Friday, 7 March 2008

Does Stability Breed Instability?

Reuters is reporting US corporate bond spreads approach widest on record.
Spreads on U.S. corporate bonds on Thursday approached their widest levels since the bankruptcy wave of 2002 on worries about hedge fund selling of a wide range of corporate, mortgage and municipal bonds.

Spreads, the extra yields that corporate bonds pay over US Treasuries, gapped out across the board, though banks and brokers were especially hard hit on fears of more writedowns as mortgage problems spread.

"Basically the gears of capitalism are pretty much grinding to a halt," said Mirko Mikelic, portfolio manager for Fifth Third Asset Management in Grand Rapids, Michigan. "What started as a little subprime problem has kind of morphed into a bigger problem for the bigger economy."

Average investment-grade spreads had closed on Wednesday at 264 basis points over Treasuries, just 8 basis points shy of a record set on Oct. 10, 2002, a year of massive bankruptcies, according to Merrill Lynch data going back to December 1996. Thursday's widening was likely to put the index at or close to a new record, analysts said.

"What's driving it is this massive deleveraging that's going on within some of the hedge funds and the mortgage bond funds," said Dan Sheppard, a director at Deutsche Bank Private Wealth Management in New York. "They can't make margin calls and so they're basically selling just about anything they can their hands on."

"The key problem here is just zero liquidity out there," said Fifth Third's Mikelic. "Investment banks are not wanting to provide any liquidity across the board -- not in muni market, not in the mortgage market, not in the corporate market."
Zero Hour 9:00 AM - I'm a rocket Man - Elton John

Zero Hour Liquidity Discussions
Tip of the hat to Elton John and Professor Bennet Sedacca for the "Zero Hour" concept.

Zero Hour Stability

Inquiring minds may be asking "Does Stability Breed Instability?" That's a good question. Sticking with the corporate bonds theme, please consider the following chart.

SWYSX (Schwab Yield Plus Select) Weekly Chart



click on chart for sharper image.

Just what does Schwab propose SWYSX to be?
Let's take a look at the fund summary. Emphasis is mine.
The investment seeks high current income with minimal changes in share price. The fund primarily invests in investment-grade bonds. It may invest in bonds from diverse market sectors based on changing economic, market, industry and issuer conditions. The fund may invest to 25% of assets in below investment-grade bonds that are rated, at the time of investment, at least B by at least one nationally recognized statistical rating organization (NRSRO) or are the unrated equivalent as determined by the investment adviser. It maintains an average portfolio duration of one year or less.
Carlyle Capital Misses More Margin Calls

Bloomberg is reporting Carlyle Fund Gets Default Notice After Margin Calls.
Carlyle Capital Corp. missed four of seven margin calls yesterday totaling more than $37 million, the Amsterdam-listed fund said today in a statement. The company expects to get at least one more notice of default related to the margin calls.

Started by David Rubenstein in 1987, Carlyle expanded its mortgage investments last year, selling $300 million of shares in Carlyle Capital. The fund used loans to buy about $22 billion of AAA rated mortgage debt issued by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, securities that Carlyle says have the "implied guarantee" of the U.S. government. Even those bonds have slumped, leading to the failure of hedge funds led by Peloton Partners LLP.

"The credit crisis is spilling over to the next asset class, agency bonds," said Philip Gisdakis, senior credit strategist at UniCredit SpA in Munich. "There's never just one cockroach. If you see one highly leveraged hedge fund going bust, then there's another on the way."

Carlyle said last month its agency mortgage securities "have the implied guarantee of the U.S. government and are expected to pay at par at maturity." The U.S. Treasury denied speculation today that the government will guarantee mortgage- backed bonds issued by Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, which are the two largest sources of American home financing.

The Carlyle fund eliminated its dividend and waived an incentive fee on Feb. 28 when it reported quarterly financial results, seeking to build liquidity as mortgage defaults in the U.S. rise.
Cockroach Theory

There never is just one. And when Carlyle eliminated its dividend and incentive fee (the latter normally 20% of profits), it is clearly sending out an SOS. Don't answer it. There are likely more cockroaches hiding.

Any fund so arrogant as to leverage illiquid investments like mortgages 32:1 deserves neither sympathy or cash.

Furthermore, Carlyle knows full well there is not a government guarantee on Fannie Mae or Freddie Mac. The statement is either a blatant lie or complete ignorance by Carlyle. Fed governor William Poole has stressed that point twice now. Please see Poole, Paulson, Bernanke on Bailouts and Bank Failures for proof.

Besides, what kind of manager leverages 32:1 on implicit, let alone explicit guarantees? Ambac (ABK) and MBIA (MBI) prove that even explicit guarantees may be worthless.

Does Stability Breed Instability?

Eventually it does. Stability Breeds Herding, Complacency, Leverage, and Risk Taking.

Seeking ever higher returns, companies like Carlyle leverage at 32:1. Funds like SWYSX resort to buying riskier and riskier bonds to maintain yield. Excessive risk taking leads to excessive complacency and ever compressing risk premiums.

Eventually it snaps. And a snap at 32:1 leverage can wreak a lot of havoc.

That is the process in which stability, given enough time, lays the groundwork for its own demise. We saw it first in housing, then corporate real estate, and now hedge funds. Leverage is going to continue to unwind and until that process completes, now is not the time to be taking excessive risks.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Unmitigated Disaster In Jobs

The February Jobs data is out. Unemployment magically dropped even as jobs unexpectedly declined.
Payrolls fell by 63,000, the biggest drop since March 2003, after a decline of 22,000 in January that was larger than initially estimated, the Labor Department said today in Washington. The jobless rate declined to 4.8 percent, reflecting a shrinking labor force as some people gave up looking for work.

Just before the jobs announcement, the Fed said it will expand two short-term auctions this month to $100 billion, from $60 billion, to address "heightened liquidity pressures in term funding markets."

Futures on the Chicago Board of Trade showed traders see a 32 percent chance that policy makers would lower the target rate for overnight lending between banks by 1 percentage point by their next scheduled meeting on March 18. The balance of bets was on a three-quarter-point reduction.
Heightened Liquidity Pressures

For more on heightened "liquidity pressures" please see Financial System Broken - Markets 'Utterly Unhinged' and Disconnect In Treasuries.

Fed to Increase TAF and Emergency Repos

Inquiring minds will be interested in emergency actions by the Fed hoping to restore liquidity. Please consider Fed To Increase TAF, Announces Up To $100 Billion In Term Repo Operations.
In an effort to inject liquidity into the market, the Federal Reserve announce Friday that it is upping the amount of credit offered through the Term Auction Facility (TAF) as well as kicking off a series of term repurchase transactions. The announcement came on the heels of a February employment report that revealed the biggest monthly job loss, a decline of 63,000, in over 5 years.

"The Federal Reserve will increase these auction sizes further if conditions warrant," the policymaking arm of the U.S. central bank said in a statement. "To provide increased certainty to market participants, the Federal Reserve will continue to conduct TAF auctions for at least the next six months unless evolving market conditions clearly indicate that such auctions are no longer necessary."

The Fed also announced a series of term repurchase transactions that will reach $100 billion. The agreements will allow "primary dealers may elect to deliver as collateral any of the types of securities--Treasury, agency debt, or agency mortgage-backed securities--that are eligible as collateral in conventional open market operations." The Fed added that they will increase the size of the repurchase operations "if conditions warrant."

"The Federal Reserve is in close consultation with foreign central bank counterparts concerning liquidity conditions in markets," the statement read.
February Jobs Report

With the above backdrop in mind, let's take a look at the February Jobs Report.

Nonfarm payroll employment edged down in February (-63,000), and the unemployment rate was essentially unchanged at 4.8 percent, the Bureau of Labor Statistics of the U.S. Department of Labor reported today. Employment fell in manufacturing, construction, and retail trade. Job growth continued in health care and in food services. Average hourly earnings rose by 5 cents, or 0.3 percent, over the month.

This notion of jobs "edging down" is preposterous. It takes about 150,000 jobs a month just to keep up with the birth rate and immigration. The loss of 63,000 jobs was an unmitigated disaster that cannot be hidden by obvious spin aimed to soften the blow.

Details Worse Than Headline Numbers
  • Construction Jobs Fell 39,000
  • Manufacturing Jobs Fell 52,000
  • Goods Producing Jobs Fell 89,000
  • Private Sector Jobs Fell 101,000
  • Government Jobs Rose 38,000
Construction jobs and Manufacturing jobs are subsets of goods producing jobs. Those jobs tend to be higher paying jobs. Leisure and hospitality added 21,000 jobs and those tend to be lower paying jobs. Worse yet, the government added 38,000 useless jobs. Without those government jobs, the headline would have read 101,000 jobs lost. Arguably the headline numbers should be about private sector jobs in any case.

The amazing thing is that this was all considered "unexpected". It was not unexpected in this corner. I talked about Commercial Slowdown A Disaster For Jobs just two days ago.

Household Survey Data

Magically the unemployment rate dropped in spite of the headline numbers and in spite of the fact that more people want a job than last month.



How did this magic happen?

From the BLS: "Both the civilian labor force, at 153.4 million, and the labor force participation rate, at 65.9 percent, declined in February."

Here is the same sentence in plain English. "The unemployment rate dropped because we stopped counting everyone who is unemployed."

Expect to see more of this kind of nonsense from the BLS and you will not be disappointed. Here is the picture in graphical form.

The "Unlabor" Force



click on chart for sharper image
The above chart shows the "unlabor" force to have risen by 644,000 "unworkers".

Birth Death Numbers Back In Outer Space

Last month there was a massive revision to the Birth/Death Model. Please see Jobs Contract as 2007 Job Growth Revised Away for more details.

This month, the BLS moonbats are back at it as the following chart shows:



click on chart for sharper image

Once again their birth/death model is somehow showing net jobs created by new businesses vs. businesses going out of business. This is preposterous especially in the financial and mortgage services sectors where countless thousands of small 1-5 person mortgage brokers and real estate brokers have ceased doing business.

This economy is clearly in contraction yet the BLS model has not figured it out yet.

One should not subtract those 135,000 jobs from the reported decline of 63,000 jobs because one set of numbers is seasonally adjusted and the other not. However, one can say that no matter how you look at it, this was an extremely weak jobs report, and that is even weaker when one goes digging through the details. It was indeed an unmitigated disaster.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Disconnect In Treasuries

Fixed rate mortgages have disconnected from 10-year treasuries.

I spoke about the disconnect yesterday in Financial System Broken - Markets 'Utterly Unhinged'. Please take a look if you have not yet done so. It's not just mortgages that are "unhinged". Our entire financial system is on the verge of locking up.

Curve Watchers Anonymous has asked to see a few pictures of exactly what's happening. That's a reasonable request, so let's take a look.

15 Year Fixed Mortgages vs. 10 Year Treasuries



click on chart for sharper image

15 year mortgages tend to track 10 year treasuries within a reasonable band. There was a major disconnect starting in January as treasury yields dropped but fixed rate mortgage rates soared. Neither Bernanke nor homeowners are pleased with this development.

A revolt on the long end of the curve (10 year and greater) is making matters even worse.

Bond Market Revolt On Long End



click on chart for sharper image

Note: The above chart is from yesterday. It is possible the revolt is over already. Blomberg is showing the 30-year long bond at 4.46 and the 10-year note at 3.50 this morning. Also this morning the Fed announced an emergency TAF increase to $100 billion and jobs were a disaster. That may have quieted the long end of the curve, at least for now. Except for this note, the text of this article remains as I wrote it yesterday.

The above chart clearly shows the start of a bond revolt at the long end of the curve. 10 year treasury yields (and even more so 30 year treasury yields) are refusing to follow the Fed Funds Rate lower. This is just a tiny revolt so far. Bernanke better be praying it does not get out of hand. I don't think it will but it could.

Both the widening spreads and the revolt are hampering moves of those hoping to refinance into fixed rate mortgages. Ironically, those in ARMs specifically tied to LIBOR are getting some relief, even though new loans do not appear to be picking up all of the yield drop in LIBOR.

What Is LIBOR?

LIBOR stands for London Interbank Offered Rate and it is the rate that banks charge each other for short term lending, overnight to as long as a year. 1 month LIBOR tends to closely track the Fed Funds Rate.

How are ARMs Rates Computed?

Answers.Com has a nice section on ARMs and how to compute the loan interest rate.
To compute the loan interest rate, the lender adds a margin to an index rate selected as the benchmark, or base rate. The most common indexes are the Constant Maturity Treasury (CMT) Index of Treasury issues with the same final maturity; the Treasury Bill index, based on the current auction yield of 3-month, 6-month or 1-year Treasury bills; the 12-month Moving Treasury Average, computed from the Treasury CMT index for the previous 12 months; the 11th District Cost of Funds Index, the weighted average cost of savings accounts, Federal Home Loan Bank advances, and other sources of funds paid by savings institutions in the 11th Federal Home Loan Bank district; the London Interbank Offered Rate (LIBOR), the rate major London banks charge each other for borrowings; the certificate of deposit (CD) index, the average rate earned by nationally traded certificates of deposit; and the bank Prime Rate, the rate banks charge their prime business borrowers. The most popular are the Treasury indexes, the 11th District Cost of Funds Index, and the LIBOR index. A popular variation of the adjustable-rate mortgage is the HYBRID ARM, in which the loan has a fixed interest rate for 3 to 10 years and thereafter adjusts according to market conditions.
Six Month LIBOR



click on chart for sharper image

5-1 ARMs National Average Yield



click on chart for sharper image

The above chart shows a national averages of 5-1 ARMs that may include points. Those loans may be tied to LIBOR, treasuries, or some other index so it is impossible to get a perfect bead on how big this disconnect is. However, on the assumption that most of those loans are tied to LIBOR, the spreads have widened when they should not be.

Interest Only Loans

We happen to be in an interest only loan tied to 1 month LIBOR. However, we make payments as if we were in a 15 year fixed loan (extra principle payments every month). Our spread is extremely low (125 basis points). One advantage of this type of loan is the flexibility to only pay interest should an emergency arise. A second advantage when the Fed is cutting, is a mortgage rate that drops right with those rate cuts. Obviously this latter point works both ways.

1 month LIBOR is currently sitting at 3.06. It was 3.10 or so at the beginning of the month when the interest rate for the month was set. That made our mortgage interest rate 4.35% (3.10+1.25).

If the Fed cuts 75 basis points in March as is priced in (assuming LIBOR drops 75 basis points along with it), our mortgage rate will drop to 3.6%.

If you can get an interest only LIBOR based loan with a good spread (and you have the discipline to make extra principal payments every month), ARMs are not a bad idea here. I am basing this statement on the belief that the Fed Funds Rate and LIBOR are going to go lower and stay lower longer than most think.

The problem is getting a good spread. On new loans it will take a sterling FICO score and probably a huge down payment to get a great spread.

It is also important to remember the "trap". One better be prepared to make higher interest payments if LIBOR acts wildly as it did last August (or if the Fed starts raising interest rates again). Our rate shot up to something like 7.5% for a couple months in the August credit crunch when LIBOR disconnected temporarily from the Fed Funds Rate.

With that in mind, if you are thinking of getting into an interest rate only loan because it is all you can afford, please don't do it. Things can happen.

Teaser Rates

If you look at Bankrate.Com or rates on Bloomberg provided by Bankrate.Com, you will see what appears to be some pretty good deals. For example, consider the following snapshot.



click on chart for sharper image

The odds are quite long that you cannot get those rates without paying an excessive number of points, are willing to make a huge down payment, have a tremendous FICO score, or possibly all of the preceding.

My friend Dave Donhoff at No Bull Mortgage had this to say about teaser rates: "Any company that pays to advertise on Bankrate.Com (or other such listing services) and gives an honest quote, is likely throwing money away. Furthermore, if rates look too good to be true, they are."

A Call To ARMs

Could the Fed specifically be targeting ARMs with their rate cuts? Yes, that is possible. Many ARMs (especially interest only loans and Pay Option ARMs) are tied to 1 month LIBOR. With $trillions in ARM mortgages about to reset, and with those underwater unable to refinance, Bernanke could very well be doing a slash and burn of both the Fed Funds Rate (and the US dollar) to help those stuck in ARMs, even if it is not helping those in fixed rate mortgages one iota.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Thursday, 6 March 2008

Citigroup's Reorganization Strategy Explained

Citigroup is reorganizing its Wealth Management Units and Mortgage Units. Let's see what we can learn about its silo busting and silo building strategies, starting with wealth management.

Reuters is reporting Citigroup reorganizes U.S. wealth management unit.
Citigroup Inc is reorganizing its U.S. wealth management unit to focus on helping clients based on their net worth, according to an internal memo dated Monday.

The largest U.S. bank will split the unit -- which includes its Smith Barney retail brokerage and its private bank -- into four segments, according to the memo from wealth management chief Sallie Krawcheck. These segments focus respectively on ultra-high net worth clients, high net worth clients, "emerging affluent" clients and institutional services, the memo said.

"Starting today, we will move from a 'silo-first' to a 'client-first' organization," Krawcheck said in the memo.
Exactly how does this eliminate silos? It seems to me that 4 silos were created out of one bigger silo. Worse yet, there is now duplication between silos. Are "high net worth" clients now second class citizens getting second class service or even second class advice? Does it take special skills to handle an "ultra-high net worth" client vs. a "high net worth" client? Does it take different skills to handle a "high net worth" client vs. an "emerging affluent" client? When someone moves up from "emerging affluent" to "high net worth" exactly what is the handoff procedure?

The best way to eliminate silos would be to sell the entire Smith Barney unit while something can be gotten for it. I said the same thing to GM about GMAC, but they pissed away time and money and still made the wrong decision to keep half of it.

Mortgage Unit Reorganized

The Street.Com is reporting Citigroup Retools Mortgage Operations.
Citigroup plans to reduce its U.S. residential mortgage assets by roughly $45 billion over the next 12 months, a 20% decrease from the end of 2007, and will cut the amount of new loans to be held in the portfolio by more than half in the next year.

In addition, Citi will combine all of its residential mortgage operations under the CitiMortgage name, including CitiMortgage, Citi Home Equity and Citi Residential Lending.

Citi will also integrate its middle office and support areas to serve first and second mortgage operations, organize its sales around customer segments and strengthen its ties with Citi Markets & Banking, which will be the primary provider of capital markets services to the U.S. mortgage business.

Bill Beckmann, president of CitiMortgage, said in a press release that the realignment "will create a simplified and streamlined organization that is more sharply focused on clients and able to direct resources to the business lines and customer segments with the highest growth potential.
Citigroup's Two Part Strategy Explained
  • Big silos will be split into small silos
  • Small silos will be combined into one big streamlined silo
This is an ingenious plan. Not many could have come up with it. It will be a travesty of justice if big bonuses are not handed out for this fine effort.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Financial System Broken - Markets 'Utterly Unhinged'

Bloomberg is reporting Mortgage Markets 'Utterly Unhinged'
Yields on agency mortgage-backed securities rose to their highest relative to U.S. Treasuries in 22 years as banks stepped up margin calls and concerns grew that the Federal Reserve may be unable to curb the credit slump.

The difference in yields, or spread, on the Bloomberg index for Fannie Mae's current-coupon, 30-year fixed-rate mortgage bonds and 10-year government notes widened about 7 basis points, to 223 basis points, the highest since 1986 and 89 basis points higher than Jan. 15. The spread helps determine the interest rate homeowners pay on new prime mortgages of $417,000 or less.

The markets have become "utterly unhinged," William O'Donnell, a UBS AG government bond strategist in Stamford, Connecticut, wrote in a note to clients today. A lack of liquidity has "led to stunning air-pockets in price levels."

"Everything is telling you the financial system is broken," Simon, whose Newport Beach, California-based unit of Allianz SE manages the world's largest bond fund, said in a telephone interview today. "Everybody's in de-levering mode."

The widening spreads prompted speculation the government may step in to support securities guaranteed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, said Tom di Galoma, head of U.S. Treasury trading in New York at Jefferies & Co., a brokerage for institutional investors. The Treasury Department said the rumor isn't true.

"The Fed can't really save the mortgage market," di Galoma said. "As they keep cutting, mortgage rates aren't going lower."
Let's take a look at the systemic rot that shows how and why the financial system is broken causing the markets to become unhinged.

Home Foreclosures Hit Record High

Yahoo Finance is reporting Industry Group Says Home Foreclosures at Record High Last Quarter.
The Mortgage Bankers Association, in a quarterly snapshot of the mortgage market released Thursday, said the proportion of all mortgages nationwide that fell into foreclosure shot up to a record high of 0.83 percent in the October-to-December quarter. That surpassed the previous high of 0.78 percent set in the prior quarter.

"Clearly it's the worst it's been," chief association economist Doug Duncan said in an interview with The Associated Press.

The delinquency rate for all mortgages climbed to 5.82 percent in the fourth quarter. That was up from the 5.59 percent in the third quarter and was the highest since 1985. Payments are considered delinquent if they are 30 or more days past due.

Homeowners with tarnished credit who have subprime adjustable-rate loans were the hardest hit. Foreclosures and late payments for these borrowers also swelled to all-time highs in the fourth quarter.

The percentage of subprime adjustable-rate mortgages that entered the foreclosure process soared to a record of 5.29 percent in the fourth quarter. That was up from 4.72 percent in the prior quarter, which had marked the previous high. Late payments skyrocketed to a record high of 20.02 percent in the fourth quarter, up from 18.81 percent -- the previous high -- in the third quarter.
Homeowner Equity Is Lowest Since 1945

The federal reserve report shows Homeowner Equity Dipping Below 50 Percent, the Lowest on Record.
Americans' percentage of equity in their homes fell below 50 percent for the first time on record since 1945, the Federal Reserve said Thursday. Homeowners' portion of equity slipped to downwardly revised 49.6 percent in the second quarter of 2007, the central bank reported in its quarterly U.S. Flow of Funds Accounts, and declined further to 47.9 percent in the fourth quarter -- the third straight quarter it was under 50 percent.

That marks the first time homeowners' debt on their houses exceeds their equity since the Fed started tracking the data in 1945. The total value of equity also fell for the third straight quarter to $9.65 trillion from a downwardly revised $9.93 trillion in the third quarter.

Moody's Economy.com estimates that 8.8 million homeowners, or about 10.3 percent of homes, will have zero or negative equity by the end of the month. Even more disturbing, about 13.8 million households, or 15.9 percent, will be "upside down" if prices fall 20 percent from their peak.

The latest Standard & Poor's/Case-Shiller index showed U.S. home prices plunging 8.9 percent in the final quarter of 2007 compared with a year ago, the steepest decline in the 20-year history of the index.
Owners Give Up

According to the Mortgage Bankers Association, Homeowners are giving up, walking away.
"We're seeing people give up even before they get to the reset because they couldn't afford the home in the first place," said Jay Brinkmann, vice president of research and economics for the Washington-based trade group.

"It comes down to an overstretching of buyers to get into homes they couldn't afford and an overextending of credit by lenders who were more willing to take risk," Brinkmann said.

Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae, the biggest U.S. mortgage finance companies, have posted their largest-ever losses as rising defaults boosted credit costs. Fannie Mae had a $3.55 billion loss in the fourth quarter, the Washington-based company said Feb. 27. Freddie Mac reported $2.45 billion fourth-quarter loss the following day.
Overleveraged Hedge Funds Are Blowing up

Hedge funds using 32 times leverage made bad nets on mortgage backed securities. Carlyle Capital Was Hit With Margin Calls And Default Notices.
Carlyle Capital Corp., a listed investment company managed by a unit of private-equity firm the Carlyle Group, added to worries about forced liquidations of residential mortgage-backed securities after failing to meet margin calls on its $21.7 billion portfolio Wednesday.
The worst Is Yet To Come

The Mortgage crisis is deepening. Rates on 1.5M home loans will reset this year.
The mortgage crisis seems to have no end and no solution, but that isn't stopping Ben Bernanke from trying.

Tuesday the Federal Reserve Chairman floated the idea that banks and investors should write off part of the loan principal for homeowners who find themselves owing more on their mortgages than their homes are worth.

"Although lenders and servicers have scaled up their efforts and adopted a wider variety of loss-mitigation techniques, more can, and should, be done," Bernanke told a meeting of the Independent Community Bankers of America. "Principal reductions that restore some equity for the homeowner may be a relatively more effective means of avoiding delinquency and foreclosure."

The idea was an instant dud with mortgage lenders, who say they already have big incentives to keep borrowers from defaulting. Wiping out some of the principal owed on homes would increase mortgage rates to all borrowers, they say, and could encourage more homeowners to default on loans to get lower payments.

Harry Glanz, co-founder of Capital Mortgage Funding in Southfield, says Bernanke's idea would do more harm than good.

"How is that going to happen without the next-door neighbor asking for the same thing?" Glanz asked. "It sounds good but, in all practicality, how are you going to put it into practice?"
Mortgage Market Action Explained

If you were by any chance wondering why mortgage rates were not following the Fed's slash and burn policy of lower rates, the long answer is above. The short answer is rising default risk.

But let's not be too gloomy here.

Other than overleverage, bad debts, sinking home prices, no jobs, shrinking wages, cash strapped US consumers, rising oil prices, a sinking US dollar, $500 trillion in derivatives not marked to market, rampant overcapacity, underfunded pension plans, looming boomer retirements, no funding for Medicaid, no funding for Medicare, and no Social Security trust fund, everything is just fine.

And even though the Fed, central bankers in general, and governments combined to create this problem, the irony is nearly everyone is begging for them to fix the problem by encouraging still more speculation in housing, commercial real estate, and the markets.

Sorry folks, it's the end of the line and payback time for the world's most reckless financial experiment in history. The deflation genie can't be put back in the bottle until leverage everywhere is unwound.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Is Citigroup's Dividend Safe?

Dateline March 4 2008: Citi Falls on Worries About Cash Levels.
Citigroup shares sank to their lowest level in more than nine years, as stockholders recoiled at forecasts of more losses at the troubled bank and comments from a Middle East fund executive that Citi must raise more cash to stay in business.

Samir al-Ansari, chief executive of the $13 billion government-owned investment firm Dubai International Capital, said Tuesday at a private equity conference that it will take more than the combined efforts of the Gulf's wealthiest investors -- the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority, the Kuwait Investment Authority and Saudi Prince Alwaleed bin Talal -- to save Citigroup.
Interesting Statement

That was an interesting statement by Dubai International Capital given the Abu Dhabi Investment Authority provided $7.6 billion in capital in return for a 4.9 percent stake in November 2007. See Abu Dhabi Deal Raises Questions About Citigroup's Health for more details.

Also note that Citigroup had to go back to the well in January, raising $14.5 billion by issuing preferred stock and slashing its dividend 41% after reporting a $14.5 billion loss. See Cost of Capital "Ratchets Up" at Citigroup and Merrill for more details.

Olstein Capital Management Forecast

Dateline March 5, 2008: Olstein Capital Management says Citigroup Shares May Double in 2 Years and dividend is safe.
"Even though there's bad news still to come in Citibank, it's discounted already," said Robert Olstein, who oversees about $1.3 billion as chairman of Olstein Capital Management. "This stock in two years is going to be in the mid-40s. You've got to be forward looking."

"They're not cutting the dividend and they are not going to go back for more capital," Olstein, whose firm owns 1.7 million Citigroup shares, said after U.S. exchanges closed today. "They're OK."
Crystal Ball Is Broken

Olstein's forward looking crysytal ball is broken. "Olstein said in an interview with Bloomberg Television in August that he had been buying shares of Citigroup because the dividend was attractive."

Since then the dividend was slashed by 41% and the stock price has fallen by more than 50 percent.

Citi tries to reassure investors

Dateline March 5, 2008: Citi tries to reassure investors.
"Citi is financially sound - we are well capitalized and extremely focused on the strength of our balance sheet," said the memo sent to Citigroup's 370,000-plus employees after a conference call between Mr Pandit senior managers.
Citigroup Turns To Bond Market To Raise Capital

Dateline March 5, 2008 3:00PM: Citi Turns To Bond Market.
Citigroup, under pressure to raise capital, is making a big bet that it can raise money from yield-hungry investors. It is selling a $2.5 billion bond issue, most of which it is underwriting by itself. Citigroup said it would sell a 30-year issue, underwriting the lion's share -- $2.1 billion, or 84.0% -- itself. The relatively long-term issue has a relatively yummy yield: 6.875% of face value.

If a bond sale cannot be placed with investors, the underwriters -- which in this case is largely the issuer -- end up having to hold the paper. So the strategy contains an element of risk for Citi.
Questions of the Day
  • If Citigroup was well capitalized would it run the risk of having to purchase $2.1 billion of its own bonds at 6.875% interest?

  • Doesn't this underwriting arrangement raise any eyebrows?
Citigroup Sheds Some U.S. Branches

Dateline March 5, 2008 3:00PM: Citigroup Sheds Some U.S. Branches.
Citigroup Inc. has started shedding clusters of U.S. bank branches in cities where the company has token presences that lag far behind larger players.

Citibank, the New York-based company's retail-banking unit, has agreed to sell its small network of branches in Amarillo, Texas, according to an internal bank memo sent Wednesday to Texas employees. Citigroup is selling the branches to a local lender, Happy State Bank, the memo said. The transaction's terms weren't disclosed.

Citibank also plans to shutter at least 11 other branches around the U.S. in May, according to people familiar with the matter. Six of the branches are in Florida, primarily in the Tampa area. Three other branches are in New Jersey, and one each is in California and Maryland.

The memo said Citibank remains "committed to maintaining and expanding in Texas," which it described as "one of our most important markets."
Citigroup's Commitment To Expand In Question

Perhaps I am mistaken, but selling branches to Happy State Bank does not seem like much of a commitment to expand in Texas. It seems more like a conscious decision to raise capital to me.

It's rare to see predictions like Olstein's fail so spectacularly in less than a day, but there you have it.

What About The Dividend?



Chart courtesy of the Wall Street Journal

In "Where's Waldo?" on February 22, 2008 I noted that analyst Meredith Whitney was calling for more writeoffs, another dividend cut, and the need for Citigroup to raise more capital. I agree on all counts.

Nothing has changed since then except that Citigroup is now borrowing (or rather attempting to borrow) $2.5 billion at 6.875% while paying approximately $6.6 billion annually in dividends. This is not a viable long term strategy.

Odds are overwhelming that Citigroup will have to cut that dividend again.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Carlyle Capital Hit With Margin Calls And Default Notice

Carlyle Capital is finding out what it's like being hit with margin calls when you use 32 times leverage and your investments are illiquid: Carlyle Capital Adds To Fears Of Forced Sales.
Carlyle Capital Corp., a listed investment company managed by a unit of private-equity firm the Carlyle Group, added to worries about forced liquidations of residential mortgage-backed securities after failing to meet margin calls on its $21.7 billion portfolio Wednesday.

Carlyle Capital said Thursday that it has received a notice of default from one of the banks that helps finance its portfolio of Freddie Mac and Fannie Mae securities through short-term repurchase agreements, known as repos, and that it expects to receive at least one more default notice after falling short of margin requirements with four lenders.
Yet Another Borrow Short Lend Long Scheme Blows Up

Professor Andrew Jeffery picks up the Carlyle story in Distressed Pools Flood Market.
The focus is back on mortgages as opportunistic buyers seize on loans out for bid by troubled sellers. The Wall Street Journal reports Carlyle Capital Corporation -- a unit of private equity firm the Carlyle Group -- missed a margin call on its $27.1 billion loan portfolio and may be forced to dump assets to pay back lenders. The company has just $670 million in equity supporting the portfolio, or a leverage ratio of 32 times.

Borrowing short to lend long doesn't work when chaos in short-term funding markets prevents borrowers from rolling over credit lines. Carlyle uses repurchase facilities (or repo lines) that act like lines of credit to finance its portfolio. The Journal reports that as early as Monday the firm assured lenders like Bank of America (BAC), Bear Stearns (BSC) and Citigroup (C) that its funding facilities were secure. Carlyle satisfied three of its seven margin requests, which totaled $37 million.

Repos are a common funding method for mortgage investors and often contain cross-default provisions, whereby a borrower is forced into default on multiple lines if it violates lending covenants on a single facility. This protects lenders in the event a portfolio starts to go sideways.

The news spooked investors after forced selling has rocked numerous mortgage companies in the past week. Thornberg Mortgage (TMA) shares have tumbled in recent days after the firm had trouble selling assets to meet margin calls in excess of $300 million. In addition, Marketwatch is reporting that UBS (UBS) sold $24.1 billion of Alt-A mortgages to Pimco at a 30 point discount to par. That a portfolio of such size sold at just 70 cents on the dollar is indicative of a market in need of buyers.

Just as equity investors look for capitulation selling to indicate a bottom, forced selling is often a sign markets are healing themselves. However, many argue that such low prices should be blamed on liquidity, rather than assets' underlying credit quality. And while this argument may have some merit, the always astute Minyan Peter offered yesterday on the Buzz & Banter that "in a deflationary environment, liquidity trumps all other cards in the deck. Credit wounds. Liquidity kills."
Small correction. It's not liquidity that kills, it's illiquidity that kills. And because of illiquidity, over leveraged hedge funds are now blowing up left and right.

Three Recent Examples
As the downward spiral of credit contraction continues, we see some widely respected geniuses were not really geniuses at all. Add Carlyle Capital to the list.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List