Sunday, 5 August 2007

Hell Fights Back

Yesterday we discussed the Pulte House From Hell. The August 13 BusinessWeek cover story Bonfire Of The Builders suggests that hell is fighting back.
Elizabeth and Armando Motto are living a real estate nightmare with a new breed of monster: the big homebuilder as lender. In November, 2005, the couple, who have four children, agreed to pay $540,000 for a newly built three-bedroom house in suburban Clarksburg, Md., near Washington, D.C. Rather than send them to a bank, the builder, Beazer Homes USA Inc. (BZH), offered to provide a mortgage itself in an arrangement of the sort that helped fuel the long housing boom across the country.

But when it appeared that the Mottos might not qualify financially for the loan, things took a troubling turn. Beazer, according to the couple, inflated the pair's earnings in loan-application documents by incorrectly stating they were collecting rental income from the house they were leaving.

"I don't want to misrepresent myself," Elizabeth said in e-mail correspondence with Beazer's outside mortgage service, dated July 14, 2006. But in the end, the couple signed the documents, and soon after they closed on the Clarksburg house.

They now regret it. The Mottos moved to Clarksburg, but they haven't succeeded in unloading their previous home in Rockville, Md. They have nearly $1 million in mortgage debt on the two dwellings. With $145,000 in family income, Elizabeth says, they are "on the brink of foreclosure" on both houses. "We are so broke."

The Atlanta company has much more than the Mottos to worry about. On Aug. 1 its stock fell nearly 18% on rumors that it was preparing to file for Chapter 11 bankruptcy court protection—which Beazer swiftly denied, calling the Wall Street gossip "scurrilous and unfounded." Just five days earlier, Beazer revealed that the Securities & Exchange Commission had elevated an informal inquiry into its mortgage business to a formal investigation. The company warned that criminal penalties could follow. Earlier this year, Beazer received a subpoena from the Justice Dept. seeking documents related to its home loans, and the company is also under civil investigation by the North Carolina Attorney General's office.

Even as the housing supply began to exceed demand last year, builders kept sales brisk by pushing adjustable-rate, interest-only, and other risky loans. In some cases they attracted clientele who couldn't afford conventional mortgages. In others, builders allegedly violated federal lending standards to get customers to sign on the dotted line. KB Home (KBH) paid a record $3.2 million settlement in July, 2005, to resolve allegations by the Housing & Urban Development Dept. that the builder's mortgage unit overstated borrowers' income, among other practices, to obtain loan approvals. KB, which denied wrongdoing, sold its loan business before settling.
It's hard to feel truly sorry for anyone in living hell if that hell was a result of being a willing party to commit fraud. But sooner or later hell nearly always strikes back at everyone involved in fraudulent transactions.

Emails of the Mottos have now provided a smoking gun for the justice department, the North Carolina Attorney General's office, and the SEC to investigate. Expect shareholder lawsuits over this matter as well.

Desperation at Beazer or just complete foolishness?

In what is likely a foolish waste of money if not an act of pure desperation given all the investigatory and liquidity problems Beazer is facing, Beazer nonetheless declared a $.10 dividend on Friday.
August 03, 2007 12:00 PM Eastern Daylight Time Beazer Homes USA, Inc. (NYSE: BZH) (www.beazer.com) today announced that its Board of Directors has declared a quarterly cash dividend of ten cents ($0.10) per share of common stock. The cash dividend will be payable on September 21, 2007 to shareholders of record at the close of business on September 10, 2007.
With a tip of the hat to Minyanville for the idea, let's take a look at a 1 minute chart of BZH before and after the news.

BZH One Minute Chart



If that dividend announcement was an act of desperation, the market sure caught on quick and commenced voting with its feet.

Investing in Homebuilders is Foolish

Over the long haul shareholders never even profit but insiders sure do. Take a look at Beazer Insider Transactions. Massive numbers of shares were acquired by insiders for $0.00 and dumped on the market for whatever the insiders could get. Especially note the transactions of Ian J. McCarthy, CEO.

Builders build until they go bust. It's the same every cycle. They keep plowing all earnings into more and more land at artificially inflated prices until the Ponzi scheme finally blows up.

BZH Monthly Chart



Anyone who bought BZH from 2001 through 2007 is now underwater. Poof. And where were the dividends four years ago? Three years ago? This is why investing in homebuilders is a foolish proposition: they do not pay dividends when they can and should but attempt to do so smack in the middle of massive investigations and liquidity issues.

Insiders have made countless millions in the last six years. But those investing in the biggest housing boom in history lost money. Sure some playing the greater Fool's game made out, but for every one those, other investors holding for the "long haul" got clobbered with as much as 86% losses.

HOV Monthly Chart



Hovnarian (HOV) is now back to 2002 prices.

LEN Monthly Chart



Lennar (LEN) is hanging out just above 2002 prices.

WCI Weekly Chart



WCI just started trading publicly in Autumn of 2003. The weekly chart shows the entire history. But check out the arrogance of WCI turning down an offer at $22 as late as May 2007.
Earlier this year, WCI rejected an offer by Icahn to purchase the company for $22 a share, saying it was financially inadequate. His tender offer expired in May, without him buying any shares. At the time Icahn made his offer, WCI’s stock traded in the range of $20. WCI moved its annual meeting from June 15 to Aug. 30 to give it more time to entertain offers.

As WCI’s stock has taken a nose dive, some have questioned whether the company made a mistake when it rejected Icahn’s original offer.
Question? There is no question. Icahn clearly lost his mind to offer $22 for WCI but was bailed out because a bigger fool refused to take the offer. Add that to the list of lawsuits to be filed.

Meanwhile Back in Hell

While the debate continues about whether or not WCI should have taken the offer (or if the offer was even real as some conspiracy theory question), the mad scramble to turn out product as fast as possible has raised a significant amount of quality issues.

BusinessWeek is asking You Call This A Home?
The next boom for builders may be complaints from angry homeowners.

Residents of a new housing development in South Carolina fear that fumes from contaminated soil have caused dizziness and blackouts.

In Colorado, homeowners say they were led to believe they'd enjoy a recreational lake that never materialized, causing property values to slip. As the housing slump worsens, U.S. homebuilders increasingly find themselves fending off complaints of shoddy construction, unsavory sales tactics, and use of unsafe land.

Criterium Engineers, a Portland (Me.) building-inspection service active in 35 states, found that from 2003 to 2006 the number of new homes with "significant problems" rose more than 13%.

"Right now you're seeing the construction claims start to come in," he says, "but it'll take five to seven years" to get a full measure of the angry fallout. Anti-builder Web sites are proliferating, and two consumer groups, HomeOwners for Better Building and Homeowners Against Deficient Dwellings, are compiling online lists of beefs against developers.

The National Association of Home Builders says 55% of customer grievances concern caulking, paint, and other nitpicky issues.

Lennar Corp. (LEN ), another large builder, has drawn scrutiny in South Carolina. Residents of its new Pebble Creek development in North Charleston, such as Bill and Holly Hurley, say they have suffered from light-headedness, lethargy, and depression. Home inspections they commissioned showed unsafe levels of methane gas, which the Hurleys and others fear may be linked to possible soil contamination by a previous land owner.
Let's rephrase that statement by the NAHB as follows: The National Association of Home Builders admits nearly 50% of homeowner grievances are both valid and significant.

Unfortunately the NAHB provided no percentages for these questions: Of the 45% of grievances that are "not nitpicky", how many homeowners are happy with the resolution? How many are not happy about forced arbitration when the homebuilders get to pick the arbitrators?

Real Estate Gripe Sites
The above list compiled by and thanks to BusinessWeek.
Two images from the article (titles mine)

Pure Hell #1




Pure Hell #2




There is much more in the issue. I'm picking up a copy.

That said, in the back of my mind is the idea that magazine covers like these often mark major turning points. Then again, unless homebuilder sales pick up dramatically several of them (or more) are going under.

Perhaps the cover marks not a turning point but a major recognition point about how bad the problem is. As late as a couple weeks ago Paulson was talking about how "contained" the problem is. Well it's obviously not contained.

Another problem the builders face is that people are going to read the issue, see the problems, and be scared to death to buy from any builder in question. And then there is the problem of massive condo building in Florida with tens of thousands of units being built even as there are tens of thousands of units that nobody wants already sitting in inventory. Finally there is the problem of a severely slowing economy with unemployment rates poised to go up dramatically.

Bankruptcy is one way out for these homebuilders to stop the lawsuits cold turkey and walk away scot free of what some might say would be their moral obligations. No doubt some of these builders will soon find that option attractive. The only real question about bankrupt homebuilders is "Who's first?" As for "Who's to blame?" the list is long but start with the Fed and proceed to Congress and this administration.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Saturday, 4 August 2007

Pulte House From Hell

Following is an Email I received about the "Pulte House From Hell". It was interesting enough for me to post, but please bear in mind that time simply does not permit me to get involved in all such endeavors.

Before diving into the house from hell let me first mention The Plight of The Implode-O-Meter. Implode-O-Meter has been sued, a motion to strike has been denied, and anyone wanting to help and/or anyone seeking more information can click on the above link for more details.

The Pulte house from hell:
My name is Susan Sabin.

I currently live in a house I purchased from Pulte Homes. I moved in on June 16, 2006 and after 28 days started experiencing problems. Almost one year later, the damage has accelerated to the point I have lost my homeowners insurance and Pulte denies any responsibility. I am not the only person in a subdivision that Pulte has built throughout the United States that is experiencing the same treatment. The website My Pulte Experience documents my experiences in detail.

I am fighting a multi-billion dollar company that couldn't care less about me as a homeowner. Their treatment of me is the antithesis of their well defined campaign on customer satisfaction and delight. I have filed more complaints than I can count. I have gone to agencies and offices where most just offer a response similar to "what do you want me to do about it?"

If you would like to read more about my journey through hell, I was featured in the Money magazine in March 2007 (Shoddy construction), There are also two media broadcasts dated Nov 06 and June 07 on youtube.com where my house (and another homeowner with a defective house) was featured on KMBC 9 (local Kansas City).

Thank you for your time. I appreciate it.

Susan Sabin
Excerpts from Susan's Website: My Pulte Experience
Since the October 11th 2006 inspection, the living floor has bowed in three places which can be visually seen causing the wooden floor slats to begin to separate. There are more cracks in the drywall in various rooms in the house. The plumbing pipes are begin to show stress from being compressed by the floor rising. The ductwork and pipes from the furnace and the water heater are bending more as the floor rises. The stair way continues to separate from the wall, the boards are being pulled apart and the stair frame is splitting and cracking. The stair frame is also rising above the steps. This can be visually seen. The blue insulation strips that are placed in between the basement top and the framework continues to be 'spit' 'squeezed' from between the two. The bolts that hold the sump pump pipes to the wall are being pulled from the concrete and the concrete is also cracking off in small hunks. The hairline cracks have gotten larger and one of them leaks when ever it rains. The one gas pipe that leads to the furnace was replaced with a flexible pipe because of an impending safety issue.

When I first moved into this house, the floors did not squeak or sway. They shouldn't because a silent floor type material was used for the joists. Now (posting this October 26th 2006 ), when I walk across the room, things I have on my table jiggle or move. The mirror above my dresser in the master bedroom sways back and forth. The floor makes noises. Of course the reason for this is the floor is heaving in places, and the more it heaves upward, the more uneven it becomes. In addition there is no support for these joists. They are just 'out there' within nothing to rest on. Of course they can't rest on anything because they have been pushed up.

The Pulte lawyer has stated they (Pulte) don't believe my engineer's report. Pulte believes there is nothing wrong with the house that a few years of settling won't fix.

....

In the meantime, the damage gets worse on a daily basis. What is worse is that in my heart I know that Pulte knew there was a soil problem before this house was built. I live on a corner and there is only one other lot on this corner. Pulte chose not to build it after pouring the basement and the flatwork. They told me that it was because the lot had not sold, but since out of approximately ten houses being built mine and the one across the street were the only houses that were not speculative (spec), that doesn't pass the logic test. In addition the floor in the basement next to me is cracking and heaving AND there is no weight on the basement. I also noticed that Pulte has added extra pipes for drainage and run an extention cord to run the sump pump. This is not normal procedure for a house that is in the basement stage.

Because I have talked about the lot next to me that was halted after the basement/flatwork stage, I have decided to show some pictures. Click enter to take a peek! I have added some new pictures. We have had some horrific rains and the basement now looks like a pool!

A day or two after I posted the pictures of the basement, Pulte people were there fixing the sump pump and pumping out the water. I have just discovered ( June 23, 2007 ) the lot has been sold. Before the sold sign went on the placard (see pictures), Pulte had taken out the basement floor, they pushed dirt against the areas that have sunken to hide the "holes" and spruced it up. It is unfortunate the people who purchased this lot bought a house that has foundation problems even before the first board is nailed with a hammer.

...

The sale price of this house was $313,100. Incentives (another story) brought the sale price to $294,130.00. This was the appraised value of the house when I moved in June 16, 2006. The appraised value of the house on 1 January 2007 is $174,900 . This is a devaluation of the house of $119,230 in just SIX MONTHS!!!

Could I sell the house for $174,900? No. However, I was offered $40,000 for it a short time ago.

....
A Cure for Shoddy Work

Additional information can be found in the CNNMoney article The Cure for Shoddy Work. The dark side of the housing boom: too much subpar construction and renovation. But you don't have to simply sit and take it.....

But that was written back in March. Nothing has happened since then according to Susan.

Reply to Susan

Susan, other than publishing your story, and wishing you the best of luck, there is little that I can do for you other than to suggest getting the best real estate attorney that you can afford.

General Thoughts
  • For anyone that has purchased but not yet closed on a Pulte home, a Lennar home, a Meritage home, a KB Homes home, a Dominion home, Beazer, etc, etc, etc, and even a privately built custom home ..... consider hiring a home inspector before you close. Know what you are getting.
  • Consider renting until this all blows over.
  • If you have a down payment especially on a Florida condo (or any other property that will immediately put you hugely underwater), hire a good attorney and see if you have a legal reason to break the deal. If you can't break the deal legally, then consider walking away after consulting a legal professional about possible consequences.
  • If you bought a home but since realize you cannot afford it and have not yet closed, consider walking away from the deal after consulting a legal professional about possible consequences.
  • Be very leery of those who claim to find a renter for for your home, will save your home, will do a lease buyback or any other thing that seems too good to be true.
  • If it seems too good to be true, rest assured it is, no matter how hard anyone tries to convince you otherwise.
Market tops and fraud go hand in hand. We saw it with the dotcom bust, we saw it with housing and subprime lending, and we are seeing it happen yet again as I type. I am speaking of course about "buyout bingo" aka leveraged buyouts and other debt funded nonsense that is now starting to implode affecting a wide spectrum of financial equities and the market in general.

Nothing in this post to anyone or even in general should be taken as financial advice or advice of any kind. If you are having difficulty with housing or personal finances please consult your financial advisor and/or attorney for personal advice specific to your situation.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Friday, 3 August 2007

Martian Economists and BLS Moonbats

The BLS has released the July 2007 Employment Report.
Nonfarm payroll employment continued to trend up (+92,000) in July, and the unemployment rate (4.6 percent) was essentially unchanged, the Bureau of Labor Statistics of the U.S. Department of Labor reported today. Employment grew in several service-providing industries. Average hourly earnings rose by 6 cents, or 0.3 percent.
Report Highlights
  • Nonfarm Employment +92,000
  • Goods Producing -12,000
  • Construction -12,000
  • Manufacturing -2,000
  • Service Providing +104,000
Construction and manufacturing are a subset of goods producing so don't add the above numbers together. The trend however is clear: We keep losing higher paying jobs for lower paying service jobs.

In addition the average work week fell slightly to 33.8 hours from 33.9 hours. Average weekly earnings rose $.29 (or $15.08/year), not even enough to buy half a tank of gas for the average SUV.

Finally I would like to point out the peculiar way the report was worded. "Nonfarm payroll employment continued to trend up..." is quite a bit of cheerleading for such a weak number. +92,000 does not come close to keeping up with the birth rate and immigration. It takes close to 150,000 to do that. Thus far in 2007, employment has increased by an average of 136,000 per month compared with an average monthly gain of 189,000 in 2006 (and it took some amazing birth/death revisions to get there).

Birth Death Model Adds Another 26,000 Jobs



(click on chart for a sharper image)

Please see Employment on Pluto Rises for a recap of the absurd job assumptions by the BLS from January to June that has caused a huge overstatement of payroll employment thus far in 2007.

The current report shows the Birth/Death revision of +26,000 jobs. Perhaps that might seem reasonable, but really it's not. Take a look at January 2007. January and July are typically revision months where the BLS makes some effort to take away some of the overstated jobs in the previous five months. There was no such revision this month, and once again the BLS model added to construction jobs in the midst of an enormous slowdown in housing.

Following is an updated snip from the above link about Employment on Pluto.
The BLS is assuming not only that jobs were added, but that new unaccounted construction businesses were created in this environment (where business capex spending has been weak, housing has been horrid, and over 60 lenders have gone out of business or stopped writing loans.

Neither economist Paul Kasriel at the Northern Trust nor I find those revisions reasonable. The reason is simple. The idea behind the birth/death model is the birth and death of businesses (supposedly in relation to the business cycle).

Are new construction companies really being created in this environment or are they going out of business? If the latter, perhaps jobs should have been subtracted (not added) to construction businesses numbers.

With 150,000 construction jobs being added over the last five months by the BLS model, these reports look like they are from some other planet.
Economists On Mars

Supposedly this slowdown in jobs is "Good News". I base that statement on the Bloomberg article Job Gains Slow, Unemployment Rate Rises.
Employers in the U.S. added fewer jobs than forecast and the unemployment rate rose as the economy cooled in response to the worst housing recession in 16 years.

"We are still creating jobs right around a pace consistent with moderate growth," said Michael Feroli, an economist with JPMorgan Chase & Co. in New York and a former Fed forecaster. "We are getting a little bit of the slack that the Fed was looking for."

After the employment report, JPMorgan pushed back its forecast for when the Fed will change interest rates. The firm expects an increase in the middle of next year, compared with its prior prediction of around the end of this year.

Chairman Ben S. Bernanke "made it clear that the Fed has been trying to engineer a rise in the unemployment rate for a while," said Christopher Low, chief economist at FTN Financial in New York. "The modest rise in payrolls should also make them happy."
Economists Michael Feroli and Christopher Low must have been schooled on Mars, Pluto, or some asteroid belt near Jupiter. Here you go guys: Rising employment does not cause inflation. It never has and it never will. Yes, rising employment can be a result of rising inflation but the difference is significant.

The latter can happen when too much money (credit/debt) goes sloshing around creating all sorts of malinvestments such as bubbles in housing. The housing bubble in turn fueled a jobs boom that would not have happened had the Fed not slashed interest rates to 1%. We are in the aftermath right now and it's not pretty.

Nonetheless the moonbats at the BLS are still sticking have a model that seems to think small businesses are being created hand over fist even though lending standards have dramatically tightened, liquidity is rapidly drying up, and IPOs are going on hold. And for some unknown reason Plutoians hiding out at JPMorgan are sticking with a forecast that has rising interest rates even though the Fed Fund Futures have a 90% probability of a rate cut priced in.

Fed's Biggest Fear

The Fed's biggest fear should be of a collapsing economy, falling jobs, and a rising unemployment rate. And all three are going to happen. Look at the unemployment rate. It has bottomed and only has one way to go: up.


Already foreclosures are at record levels nearly everywhere. Clearly consumers are cash strapped. Even a modest 1% rise in the unemployment rate would wreck consumer's ability to meet debt obligations. All those who foolishly plowed into housing at absurd prices they could not afford (making wall street insiders filthy rich by unloading worthless CDOs for enormous fees to unsuspecting and/or greedy pension plans and insurance companies) are now facing margin calls of their own.

Essentially that is what is happening. Overleveraged consumers are now facing margin calls on their houses. For a while, home owners were able to meet those margin calls by borrowing still further against rising asset prices. Now that home prices are no longer rising, there is no means to make those margin calls. Rising unemployment is sure not going to help any.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Consumer Sentiment vs. Gasoline Prices

One of the bullish arguments that I have repeatedly heard during the latest pullback is that consumer sentiment shows how wrong I am. Indeed Reuters is reporting July consumer confidence at 6-year high.
Consumer confidence rose to a nearly six-year high in July as consumers perceived improvements in business conditions and the labor market, a report said on Tuesday. The Conference Board said its index of consumer sentiment rose to 112.6 in July, the highest reading since August 2001 and above an upwardly revised 105.3 in June.

"An improvement in business conditions and the job market has lifted consumers' spirits in July," said Lynn Franco, director of The Conference Board Consumer Research Center, in a press release.

The reading was well above expectations. The median forecast of economists polled by Reuters was for 105.0, up from an originally reported 103.9 in June.

"Looking ahead, consumers are more upbeat about short-term economic prospects, mainly the result of a decline in the number of pessimists, not an increase in the number of optimists. This rebound in confidence suggests economic activity may gather a little momentum in the coming months," Franco said.
Wow. That's stunning is it not? Wait a second. I think I mean perplexing. I do not know the exact nature of the survey but whatever it is I think it is seriously flawed. I can hear the chimes now "Of course you think it's flawed you are a bear".

My response is that "I think it's flawed because it is flawed, and I will offer proof . I have no legal background but in case I am wrong about it being flawed I offer this second opinion: Even if it's not flawed, the consumer confidence survey is useless."

Of course inquiring minds want to see that proof of that last statement. Let's tackle the useless part first. In Leading Economic Indicators I discussed the stock market, consumer sentiment, housing permits, money supply and the yield curve. It is surprising how few of those "leading indicators" actually lead. The post was made back in January so apologies offered for the fact that the following chat is not current but I think the idea is still valid.

As far as recessions go consumer confidence sure is not leading. More to the point, look at the chart and see countless dips below 0% with the stock market rising in most of them.

Inquiring minds no doubt are not convinced on such flimsy evidence (and who can blame them) so I propose we take a look at gasoline prices.

Gasoline Prices

I was thinking about the recent rise in consumer sentiment and I was asking "How can this be? What has changed? Is the economy really getting better? " Then it occurred to me that gasoline prices have been falling. That is odd given that crude prices have been rising and are near all time highs. Nonetheless consumers do not give a damn about crude prices. They do, however, care about gasoline prices. And gasoline prices here have recently fallen over $.45
(or more) even as crude prices are hitting all time highs.

Acting on a hunch I phoned "Bart" at NowAndFutures on Thursday and asked him to put together a chart of consumer sentiment vs. gasoline prices for me. Bart was happy to oblige. Thanks Bart. Here is that chart.

Wholesale Gasoline Prices vs. Consumer Sentiment



Mish notes: In the above chart, gasoline prices are declining in scale. The previous reference to a 6 year consumer confidence high is based on the Conference Board Consumer Research Center, not the University of Michigan consumer sentiment index (we used the data we had).

I expected an inverse correlation lately between the UOM sentiment index and gasoline prices but I sure did not expect a near perfect inverse correlation. I asked Bart to go back as far as he could to see if the correlation held. Bart took it back to 1995. From 1995 to 1999 there simply was no correlation. Could it be because gasoline prices were range bound between $.93 and $1.30 for those 5 years and now we have seen prices soar above $3.50?

Inquiring minds are no doubt asking "What happened? ". The above chart should make it clear: As gasoline prices rose above $2.00 (roughly January 2004), consumer sentiment based on the University of Michigan Survey has been perfectly inverse correlated to gasoline prices.

Many inquiring minds are still not convinced. They are saying "Mish, is that all you've got?" Actually I thought that was enough but yes I do have more. Please consider a recent NBC poll of consumer sentiment: America's Economic Mood: Gloomy.
Americans are feeling decidedly sour about the economy and those in charge of it.
More than two-thirds of Americans believe the U.S. economy is either in recession now or will be in the next year, a new Wall Street Journal/NBC News poll shows. That assessment comes despite the fact the economy has experienced sustained growth with low inflation and unemployment and generally rising stock values ever since the recession that ended early in President Bush's tenure.

In addition, the poll shows a lack of confidence in economic leaders. That includes not just Mr. Bush and Congress, both of whom have the approval of fewer than one-third of all Americans, but the financial industry, large corporations in general and energy, drug and insurance companies in particular.

"There's a combination of anxiety and loathing," Mr. Hart said. "There's a sense that every single one of these institutions is totally out for their own betterment, versus the public they serve."

The poll shows Wall Street itself is a target of public ire. Just 16% expressed substantial confidence in the financial industry, slightly below those expressing confidence in the energy industry (18%) or the pharmaceutical industry (17%). Large corporations (11%) and health-insurance companies in particular (10%) fared even worse.

One bright spot for the world of commerce: 54% of Americans expressed high confidence in small businesses, which tied with law-enforcement agencies for the second ranking behind the U.S. military among institutions rated by respondents.
For more on the NBC News Poll see point #2 of Glass Half Empty? in Kevin Depew's daily dose of "Five Things".

So there you have it:
  • The Consumer Confidence Board consumer sentiment index is at a 6 year high.
  • The University of Michigan index is nowhere near a six year high but is perfectly inverse correlated to gasoline prices ever since gasoline prices rose above $2.00 (January 2004).
  • The NBC news poll shows more than two-thirds of Americans believe the U.S. economy is either in recession now or will be in the next year.
Cast your votes please as to which if any of the above polls makes any sense.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Cold Feet and Sea Bass

Fear of risk is sending investors into retreat as cold feet become the factor.
The widening fallout in the U.S. mortgage industry has reminded investors of a risk they had forgotten: the fear of risk itself. Corporations are paying higher interest rates on their bonds, some private-equity firms are having trouble raising money to close big purchases, and the stock market has lost 7 percent of its value in less than two weeks — all mainly because of an exodus from risk.

“I would characterize it as a loss of excessive risk appetite," said Ian Lyngen, an interest-rate strategist at RBS Greenwich Capital. "There is a lot more apprehension about layering on riskier assets."

The meltdown of this comparatively small segment of the U.S. economy is contributing to a much bigger and broader issue: Lenders around the world are growing scared to lend.

"It is making people pull in their tolerance for risk," said Doug Sandler, Wachovia’s chief equity strategist. But Sandler thinks investors had been way too eager take on risk without enough compensation.

“We have the strongest global economy I’ve seen in my business lifetime today,” Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson — the former CEO of Goldman Sachs — told reporters in Beijing yesterday.

“There has been a change in attitude,” said Eric Thorne, investment strategist at Bryn Mawr Trust. “We were in a situation a couple of weeks ago where there wasn’t much that investors were worried about. It’s more a psychological impact of the lending environment in general.”

Two mortgage insurers said this week a $1 billion partnership created to invest in mortgage debt may now be worthless for that very reason.

The partnership — C-Bass LLC — insists nothing fundamental has changed and the credit quality in its portfolio remains intact. The only problem, it claims, is that it cannot come up with the cash to repay the skittish lenders who have demanded their money back.

"It’s just a broader fear," said Grubb & Ellis’s Bach. "That credit disruption has spread to the point where people are reluctant to make loans. What started in subprime mortgage has sort of transferred into other kinds of debt right now."
Key Ideas
  • Loss of excessive risk appetite
  • Lenders around the world are growing scared to lend
  • There has been a change in attitude
Oddly enough this change in risk appetite is occurring in what Paulson claims is "the strongest global economy I’ve seen in my business lifetime today". Then again if things can't get any better, they only have one way to go don't they? Certainly liquidity is not going to get any better than it was early this year when senseless leveraged buyouts could be funded with ease. It's also interesting that there are record numbers of foreclosures in the strongest global economy ever.

With those rising foreclosures, attitudes of consumers about consumption are changing as well. In spite of solid growth in the 2ns quarter, consumer spending is weakening.
Consumer spending grew just 1.3 percent in the second quarter, a dramatic falloff from the first quarter's 3.7 percent and the 3.4 percent growth in 2006.

Capital spending rose a lackluster 2.3 percent in the second quarter, a performance that looks good only in comparison to the anemic 0.3 percent growth in the first quarter or the decline of 4.9 percent in the last quarter of 2006.

Capital outlays were "on the weak side," said Merrill Lynch's Rosenberg, and, despite the higher-than-expected GDP reading, "we still believe that the weak handoff into the third quarter remains intact."

Rosenberg expects a sluggish 1.7 percent growth rate in the third quarter.
C-Bass Liquidity Problems

The Wall Street Journal is reporting a liquidity crisis for sea bass. Oops that's C-Bass not sea bass. Thankfully there's still plenty of water for our friend there on the left.

On the other hand C-Bass is liquidity challenged and flopping around like a wet fish on dry land hoping to find water as the following statements show:
C-BASS LLC, an affiliate of MGIC Investment Corporation (MTG) and Radian Group Inc. (RDN) today issued the following statement in response to the announcements made last night by MGIC and Radian regarding the liquidity challenges faced by C-BASS.

While nothing fundamentally has changed at C-BASS, like many other firms in the industry, the current severe state of disruption in the credit markets has caused C-BASS to be subject to an unprecedented amount of margin calls from our lenders. The frequency and magnitude of these calls have adversely affected our liquidity. To address this, C-BASS is in advanced discussions with a number of investors to provide increased liquidity and is exploring all options to mitigate the liquidity risk in this difficult market.

At the beginning of 2007, we had $302 million of liquidity, representing greater than 30% of our capital of $926 million. During the first 6 months of 2007, a very tumultuous time in the subprime mortgage market, C-BASS' disciplined liquidity strategy enabled the company to meet $290 million in lender margin calls. During the first 24 days of July alone, C-BASS met an additional $260 million of margin calls, representing greater than a 20% decline in the lender's value. We believe that nothing justifies this substantial amount of margin calls received in such a short period of time, particularly as there has been no change in the underlying fundamentals of our portfolio.
"There has been no change in the underlying fundamentals of our portfolio."

That statement seems laughable at first glance but it's possible. Let's see if this slight revision expresses the idea: "The underlying fundamentals of our portfolio were god awful from the beginning and they are still god awful today. What has changed is the willingness of lenders to slosh water on our gills. Liquidity is drying up and that is affecting our stock price."

MTG
(click on charts for a crisper image)



RDN



C-Blass claims a "disciplined liquidity strategy" enabled them to meet a total of $556 million in lender margin calls.

Two questions:
  • Is it possible to repeatedly have disciplined margin calls?
  • How much more discipline can C-Bass take?
Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Thursday, 2 August 2007

PPT Exposed (Part 2)

This morning I received numerous Emails from those reading PPT Exposed. Caroline Baum emailed me the same thing. Most are unprintable.

I did however, have this Email exchange with Trotsky (One of few who supported my position).

Mish to Trotsky:
PPT Exposed
I hope you find this hilarious.
It's supposed to be.
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/2007/08/ppt-exposed.html
A spoof "telepathic conversation" with "Bob" about the PPT (plunge protection team), Kennedy conspiracy theories, GATA (gold), and in fact conspiracies in general, all of which are poked fun at.
Mish
Trotsky to Mish:
absolutely! you've put your finger on the major flaws - namely how complicated those CT's are, and how apparently everybody involved has kept his mouth shut about them so far (an impossibility, which we can glean from the fact that the contents of the CIA's 'family jewels' collection were all well known in advance - due to the people involved NOT keeping their mouths shut).
Kevin Depew on Minyanvile Emailed "That's a great piece Mish". It was also Minyanville that alerted me to Barry Ritholtz's Big Picture Blog post Mystery Solved: Another Fat Thumbed Trader.
Turns out that 200 point swing was the reversing of a bulge-bracket firm trading error. The following is from a top 5 firm (rhymes with Sheryl), who plainly explains the source of the error, and how its unwind caused the reversal.

"Error at the bell last night (clarification): This error at the bell last night really did contribute to the rally. Bottom line is that one of our competitors inadvertently sold 5346 too many of the SPX Sep 1450 calls and needed to cover them in a hurry. At the time the mkt was down 1% on the day.

In covering, it is likely the crowd front ran the order, exaggerating the move.

Once the move got going, the variance hedging phenomenon kicked in. Most dealers place MOC (Mark on Close) orders to hedge their daily delta risk.

If this theory holds, then they would have put in large sell orders yesterday MOC at around 3:40PM. Once the mkt started to run, their delta position would've changed from net long to net short and they would have needed to buy that much more SPX exposure into the bell. Our index trading desk predicts that for every 2 pt move up in the SPU, dealers needed to buy approx 500MM notional in delta.

With liquidity being lousy right now, that created the violent move."
Barry went on to say: "That makes some sense to me."

But does it? Why couldn't Sheryl Flynch be making this stuff up? Alternatively, how can we be sure that Sheryl Flynch was not in on this from the get go? In fact, what was stopping Sheryl Flynch from purposely entering that order incorrectly on orders from the PPT knowing full well that the unwind of the trade would send futures soaring? How can anyone believe this was just an accident? Was someone on the grassy flow phoning Sheryl? BTW Who is this Sheryl Flynch in the first place? What do you really know about her Barry? Did you trace the call back to Flynch headquarters? If not, why not? Are you in on this too?

Seriously folks, I had a long conversation with Barry this afternoon. He believes as I do, the PPT exists but they seldom if ever act. As Barry pointed out to me in the phone call "a 70% Nasdaq plunge is hardly supportive of effective PPT action". I am also going to take the liberty of sharing an Email from Caroline Baum. "I don't dis the PPT because I think govt is virtuous. I don't. They are corrupt. It's just with his, the paper trail would be too long, and some $30,000 a year clearing clerk at the merc would take his proof to random house and get a $5 mln advance."

Nonetheless in spite of what Barry, Caroline, or I think, some additional proof came in this afternoon proving the PPT can and does act. In what could be the story of the year, Minyanville was able to get a hold of the asset allocation plan of various Fed members. If this is not proof that the PPT is taking action then what is?



The above chart copyright and courtesy of Minyanvile.

As convincing as that chart is, the cynical will suggest that it's just another spoof making fun of the PPT Religious Right (PPTRR).

On that note another telepathic message just came through loud and clear. Here is the message: "Mish it is quite obvious that you, Trotsky, Kevin Depew, Barry Ritholtz , Caroline Baum, The Big Picture Blog, and Bloomberg are all in on the conspiracy to cover up and/or make a mockery not only of the illegal actions of the PPT but more importantly of the PPTRR. We have little choice than to place your blog under watch for further slander of our fine group."

OK - enough of this stuff. Back to the economy and the markets.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

PPT Exposed

Tonight I am also pleased to announce the first ever telepathic thought line two way conversation (TTL2) with an inquiring reader. It was about the Plunge Protection Team (PPT). Here is the startling telepathic conversation in entirety with Bob.

Bob: Mish, did you see the PPT in action today?
Mish: You mean the late day bounce on 2007-08-01?

Bob: What else could I mean?
Mish: Was that the PPT?

Bob: Of course it was. Look at the chart.
Mish: A bounce on the 200 EMA was the PPT? Was this expected?

Bob: Heck yes it was expected. The PPT always shows up when expected.
Mish: Always? That's interesting. Did you play for it?

Bob: Are you kidding? Of course I did. Who wants to stand in front of the PPT?
Mish: So you bought right on the 200 MA?

Bob: Damn straight. I knew the PPT was waiting there.
Mish: What else has the PPT been buying?

Bob: Homebuilders. Isn't it obvious?
Mish: Homebuilders?

Bob: Yep. They have been buying homebuilders for months. And lenders like Countrywide Financial too.
Mish: Wow. That's stunning news. But it does not seem to be working very well does it? Look at BZH and AHM and CFC.

Bob: Don't get me started. Of course it's working. Share prices would be much lower if the PPT was not propping them up daily.
Mish: AHM would be lower than $1 if it was not propped up by the PPT? That's amazing. By the way, when was the last time the PPT was in serious action?

Bob: When the S&P hit 1520.
Mish: 1520? Wasn't that the 50 MA? And aren't we at 1460?

Bob: Don't get cute. They fail on purpose from time to time.
Mish: The PPT fails on purpose?

Bob: Of course they do. The PPT has to make it look like they don't exist. It's all part of the plan.
Mish: Wow. That's quite an elaborate plan. Did you buy at 1520?

Bob: Don't be silly Mish. Of course I did. You would have to be nuts not to buy where the PPT is buying?
Mish: What happened?

Bob: The PPT stepped aside so I had to bail. I figured the PPT would try again.
Mish: How unfortunate that the PPT would step aside right when everyone depended on them. Where did you figure the PPT would make another stand?

Bob: Mish you really don't get this PPT stuff at all do you? I bought right at the 200 MA where the PPT and 8,263 hedge funds were all waiting. Who wouldn't want to buy there?
Mish: Uh.. Thanks Bob for exposing the PPT.

I was hoping for additional proof about the PPT's actions. That proof was supposedly on its way but simply never made it through. I think sunspots must have been acting up because the telepathic connection quickly went into complete disarray. Nonetheless I am pleased to show the very last telepathic transmission that did make it through before the lines of communication were disrupted. The last message from Bob was this chart of the PPT in action.

Signature Actions of the PPT
(click on chart for a crisper image)



A tip of the hat goes to Bob for that stunning chart of the PPT in action, complete with planned failures.

Earlier this week I had been discussing the PPT with Caroline Baum. The discussion centered around her article Rubin Should Teach Paulson Secret PPT Handshake. She sent me a few priceless reader comments about that article. It seems Caroline and I are basically in violent agreement. I do not think the PPT intervenes on a day to day basis. In fact I think they only intervene under severe distress but I could only give one example.

That however was enough to be jokingly labeled a CT (conspiracy theorist) by Caroline Baum. She has a point, however, a very solid point. And if I had to choose between picking between an activist PPT and one that has never acted to date, I say this: Believe Baum.

I could only name a single instance in which I actually thought the PPT was involved (Spring 2000 on an enormous Nasdaq plunge that rectified itself). It was the nature of the rally (indiscriminate and massive buying of futures ridiculously above the market price of the underlying equities for a very considerable length of time). That is what I would expect from a PPT attempting to stabilize the market. I am open to being wrong about that instance.

Conspiracies Theories in General are Bunk

I think nearly all conspiracy theories are total bunk. I do not really want to drag politics into this debate but the Kennedy assassination CTs are absurd. Supposedly we are to believe there was someone firing from the grassy knoll, from an overpass, out of a manhole, and from a building to Kill Kennedy. In addition the plot was hatched by the CIA, the FBI, Russia, Cuba, and the US treasury. "Proof" was that Oswald could not have fired off all those shots in the timeframe allotted and could not have walked to the building in time in the first place.

I have met people that can fire those rounds in the allotted time, and it has been proven time and time again that Oswald could easily have walked the distance (in the allotted time) to the building where he fired shots. On the other hand, many of the suggested angles from the overpass, manhole, and even grassy knoll are virtually impossible.

The theories that the US government blew a hole in the Pentagon with a missile on 911 are so absurd that I refuse to even rebut them.

GATA Conspiracy Theories

But people believe what they want to believe. The fact remains that people like to believe conspiracy theories. This will not win kudos with much of the gold crowd but I feel the same way about GATA (Gold Anti Trust Action Committee) theories as well as various silver conspiracies I hear literally every week.

I have rebutted them in the past and so has "Trotsky". Speaking about GATA in Misconceptions about Gold Trotsky had this to say:
Many gold analysts, from the mainstream to fringe groups such as the Gold Anti-Trust Action Committee (GATA) claim that they can predict what the gold price will do by adding up annual fabrication and investment demand (as well as dehedging demand by miners) and contrasting the resulting total with annual supply (mine supply, central bank selling, disinvestment and scrap). In short, they analyze the gold market in the same manner as they would analyze the copper market.

It should be immediately obvious that this can't be correct. After all, nearly the entire gold ever mined (approximately 150,000-160,000 tons) is still here. In short, the total potential supply of gold is some 97-98% greater than the gold produced every year (approximately 2,600 tons).

On that basis it makes no sense to apply traditional commodity supply/demand analysis based on annualized trends in the gold market.

Simply put, there is a big difference between commodities that are effectively used up (aside from scrap residual returning to the market every year) and a commodity the indestructibility and durability of which inter alia made gold the 'money commodity' in the first place.
I would like to add that with futures there is a short for every long. It is impossible for there to be record long interest without there being record short interest. When prices are extended and delivery is not taken, corrections occur as part of normal market action during futures rollovers. But I think the best indicator of the conspiracy nonsense is the price of gold itself. Gold has little industrial demand yet its price has gone from $250 to over $650. If there was a conspiracy to hold down the price of gold, it sure as hell isn't working very well is it?

Occam's Razor

When confronted with issues like these I often turn to Occam's Razor which states that the explanation of any phenomenon should make as few assumptions as possible, eliminating, or "shaving off," those that make no difference in the observable predictions of the explanatory hypothesis or theory. In short, when given two equally valid explanations for a phenomenon, one should embrace the less complicated formulation.

I did not expect to be talking about conspiracy theories toady. Heck I never know what I am going to be talking about. But let's Compare Kennedy assassination theories.

Kennedy Conspiracy Theory

Kennedy was killed in a massive conspiracy by someone on the grassy knoll, someone from a manhole, someone on an overpass, and Oswald from a building window, all directed by orders from the CIA, FBI, Cuba, Russia, and the Treasury department, and perhaps even LBJ. Doctors that did the autopsy covered up the results as did the FBI and CIA with their bullet analysis. To dispose of Oswald before he talked, Jack Ruby was hired to kill Oswald by the same set of conspirators that hired Oswald to kill Kennedy. Everyone else involved in the conspiracy kept their mouths shut forever and ever.

Kennedy Nutcase Theory

Some nutcase (Oswald) with some unknown grudge killed Kennedy. Another nutcase (Ruby) seeking fame killed Oswald.

PPT Conspiracy Theory
  • The government created a good working plan to frequently stabilize the markets.
  • The government kept that plan quiet.
  • The government implemented that plan with the help of others (market makers, order takers, etc).
  • The participants in the plan all keep quiet about it.
  • The government plan is carried out to perfection.
  • The plan works so well that no one can even prove the existence of the plan.
  • The results mysteriously happen right near moving averages.
Massive Sheep Herding Theory
  • A 8,263+ hedge funds all have been trained over time to buy breakdowns especially at or near moving averages.
  • Loose monetary policy by the Fed has been supportive of that action.
So which is it? To believe the former you have to believe that this administration and/or this Fed can routinely carry out such a plan to perfection for 6 years running with no one willing to expose it. Making the problem even more difficult is the fact that most CTs think this administration and this Fed are both completely incompetent. It's time to face the facts. The PPT is simply not operating on a day to day or even a routine basis. In fact it's entirely possible, perhaps even likely, that it has never acted ever.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/