Tuesday, 30 October 2007

The Litigation Scorecard

Now that the World Series is over, many fans are suffering withdrawal symptoms over the need to keep a current scorecard of exciting day to day sports action. Weekend football just is not sufficient and Hockey belongs in Canada. Yes, there is basketball, but something is needed to replace baseball.

I have just the ticket: The Litigation Scorecard. Action has been fast and furious since October 18.

For example: Merrill Lynch (MER) and Countrywide (CFC) were both hit hard by their respective opponents in boxing matches earlier today. Earlier this month New Century was accused of illegal procedure in a football game with a young couple. Bank of America (BAC) stands accused of reneging in a high stakes Euchre Game. Details will follow but let's first consider the October Litigation Scorecard.

Litigation Scorecard
  • October 30 - Merrill Lynch (MER) hit with shareholder lawsuit
  • October 30 - Mozilo and Countrywide (CFC) hit with shareholder lawsuit
  • October 25 - American Home accuses Lehman Bros. (LEH) of hitting American Home below the belt with improper margin calls in July and demanding money the company says it did not owe.
  • October 24 - A couple sues New Century for illegal procedure in loan disclosure documents
  • October 24 - HSBC sued by Canadian firm Aastra Technologies Ltd. over asset-backed commercial paper investments. Aastra's puck (assets) have been frozen since August.
  • October 23 - American Home is accusing Bank of America (BAC) of reneging on swap agreements in a high stakes Euchre Game. American Home seeks $25 million for the reneg.
  • October 19 - Luminent Mortgage Capital Inc. (LUM) is seeking a penalty kick in an international soccer match with HSBC.
  • October 18 - Book publisher Unisystems Inc., on behalf of all all retirement plans that invested in State Street-managed bond funds sues State Street (STT) for being offsides in an investment gamble by investing pension plan funds meant for low-risk investments into high-risk mortgage-backed securities
  • October 06 - Fremont sued by Massachusetts attorney general for predatory lending encroachment
  • October 02 - In a battle between middle-heavyweights, State Street (STT) was Sued by Prudential (PRU) Over Subprime Losses
Litigation Details and Links

On October 30 Merrill Lynch was hit with shareholder lawsuit over subprime
An investor lawsuit has been filed against Merrill Lynch & Co Inc (MER.N), contending that the company issued false and misleading statements about its exposure to risky mortgage investments, the plaintiffs' lawyers said on Tuesday.

The complaint accused Merrill of issuing materially false and misleading statements about its financial exposure to collateralized debt obligations (CDOS) containing subprime mortgage securities.

The company's statements "were materially false due to their failure to inform the market of the ticking time bomb in the company's CDO portfolio due to the deteriorating subprime mortgage market," the complaint said.
On October 30, Countrywide shareholders sued CEO Mozilo, board
Countrywide Financial Corp Chief Executive Angelo Mozilo has been sued by a pension fund that accused the largest U.S. mortgage lender of helping executives pocket improper gains by artificially inflating its stock price through share buybacks.

The New England Teamsters & Trucking Industry Pension Fund accused Mozilo, other Countrywide executives and the company's board of directors of gross mismanagement for improperly using $2 billion of cash to repurchase stock.

It said the move allowed executives to sell $842 million of Countrywide shares at artificially high prices between April 2004 and October 2007, at the expense of ordinary shareholders.

In addition to Mozilo, the lawsuit names President and Chief Operating Officer David Sambol; Executive Managing Directors Carlos Garcia, Ranjit Kripalani and Andrew Gissinger III; Chief Legal Officer Sandor Samuels and Chief Financial Officer Eric Sieracki.

It also names board members Oscar Robertson, Michael Dougherty, Robert Donato, Jeffrey Cunningham, Harley Snyder, Martin Melone, Keith Russell, Robert Parry and former directors Stanford Kurland, Ben Enis, Edwin Heller, Henry Cisneros, Kathleen Brown, as well as Countrywide's auditor KPMG.
On October 25 American Home Sued Lehman Bros.
Bankrupt lender American Home Mortgage Investment Corp. has sued Lehman Bros., accusing the investment bank of essentially stealing from the company as it struggled to stay on its feet.

The lawsuit, filed Wednesday in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court in Wilmington, Del., accuses Lehman Bros. of hitting American Home with improper margin calls in July and demanding money the company says it did not owe.

When the Melville, N.Y.-based lender couldn't meet Lehman's second margin call, for $7 million, Lehman foreclosed on $84 million worth of subordinated notes issued in American Home's structured-finance operation.

"In so doing, Lehman Bros. did nothing short of 'stealing' property" of American Home, the company said.
Improper margin calls are clearly hitting below the belt.

Here's an interesting illegal procedure case from October 24: Couple sues subprime lender New Century Mortgage Co
A Lowell couple is suing their subprime mortgage lender in Hammond federal court in an attempt to rescind their $126,000 home-equity loan, alleging the company did not disclose the terms of the deal.

Kerry and Susan Burke argue the New Century Mortgage Co., which went bankrupt earlier this year amidst the subprime industry meltdown, should have disclosed their mortgage payments were due each month.

The case was filed by Chicago class-action lawyer Daniel Edelman, who said the Burkes and other people in the same situations could have their home-equity mortgages rescinded.

"If you can rescind it, you can have all the payments applied to the principal," Edelman said. "So it could solve your predatory lending problem."

The Burkes' case is based on a legal technicality. Although their mortgage paperwork states at least 11 times that the payments are monthly, a separate form called the Federal Truth-In-Lending Disclosure Statement does not explicitly make that statement.

The ability to rescind a mortgage for violating the Truth-in-Lending Act in this way only applies to home-equity loans, not mortgages used to buy new or existing homes.
On October 24, in a corporate hockey match, HSBC sued over asset-backed commercial paper, subprime
HSBC Holdings Plc’s Canadian unit became the first financial adviser in the country to be sued over investments in asset-backed commercial paper that were frozen following the U.S. subprime mortgage industry collapse.

Aastra Technologies Ltd., which makes telecommunications equipment, filed the suit today in Ontario Superior Court, alleging HSBC and adviser Nicolas Del Sorbo gave bad advice in recommending asset-backed commercial paper investments.

The assets have been frozen since August. Asset-backed commercial paper consists of short-term notes issued by special-purpose trusts created to hold longer-term investments.

Del Sorbo “acted negligently in failing to perform the necessary investigations'’ of the investments, Aastra said in its complaint. “But for Del Sorbo’s representations, Aastra would not have made the investment.'’
On October 23 American Home Units Sue BofA For $25M
Three affiliates of bankrupt American Home Mortgage Holdings Inc. have accused Bank of America NA of reneging on swap agreements in which they are entitled to more than $25 million.

Broadhollow Funding LLC, Melville Funding LLC and a unit of American Home filed an adversary suit on Monday in a Delaware bankruptcy court which seeks to hold BofA accountable for a shortfall in their sale of American Home...
I have inside knowledge on this one. I know for a fact that the game being played was Euchre. Those who guessed Bridge simply guessed incorrectly. $25 million for a reneg in Euchre is indeed quite high stakes.

On October 19th HSBC was sued over subprime bond valuation
U.K. banking group HSBC is being sued by U.S. real-estate fund Luminent Mortgage Capital Inc. over allegations the bank's U.S. mortgage-trading operations took advantage of the recent credit crisis to profit at the fund's expense, according to a report in the Wall Street Journal. Luminent is claiming that HSBC applied an improperly-low valuation to several subprime-mortgage bonds that were used as collateral for loans, the newspaper reported. The complaint says HSBC bought the bonds at a deep discount to their fair value, the Journal said.
On October 18th State St. Sued Over Subprime Investment "Gamble"
State Street Bank and Trust Co. and its advisory firm have been hit with a purported class action for allegedly investing pension plan funds meant for low-risk investments into high-risk mortgage-backed securities which tanked after the subprime mortgage meltdown.
On October 6th, Subprime lender Fremont sued under predator law
The Massachusetts attorney general's office has sued Fremont Investment and Loan, once the state's second-largest subprime lender, accusing it of using predatory lending practices to sell loans to some borrowers who eventually lost their homes or had to file bankruptcy.

The attorney general is seeking fines from Fremont for violating the state's 2004 antipredatory lending law, which bars lenders from making loans that customers are unable to pay, as well as compensation for borrowers.

In a statement, Fremont General Corp., the Brea, Calif., parent company of Fremont Investment, said that it continues to work with regulators around the country to modify loans for customers struggling to make their payments. The company said it is "regrettable that the Massachusetts attorney general has abandoned these cooperative efforts to help borrowers keep their homes."

The above is a clear case of encroachment. Fremont is accused of sticking its neck into disallowed territory.

On October 2 State Street Sued by Prudential Over Subprime Losses
Prudential Financial is suing State Street because of $80 million in losses in two State Street funds caused by "undisclosed, highly leveraged" investments including subprime mortgages. Prudential says the losses were in accounts held by 28,000 individuals in 165 retirement plans that it markets.
Obviously the above is a boxing match between two middle-heavyweights.

This is but a drop in the bucket of an upcoming firestorm of litigation. Have your scorecards ready. Be sure to keep track of all the penalties. Also note on your scorecards the sport or game being played.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Stock Buybacks: A Good Thing Or Slipped DISCs?

When a company announces share buybacks, is that a sign that good things are coming? Does management really know what it is doing? Do analysts following those CEOs know what they are doing? If a guy is a CEO he must know what he is doing, right?

Let's explore those questions starting with a February press release from Ambac (ABK), followed by set of Emails I received last weekend from a contact at Morgan Stanley. The Emails are about stock buybacks and internal research at Morgan Stanley related to Ambac.

Here is the press release from Ambac.
Feb. 12, 2007--Ambac Financial Group, Inc. (ABK) today announced the closing of 6.15% $400 million Directly-Issued Subordinated Capital Securities (DISCS(SM)). The DISCs were sold at a discount to par to yield 6.199%. Ambac will use all of the net proceeds from the offering and additional funds to purchase $400 million worth of shares of its common stock. The common stock will be purchased through an accelerated share repurchase agreement.
Morgan Stanley Comments Feb 2007
Ambac Financial announced AMC that they have closed on a $400mln offering of Directly-Issued Subordinated Capital Securities (DISCs).

This is a positive surprise since most investors did not expect/saw any meaningful share repurchases in 1Q06 or 4Q06.

Ken Zerbe is increasing his price target following his recent meeting with the CEO of ABK. Ken felt the meeting was positive and provided him with greater confidence in the long-term story of ABK. His price target increases from $98 to $100 and EPS estimates remain above the street at 2007 $7.97 and 2008 $8.78.
My contact at Morgan Stanley, who for obvious reasons wishes to remain anonymous made the following sarcastic comments at the time of the stock buyback announcement.
Ambac Financial, a New York-based insurance and financial services company, has just issued $400 million worth of new debt in complex hybrid debt notes, so-called Directly-Issued Subordinated Capital Securities (DISCs). ...

Why issue 400mln worth of debt to buy 400mln worth of stock, when one can issue 800mln worth of debt to buy 800mln worth of stock? Another question for another time would be: if the company generates so much extra cash flow to pay the very substantial cost of this transaction plus the very substantial interest on the debt, why not just buy the stock in the open market with its own cash?

Think about the complexity of the deal; think about the work that has been done by lawyers, underwriters, analysts, brokers, compliance people, technology professionals, etc. All of them need to be paid. Think about the very complex nature of this debt, which will be sitting in someone's books as an asset; think about all the even more complex derivatives that will be, without question, created based on this debt.

Heck, we should all be grateful to ABK: This deal, as absurd as it is, has done its small part to maintain all this complexity for another 15 minutes.
Inquiring minds are wondering what the CEO and former CEO (current director) were doing with their own money shortly after the buyback announcement.

Director (former CEO) Phillip B. Lassiter Dumps Shares



click on chart for a sharper image

Current CEO Robert Genader Dumps Shares



Click here for all Ambac insider transactions over the last 2 years


Ambac (ABK) Daily Chart



Flashback August 16, 2007

Morgan Stanley cuts Ambac target on possible CDO losses
The brokerage, which has an "overweight" rating on Ambac, cut its price target on the stock to $92 from $100 and said Ambac could face losses of $1.3 billion to $5.0 billion. Analyst Ken Zerbe said he was building in a subprime/CDO loss expectation of $1.8 billion pretax, which he assumed the company will take beginning in 2008 through 2011.
Let's do the Math

At current share prices Ambac has lost $200 million+- on share buybacks, not counting interest on the debt and transaction fees.

Meanwhile, former CEO Phillip B. Lassiter somehow had the foresight to dump $10.37 million worth of shares that would now be worth $5.18 million+-. In addition, current CEO Robert Genader had the foresight to dump $10.20 million worth of shares that would now be worth $5.00 million+-.

Clearly these guys are worth the big bucks because they alone know how to make these kind of mission critical decisions.

Non-Performance Rewarded

Professor David Nelson is asking Does Executive Compensation Pass the Smell Test?
Page after page has been written about Merrill Lynch (MER), the $8 bln loss and the failure of risk managers at not just Merrill but many of the U.S.' top financial institutions.

When Robert Nardelli was ousted as Chairman and Chief Executive of Home Depot (HD) he received over $200 mln in severance compensation. Now we find that Stan O’Neil, the controversial and soon to be ex-CEO of Merrill Lynch, would have received over $200 mln if there was a change of control at Mother Merrill.

With the company reeling from recent financial losses and the stock down significantly how does a shareholder maintain confidence that management is working on their behalf?
Forgive me for being so cynical but why should anyone think management is acting on behalf of shareholders? Time and time again, history has proven otherwise. Insider greed has never been greater.

What do we have to show for it?
  • Overbuilding of houses by homebuilders (TOL, WCI, PHM, DHOM, CTX, etc).
  • A "Dancing Price", SIV problems, and Enron Accounting at Citigroup (C).
  • Banking problems everywhere related to mortgages.
  • Two Bears Stearns (BSC) hedge funds go to zero.
  • Enormous shareholder dilution in the number of options granted to insiders at Google (GOOG), Broadcom (BRCM), and for that matter many tech companies.
  • Countrywide (CFC) CEO Mozilo cashes out $1 billion worth of stock a while running the company into the ground.
  • Earnings are "managed" to beat the street by a penny practically everywhere even if it means holding assets off the balance sheet, stuffing the channel with merchandise, playing games with pension assumptions, stretching to the limit accounting practices, etc..
  • Insiders have been bailing like mad, and in some instances borrowing money to do so.
  • Dividends are in the sewer.
If corporations want to align themselves with shareholders there are numerous things they can do. Here are four of them.

1) Increase dividends
2) Stop managing earnings
3) Reduce executive compensation
4) Reduce option expenses

Imagine there was one major homebuilder that instead of buying more and more land at ever increasing prices was instead paying huge dividends for the past 5 years. Who would be ahead of the game now? The answer should be clear, both the corporation and the shareholder. Arguably the CEO would be behind because of stock options.

Stock options encourage excessive risk taking to the point of ridiculousness. But when the inevitable collapse comes, the CEOs don't care, they have all cashed out hundreds of millions. In the case of Countrywide, over a $billion. It's sad to say, but in many corporations shares were repurchased with borrowed money even as insiders were bailing.

Question: With the company reeling from recent financial losses and the stock down significantly how does a shareholder maintain confidence that management is working on their behalf?

Answer: One can't. If you start with that assumption you will be far better off.

Addendum

Thanks to EconShift for the following information:

The selling plan used by the Director was implemented on Jan 31st, 2007. That was while the DISC was being finalized.

The selling plan for Genader was cleverly implemented after the fact on March 31st 2007.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Monday, 29 October 2007

Problems Delayed Are Not Problems Solved

Reuters is reporting Stressed US borrowers use plastic to delay default.
In August 2006, Reeves and her husband bought a $214,000 home with almost no money down, leaving them with a monthly payment of $1,636 -- higher than they planned on, especially with her husband's furniture sales job largely commission-based and business not good due to the U.S. housing slowdown.

But as part of her efforts to avoid defaulting on the mortgage, Reeves said she has "maxed out" all her credit cards, spending to the limit on basic needs. "Now all I'm doing is making the minimum monthly payments."

"When credit conditions dry up, marginal borrowers turn to plastic," said Merrill Lynch North American Economist David Rosenberg. "We're seeing signs of that already."

In an October 5 research note, Rosenberg called rising credit- card delinquency rates as the "next skeleton in the closet."

"Our biggest concern right now is that there are lot of people who will face a choice between bankruptcy or foreclosure," he said. "Either way, it's going to suck."

HOLDING OFF THE TIDE?

Nancy Barba -- a financial counselor at a local community group, the Resurrection Project -- helped Johari Reeves negotiate her latest attempt at a repayment schedule for her mortgage.

"The credit cards will be a problem later," Barba said. "But right now, the main concern is the house."
How much bad advice is being given by credit counselors to keep them in their homes? If Barba is any guide, perhaps a ton of it. Postponing problems is not a solution, it merely makes them worse. And certainly maxing out credit cards to pay the mortgage is not clear thinking.

In this case, the problem is the house. Reeves cannot afford it. With maxed out credit cards, a small reduction in a loan rate is not going to help much either given Barba's admission that "credit cards will be a problem later".

Reeves ought to be talking to a bankruptcy lawyer. Instead, Barba is doing everything possible to keep the albatross around Reeves' neck.

Barba says "Right now, the main concern is the house." In actuality, the main concern should be how to get rid of the house, not how to keep it. The house has to go. It can go now or it can go later after more money is wasted making minimum payments on credit cards.

Life would be so much simpler if Reeves started all over renting an apartment she and her husband can comfortably afford, while saving money for a rainy day (or a house they can afford sometime down the road). Instead they are paying usurious credit card rates and sinking further behind on a house that is likely declining in value.

Everyone is doing their part to make people debt slaves forever. Even financial counselors are in on the act.

Mike Shedlock / Mish

Sunday, 28 October 2007

Pent Up Housing Supply

Recent data shows U.S. Home Vacancies Rise to New Record.
A record 17.9 million U.S. homes stood empty in the third quarter as lenders took possession of a growing number of properties in foreclosure.

The figure is a 7.8 percent gain from a year ago, when 16.6 million properties were vacant, the U.S. Census Bureau said in a report today. About 2.07 million empty homes were for sale, compared with 1.94 million a year earlier, the report said.

New foreclosures have risen to a record, led by defaults in adjustable-rate loans to people with tainted or limited credit histories, according to the Mortgage Bankers Association. Home- price declines and tougher lending standards are making it difficult for owners who fall behind in mortgage payments to sell or refinance into better loans.

The U.S. homeownership rate fell for the fourth consecutive quarter to 68.1 percent, seasonally adjusted, from 68.9 percent a year ago, the report said.
Let's stop right there. Did you catch it?
  • A record 17.9 million U.S. homes stood empty in the third quarter.
  • A mere 2.07 million empty homes were for sale.
Let's do the math.
There are 15.83 million vacant homes just sitting there. How long can that last?

That is a huge potential supply of homes that for some reason or other is not listed yet. I suspect many of those are REOs (real estate owned ) by banks and mortgage companies like Countrywide. Every passing month those REOs sit on the books waiting for higher prices is lost property taxes, upkeep costs, and balance sheet impairment.

Every month the figures get worse. For example, Countrywide has 13,000+- REOs for sale, but they also have 82,000 foreclosures. That alone represents significant pent up supply as those foreclosures become REOs. See Option Arm & REO Problems At Countrywide for more information.

Add to that pent up supply are those with a second home who want to sell it as soon as they can "get even" on it. In the meantime those people are "content" to rent. That contentment will turn to sour milk given enough time, or any problems necessitating a sale sooner rather than later.

This kind of supply can last for years. In fact, as home prices sink, this kind of supply can grow as people become disgusted with the idea that "real estate prices always goes up".

The siren song from Realtors is that now is the best time to buy ever. Straight up it's easy to see that is a lie. The best time to buy was 10 or more years ago and the best time to sell was in 2005. It's still a long way down from here. Rising inventory, falling prices, and pent up supply should be proof enough.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Basket of Insanity at OPEC

I am somewhat leery of this news source, but let's presume for a moment that OPEC will study currency basket for pricing.
OPEC is likely to discuss creating a basket of currencies for oil pricing at its next summit due to the steady decline in the dollar, Venezuela's Energy Minister Rafael Ramirez said.

"The need to establish a basket of currencies ... will probably be a point of discussion in the next OPEC summit," Ramirez told reporters during an evening event in the presidential palace.
Consider for a moment the US Dollar Index
Here are the relative weightings
  • Euro 0.576
  • Yen 0.136
  • Sterling 0.119
  • Canadian Dollar 0.091
  • Swedish Kroner 0.042
  • Swiss Franc 0.036
Imagine that you were to buy gold and had to consider the value of the Swedish Kroner, the Yen, the Pound, etc. No one buys gold this way. Gold is priced in dollars but people go into the nearest gold dealer (or online dealer) and buy gold in whatever currency they want, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week. Pricing gold in a basket of currencies simply makes no sense. The quote is always in one currency, but the currency can be ANY major currency.

Pricing oil in a basket of currencies makes no sense either, even if one eliminates oddballs like the Swedish Kroner. I am assuming that "basket" means some sort of blended price just as the U.S. dollar index is.

People buy things with local currencies. It makes no more sense to price oil in a basket of currencies than it does to price a loaf of bread at the grocery store in a basket of currencies.

I expect dollar bears are gloating over this nonsense. However, even if OPEC was to proceed with this insanity, it simply would not change a thing. In less than a day there would be individual quotes for oil in any and every currency individually, just as there is now.

Practical Example of the Silliness of Basket Pricing

If bread or T-Bone steaks in the U.S. were priced in Euros (or a basket of currencies) tomorrow, would it change the price in dollars? The answer is of course not. All that would happen is that the frequency of quoted price changes would increase.

For example, if T-Bone steaks were advertised at $4.99 lb for a week they would remain on sale at $4.99 lb for as week even though a quote in Euros or a basket of currencies would change daily. It would not make any sense to advertise T-Bone steaks in a basket of currencies because no one is carrying a basket of currencies in their wallet or their checking accounts. It would also be enormously confusing to consumers.

Hopefully, this simple example shows it would actually be complete foolishness for butchers and bakers to price bread and steaks in a basket of currencies. The same applies to oil.

Pricing Units vs. Reserve Units

Pricing oil in Euros or Yen would not matter one bit. Given that currency conversions are instantaneous, 24 hours a day, 7 days a week, as a practical matter oil is already priced in any currency anyone wants. One does not need dollars to buy oil.

Furthermore, if one is sure the Yen or British Pound is going to rise vs. the dollar then one should hold Yen or Pounds (not dollars) to buy oil with. Yes, it really is that simple.

I have said this before and I will keep saying it until everyone understands it: It does not make any difference what currency oil is priced in, and that logic can be expanded to include baskets of currencies.

However, It does however matter where the oil producers hold their reserves. I failed to bring up this point in What Factors are Affecting the U.S. Dollar?

Pricing units are one thing, willingness to hold dollars is another. Indeed, decreasing willingness by the oil producers to hold dollars likely accounts for some of the recent strength of the Euro.

Furthermore, this decreased willingness by the oil producers (and other countries including China) to hold dollars is part of a growing anti-dollar sentiment. Sentiment, at least in the short term, is the most powerful force driving currencies.

Misguided Mad Dash Into Euros

Fundamentally speaking, the ongoing mad dash out of dollars into Euros is misguided.

My rationale is:
1) Europe is printing money faster than the U.S.
2) Credit in Europe is expanding as fast as in the U.S.
3) Interest rates are higher in the U.S. than Europe (at least for now).

A mad dash into Yen would make more sense from a monetary perspective, but that play is avoided because interest rates in Japan are too low.

Eventually, all currencies (except gold) go to zero. The only difference is the speed at which they get there. Warranted or not on relative merits, the U.S. dollar is winning the race among major currency pairs.

Politics Vs. Need

Let's return the article for one last look:

"The need to establish a basket of currencies ... will probably be a point of discussion in the next OPEC summit," Ramirez told reporters during an evening event in the presidential palace.

As discussed above there is absolutely no "need" for OPEC to do anything.

Given that both Venezuela and Iran already hold no dollar reserves, it is highly likely this story is nothing but a political ploy by Venezuela, with no practical relevance.

Ignoring the political aspects, if OPEC actually does have a discussion on pricing oil in a basket of currencies that is not dismissed in 1 minute flat, they are wasting time at best or proving themselves to be complete fools at worst.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Saturday, 27 October 2007

Drop in Revenue Growth at State and Federal Level

The White House budget chief is seeing a drop in revenue growth.
The federal government is seeing a drop in the rate of growth of revenue as the debt crisis starts to slow economic growth, said Jim Nussle, the White House Budget chief. Asked on CNBC if the White House was seeing a drop in revenue growth, Nussle replied: "we're starting to." Private and government economists are forecasting a slight slowing in the U.S. economy, but are not projecting a recession, Nussle said
In California Schwarzenegger's Fiscal Discipline Shattered by Subprime Slump
Four years after Arnold Schwarzenegger was elected governor of California, vowing to "tear up the state's credit card," the actor and former body-builder is about to charge $7 billion to taxpayers' accounts.
My Comment: Using the words "Fiscal Discipline" and "Arnold Schwarzenegger" in the same sentence together is a joke unless there is a "negative" in the sentence somewhere.
California is selling notes tomorrow due in eight months to help pay its bills until tax revenue comes in, the largest short-term loan since Schwarzenegger took office and almost five times more than last year. Debt is increasing after cash receipts fell $777 million below the state's projections during the first three months of the fiscal year that started July 1.
My comment: Selling bonds with a promise to pay back later is Schwarzenegger's answer to every problem. In March, Schwarzenegger asked for $500 billion to rebuild California.

Sound Bytes From The Above Link
  • It will take $500 billion to "rebuild California the way it ought to be".
  • $500 billion is "too big for people to digest, so you don't talk about that" even though he is talking about it.
  • California needs $500 billion even though it has "done tremendously with the revenue increases".
  • California will not issue less debt even if the economy slows.
  • California "could face lower tax revenues" but he opposes tax hikes.
The day of reckoning has now arrived. Will he keep spending money he does not have while refusing to hike taxes to pay for it all?
Schwarzenegger is losing the revenue cushion he used to plug budget deficits as home foreclosure rates increase at a faster pace than the rest of the country. The rise in IOUs is an early sign that finances are deteriorating after four years of revenue growth won credit-rating upgrades and spurred gains of more than 20 percent on California bonds.

"A California budget crisis is beginning to recur, and the big increase in short-term seasonal borrowing is the classic leading indicator," said Richard Larkin, a municipal bond analyst at J.B. Hanauer & Co., a Parsippany, New Jersey-based money manager that oversees $10 billion.
My comment: California never left a budget crisis. All it ever did was forestall the day of reckoning. Even that "plan" is now failing. It is going to take increasing revenue to be able to pay back the bonds that were already issued. Now what?
Schwarzenegger, 60, may have to cut spending, said H.D. Palmer, his budget spokesman. The state needs to borrow to shore up its reserves after ending last year with about $6 billion less in cash than fiscal 2006, Palmer said.
My comment: Schwarzenegger has vowed to not cut spending even if revenue growth slows. Schwarzenegger claims he will not raise taxes either. Right now, he is keeping his words. To get by he is playing various shell games.

His latest scheme is to use lottery proceeds to expand health care. Given that lottery proceeds now fund education, the governor's proposal would replace money from the lottery that now goes to education with funds from the state's general fund. Schwarzenegger did not say what would be used to fund the shortfall in the state's general fund.
In the three months ended Sept. 30, the state has spent $10.2 billion more than it received in taxes and fees, according to Controller John Chiang. Officials project a $6.1 billion budget gap in fiscal 2009 between mandated expenditures and projected revenue, up from $1.5 billion in the current year.
My comment: That's quite a feat for someone who vowed to "tear up the state's credit card".
No 'Upside'

Investors require an extra quarter of a percentage point in yield to own California debt instead of top-rated municipal bonds, down from a high of 63 basis points in July 2003, according to data on 20-year bonds compiled by Bloomberg. That was during the height of the budget crisis under Davis.

The bonds have gained 20.8 percent since Schwarzenegger took office in November 2003, compared with 19.9 percent for the broader municipal market, according to indexes compiled by New York-based Merrill Lynch & Co.

"There doesn't appear to be much upside potential,'' Brennan said.
My comment: No upside in California bonds is correct. California will likely default at some point, but that could be many years away. In the meantime however, Moody's, Fitch, and the S&P are going to have to start lowering California's debt rating. That will increase the state's borrowing costs looking ahead.
The state had the third-highest foreclosure rate in September, or one for every 253 households, according to RealtyTrac Inc., an Irvine, California-based company that has a database of more than 1 million properties from 2,500 U.S. counties. Only Nevada and Florida had higher foreclosure rates.

Home sales have declined 23 percent this year, the California Association of Realtors said Oct. 10. The trade group estimates a decline of 9 percent in 2008.
My comment: The foreclosure party in California is just beginning. Unemployment is going to rise and commercial real estate prices will plunge as well.
Schwarzenegger campaigned on a promise to rein in spending without raising taxes. "We tore up the credit card," he told lawmakers during his first State of the State speech in January 2004. "Never again will government be allowed to spend money it doesn't have. Never again will the state be allowed to borrow money to pay for its operating expenses."
My comment: Obviously every bit of that is a lie, except perhaps for not raising taxes.

Revenue drops are now being seen in many states, not just California. See Grim Forecast for State Budgets for more details.

Amazingly enough, no one sees a recession coming, even though it is likely we are already in one. I am not the only one who feels that way. U.S. "undoubtedly in recession" says Jim Rogers.

Officially, the U.S. is not in a recession, but housing already is and retail spending is quickly headed there. In real (inflation adjusted) terms, retail spending is also in a recession. Revenue declines are looking recessionary as well. Finally, the first 2 percent of GDP is hedonics and imputations and fictional reporting that increases every year.

Whoever the next president is will backdate the start of the recession as much as possible, to prove it did not start on their watch. So even if the official stats don't show it now, GDP will be revised to show it a couple years down the road. That is the way the game is played.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Friday, 26 October 2007

Mammoth Short Squeeze in Countrywide

Countrywide posted an enormous $1.2 billion loss but Mozilo's statement that Countrywide projects return to profit sent shorts scrambling for cover.
Countrywide's quarterly net loss, its first in 25 years, totaled $2.85 per share and reflected about $2.9 billion of write-downs and credit losses. A year earlier, profit was $647.6 million, or $1.03 per share. Analysts on average expected a loss of $1.65 per share, according to Reuters Estimates.

The company wrote down $1 billion related to capital market disruptions. It set aside $934.3 million for credit losses, up from $38 million a year earlier, as more borrowers fell behind on payments, particularly on adjustable-rate and prime home equity loans. Other credit costs totaled $981 million.

'PERFECT STORM'

Countrywide said the third quarter represented an "earnings trough." It forecast fourth-quarter profit of 25 cents to 75 cents per share, and a profitable 2008, with a 10 percent to 15 percent return on equity. It also said it has negotiated $18 billion of "highly reliable" new liquidity.

Countrywide said borrowers were behind in payments on 29.08 percent of subprime loans it services as of September 30, up from 23.71 percent in June. The delinquency rate rose to 5.76 percent from 4.56 percent on prime home equity loans, and to 4.41 percent from 3.35 percent on conventional first mortgages.

"We've seen the perfect storm," Chief Operating Officer David Sambol said on the conference call.
It appears that Countrywide attempted to throw in everything but the kitchen sink into those "one time losses". But even with that strategy it is premature for Countrywide to be acting as if the "perfect storm" is over. Those increases in delinquencies are going to translate into increased foreclosures and increased REOs (Real Estate Owned) sometime down the line.

One has to laugh at the statement that the third quarter represented an "earnings trough." After all, a $2.85 per share loss is quite a "trough". The estimate was a loss of $1.65 per share. It's quite amazing to see a $1.20 per share earnings miss be treated as such magnificent news.

In addition, Countrywide appears to be bragging about securing another $18 billion in "highly reliable" credit lines. Instead investors ought to be worried about the possibility that Countrywide will again need those credit lines.

Finally I am noting that S&P credit analysts downgraded Countrywide one notch to "BBB-plus", the third lowest investment grade. Why it is investment grade at all remains a mystery.

However, the market as spoken and those issues are now "tomorrow's business".

Today the market has responded as if it believes those "one time" charges are a thing of the past and the perfect storm is now over. We will see.

Meanwhile, practical investors are wondering if there is a practical way to look at earnings. Indeed there is. In case you missed it, here it is, from Mr. Practical himself.

Practical Earnings
Back in the 1960s stock analysts began to compute operating earnings. Companies were regularly reporting gains from activities separate from their core business, so analysts began subtracting gains and losses from earnings that they did not expect to repeat. In those days operating earnings were almost always less than net earnings so analysts were being more conservative by computing price to earnings ratios in this manner.

Since 1990 this relationship between operating earnings and net earnings has completely reversed: operating earnings are almost always higher than net earnings because companies regularly show losses that they say are not recurring. Yet for anyone who cares to open their eyes, those losses seem to recur very frequently.

If you really study today’s PE ratios and compare them to yesterday’s methods, stocks are at least 20% higher in valuation.

As today’s banks take “write-off” after write-off, some as large as last years total earnings, the market seems to be finally catching on that these losses are not one time and are the direct result of core business activities gone bad.

But don’t forget the manufacturing companies that are doing the same thing. We long ago gave up as archaic looking at dividend yields and book value as tools to value stocks.

Perhaps as a measure of risk, you should check your favorite stocks for these. Maybe it has a lot more downside than you guessed.

Mr. Practical
The bulls won today with a Microsoft (MSFT) and Countrywide Financial (CFC) sponsored love fest. Let's see how long it lasts.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/