiple margin calls, it simply ran out of cash. Bear in mind that just a couple weeks ago it "reaffirmed" its $.70 dividend. Today it was lights out. The stock was halted on Monday and sank 90% when trading resumed today. See Liquidity Crunch at American Home and Unable to Borrow for a recap.

Dave Donhoff at No Bull Mortgage sent me the following earlier today.
AHM/ABC Kapputt
From our clearing firm's office this AM;
Subject: Notice: American Brokers Conduit closes it's doors

Our office received a phone call this morning from the Operations Manager of American Brokers Conduit in Las Vegas, Nevada. They have ceased doing business as of this morning. They have no money for wires on loans that have already signed loan docs. Please contact our Rep, Sanja and she will see that your files are returned to you so you can place your loans with other lenders.
Dave posted this comment on The Market Traders: "This is significant as the first MAJOR A-paper mortgage bank, with significant volume and a huge brokerage base, to go belly up."

AHM is out of money and out of business. It's the end of the line for American Home Mortgage. Judging from insider sales, it seems only one insider, John A. Johnston (president Western Division) saw this coming and bailed. A few of the losses are staggering.

Absurdity at the S&P

The S&P is sure right on top of things as this 3:42 PM headline shows: S&P Puts AHM Rankings on Negative Watch. Wow. What a bold, stunning, and timely move by the S&P. Let's take a look.
Standard & Poor's Ratings Services on Tuesday placed its "average" residential prime ranking for American Home Mortgage Investment Corp. on credit watch with negative implications.

The ratings agency also removed the home lender from its "select servicer list."

S&P believes the company's financial troubles could result in higher turnover in its servicing operation and hurt servicing performance.
How clever of the S&P to figure out that a company that has stopped doing business might experience "higher turnover in its servicing operation and hurt servicing performance". That is simply stunning analysis. Who else could have figured that out?

Now that American Home Mortgage has ceased doing business, I suppose it's safe for the S&P to remove AHM from its "select servicer list". Does (or did) the S&P have a relationship with AHM and if so what was the nature of it? (I don't know, I'm simply asking).

Rating Company Disclosures
  • Moody's: "Moody's has no obligation to perform, and does not perform, due diligence."
  • S&P: “Any user of the information contained herein should not rely on any credit rating or other opinion contained herein in making any investment decision.”
In Fitch Discloses Its Fatally Flawed Rating Model I asked a series of questions and still have no answers. Here they are again.

Questions To Ponder
  • How many billions of dollars will be lost because of absurd pricing models?
  • How can it be that an entire system of investment decisions are based on ratings that the ratings companies tell everyone not to use for investment purposes?
  • Were the ratings companies grossly incompetent or just foolish?
  • Will the disclaimers of the ratings companies hold up in court?
  • How long will it be before there be a court test of those disclaimers?
  • Why has only a minuscule portion of subprime debt (2.1% or $12 billion of a massive $565.3 billion of subprime bonds) downgraded. See Stress Test.
  • Are the ratings companies under pressure by the banks and/or the Fed to not rerate this debt?
  • Why is it that ratings companies are allowed to have outside business relationships with the companies whose debt they rate?
  • Did banks realize how absurd those ratings were but look away because of greed and the ease in offloading he debt to pension plans, insurance companies, and hedge funds out of pure greed?
  • Heck, did the upper echelons at the ratings companies themselves know their ratings model was flawed and look the other way out of greed?
  • How long before there is a government sponsored bailout of this mess? Hint small ones are starting already. See Please - No More Help! for a discussion.
  • How long before Bernanke starts cutting rates?
  • How high will gold prices rise when Bernanke starts cutting?
Here's the big question:
How big will the taxpayer bailout be?

Running Scared

Forbes has an interesting article out today called Running Scared.
On a day when another mortgage lender, American Home Mortgage, teetered toward liquidation, Standard & Poor's said the U.S. corporate bond market was officially speculative grade.

The big ratings agency said 50.7% of the corporate bond market is now rated speculative grade, the first time this has happened, marking a decade-long shift toward more aggressive finance strategies and the evolution of the leveraged finance market. S&P calls anything below BBB- "speculative," but most people just call it junk. These days, the market calls it scary.

S&P said the ratings mix of corporate bonds continues to deteriorate as firms borrow to buy back shares and make acquisitions, but the key factor to the deterioration is simply the sheer number of lower-rated bonds coming to market. Through the first half of 2007, 70% of 158 new issues were rated B, according to S&P research.

"It would not be surprising to see even more new speculative-grade entrants this year," wrote Diane Vazza, S&P's managing director of fixed-income research, in a note Tuesday. "Though firms may have to curtail leverage" to find buyers.
Without a doubt the S&P has made many huge mistakes recently in rating debt associated with mortgages. The models Moody's, Fitch, and the S&P used to rate mortgage debt are now thoroughly discredited. Worse yet is the fact that everyone of the rating companies refuse to downgrade all but 2%-3% of the worst mortgage debt. And putting American Home Mortgage on credit watch after it ceased business can only be considered bizarre.

The S&P says 50.7% of the corporate bond market is now rated speculative grade. What the S&P does not say is how much of the debt that is not rated speculative should be rated speculative. What the S&P also does not say is how much of the total debt it has rated is over rated.

According to Bloomberg "Almost 65 percent of the bonds in indexes that track subprime mortgage debt don't meet the ratings criteria in place when they were sold." The S&P is so freaking behind the curve in debt downgrades that a company has to cease doing business before being removed from its "select servicer list". So exactly who (and why) would anyone have any confidence in the S&P's ratings of damn near anything?

But whether or not the S&P, Moody's, or Fitch has the nerve to act, the credit markets won't sand still. American Home Mortgage sure proved that with a stunning 90% drop overnight.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

One Speech Two Interpretations

In Unable to Borrow I mentioned a speech by the Fed's Poole. Minutes later a second version of the same story hit the news. Here are the headlines and stories.

From MarketWatch

Fed won't ride to rescue of upset markets: Poole
Last Update: 1:30 PM ET Jul 31, 2007
Financial markets understand that the Federal Reserve will not respond quickly to a typical financial market upset such as last week's sharp stock sell off, said St. Louis Fed President William Poole on Tuesday. Poole said the best policy for the Fed in cases of market turmoil is to be cautious and try to understand the reasons for the volatility. The Fed should only act "in due time" if evidence accumulates that the market upsets threaten to cause price stability or low unemployment, or when financial-market developments threaten market processes themselves, Poole said. "If the market believes that the Fed is always primed to adjust policy, then market participants will spend more time trying to second guess the Fed than trying to understand what is happening to business and household behavior," Poole said in a speech prepared for delivery at the University of Missouri.
From Reuters (14 minutes later)
Fed will act on market slide if warranted: Poole
Tuesday July 31, 1:44 pm ET
The U.S. central bank is still examining the impact of last week's stock market slide, but would act if this threatened its goals for inflation or employment, a top Federal Reserve official said on Tuesday. Poole said the Fed should not add to the uncertainty by making its own policy less predictable. But if it was convinced about the scale of the risks, it would not stand idle.

"The market understands, I believe, that the Fed will act in due time if and when evidence accumulates that action would be appropriate," he said.

"Most of these upsets stabilize on their own, but some do not. I'm not saying that the Fed should ignore what happened last week - we need to understand what is happening," he said.

Poole also said the decline in long-term interest rates last week as investors sought the sanctuary of U.S. Treasury bonds had helped to stabilize financial markets. He said that this was thanks to well-anchored inflation expectations.
What a difference reporting makes. Here is the key sentence:
"The market understands, I believe, that the Fed will act in due time if and when evidence accumulates that action would be appropriate," he said.

Essentially the Fed views a falling market as a threat. Of course a rising market, no matter how reckless or speculative is not a threat. Such is the nature of the misguided policies of the Fed that constantly blows bigger and bigger bubbles to cover up its own mistakes.

To top it off there is enormous hubris by Poole to think the Fed can control the market. See Can the Fed control prices? for a discussion of how the Fed is not really in control of prices or anything else.

Meanwhile another Bear Stearns hedge fund is in trouble.

15:22 *BEAR STEARNS FACES LOSSES FROM THIRD HEDGE FUND, WSJ SAYS
15:22 *BEAR STEARNS FUND HAS $900M IN MORTGAGE INVESTMENTS, WSJ SAYS
15:28 *BEAR STEARNS HALTS REDEMPTIONS ON ABS FUND, SPOKESMAN SAYS
15:28 *BEAR STEARNS FUND HAS $900M OF ASSETS UNDER MANAGEMENT
15:29 *BEAR STEARNS SAYS SUBPRIME LESS THAN 1% OF HEDGE FUND ASSETS
15:29 *BEAR STEARNS SPOKESMAN SAYS HEDGE FUND HAS NO DEBT
15:30 *BEAR STEARNS SPOKESMAN SPEAKS IN TELEPHONE INTERVIEW
15:31 *BEAR STEARNS SAYS HEDGE FUND REDEMPTION REQUESTS ROSE IN JULY

Six Questions
  • Want to stop serial bubble blowing?
  • Want to get rid of the Fed and its misguided policies?
  • Want to get rid of the IRS?
  • Want to restore sound monetary policies?
  • Want to restore sound fiscal policies?
  • Want a currency backed by gold as the constitution says?
One Answer

Vote for Ron Paul.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Unable to Borrow

Reuters is reporting American Home Mortgage unable to borrow.
American Home Mortgage Investment Corp., (AHM) a mortgage lender, said that it is unable to borrow under its bank lines and is looking at ways to raise money, including "the orderly liquidation of its assets."

The company said it has retained Milestone Advisors and Lazard to help it evaluate its strategic options.
MarketWatch is reporting American Home Mortgage Working To Resolve Liquidity Issues.
American Home Mortgage Investment Corp. (AHM) said Tuesday it is trying to resolve liquidity issues, which it said arose from disruptions in the secondary mortgage market. The Melville, N.Y., mortgage real-estate investment trust said Tuesday that lenders have initiated margin calls in response to the declining collateral value of certain loans and securities in its portfolio. American Home Mortgage has received and paid significant margin calls in the last three weeks and has substantial unpaid margin calls pending, the company said. The company said that, at present, it can't borrow on its credit facilities and couldn't fund its lending obligations Monday of about $300 million. It doesn't anticipate being able to fund about $450 million to $500 million Tuesday
Q: What happens when you are unable to borrow and can't fund margin calls and other obligations?
A: Something like this (except divided by 10) ...



AHM is currently sitting at a $1.10 (but changing rapidly now) having hit a low of $1.06, down 90% (overnight) from already depressed levels.

Obviously another chapter in the Liquidity Crunch at American Home is being written today. Eventually someone will buy them out at pennies on the dollar but the final chapter will no doubt be massive numbers of lawsuits.

No Poole Party

Earlier today Fed member Poole said Fed won't ride to rescue of upset markets.
Financial markets understand that the Federal Reserve will not respond quickly to a typical financial market upset such as last week's sharp stock sell off, said St. Louis Fed President William Poole on Tuesday. Poole said the best policy for the Fed in cases of market turmoil is to be cautious and try to understand the reasons for the volatility. The Fed should only act "in due time" if evidence accumulates that the market upsets threaten to cause price stability or low unemployment, or when financial-market developments threaten market processes themselves, Poole said. "If the market believes that the Fed is always primed to adjust policy, then market participants will spend more time trying to second guess the Fed than trying to understand what is happening to business and household behavior," Poole said in a speech prepared for delivery at the University of Missouri.
There is no such thing as "In Due Time". The Fed should not attempt to bail out the market place, ever, period. It is the repeated intervention over the years (otherwise known as the "Greenspan Put") that puts an unnatural bid on the market and promotes speculative behavior.

The foreclosures and the housing related blowups we see now are a direct result of the last party. The Fed managed to bailout lenders in the wake of a dotcom bust by slashing rates to 1%. What's next? I suggest the biggest party has already been thrown. There is no conceivable bailout coming that is going to create jobs and encourage reckless spending like housing did. It's the end of the line.

Today Poole says "No Party ... yet". What the Fed doesn't know is that few will be willing to put on those party hats when they next attempt to pass them out. Banks wont lend to poor credit risks and good credit risks will have no reason to borrow in a world awash in overcapacity. Cheap labor enhances the problem and will make it impossible for many consumers to pay back debts.

The party is over but a massive hangover is just starting.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Monday, 30 July 2007

Massive Bets On Idiots

CNN Money is reporting Fund manager's fun sailing away.
Hedge fund manager [John Devaney] whose fund ran into trouble from the sell-off in securities backed by subprime mortgages is having to put his huge yacht up for sale, seeking $23.5 million.

John Devaney, the CEO of United Capital Markets, a fund that specializes in buying and selling bonds that are backed by the mortgage payments, particularly adjustable rate subprime mortgages, has put his 142-foot yacht "Positive Carry" up for sale, according to a yacht broker's Web site.

Devaney's fund has run into trouble lately. A spokesman for the firm told Reuters on July 3 that it had stopped honoring request from some of its investors for redemptions, or withdrawal, of investments.

Devaney told Money magazine this spring that despite problems that the loans cause for borrowers, the assets backed by them provided a good return for his fund.

"The consumer has to be an idiot to take on those loans," he said. "But it has been one of our best-performing investments."

But with rising delinquency and default rates in the sector, investors have been scared away from the assets lately, hitting those like Devaney who made a big bet on the investment.

According to the yacht broker's listing, the yacht has accommodations for 10 passengers in its five staterooms, along with space for a crew of seven. Its amenities include his and her baths in the master suite, and four guest bathrooms with Jacuzzi tubs and showers and cherry wood interior throughout.

It has two 2,250-horsepower engines and a range of 3,500 nautical miles.

The New York Post reported Monday that Devaney is also seeking to sell a home in Aspen for $16.5 million.
Pure Arrogance

On 2007-05-02 Devaney spoke with CNN Money about How to get rich trading "idiot" loans.
The housing boom was good to John Devaney. Really good. He owns a Rolls-Royce, a Gulfstream Jet, a 12,000-square-foot mansion in Key Biscayne and a 143-foot yacht, as well as a few Renoirs and a valuable 1823 reproduction of the Declaration of Independence.

Devaney's not a developer, and he's certainly not a flipper. The 36-year-old CEO of United Capital Markets is a bond trader. And one of his specialties is buying and selling bonds that are backed by the mortgage payments of ordinary homeowners.

Option ARMs? Devaney loves 'em. "The consumer has to be an idiot to take on those loans," he says. "But it has been one of our best-performing investments."

"Some of the investors who bought CDOs certainly took on more risk than they thought," says John Weicher, a former assistant secretary of housing now at the Hudson Institute. But Devaney, who told a crowd of investors that the riskiest mortgage bonds looked "awful" before the crash, says he thinks he'll be buying. "I don't believe the carnage and fallout will be as bad as people think," he says.

Whether or not big investors come out okay, the damage is done for many homeowners. "The system allowed banks to create unsustainable loans that are going to haunt borrowers for years to come," says Allen Fishbein, director of credit and housing policy at the Consumer Federation of America. "Unlike the bank, the borrower has no way to lay off the risk."
Indeed "the damage is done". In more ways than one. Not only was he willing to bet on "idiots" willing to buy houses at ever absurd prices he was willing to roll the dice with OPM (other people's money) with that idea on his hedge fund. Why not? Hedge funds collects 20% of the profits and suffer 0% of the losses when they blow up.

Devaney, like Bear Stearns (whose High-Grade Structured Credit Strategies Enhanced Leverage Fund went to zero) has locked in investors and has stopped redemptions.

Devaney did NOT say this, but he may as well have: "You have to be an idiot to knowingly invest in a hedge fund that admittedly makes money by betting on the behavior of other idiots (with leverage), knowing full well that one or the other or both idiots is bound to blow up".

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Sunday, 29 July 2007

Liquidity Crunch at American Home (a complete recap)

Brian McAuley, my partner at Sitka Pacific Capital Management tells me that "things always happen when I am on the road". They sure did last week while I was in Vancouver for an Agora sponsored wealth symposium called "Rim of Fire".

The conference was about Crisis and Opportunity in the New Asian Era. It was a fantastic conference with speakers including Bill Bonner, Rick Rule, Nassim Taleb (author of The Black Swan) Frank Trotter (president of Everbank), Richard "Mogambo Guru" Daughty, James Kunstler, Paul Van Eden, Agora newsletter writers, and many more. A multitude of commodity oriented vendors were there (energy, base metals, gold, silver, nickel, uranium, copper, alternative energy). It was a fantastic conference and if you get a chance to go next year I think it would be worth your while to do so. Obviously my association with Agora makes my opinion somewhat biased but I am not getting anything per se for putting in this plug, nor was I asked to do it by Agora or anyone else.

With the conference going on, and not wanting to miss any sessions, it was a struggle trying to keep up with commenting on all the news about canceled IPOs, the falling stock market and other things. Saturday was a travel day and it was not until late Saturday evening that I saw what could be one of the stories of the year: a Liquidity Crunch at American Home Mortgage. This story had been brewing for a long time. And it worsened again this weekend, dramatically. Let's recap.

Recap of American Home Mortgage Woes

2007-06-29

Roof Caves In For American Home Mortgage

American Home Mortgage announced missed payments on loans will lead to a big second quarter loss just as concerns escalate that defaulting mortgages could roil the economy. Shares of American Home Mortgage (AHM) plummeted 2.51, or 12.0%, to $18.40, after the company yanked its second quarter guidance. American Home said "substantial" charges will push the company to a second quarter loss. Analysts were expecting earnings per share of 75 cents.
2007-07-19

AHM Plunges On Rumor Credit Line Yanked
American Home Mortgage Investment shares plunged 21% Thursday on rumors that a large lender had withdrawn a credit line. Keefe, Bruyette & Woods analyst Bose George said that the rumor circulating was that Lehman Brothers had pulled the company’s credit line, however, George said American Home doesn’t receive a credit line from Lehman Brothers and that American Home’s chief financial officer had denied the rumor.

Nonetheless, shares of the Melville, N.Y.-based company plunged 20.8%, or $2.83, to $10.76 at the close on Thursday, although it gained 3.2% in after-hours trading.
2007-07-20
American Home Mortgage Back On Track?
Talk about a rebound! Although American Home Mortgage Investment hasn’t recovered all of the value it lost when the stock plunged on Thursday following a rumor that Lehman Brothers had yanked its credit line, it has certainly made up lost ground.

Another boost to American Homes shares may have been a research note put out by RBC Capital Markets analyst James Ackor saying the stock tumbled on Thursday well below its value. While investors fear the investment banks that lend the company money might withdraw their credit lines, Ackor said he doesn’t believe they will.
2007-07-20
American Home Mortgage Holdings "outperform," target price raised
Analysts at RBC Capital Markets maintain their "outperform" rating on American Home Mortgage Holdings, while reducing their estimates for the company. The target price has been raised from $20 to $25.
2007-07-25
American Home Mortgage Plunge is Portfolio-Management Lesson
Thursday's selloff was evidently triggered by speculation the company was being denied access to short-term lines of credit, the lifeblood of a mortgage lender. When I contacted AHM, a spokeswoman said no credit line had been pulled. Apart from the speculation, there's little to explain why AHM stock has been punished so severely. Some bargain hunters stepped in Friday, and on the face of it, the stock screams "buy." The dividend yield is 22%, and the P/E is 7.7.

In June, AHM forecast a second-quarter loss and withdrew guidance for the year, but reaffirmed its dividend of 70 cents a share. It attributed the shortfall to rising delinquencies on mortgages it issued, a reduced demand for the mortgages it packages and sells to investors, and losses on loans it had to buy back under warranties extended to buyers. But it said these trends were stabilizing and had shown some improvement.

My initial recommendation was based on the good reputation of the company's management, its excellent liquidity and its lack of exposure to the subprime crisis. None of that has changed. But what started as a subprime-mortgage crisis is working its way through the financial system in some unexpected and unpredictable ways.
2007-07-26

AHM Infected By Subprime Problems.
The tentacles of the subprime mortgage debacle have now reached even further. American Home Mortgage Investment, which specializes in both prime and “Alt-A” loans, which are riskier than prime loans but safer than subprime loans, is laying off 500 employees nationwide Thursday.

A senior staffer at AHM, who only agreed to speak anonymously, told Forbes.com that in their office, which only has 100 employees, 25 positions are being cut. “The company is calling this ‘the largest lay-off in AHM company history’ and a necessary reaction to market trends,” the employee said. "Unless volume increases in the next 60 to 90 days, most feel these lay-offs are only the beginning and additional lay-offs seem inevitable."
2007-07-26
American Home Mortgage cuts more jobs
American Home Mortgage Investment Corp., the beleaguered Melville-based mortgage bank, has laid off another 228 employees, bringing to 428 the number of job cuts this month, a company spokeswoman said yesterday.

Several current and former employees numbered the total planned layoffs at 1,200, including the 448 already announced. The company would not respond to questions about future layoffs.

Another cause for concern is the company's delay in scheduling the release of second-quarter earnings. The earnings are due by early August and historically American Home has set a date two weeks in advance. But no such announcement has been made.

One possible reason for this, analysts said, is that market turbulence makes it more difficult for the company to determine the value of the $10.7 billion in loans it was carrying as "Off-balance sheet securities" at the end of fiscal 2006. Many of these loans carry higher credit risk than those the company bundles and sells to investors, and if market conditions cause their value to drop, the company will be required to take an earnings mark-down.
2007-07-27
American Home Mortgage Investment Corp. Delays Payment of Dividends
The quarterly cash dividend of $0.70 per share on the Company’s common stock had been declared on June 15, 2007 and was to be paid on July 27, 2007 to all shareholders of record as of July 9, 2007. The Series A Preferred Stock dividend and Series B Preferred Stock dividend had been declared on June 15, 2007 and are payable on July 31, 2007, to shareholders of record as of July 9, 2007.

American Home Mortgage Investment Corp. is a mortgage real estate investment trust (REIT) focused on earning net interest income from self-originated loans and mortgage-backed securities, and, through its taxable subsidiaries, from originating and selling mortgage loans and servicing mortgage loans for institutional investors.
2007-07-28
American Home Mortgage yanks dividend at last minute
In a sign of continuing tumult at American Home Mortgage Investment Corp., the troubled Melville-based mortgage bank announced at 10:19 p.m. Friday that it would not deliver the 70 cent per share dividend that was to be paid out that day of major write-downs in its loan portfolios.

Company officials made the move, which they called a delay, because, "The disruption in the credit markets in the past few weeks ... has caused major write-downs of its loan and security portfolios and consequently has caused significant margin calls with respect to its credit facilities," according to a release.

Dividends were pulled "in order to preserve liquidity until it obtains a better understanding of the impact that current market conditions in the mortgage industry and the broader credit market will have on the Company's balance sheet and overall liquidity," the company said.

The deadline for American Home's second-quarter earnings release is August 8, but the company has yet to set a date for that announcement.
2007-07-29
American Home Mortgage says faces margin calls
American Home Mortgage Investment Corp. said its lenders are demanding it put up more cash after the mortgage lender wrote down the value of its loan and security portfolios significantly.

The company said in a statement released late Friday that as a result of the margin calls from lenders, it has delayed paying dividends on its common stock, and plans to delay payments on its preferred shares.

Margin calls can create severe difficulty for a company that depends on funds from its lenders to finance loans, and can force the company to sell assets or seek other financing. If the company cannot generate enough money to satisfy its lenders, in the worst case scenario it can be forced to reorganize its debt or file for bankruptcy.
One has to laugh at the staunch belief that that American Home Mortgage could maintain a 22% dividend while the share price and spreading credit risks said otherwise. That 22% dividend is now 0%. About that PE... Well there are no earnings.

James B. Stewart at the WSJ put out a buy recommendation apparently based on the following ideas.
  • The carnage in the subprime-mortgage market should be reflected in its share price
  • The good reputation of the company's management
  • Its excellent liquidity
  • Its lack of exposure to the subprime crisis
Excellent liquidity?! In the face of the debacle at Bear Stearns how can anyone think there is (or recently was) excellent liquidity in ANY mortgage related stocks?

Or are Mortgage "REITs" supposedly different? Did Stewart not see the debacle at New Century Financial Corporation? Was there any doubt that things were spreading from subprime to Alt-A to Prime?

If American Home Mortgage is facing margin calls what does that say about its use of leverage? The next question then must be: what does that say about the company's management?

I happened to talk to a commercial real estate developer going back some 30 years at the Agora symposium late Friday. He was not a reader of my blog and had no idea I had written about Sam Zell in a Vital Lesson From Blackstone. But somehow we got to discussing the Florida condo situation and other real estate woes when all of a sudden he exclaimed, "Commercial real estate is through". I asked him why and he told me about cycles: Residential followed by commercial followed by industrial, and how they peak in that order. He went on to tell me about how Sam Zell marked the top in commercial and there was at most one year left or so in industrial. The developer I was speaking to "cashed out" over the past few years.

Perhaps it's time to review Debating the Flat Earth Society (Part 1) and Debating the Flat Earth Society (Part 2). In particular, let's take a look at the addendum of part 2 written December 28, 2006. Here goes:

I want to include a few comments from Professor John Succo on Minyanville:
As central banks rain liquidity (credit) down on markets, its long range effects eventually cause the very thing central banks are trying to avoid: deflation. The reason people don’t understand this is that it is cumulative: the accumulation of debt is in itself inflationary, but at a certain point it becomes unmanageable. Why is this?

Easy or free money (when central banks drive real interest rates below inflation rates) is irresistible. It wouldn’t be if people managed risk properly but they do not. Easy money causes competition for “projects” to increase: companies with free money take risk with it for less and less return. We are seeing deals getting done in LBO land and commercial real estate being built using very aggressive assumptions and low cap rates. With all that “money” out there rates of return drops dramatically. Everyone is starved for income.

At the very time that income and returns are dropping debt is increasing. Less income with more debt means that eventually it gets impossible to service that debt.
That was an on time, real time, warning from Professor Succo much along the lines of what I have been writing about in my deflation themes. The warning was virtually ignored by everyone. The arrogance in which it was ignored caused a total 100% wipeout of Bear Stearns' High-Grade Structured Credit Strategies Enhanced Leverage Fund. Sadly, some Bear Stearns investors wanted out as early as January but Bear Stearns would not let them out. I am sure those assets were worth something (perhaps even 60% or more) in January or even March, but Bear Stearns halted redemptions and held on until the fund went to zero. Lawsuits will fly over this.

If the market dips a bit more, the buy the dip mantra will be sung loud and clear. I have no doubt it will be based on an absurd Fed Model and/or expected interest rate cuts by the Fed (see Rate Hike Odds Plunge - Gold Should Benefit). Of course the same people were singing the tune: The Fed hiking shows the economy is strong.

The Fed Model was thoroughly trashed by Hussman (see Tightening Cycle) but that will not slow down the number of comments on it one bit. Earnings?! forget about it. Where are earning headed in a slowing economy? What are the forward earnings of Merrill Lynch (MER) , Lehman (LEH), Goldman Sachs (GS), and Morgan Stanley (MS) going to look like when it becomes harder and harder to get pools of CDOs out the door and demand for leveraged buyouts dries up? The earnings of American Home Mortgage (AHM) effectively went negative. There is only one reason to buy major market indices here (a belief that he greater FOOL theory will be revived) because the case sure can't be made on fundamentals.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/