Tuesday, 29 July 2008

Paulson's Covered Bond Proposal

Many people are asking about Treasury Secretary Paulson's Covered Bond Plan.
Bank of America Corp., Citigroup Inc., JPMorgan Chase & Co. and Wells Fargo & Co. threw their support behind Treasury Secretary Henry Paulson's effort to spur covered bonds as a new source of mortgage financing.

"We look forward to being leading issuers as the U.S. covered bond market develops," the banks said in a joint statement in Washington. They applauded Paulson's release today of guidelines for issuers of covered bonds, which detail the types of loans that should go into the securities and how their payments ought to be made.

Even in Europe, where covered bonds are a market in excess of $3 trillion, investors are shunning the debt amid a collapse in appetite for investments in housing.

"Mortgage-backed securities investors are not in the mood right now to buy bonds with anything less than government backing," Kenneth Hackel, managing director of fixed-income strategy at RBS Greenwich Capital Markets in Greenwich, Connecticut, said in an interview, referring to debt guaranteed by Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac.

Paulson said the four U.S. banks are "ready to go" and that sales by the largest banks can help encourage smaller mortgage lenders to proceed. "Covered bonds have the potential to increase mortgage financing, improve underwriting standards and strengthen U.S. financial institutions," he said.

Covered bonds offer greater protection to investors because banks keep the home loans on their books, and must make up shortfalls if homeowners fail to pay.

Covered bonds achieve higher ratings than regular notes by augmenting the issuer's pledge to pay with a group of assets such as mortgages that can be sold in a default. The extra security allows lenders to pay less interest.

While the securities are backed by loans and bank assets to get AAA ratings, most are valued, on average, as if they were three levels lower.

The Treasury's guidelines spell out a formal definition for covered bonds. The bonds should have maturities of at least one year and no more than 30 years. Home loans in covered-bond pools would have a maximum loan-to-value ratio of 80 percent.
First off, I like the idea of covered bonds. Over time they could allow for a somewhat graceful unwinding of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac. See Nature of the Fannie Mae Bailout for more on this idea.

In addition, forcing banks to keep responsibility for the loans will encourage far sounder lending practices than the current originate and securitize model, especially after the debacle we are in with Alt-A and subprime loans.

However, note that the maximum LTV is 80%. How many people have 20% down payments? The second problem is that banks are capital impaired and selling off assets. How likely is it for those same banks to be taking on additional debt? The answer is not very.

Finally, the credit crunch is not going away anytime soon. The general idea at many banks right now is We�re Saying No To Almost Everybody.

So while covered bonds are a reasonably good idea in a sea of horrid ideas, they simply are not going to do much to alleviate any problems in the mortgage markets, anytime soon. What politicians should do is give this market time to develop but politicians never want to wait.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Monday, 28 July 2008

Ratchet Provisions Soak Merrill Lynch, Will Sink WaMu

It was just 5 days ago in Death Spiral Financing at WaMu, Merrill Lynch, Citigroup that I wrote about ratchet provisions and how they would bite companies that agreed to them. Here is the key snip:
The investors in the equity raise would have their investment �protected� by a provision which states that should the bank afterwards raise money at a lower price than what they paid, these investors would be compensated retroactively by having their initial investment priced at this lower price, thereby being issued new shares for free.

It doesn�t take a mathematician to see how these provisions can result in massive dilution should the bank subsequently raise even a paltry amount of capital. A new offering will trigger a lower price because of the dilution it would cause, which would trigger even more dilution because of the lower price, which would then trigger an even lower price because of the even higher dilution, etc. This is why we call such securities a death spiral.
As expected, Merrill Lynch needed to raise capital again. And this one hurts because Merrill previously agree to ratchet provisions. Inquiring minds may wish to consider Merrill to Sell $8.5 Billion of Stock, Unload Money-Losing CDOs.
Merrill Lynch & Co., the third biggest U.S. securities firm, will sell $8.5 billion of stock and liquidate $30.6 billion of bonds at a fifth of their face value to shore up credit ratings imperiled by mortgage losses.

Temasek Holdings Pte., the Singapore-owned fund that became Merrill's biggest investor by acquiring shares in December, will buy $3.4 billion of the new stock, Merrill said yesterday in a statement. The New York-based company is paying Temasek $2.5 billion to offset losses on its earlier investment.
My Comment: That $2.5 billion is because of ratchet provisions. Mother Merrill is really only raising $6 billion.
Almost $19 billion of net losses in the past year forced Merrill Chief Executive Officer John Thain to backtrack from assurances that the firm had enough capital to weather the credit crisis. Since taking the post in December, Thain has raised $30 billion in an effort to keep pace with mounting charges on mortgage bonds amassed by his predecessor, Stan O'Neal.
My Comment: The market cap of Merrill Lynch is $23.97 billion. Mother Merrill has raised $30 billion since December. It is taking herculean capital raising efforts to keep the good ship Merrill afloat.
In yesterday's statement, Merrill said it agreed to sell $30.6 billion of collateralized debt obligations -- the mortgage-related bonds that have caused most of the firm's losses -- for $6.7 billion. The buyer is an affiliate of Lone Star Funds, a Dallas-based investment manager.

Merrill will provide financing for about 75 percent of the purchase price, according to the statement. The financing is secured only by the assets being sold, meaning Merrill would absorb any losses on the CDOs beyond $1.68 billion.
My Comment: Desperate mothers do desperate things, such as provide 75% of the financing to sell CDOs at 22 cents on the dollar.

Thain's Track Record

In December and January after raising $6.6 billion each month Bloomberg quoted Thain "We're very comfortable with our position. We could have raised substantially more money. We turned people away.''

In April he sold $2.55 billion of preferred stock.

On July 17 in a conference call Thain said "We believe that we are in a very comfortable spot in terms of our capital."

Now Thain is back at it again, selling $8.5 billion in stock but only netting $6 billion in cash from it. It will be interesting to see how long it takes before Thain is back at it. One thing we can assume is that this will not be the last time Thain needs to raise cash, no matter what Thain says.

One good thing for Merrill is their Press Release shows Merrill is no longer exposed to those death spiral ratchets.
In satisfaction of Merrill Lynch�s obligations under the reset provisions contained in the investment agreement with Temasek Holdings, Merrill Lynch has agreed to pay Temasek $2.5 billion, 100% of which Temasek has contractually agreed to invest in the offering at the public offering price without any future reset protection.
Washington Mutual Ratchets

A quick check shows WaMu's market cap is $6.71 Billion. It's share price is $3.95. TPG bought $7 billion of stock at $8.75 with a ratchet provision that if WaMu raises more than $500 million in equity, WaMu has to pay TPG the difference. The odds of WaMu not needing to raise capital are slim and none. Washington Mutual is in deep trouble over many things, and those ratchets make matters worse.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

McCain's son resigns from Silver State Bank board

ReviewJournal is reporting McCain's son resigns from boards of Henderson bank.
Silver State Bancorp, the Henderson-based holding company for the similarly named bank, reported that Andrew McCain, son of Republican presidential candidate John McCain, resigned today from the boards of directors of the bank and bank holding company.

The company cited �personal reasons� for McCain�s resignation, and a Silver State spokesman declined further comment.
Gettin' While The Gettin' Is Good?

I was not even going to report on this until I looked up Silver State Bank on bankrate.com.

Silver State Bank Financial Summary



click on chart for sharper image

Silver State Safe & Sound?



In a word, No.

Notes on Safe & Sound� star ratings, CAEL rating
The most desirable Safe & Sound� CAEL rating is one, the least desirable is five, in accordance with industry standards. Bankrate.com has reversed this order in its graphic rankings for easy visual recognition. The top star rating is five, the lowest star rating is one. Performing institutions will generally receive a rating of 3 or better stars with the majority of banks falling into the 3-4 star range. By contrast, the performing Safe & Sound CAEL range would be 1, 2 and 3 with the majority of institutions falling into the 2 range.
The Street.Com has a bank rating service that they bought from Weiss. However, Silver State Bank was not listed. Furthermore, I could not get that page to work in Firefox. Your results may vary.

Strongest Banks As Of 2008-06-20



click on chart for sharper image

Weakest Banks As Of 2008-06-20



click on chart for sharper image

The above charts of Strongest and Weakest Banks and Thrifts are courtesy of the Street.Com.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Macon Mall Faces Foreclosure

Macon.Com is reporting Macon Mall faces foreclosure.
Foreclosure action has begun against Macon [Georgia] Mall because of nonpayment on a $141.2 million loan, and a new management company has been approved by the court to take control of the 1.4 million-square-foot facility.

"We don't expect any operational interruptions to the mall," said Brooke Houghton, spokeswoman for Chicago-based Jones Lang LaSalle Americas Inc., the court-appointed retail management company now managing Macon Mall. "We don't think there will be any impact on the stores or the customers we serve. We are open and ready for business as usual."

According to court documents, in June 2005 when New Jersey-based The Lightstone Group borrowed $141.2 million, Macon Mall LLC and Burlington Mall LLC in North Carolina were used as collateral for the loan, as well as rents and other income from the properties. The company purchased the two malls about the same time in 2005 for $166 million. The loan currently is held by LaSalle Bank National Association as trustee for a trust that holds and owns a pool of loans including the one for Macon Mall. The trust filed the complaint.

Since the loan was made, Parisians and the Piccadilly Cafeteria have closed at the mall, and Linens-N-Things - part of the mall property, even though it's not inside the main building - is in the process of closing.

In a letter filed in the case, "Dillard's has apparently communicated its intent to close its store location at Macon Mall."

Based on an appraisal "the value of the property has fallen approximately 60 percent since June 30, 2005."
The Shopping Center Economic Model Is History. More mall foreclosures are coming. 50-60% writeoffs will be common, and dozens of already stressed banks will fail as a result.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Sunday, 27 July 2008

Open Letter To Obama

Dear Senator Obama. The US economy is in the worst economic crisis in decades, arguably since the great depression. Housing is collapsing, state budgets are in shambles, unemployment is soaring, and the US dollar is sinking.

Things are going to get even worse when the commercial real estate bust picks up steam. We have seen six bank failures already this year. There are 90 more banks on the problem list. Many of them will fail.

Meanwhile, Treasury Secretary Paulson and President Bush are both stressing "The U.S. economy is fundamentally strong, diverse and resilient." Indeed, Paulson speaks of the "strong dollar policy" at every opportunity.

The vast majority of citizens in the United States know that the above statements by President Bush and Paulson are lies.

What we really need is for politicians to face the public and state the truth.

The Truth Is Easy To See
  • The US can no longer afford to be the world's policeman.
  • Congress has been spending beyond its means.
  • Deficit spending is cheapening the US dollar.
  • Cutbacks and sacrifices have to be made.

Interest On The National Debt Is $377 Billion


The national debt as of July 17, 2008 is $9.5 Trillion dollars. Interest for the first nine months of Fiscal Year 2008 as noted in Interest Expense on the Debt Outstanding is $377 billion!

Paulson talks about the "strong fundamentals" of the US dollar. Our entire "Strong Dollar Policy" consists of nothing more than Paulson yapping about the strong dollar. It is an international disgrace. It is sad the Treasury Secretary does not understand that the two biggest factors affecting the US dollar are interest rates differentials and deficit financing.

Our Feds Fund Rate is 2.00% in comparison to 5.00% in the UK and 4.25% in the EU. In regards to the budget deficit, China and Japan have been financing our out of control spending.

Some fundamentals! If Paulson believes what he says, he is not qualified to be Treasury Secretary.

US Banking System Is Unsound

Senator Obama our banking system is unsound. I presented the case in You Know The Banking System Is Unsound When....

I ask you to take the time to read that post. In it, I presented 25 reasons our system is unsound. Here is reason number 25.
25. Of the $6.84 Trillion in bank deposits, the total cash on hand at banks is a mere $273.7 Billion. Where is the rest of the loot? The answer is in off balance sheet SIVs, imploding commercial real estate deals, Alt-A liar loans, Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac bonds, toggle bonds where debt is amazingly paid back with more debt, and all sorts of other silly (and arguably fraudulent) financial wizardry schemes that have bank and brokerage firms leveraged at 30-1 or more. Those loans cannot be paid back.

What cannot be paid back will be defaulted on. If you did not know it before, you do now. The entire US banking system is insolvent.
The problem is not bank regulation or lack thereof. The problem is fractional reserve lending accompanied by runaway spending in Congress.

Congress Must Be Held Accountable

Congress must be held accountable for deficit spending. Clearly the Republican plan of reducing taxes, foolishly wasting hundreds of billions in Iraq, and praying for an economic miracle did not work.

Phil Gramm, senator McCain's economic advisor, said we were in a "mental recession". You rightfully blasted him for it, stating "He didn't say this but I guess what he meant was that it's a figment of your imagination, these high gas prices."

Economically, you are calling for another $50 billion dollar spending stimulus. If that fails (which it will) do you want another one, and another one after that? Where does it stop? I am all in favor of returning $50 billion to the taxpayers. I just want to know how we are going to pay for it.

Senator Obama how do you propose we pay for that?

The 100 Year's War

Senator Obama, the entire nation knows we went to war under false pretenses, if not blatant lies. Yet Senator McCain is willing to keep us in Iraq for a hundred more years if necessary. Unfortunately, you have not found the courage to commit to a timetable to pull all of our troops out of Iraq. Senator, the nation is sick of this war. ALL of our troops need to come home. Every one of them.

It is time for someone to stand up and say "This war was a mistake. We are pulling out. And here is the time table in which we are going to do it."

Since that person is not going to be McCain, it better be you.

Everyone I speak to is now unsure of your commitment to get us out of Iraq. Leaving 1/2 or 1/3 of our troops in Iraq is a miserable compromise. Iraq belongs to the Iraqis. Those who fear moral consequences of an exit should look at the moral and economic consequences of keeping our troops in harm's way for another 100 years.

The biggest mistake we can now make in Iraq is prolonging the big mistake we already made.

Horrendous Ethanol Policies

Senator Obama, you support ethanol tariffs and subsidies. These policies are nothing short of an economic disaster. Congress passed a 54 cent tariff on ethanol imports. That tariff is increasing the price of gasoline at the pump.

Is that tariff creating any jobs here? Of course not. Government mandated solutions never work. The US Ethanol Industry Is In Distress. There are "16 Ethanol Plants Filing For Bankruptcy. Many More Will Come." If that is not bad enough, the corn subsidy is uneconomically diverting corn production to ethanol production. This in turn is causing food prices to rise.

So much for government mandated "solutions".

Why We Are In This Mess

Senator Obama, the root cause of this mess is uncontrolled Congressional spending, government sponsorship of GSEs and rating agencies, fractional reserve lending, and the Fed.

The Fed attempting to stave off the last recession slashed interest rates to 1% to bail out their banking buddies in deep trouble over dotcom loans as well as loans to emerging markets. Congress compounded the problem by spending like complete fools. And the Bush Administration with help from Congress was willing to waste billions of dollars we did not have in that hellhole called Iraq.

Finally, SEC sponsorship of the rating agencies led to insane AAA ratings on all sorts of subprime and Alt-A mortgage debt that Wall Street could package and sell to unsuspecting suckers like state pension plans.

Biggest Party Wall Street Ever Had

Paulson called this "The strongest global economy he has ever seen". The reality is throwing money around created "The biggest party Wall Street has ever had". This was an unfounded boom based on low interest rates and cheap credit. Millions of people, sucked in the vortex of this artificial boom, are now being foreclosed on.

And instead of fixing the fundamental problem (The Fed, runaway Congressional spending, governments sponsorship of the GSEs, and government sponsorship of the big 3 rating agencies), you along with most of congress are looking towards more regulation as the solution.

Senator Obama, The Fed IS the problem. Congress IS the problem. Bernanke IS the problem. Fractional Reserve Lending IS the problem. If you do not see the light, YOU are the problem.

The Problem Cannot Be The Solution

If runaway government spending is part of the problem (and it is clear that it is), then it should be equally clear that runaway government spending is NOT the solution. If government sponsorship of the GSE was part of the problem (and it was) then even bigger government sponsorship of the GSEs is not the solution.

The plain fact of the matter is that home prices are still too high. They need to come down. Artificial attempts to force home prices up will drag this economic mess out for a decade longer, just as happened in Japan.

It was a sad day last week when Bernanke said "It's important for Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac bonds and stocks to rise so they can keep raising capital and aid the mortgage market."

With that we lost every semblance of the free market we had left. We now have government sponsorship if not outright nationalization of GSEs.

Senator Obama, do you even remember the Mission Statement of Fannie Mae?

We are a shareholder-owned company with a public mission. We exist to expand affordable housing and bring global capital to local communities in order to serve the U.S. housing market.

Fannie Mae exists to expand affordable housing. Clearly Fannie Mae has failed its core mission. All government sponsored corporations fail their mission. The very nature of promoting housing makes prices go up, until the final blowoff top which we are now on the backside of, having reached Peak Credit.

The US has partied too long and too hard at the federal level, the state level, the corporate level, and the personal level. The cure for a hangover is most emphatically not more booze. The cure for a credit crisis is not more "free money", from either Congress or the Fed.

The Fed Uncertainty Principle

Sadly, we are moving in the wrong direction as predicted by the Fed Uncertainty Principle.

Uncertainty Principle Corollary Number One: The Fed has no idea where interest rates should be. Only a free market does. The Fed will be disingenuous about what it knows (nothing of use) and doesn't know (much more than it wants to admit), particularly in times of economic stress.

Uncertainty Principle Corollary Number Two: The government/quasi-government body most responsible for creating this mess (the Fed), will attempt a big power grab, purportedly to fix whatever problems it creates. The bigger the mess it creates, the more power it will attempt to grab. Over time this leads to dangerously concentrated power into the hands of those who have already proven they do not know what they are doing.

Uncertainty Principle Corollary Number Three: Don't expect the Fed to learn from past mistakes. Instead, expect the Fed to repeat them with bigger and bigger doses of exactly what created the initial problem.

Uncertainty Principle Corollary Number Four: The Fed simply does not care whether its actions are illegal or not. The Fed is operating under the principle that it's easier to get forgiveness than permission. And forgiveness is just another means to the desired power grab it is seeking.

The Cure

The only cure for an artificial boom is time and price, in conjunction with sound economic policies.

Senator Obama, you have a chance to make history. Assuming you are elected, you will have the opportunity to do something no President has done for decades: Stand before the American people and tell the plain hard truth.
  • The US can no longer afford to be the world's policeman.
  • Congress has been spending beyond its means.
  • Deficit spending is cheapening the US dollar.
  • Cutbacks and sacrifices have to be made.
People will understand as long as they are being leveled with.

A New Economic Advisor

Before you can lead the way, you need a new economic advisor, preferably one as Vice President.

One thing is certain: Giving away $50 billion dollars on top of the $150 billion in stimulus Congress already gave away is not going to solve any problems.

If printing money and handing it out solved economic problems, Zimbabwe would be the most economically powerful nation in the world.

Why is it the same solution "free money" is tried over and over and over, when it never works?

The Nation Needs Healing

This war torn, economically tortured country needs heeling. To meet that goal we can no longer afford the same bitter partisanship in Congress that we have seen for what seems like forever.

McCain is unable and unwilling to heal the nation. His willingness to spend another 10 years in Iraq, wasting trillions more dollars at a time the nation is sick of this war, is proof enough.

Senator Obama, you are clearly able to heal the nation, but are you willing? If you can just see fit to have the courage to reach across the aisle you can electrify the nation, re-energize the country based on sound economic free market principles, and minimize the partisan bickering in Congress.

Senator Obama, I ask you to nominate Ron Paul as your Vice President, embrace sound economic policies, and return this country to greatness. If you have the courage to do so, the upcoming election will be the biggest surprise blowout in history. On the other hand, if you stick to policies of giving away "free money" this nation will be in ruins four years from now.

Senator Obama I ask you, "What's it gonna be?"

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

We�re Saying No To Almost Everybody

Astonishingly I am reading What Credit Crunch? by Robert Higgs on The Beacon.
For months, the news media have been dispensing reports of a �credit crunch.�

If credit were being crunched, one supposes that lenders would be willing to pay higher rates for funds placed at their disposal. Yet six-month certificates of deposit are now yielding less than the rate of inflation�people are paying the banks to take their money! Some credit crunch.

Perhaps someone can enlighten me. I simply don�t understand how we can have a �credit crunch� without substantial increases in real interest rates across the board.
It would help to have an idea of what a credit crunch was and for that matter what inflation is.

Let's start with the latter. Those who do not know what inflation is are advised to read Inflation: What the heck is it? The short version is inflation is a net expansion of money supply and credit while deflation is the opposite.

Now let's tackle the alleged non-existent Credit Crunch.

I find it amazing that anyone cannot sees there is an ongoing credit crunch when Bernanke resorts to an alphabet soup of lending facilities (FAF, PDCF, TSLF) to stimulate lending.

If that was not enough in and of itself, what about Henry Paulson saying Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac are "essential" because they represent the only "functioning" part of the home loan market. For more on this idea please see You Know The Banking System Is Unsound When....

Is it possible to not be in a credit crunch when the mortgage market is not functioning?

Furthermore, mortgage lending standards are tightening, credit card lending standard are tightening, and in fact Bank Credit Is Contracting. How often does that happen?

Worried Banks Sharply Reduce Business Loans

The New York Times is reporting Worried Banks Sharply Reduce Business Loans.
Two vital forms of credit used by companies � commercial and industrial loans from banks, and short-term �commercial paper� not backed by collateral � collectively dropped almost 3 percent over the last year, to $3.27 trillion from $3.36 trillion, according to Federal Reserve data. That is the largest annual decline since the credit tightening that began with the last recession, in 2001.

The scarcity of credit has intensified the strains on the economy by withholding capital from many companies, just as joblessness grows and consumers pull back from spending in the face of high gas prices, plummeting home values and mounting debt.

When Mr. Greenblatt called the local branch of Wachovia � the same bank that had been aggressively marketing loans to him for years � he was distressed by the response.

"The exact words were, �We�re saying no to almost everybody,� " Mr. Greenblatt recalled.
We�re Saying No To Almost Everybody

The above sentence is the very epitome of a credit crunch. Banks do not want to lend to all but the most credit worthy borrowers. However, the most credit worthy borrowers have no need to expand in this environment.

Let's look at another snip from "What Credit Crunch?"
If credit were being crunched, one supposes that lenders would be willing to pay higher rates for funds placed at their disposal. Yet six-month certificates of deposit are now yielding less than the rate of inflation�people are paying the banks to take their money! Some credit crunch: banks and thrift institutions don't even have to pay a positive real rate of interest to attract funds! This situation makes sense only if the world is awash in loanable funds, so much so that people are clamoring to part with their money for less than zero reward.

Perhaps someone can enlighten me. I simply don't understand how we can have a "credit crunch" without substantial increases in real interest rates across the board.
Well lenders are paying above market rates for money. Many banks, especially the unsound ones, are offering 250 basis points or more above treasury rates. On a percentage basis that is an enormous spread.

Furthermore, in a credit crunch, junk yields should rise and they are. In a credit crunch lending standards will tighten and they are. In a credit crunch lenders will "Say No To Almost Everyone" and they are.

Finally, it makes perfect sense for money to be parked in money market funds below the alleged rate of "inflation". I have talked about this on many occasions. The reason M3 has been rising is that corporations have been tapping credit lines, not for expansion, but in case those lines are shut off. Those corporations have been parking that money in institutional money market accounts.

This is not "inflationary" in any way shape or form. Deflation is here and upon us, and some cannot even see there is a credit crunch. It's rather amazing.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Bank of Canada's Monkey See Monkey Do Policy

The Globe And Mail is reporting the Bank Of Canada to take riskier assets as collateral.
The Bank of Canada says it is prepared to accept some of the riskiest assets on the market, giving it more power to fight the credit crisis. For the first time, the central bank will accept as collateral for emergency loans asset-backed securities of the type at the heart of the crisis of confidence that has seized financial markets for the past year.

Governor Mark Carney revealed yesterday in the Canada Gazette how he intends to use new powers granted him by Finance Minister Jim Flaherty in legislation that cleared Parliament in June. It was left up to Mr. Carney to decide which assets would be acceptable to the central bank.

The change aligns the Bank of Canada with other major central banks, including the U.S. Federal Reserve and the European Central Bank, and clears the way for Mr. Carney to more forcefully attack a problem that he says has subsided in Canada for now.

"This is a positive development as it brings the Bank of Canada's powers more in line with that of its peers, and it reduces the risk of further credit market problems in Canada," said Eric Lascalles, an economist at Toronto-Dominion Bank.
There is no evidence the TAF, PDCF, or TSLF do what they are supposed to do. I talked about this back in April in Failures of the Term Auction Facility.

No one in their right mind should want to replicate the failed policies of Ben Bernanke. Indeed, common sense alone would suggest that any program designed to swap good assets for bad, when they eventually have to be swapped back is an exercise in futility and a waste of time for all involved.

So why is the Canadian Central Bank embarking down the same silly path? The reason is simple. Bureaucrats, being bureaucrats have to do something. It is simply impossible for bureaucrats to do nothing, even when compelling reasons can be given for doing just that: nothing. This concept was explained in Bernanke's, Paulson's, Bair's, and Cox's Next Step,

It's always important to remember that the primary goal of a bureaucrat is to make sure that when the finger is being pointed, that it is pointed at someone else. In that regard, the safe thing to do is what other bureaucrats are doing, whether it makes any sense or not (and sadly it never does). This of course gives all of them cover when the scheme blows sky high, which it will. When it does, the Central Bankers will all get together and say "Everyone else was doing it, who could have possibly known?"

This is of course the exact same kind of "Monkey See Monkey Do" rationale that every bank in the U.S. was using while pursuing subprime loans, Alt-A liar loans, toggle bonds, and all sorts of other harebrained products that any sane person knew would blow sky high and eventually did.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here
To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List