Sunday, 5 April 2009

Artist's Rendition on the State of the Economy

I received a unique email from Scott Moore about the State of the Economy.

Scott writes:

Hi Mish,
I'm an artist in Laguna Beach, California and I'm painting a 5 1/2' x 7' canvas on the state of the economy. Here's some details from the painting and work in progress:



I will be using vintage banks to represent the various areas of the economy. A plastic piggy bank will represent our personal monetary problems. Sometimes real people pose as models for my work.




Today the sun was out and Budge, a good friend and client posed as my businessman for this painting. I tied a rope onto the end of an extension ladder which I lashed to the house (you can see the shadow of the ladder on the cement just past Budge).



Detail of Budge on the mural.



Details added to AIG pig



I'm also beginning to label some of the objects in the sky with the names and logos/logotypes of failing institutions like Chrysler, Bear Stearns, and Fannie Mae.



We would not want to forget Bernie Madoff would we?



Of course there's Bank of America.



Here is the original concept as laid out in Photoshop. The one ray of hope will be one lone figure, representing each of us as we try to hold onto what seems to be slipping away. There will be chess pieces randomly placed across a spanse of chessboard hills, illustrating the financial 'game' that seems impossible to play.



The final rendition is beginning to take shape but I still have a couple more months before it is complete.
===============================================

Wow.
Thanks Scott

Scott's website has many additional details on this and other paintings that are well worth a look. Please visit Scott Moore's Gallery where he takes you step by step through the creation of "The Money Game" and other original works.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Case Shiller March 2009 Analysis

Inquiring minds are considering the Case Shiller Home Price Release for March 2009.
New York, March 31, 2009 � Data through January 2009, released today by Standard & Poor�s for its S&P/Case-Shiller1 Home Price Indices, the leading measure of U.S. home prices, shows continued broad based declines in the prices of existing single family homes across the United States, with 13 of the 20 metro areas showing record rates of annual decline, and 14 reporting declines in excess of 10% versus January 2008.



The chart above depicts the annual returns of the 10-City Composite and the 20-City Composite Home Price Indices. Following the lead of the 14 metro areas described above, the 10-City and 20-City Composites also set new records, with annual declines of 19.4% and 19.0%, respectively.



The chart above shows the index levels for the 10-City Composite and 20-City Composite Home Price Indices. As of January 2009, average home prices across the United States are at similar levels to what they were in late 2003. From the peak in the second quarter of 2006, the 10-City Composite is down 30.2% and the 20-City Composite is down 29.1%.
Please see the original article for more commentary and tables on the data.

Case-Shiller Declines Since Peak

The following charts were produced by my friend "TC" who has been monitoring Case-Shiller Data. Although individual cities topped at varying times, the top-10 and top-20 city composites peaked in a June-July 2006 timeframe.

Case-Shiller Declines Since Peak Current Data



click on chart for sharper image

Case-Shiller Declines Since Peak Futures Data



click on chart for sharper image


"TC" writes:
The Jan 2009 Case-Shiller data continues to accelerate to the downside at a record pace. The 10 and 20 city index show declines from their peak at 30% and the bubble cities (along with Detroit) all have declines of 40% or more with Phoenix having the largest percentage drop of nearly 50%. Additionally, all 20 cities tracked by Case-Shiller have now experienced price declines in excess of 10%. I want to once again remind your readers that the Case-Shiller data uses a Repeated Sales Methodology (RSM) which provides the most accurate housing data available. Additionally, there are two newer columns titled "Price Level" which show both the last time prices were at the current level and what price level prices are projected to decline to based upon the CME Futures market.

When one looks more closing at the current "Price Level" data you can see that cities such as San Francisco have likely already experienced the bulk of their price decline as prices have already returned to those of 8 1/2 years ago (Oct 2000). However, cities in the Pacific Northwest (Seattle & Portland) have only seen prices return to mid-2005 levels and likely have significant price declines in their future.

Lastly, I've added another chart titled "Negative Quarters" which shows many quarters each city has seen price declines (for example Phoenix and New York Metro have seen price declines for 11 of the last 11 quarters).
Thanks "TC"

Unemployment is soaring in 2009 and so will foreclosures, credit card writeoffs, and bankruptcies. That will add to the inventory problems.

As much as housing prices have declined, take another look at the second chart in the news release above. Imagine where prices will be if they fall back to 2001 levels or worse yet 2000 levels. Moreover, why shouldn't prices fall back that far? Finally, how many are prepared for it, if indeed that were that to happen?

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Saturday, 4 April 2009

John Hancock Tower Foreclosure Sale, a 65% Haircut In 3 Years

Commercial property values are down a lot more than people realize, especially when considering the implied value of financing. Please consider Hancock Tower sells for $660m at auction.

March 31, 2009 10:33 AM - The John Hancock Tower was sold today for $660.6 million at a foreclosure auction in New York City.

The signature Back Bay building was acquired by a partnership between Normandy Real Estate Partners and Five Mile Capital Partners. The partnership was the only entity to bid for the Hancock during the auction, which lasted less than 10 minutes.

The firms initiated foreclosure after the Hancock's previous owner, Broadway Partners of New York, defaulted on some of the loans it used to buy property for $1.3 billion in late 2006.

This property sold for $1.3 billion in 2006 and $935 million in 2003. Today's price is $660 million, a 50% haircut.

But that's only part of the story. A friend writes "Don't forget the value of the financing that Normandy now gets to assume: $640 million mortgage at a rate of 5.6%."

Assuming the building is worth $660, Normandy managed to get 97% financing on an enormous sum of money, at a rate impossible to get in this market, at least starting from scratch. Financing 97% now on that size a loan would entail combined rates at 11% or higher. The value of that cheap financing might be worth $190 million or more.

Thus the real price the Hancock sold at foreclosure is more like $470 million not $660 million. That is a 65% haircut in three years.

Addendum

I received a surprising number of emails regarding this post.

Here is one from "A Loyal Reader" an attorney and commercial real estate broker very familiar with large commercial real estate transactions.

"Loyal Reader" Replies ...
An addendum is needed for your post on the Hancock sale. The auction buyers apparently had been buying up slices of junior debt. According to the Boston Globe, the auction buyers had bought a "$75 million slice" of the debt; presumably, that was the face value, which they probably got for a hefty discount.

Nonetheless, in addition to backing out the implied value of the assumed financing, you should back in an estimate of the cost to the buyer of picking up the slices of junior debt that allowed them to foreclose. Even if they paid 50%, or $37.5 million, their total cash outlay for getting the building was $57.5 million, and the assumption of a $640M note at a sweetheart rate. The value of the assumed loan was over 3X their cash investment!

Another point of interest: why did the first lender allow the assumption, instead of demanding repayment and leaving the auction buyers to get new financing? The foreclosure event should have given them the right to do that; if not, if the junior debt holders could walk in and assume, then the first lien holder had terrible lawyers.

The auction buyers get all the benefit of owning the building, while the first lien holder is stuck with a loan which, at 97% LTV and 5.6%, will have to be written down on a mark to market basis to something far less than par (although they are probably laboring mightily not to have to do that).
Thanks Loyal Reader

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Time to Remove the "L" from "BLS"

For seven consecutive months the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) has revised downward, prior job loss data.

The New York Times mentioned this on March 6 in Will Job Numbers Keep Being Revised Down?
Robert Barbera, the chief economist of ITG, points out a more disturbing trend: The Labor Department keeps concluding that its initial estimates were too optimistic.

Here are the total job losses reported for recent months, as originally reported and as shown in the latest revisions.

August 2008: Initially 84,000, revised to 175,000
September 2008: Initially 159,000, revised to 321,000
October 2008: Initially 240,000, revised to 380,000
November 2008: Initially 533,000, revised to 597,000
December 2008: Initially 524,000, revised to 681,000
January 2009: Initially 598,000, revised to 655,000
February 2009: Initially 651,000, as released today.

On average, from August through January, the first estimate was too optimistic by 112,000 jobs.
March Jobs Data

Inquiring minds are now investigating the BLS March Employment Report for additional revisions.

Sure enough there were more revisions. However, instead of revising the February data, the BLS revised the January data a second time as follows.

The change in total nonfarm employment for January was revised from -655,000 to -741,000, while the change for February remained -651,000.

A tip of the hat to Gonzalo who sent me the Times link. I am going to start tracking these revisions going forward.

For more details on March jobs, please see Jobs Contract 15th Straight Month; Unemployment Rate Soars to 8.5%.

Birth Death Madness

Naked Capitalism has a series of four interesting charts in Guest Post: Non-Farm Payrolls Report: Revisio ad Absurdum Here is the one that most caught my eye.



click on chart for sharper image

There is simply no way there is net new business creation or a pattern this consistent in face of the biggest recession since the great depression.

Limitations of the residual net birth/death model

The BLS explains the flaw in its own methodology quite nicely. Please consider Technical Information: Estimation Methods for Business Births and Deaths.
Limitations of the residual net birth/death model

The current modeling technique consistently reduces error in the estimate of nonfarm payroll employment, as compared to making no adjustment, however it has limitations. The primary limitation stems from the fact that the model is, of necessity, based on historical data. If at some future time, there is a substantial departure from historical patterns of employment changes associated with the residual of net business births and deaths, the model's contribution to error reduction could erode.

Because there is no current monthly information available on business births, and because only incomplete sample data is available on business deaths, estimation of this component will always be potentially more problematic than estimation of change from continuing businesses.
Birth Death Model Horribly Wrong At Turns

In short, the BLS model is horribly wrong at economic turns. We have been in recession for a year and a half, and the BLS is clearly using a historical model from a non-recessionary period as its guide.

Frequently Asked Questions

Let's wrap up with CES Birth/Death Model Frequently Asked Questions.
Q: Are birth/death factors seasonally adjusted?

A: No, they are calculated using population data that is not seasonally adjusted and the factors are applied to the sample-based not seasonally adjusted estimates. Months with generally strong seasonal increases such as April, May and June generally have a relatively large positive factor. Conversely, months with overall strong seasonal decreases, such as January, generally have a relatively large negative factor.

Q: Can I subtract the birth/death adjustment from the seasonally adjusted over-the-month change to determine what it is adding to employment?

A: No. Birth/death factors are a component of the not seasonally adjusted estimate and therefore are not directly comparable to the seasonally adjusted monthly changes. Instead, the birth/death factor should be assessed in the context of its effect on the not seasonally adjusted estimate.

Q: Can BLS provide an estimate of the contribution of the birth/death adjustment to the seasonally adjusted monthly payroll change?

A: BLS does not calculate an estimate of the seasonally adjusted contribution of the birth/death model. The sample, the imputation of business births using deaths, and the net birth/death model are all necessary components for obtaining an accurate total employment estimate. The components are not seasonally adjusted separately because they do not have any particular economic meaning in and of themselves.
Please read those answers carefully. Many make the mistake of subtracting the birth death revisions from the reported job numbers. It simply does not work that way.

Of interest to me is the answer to the third question. The BLS maintains that the Birth Death revisions make the job reports more accurate than without them. Yet they cannot (or simply will not) tell us exactly how the Birth Death revisions affect the reported monthly job numbers!

It's time to remove the "L" from "BLS".

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Friday, 3 April 2009

New York Times Threatens To Shut Boston Globe

Deflationary news continues to hit the newsprint industry. Please consider New York Times threatens to shut Boston Globe.
The New York Times Co has threatened to shut The Boston Globe unless the newspaper's unions quickly agree to $20 million in concessions, the Globe reported on Friday, quoting union leaders.

The union officials said executives from the Globe and the Times, which owns the Boston newspaper, made the demands on Thursday morning in a meeting with leaders of the newspaper's 13 unions, the Globe reported.

Possible concessions include pay cuts, the end of pension contributions by the company and the elimination of lifetime job guarantees for some veteran staff, the newspaper reported, quoting Boston Newspaper Guild president Daniel Totten.

The guild is the Globe's biggest union, representing more than 700 editorial, advertising and business office employees, the report said.

"Management told union leaders Thursday that the Globe will lose $85 million in 2009, unless serious cutbacks are made, according to a Globe employee briefed on the discussions," the Globe report said. That compares with an estimated $50 million loss last year, the newspaper quoted the employee as saying.

The Times sought the concessions because it can no longer subsidize the Globe's losses, the report said, quoting the Globe employee, who requested anonymity because the person was not authorized to speak publicly.

The threat comes as a host of U.S. newspaper publishers have reduced staff, declared bankruptcy or shuttered newspapers to cope with a recession that has squeezed advertising revenues and with a new era in which readers seek news online.

Many U.S. newspapers have lost 20 percent or more of their advertising revenue as more people get news online for free.
I happen to be fond of the Boston Globe. I get many interesting stories from the Globe and other troubled newspapers. However, the model is what the model is. And the newsprint model simply is not working. Ad revenues are falling, internet competition is increasing, and the quality of commentary and news content from free sources such as blogs is soaring.

Therefore, I strongly advise the union to accept the concessions demanded by the New York Times. There simply is no other way that leads to survival.

Unfortunately, this is likely to be round one with many rounds to come. Pensions, benefits, and wages are headed lower and that trend is unstoppable.

Images From The Globe

The images the Globe puts together are often the best in the nation. Please consider Scenes from the recession.

Here are some stunning images of Earth From Above comes to NYC.

Those are quality images. I know quality. I have had 80 magazine cover images myself. You can see some of my images at MichaelShedlock.Com. (By the way, that site is not maintained, there are some known typos, and I am no longer active in photographic journalism although sometimes my images reappear in print).

So please click on the Globe "Big Picture" images to see some breathtaking images. I saved those links for months, not knowing quite what to do with them. Today I knew.

I wish the Boston Globe well. I think the Globe is a quality newspaper and I hope it survives. Those "Big Picture" images alone are reason enough alone.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Jobs Contract 15th Straight Month; Unemployment Rate Soars to 8.5%

This morning, the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS) released the March Employment Report.

Nonfarm payroll employment continued to decline sharply in March (-663,000), and the unemployment rate rose from 8.1 to 8.5 percent, the Bureau of Labor Statistics of the U.S. Department of Labor reported today. Since the recession began in December 2007, 5.1 million jobs have been lost, with almost two-thirds (3.3 million) of the decrease occurring in the last 5 months. In March, job losses were large and widespread across the major industry sectors.





Nonfarm Payroll employment has shrunk below early 2006 levels.

Establishment Data



click on chart for sharper image

Highlights

  • 663,00 jobs were lost in total
  • 126,000 construction jobs were lost
  • 161,000 manufacturing jobs were lost
  • 358,000 service providing jobs were lost
  • 48,000 retail trade jobs were lost
  • 133,000 professional and business services jobs were lost
  • 8,000 education and health services jobs were added
  • 40,000 leisure and hospitality jobs were lost
  • 5,000 government jobs were lost

A total of 305,000 goods producing jobs were lost (higher paying jobs), and the service sector was clobbered once again as well. Government lost 5,000 jobs, a welcome event, but I expect this to change in the months ahead along with various stimulus programs.

It was nearly a clean sweep this month. 8,000 education and health services jobs were the only gains for march.

Note: some of the above categories overlap as shown in the preceding chart, so do not attempt to total them up.

Birth Death Model Revisions 2008



click on chart for sharper image

Birth Death Model Revisions 2009



click on chart for sharper image

Birth/Death Model Revisions

After the typical in January in which the Birth/Death Model revisions bore some semblance of reality, the Birth/Death numbers are back in outer space.

Many small 1-5 person service providing shops in mortgage lending and real estate are throwing in the towel. Those small businesses are not properly accounted for in the Birth-Death Model. At this point in the cycle birth death numbers should be massively contracting.

Month after month, with the exception of January, the BLS is assuming more jobs were created by new businesses than lost by businesses closing shop. The BLS model is horribly wrong.

BLS Black Box

For those unfamiliar with the birth/death model, monthly jobs adjustments are made by the BLS based on economic assumptions about the birth and death of businesses (not individuals). Those assumptions are made according to estimates of where the BLS thinks we are in the economic cycle.

The BLS has admitted however, that their model will be wrong at economic turning points. And there is no doubt we are long past an economic turning point.

Here is the pertinent snip from the BLS on Birth/Death Methodology.

  • The net birth/death model component figures are unique to each month and exhibit a seasonal pattern that can result in negative adjustments in some months. These models do not attempt to correct for any other potential error sources in the CES estimates such as sampling error or design limitations.
  • Note that the net birth/death figures are not seasonally adjusted, and are applied to not seasonally adjusted monthly employment links to determine the final estimate.
  • The most significant potential drawback to this or any model-based approach is that time series modeling assumes a predictable continuation of historical patterns and relationships and therefore is likely to have some difficulty producing reliable estimates at economic turning points or during periods when there are sudden changes in trend.

Household Data
In March, the number of persons working part time for economic reasons (sometimes referred to as involuntary part-time workers) climbed by 423,000 to 9.0 million. This category includes persons who would like to work full time but were working part time because their hours had been cut back or because they were unable to find full-time jobs.

Persons Not in the Labor Force

About 2.1 million persons (not seasonally adjusted) were marginally attached to the labor force in March, 754,000 more than a year earlier. These individuals wanted and were available for work and had looked for a job sometime in the prior 12 months. They were not counted as unemployed because they had not searched for work in the 4 weeks preceding the survey.

Among the marginally attached, there were 685,000 discouraged workers in March, up by 284,000 from a year earlier. Discouraged workers are persons not currently looking for work because they believe no jobs are available for them. The
other 1.4 million persons marginally attached to the labor force in March had not searched for work in the 4 weeks preceding the survey for reasons such as school attendance or family responsibilities.
Table A-5 Part Time Status



click on chart for sharper image

The chart shows 9 million people are working part time but want a full time job. A year ago the number was 4.9 million.

Table A-12

Table A-12 is where one can find a better approximation of what the unemployment rate really is. Let's take a look



click on chart for sharper image

Grim Statistics

The official unemployment rate is 8.5% and rising sharply. However, if you start counting all the people that want a job but gave up, all the people with part-time jobs that want a full-time job, all the people who dropped off the unemployment rolls because their unemployment benefits ran out, etc., you get a closer picture of what the unemployment rate is. That number is in the last row labeled U-6.

It reflects how unemployment feels to the average Joe on the street. U-6 is 15.6%. Both U-6 and U-3 (the so called "official" unemployment number) are poised to rise further.

Looking ahead, I expect the service sector to continue to weaken. Mall vacancy rates are rising and a huge contraction in commercial real estate is finally started. There is no driver for jobs and states in forced cutback mode are making matters far worse.

Unemployment is a lagging indicator, it is likely to continue rising until sometime in 2010.

ADP Employment Report

For another look at March jobs including a breakdown of stats by small, medium, and large sized businesses, please take a look at ADP Reports March Nonfarm Private Employment Decreased 742,000.

Depression Level Statistics

I consider these job losses to be depression level totals. Admittedly conditions are not as bad as the great depression, but this is certainly no ordinary recession by any economic measure including lending, housing, bank failures, jobs, the stock market, commodity prices, treasury yields etc. For more on this idea please see Humpty Dumpty On Inflation.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Social Security: There Is No Trust; There Is No Fund

Social Security is back in the limelight where once again its problems will no doubt be ignored.

Please consider Recession Puts a Major Strain On Social Security Trust Fund.
The U.S. recession is wreaking havoc on yet another front: the Social Security trust fund.

With unemployment rising, the payroll tax revenue that finances Social Security benefits for nearly 51 million retirees and other recipients is falling, according to a report from the Congressional Budget Office. As a result, the trust fund's annual surplus is forecast to all but vanish next year -- nearly a decade ahead of schedule -- and deprive the government of billions of dollars it had been counting on to help balance the nation's books.

The Treasury Department has for decades borrowed money from the Social Security trust fund to finance government operations. If it is no longer able to do so, it could be forced to borrow an additional $700 billion over the next decade from China, Japan and other investors. And at some point, perhaps as early as 2017, according to the CBO, the Treasury would have to start repaying the billions it has borrowed from the trust fund over the past 25 years, driving the nation further into debt or forcing Congress to raise taxes.
My Comment: Therein lies the rub. There is no fund per se. It's all been spent, and then some.
"It suggests we better get working on Social Security and stop burying our heads in the sand," said Sen. Judd Gregg (N.H.), the senior Republican on the Senate Budget Committee. "The Social Security trust fund, though technically in balance, is going to put huge pressures on taxpayers very soon."
My Comment: There is negative money in the fund so it's complete nonsense to claim it is "technically in balance".
Many liberal analysts reject the notion that Social Security needs fixing, arguing that the system is projected to fully support payments to beneficiaries through 2041 -- so long as the Treasury repays its debts.
My Comment: "...So long as the Treasury repays its debt" And exactly how likely is that? Has anyone looked at Obama's budget?
The trust fund has long taken in more in revenue from payroll taxes and other sources than it pays out in benefits. Last August, the CBO predicted that surplus would exceed $80 billion this year and next, then rise to around $90 billion before slowly evaporating by 2020. But the rapidly deteriorating economy -- particularly the loss of more than 4 million jobs -- has driven those numbers much lower much faster, with the surplus expected to hit $16 billion this year and only $3 billion next year, then vanish entirely by 2017.

In his budget, Obama predicted that the trust fund surplus would hit $30 billion this year, according to Mark Lassiter, a spokesman for the Social Security Administration.

But that number, too, is far less than the $80 billion the trustees had forecast for 2009. In addition to declining revenues, Lassiter said the system is likely to incur higher expenses due to big jumps in new retirement and disability claims. Both are expected to rise by at least 12 percent this year compared with 2008.
My Comment: Can we stop with the nonsense? Revenues exceed payouts but that does not mean there is a fund. Every penny and then some has been borrowed and spent. And even the so called surplus is falling like a rock, a decade faster than expected.

Obama's $9.3 Trillion Budget Deficit

Inquiring minds are pondering Obama budget could bring $9.3 trillion in deficits.
President Barack Obama's budget would produce $9.3 trillion in deficits over the next decade, more than four times the deficits of Republican George W. Bush's presidency, congressional auditors said Friday.

The new Congressional Budget Office figures offered a far more dire outlook for Obama's budget than the new administration predicted just last month � a deficit $2.3 trillion worse. It's a prospect even the president's own budget director called unsustainable.

The dismal deficit figures, if they prove to be accurate, inevitably raise the prospect that Obama and his Democratic allies controlling Congress would have to consider raising taxes after the recession ends or else pare back his agenda.

By CBO's calculation, Obama's budget would generate deficits averaging almost $1 trillion a year of red ink over 2010-2019.

Worst of all, CBO says the deficit under Obama's policies would never go below 4 percent of the size of the economy, figures that economists agree are unsustainable. By the end of the decade, the deficit would exceed 5 percent of gross domestic product, a dangerously high level.

Most disturbing to Obama allies like Senate Budget Committee Chairman Kent Conrad, D-N.D., are the longer term projections, which climb above $1 trillion again by the end of the next decade and approach 6 percent of GDP by 2019.

The worsening economy is responsible for the even deeper fiscal mess inherited by Obama. As an illustration, CBO says the deficit for the current budget year, which began Oct. 1, will top $1.8 trillion, $93 billion more than foreseen by the White House. That would equal 13 percent of GDP, a level not seen since World War II.
Trust Fund Projections



click on chart for sharper image

Let's return to the ridiculous claim made by analysts: Many liberal analysts reject the notion that Social Security needs fixing, arguing that the system is projected to fully support payments to beneficiaries through 2041 -- so long as the Treasury repays its debts.

For starters it is clear to see the 2041 figure is nonsense. And given that every cent of the fund has been spent, exactly how is the treasury supposed to repay that fund in light of $9.3 trillion (with a T) budget deficits when the "surplus" is a mere $16 Billion (with a B)?

Finally, why does everyone continue the charade of calling Social Security a "trust fund" when it's clearly not a fund and there cannot possibly be any trust in it?

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List