Monday, 10 August 2009

US Consumer Credit Shows Steepest Contraction in Over 5 Decades

Please consider Monday morning's Breakfast With Dave regarding an unprecedented drop in consumer credit.
No Credit Where Credit Is Due

U.S. consumer credit outstanding fell $10 billion in June, the fifth decline in a row during which the debt balance has shrunk $60 billion or 5.5% at an annual rate � both figures are unprecedented. As the chart below shows, the YoY trend, at -2.8%, is also running at its steepest contractionary rate in over five decades.

Welcome to the new paradigm of savings, asset liquidation and debt repayment � the era of consumer frugality. After 20 years of living beyond their means, American consumers will be spending the next several years living below their means, and no, this will not be the end of the world, but it will put a firm ceiling on overall demand growth for some time to come.

Consumer Credit Outstanding



10-Year Treasuries vs. Consumer Credit



CPI vs. Consumer Inflation



Consumer Spending vs. Consumer Credit



Record Slide In Bank Lending



We just received the monthly data on commercial bank lending in July and it showed a record contraction of $64.0 billion, which is the equivalent of a 12.0% annualized decline. This was the third month in a row of declining bank credit to households and businesses during which the contraction has totaled $149.0 billion (again, an unprecedented 9.0% decline at an annual rate). We are not sure if a recovery can be sustained without credit creation � we haven�t seen it happen in the past, but maybe there is a new paradigm of a credit-less recovery awaiting us.
Thanks to Dave Rosenberg for the above series of 5 stunning charts that highlight the inflation/deflation debate. The key take away is those charts all show deflation.

Indeed, in a credit based economy a better title for chart 3 might be "Credit IS Inflation".

With that thought, you may wish to review the Fiat World Mathematical Model that explains why the money multiplier lag theory fails and why it's credit, not base money supply that is important.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Zombie Subdivisions and "Pig In The Python" Shadow Inventory

The Atlanta Journal Constitution is reporting fire-sale prices on some lots have dipped to 20 to 30 cents on the dollar as the Volume of 'subdivision' vacant lots overwhelms banks.
You think it�s hard selling a house these days? Try unloading a subdivision. And not just any subdivision, but one with few if any completed homes and a weedy patch where the swim-and-tennis center was planned.

That�s the reality many Georgia banks find themselves in amid a foreclosure crisis that has claimed not only individual homes but also entire failed developments.

These idled, �zombie� subdivisions can be found across metro Atlanta, but they�re most prevalent in outer-ring suburban areas. Selling them has proven tough, with some properties sitting on the market for months on end without even a nibble. In the past year, 16 Georgia banks have failed, more than in any other state, largely because of residential real estate losses. Dozens more are struggling.

To say the market has been sluggish would be an understatement. The main problem is sheer volume � a staggering 150,000 vacant housing lots across metro Atlanta are available, more than a decade�s supply at current absorption rates.

The flood of distressed subdivisions is unprecedented and has given banks numerous headaches.

Is it more cost-effective to complete half-finished homes before selling or to put them on the market as-is? Should they sell lots in a distressed market or hold onto them until prices rebound?

Complicating matters, subdivisions often were financed by more than one bank. And different lenders frequently disagree on what steps to take when problems arise.
Shadow Inventory Is "Pig In The Python"

RealtyCheck asks the question How big is the Shadow Housing Inventory?
For the past few months I've talked a little bit about so-called "shadow inventory." These are the homes that banks have taken back after foreclosures (known as REO properties). In normal times banks immediately turn REOs around and up them up for sale, but that's not happening at a very fast clip these days. The Realtor's chief economist, Lawrence Yun, called it a "business decision" by the banks:

"I believe that many banks including Fannie and Freddie, who are also holding onto some properties, are releasing foreclosed properties in a measured way so as to not to flood the market which they perceive then perhaps could lead them to even more drastic price cuts. So they are releasing properties on a measured pace as a business decision to minimize losses."

So what exactly is the size of this shadow inventory?

Hard to say, but estimates are that it could be around 700,000.

This of course does not include the foreclosures that are still in process, which builder analyst Ivy Zelman refers to as "the pig in the python." Builders are concerned that if these properties suddenly flood the market, their new high hopes could turn right back around.
Shadow Units Cast Pall

Here is an article I picked up from Calculated Risk. Crain's New York is reporting Shadow units cast pall.
New York City's condominium market may be in even worse shape than the commonly used yardsticks show.

In Manhattan in the first quarter, sales were halved from year-earlier levels even as more apartments flooded onto the market, leaving it choking on an 18.6-month supply of units. Meanwhile, in the recently red-hot neighborhood of Williamsburg in Brooklyn, sales in the period plummeted by 70% as even more units expanded the property glut there.

As bad as those figures look, they may actually overstate the health of the market. Industry experts point to a growing mountain of so-called shadow inventory that is not reflected in the data. This includes units that are held by developers in soon-to-be completed buildings, as well as those kept off the market by banks and by individual owners who are waiting for conditions to improve before they tack up �For Sale� signs.

Flawed inventory count

�We are undercounting the housing stock,� says Jonathan Miller, chief executive of appraisal firm Miller Samuel Inc. �And when you have more inventory than the market can absorb, it places pressure on prices.�

�More inventory will continue to lower rents,� says Marc Lewis, president of Century 21 NY Metro, who believes that Manhattan vacancy rates are closer to 5% than the 2% reported by most industry players.

Given the dismal market and a lack of financing, few new buildings�if any�will be started in coming months. But scores of properties that were already under construction before the credit crisis of 2007 will hit the market in the next few years.

�It is hard to keep steady watch on how much shadow there is in the city,� explains Mr. Miller. �The number is constantly moving.�
Pent-Up Demand To Sell

The above articles represent one kind of shadow inventory, condos, homes, and lots held off the market in fear of overwhelming demand. There is another kind of shadow inventory at stake: those who do not need to sell and do not have their units for sale officially or unofficially, but would sell if prices started rising.

Please consider "Shadow" inventory lurks over U.S. housing recovery.
"The number of homes listed officially on the market, while still at historically high levels, might be only the tip of the iceberg," said Stan Humphries, chief economist at real estate website Zillow.com in Seattle, Washington.

According to Zillow's latest Homeowner Confidence Survey, 12 percent of homeowners said they would be "very likely" to put their home on the market in the next 12 months if they saw signs of a real estate market turnaround, 8 percent said "likely," while 12 percent said "somewhat likely."

Survey results could translate into around 20 million homeowners trying to sell their homes, a startling number given that the Census bureau indicates there are 93 million U.S. houses, condos and co-ops, Humphries said.

According to the National Association of Realtors, the market is currently on track to sell 4.89 million homes annually.

"At this pace, it would take about four years to run through this amount of backlogged inventory," he said.

"Shadow inventory has the potential to give us another leg down on home prices during the second half of the year," said Steven Wood, chief economist at Insight Economics in Danville, California.
Fundamental Factors Affecting Housing

  • Tougher lending standards: no more liar loans, bigger down payments, closer look at incomes, etc.
  • Tougher appraisal standards
  • The difficulty of finding jobs
  • Wage and benefit cuts shrinks affordability for those who do have a job
  • Huge bank-owned shadow inventories
  • Huge developer shadow inventories, especially in condos
  • Consumer willingness to "walk away"
  • Rising delinquencies and foreclosures due to rising unemployment
  • Rising taxes
  • Overleveraged consumers
  • Pent-up demand to sell in a "please get me out mentality" if prices rise just a bit
  • The upcoming boomer retirement downsizing event
  • A change in consumer attitudes regarding housing as an investment
  • A new frugality in consumer attitudes towards debt in general

Every market is different, but in general, the odds of a huge nation-wide rebound in home prices is slim given that backdrop. Housing prices will likely remain depressed for several more years at least. In "real terms" I expect prices will decline for another decade.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Shattered Housing Dreams and the Painful Process of Household Deleveraging

Inquiring minds are reading a Comstock Special Report on Deleveraging the U.S. Economy.
We are in the process of deleveraging the most leveraged economy in history. Many investors look at this deleveraging as a positive for the United States. We, on the other hand, look at this deleveraging as a major negative that will weigh on the economy for years to come and we could wind up with a lost couple of decades just as Japan experienced over the past 20 years.

We, however, don't believe that the U.S. massive stimulus programs and money printing can solve a problem of excess debt generation that resulted from greed and living way beyond our means. If this were the answer Argentina would be one of the most prosperous countries in the world. This excess debt actually resulted from the same money printing and easy money that we are now using to alleviate the pain.

The attached chart of total debt relative to GDP shows exactly how much debt grew in this country relative to GDP (it is now 375% of GDP). The total debt grew to over $52 trillion relative to our current GDP of approximately $14 trillion. This is worse than the debt to GDP relationship in the great depression (even when the GDP imploded) and greater than the debt to GDP that existed in Japan in 1989. Even if you took the debt to GDP when the U.S. entered the secular bear market in early 2000 and compared that to 1929 and Japan in late 1989, our debt to GDP still exceeded both (by a substantial margin relative to 1929). The approximate numbers at that time were about 275% in the U.S. in early 2000, 190% in 1929, and about 270% in Japan in 1989.

In fact, the similarities between Japan's deleveraging and the U.S. presently are eerie. Japan's total debt to GDP increased from 270% when their secular bear market started to just about 350% 7 years later (1998) before declining to 110% presently. The U.S. increased their total debt to GDP from 275% of GDP when our secular bear market started (in our opinion) to 375% presently (10 years later), and we suspect the total debt to decline similar to Japan's even though the Japanese govenment debt tripled during their deleveraging.

We expect that the U.S. deleveraging will follow along the path of Japan for years as real estate continues to decline and the deleveraging extracts a significant toll from any growth the economy might experience. We also expect that, just like Japan, the stock market will also be sluggish to down during the next few years as the most leveraged economy in history unwinds the debt.
Is Deleveraging a Positive or Negative Thing?

Comstock's opening gambit was:

"Many investors look at this deleveraging as a positive for the United States. We, on the other hand, look at this deleveraging as a major negative that will weigh on the economy for years to come and we could wind up with a lost couple of decades just as Japan experienced over the past 20 years."

Given the longer we go without deleveraging the worse things get in the long run, I would suggest that deleveraging is a very positive thing as well as a necessary adjustment for the United States.

However, if one is talking about the effect on the stock market, it will not feel like a good thing because it will lower earnings.

I have talked about the concept of the lost decades and deleveraging many times myself, most recently in Effect of Household Deleveraging on Housing, Consumption and the Stock Market.

Peak Credit and Peak Earnings

Not long ago, the US was once a nation of savers. Now that the housing bubble has crashed and the stock market along with it, the US is poised to become a nation of savers again.

Peak Credit and her twin sister Peak Earnings have arrived. Here is a snip from the former.

... That final wave of consumer recklessness created the exact conditions required for its own destruction. The housing bubble orgy was the last hurrah. It is not coming back and there will be no bigger bubble to replace it. Consumers and banks have both been burnt, and attitudes have changed.

It took nearly 80 years for people to get as reckless as they did in 1929. 80 years! Few are still alive that went through the great depression. No one listened to them. That is the nature of the game. The odds of a significant bout of inflation now are about the same as they were in 1929. Next to none.

Children whose parents are being destroyed by debt now, will keep those memories for a long time.

Deflation or Inflation?

The raging debate now is when (not if) the Fed's massive printing is going to spark a huge round of "inflation" forcing up interest rates. The fears are unfounded.

The key to sorting this endgame out is simple: Financial deleveraging constitutes deflation by definition.

Household debt via bankruptcies, foreclosures, credit card defaults, and walk-aways is falling faster than the Fed is "effectively printing". I use the term "effectively printing" because the Fed can print all it wants and if the money just sits as excess reserves, the velocity of that money will be zero and it will not affect the economy or prices.

Moreover, savings are rising, and banks have little impetus to lend, and consumers and businesses are reluctant to borrow.

Excess Reserves



click on chart for sharper image

The above chart is proof enough of banks' unwillingness to lend and/or credit worthy individuals and businesses unwillingness to borrow.

Shattered Housing Dreams

In the long run, consumption cannot grow faster than income. Borrowing to support consumption only works as long as asset prices are rising. Consumers were willing to go deeper in debt and banks were willing to lend based on the now-shattered dreams of forever rising home prices.

In aggregate, consumers are now unable to service their debt, and the deflationary deleveraging process has started. Consumers will either default on debt, pay their debt down very slowly over time, or some combination of both.

Thus, the most likely result of Bernanke's printing press operation will be to drag the "job loss recovery" out for another decade, just as happened in Japan.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Sunday, 9 August 2009

On the Brink of Recovery

Economist Paul Krugman and Obama's economic adviser Laura Tyson claim U.S. Economy May Be on Brink of Recovery.
The U.S. economy may be on the cusp of a recovery and the impact of the nation�s stimulus plan should increase this quarter, said Laura Tyson, an adviser to President Barack Obama.

�We may have hit stability, we may be in the beginning of an upturn� based on the latest economic data, Tyson, a member of the White House�s Economic Recovery Advisory Board, said yesterday during an interview in Kuala Lumpur. Nobel Prize- winning economist Paul Krugman said the deepest slump since the Great Depression may be ending.

�It�s quite possible, though not certain, that retrospectively, we�ll say that the recession ended in July or August, maybe September,� Krugman said in a separate interview in the Malaysian capital. �My guess is that we�ve bottomed out now, that August was probably the trough month.�

There�s no reason for a second stimulus package now, Tyson said in the interview. She suggested on July 7 the U.S. should consider drafting a second stimulus package focusing on infrastructure projects because the $787 billion approved in February was �a bit too small.� She told CNBC three days later that it�s premature to plan for a second stimulus package.

�We know that relative to plan, the stimulus package in place is performing along expectations,� Tyson said yesterday. �Right now, based on the evidence that the economy has put forward and the stimulus spend out relative to plan, there isn�t any reason to think about a next round.�
Krugman Thinks Stimulus Round Two Needed

In contrast to Tyson, Paul Krugman argues a second stimulus is still needed. Please consider U.S. Economy May Have Reached �Trough,� Krugman Says.
The U.S. economy is stabilizing and may have bottomed out, as the government�s stimulus plan probably saved a million jobs, Nobel Prize winner Paul Krugman said today.

A second stimulus package for the economy is still needed, and should be directed at state and local governments as well as infrastructure spending, he said in an interview in Kuala Lumpur. The world economy may face several years of weak growth without falling into a �double-dip� recession, he said.

�It�s quite possible, though not certain, that retrospectively, we�ll say that the recession ended in July or August, maybe September,� Krugman, 56, said. �My guess is that we�ve bottomed out now, that August was probably the trough month.�

The Princeton University economist said Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke �has done a really good job� to contain the financial and economic crisis.

�He failed to see this coming and he was behind the curve in early phases,� Krugman said. �But he�s been really very good in the sense that it�s really very hard to see how anyone could have done more to stem this crisis. He�s earned the right to a second term.�

Krugman said in June the U.S. may emerge from its downturn by September. In a June 9 speech, he said damage from the U.S. recession may persist �for a very long time,� with no clear engine for renewed growth.
Bernanke Should Be Fired

Bernanke never saw this coming then had a panic attack of various alphabet soup measures attempting to prevent another "Great Depression".

About a week ago Calculated Risk wrote "I'd like a doctor who never gave up trying for a cure, but I'd prefer someone with better diagnostic skills."

Indeed.

Praising Bernanke now is like praising a doctor for nearly killing your son because he finally guessed right on the fourth guess (in this case assuming that the right medicine has finally been prescribed, which is debatable).

Bear Stearns collapsed. Did the world end? Lehman went bankrupt. Did the world end? If Citigroup went under would the world have ended? I think not but I cannot prove it. Nor can Bernanke or Krugman prove the world would have ended had Citigroup gone under.

Campaigning For Fed Chairman

In an unprecedented move, Bernanke is clearly campaigning for reappointment. Please see Bernanke Goes On Self-Promotional Media Blitz for details.

It is equally clear that Janet Yellen, president of the Federal Reserve bank of San Francisco, and Larry Summers, Director of the White House's National Economic Council for President Barack Obama, are campaigning to replace Bernanke.

The correct solution of course is none of the above. We need to abolish the Fed and its serial bubble blowing tactics entirely.

Keynesian Clowns Want To "Make Sure"


If the economy has bottomed, pray tell why is a second stimulus needed? Just to make sure?

Keynesian clowns always want to make sure. Then when the stimulus fails anyway, which it will, the clowns will blame it on failure to "Make Sure".

Easy To Praise Keynesian Clowns When You Are One

Krugman has high praise for Bernanke. The reason should be clear but it probably isn't. The reason Krugman likes Bernanke is that Bernanke is willing to throw money at problems just as Krugman would do.

It's easy to praise Keynesian clowns when you are one yourself.

Bernanke (in misguided praise of himself), and Krugman (in misguided praise of a fellow fool), both think Bernanke saved the day.

I think they did nothing of the kind. However, the debate cannot be proven no matter what happens from here on out.

Perhaps Armageddon was not coming no matter what silly measures were taken by Bernanke. Indeed I claim that Bernanke's measures will drag this mess on for another decade, just as happened in Japan.

My claim can only be verified 5-10 years from now. Bernanke and Krugman have a distinct advantage: Their claim can never be proven or disproved given their inevitable fallback excuse "we failed to stimulate enough".

The Seen and The Unseen

The "seen" benefits (prevention of Armageddon) may be a mirage. Financial Armageddon may come anyway, or it may not have come regardless of what Bernanke did. After all, social safety nets are vastly different now than in 1929!

And while most have their party hats are celebrating the "recovery" now, others are asking What Growth is the S&P 500 Pricing In?

Right now we know that the jobs picture still sucks, that credit card defaults are still rising, that bankruptcies and foreclosures are still rising and the budget deficit is out of control.

Furthermore, we can easily see the massive $14 trillion balance sheet of the Fed while the benefit is debatable. The "unseen" is the massive set of problems down the road unwinding the Fed's positions. Those consequences are without a doubt coming down the road.

Presuming we are indeed "On the Brink of Recovery", what PE are you willing to pay given the recovery has not even started, yet we still face the seen and unseen consequences at highlighted above?

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Saturday, 8 August 2009

What Growth is the S&P 500 Pricing In?

Dave Rosenberg is asking the important question What Growth is the S&P 500 Pricing In?
Based on past linkages between earnings trends and the pace of economic activity, believe it or not, the S&P 500 is now de facto discounting a 4�% real GDP growth rate for the coming year. That is what we would call a V-shaped recovery. While it is possible, though in our opinion a low-odds event, it is doubtful that the economy is going to be better than that. So we have a market that is more than fully priced for a post-recession world � any further gains would suggest that we are moving further into the �greed� trade.

We realize that the market has to climb a wall of worry and that it will often price in a lot of bad news, but for the first time ever, it has rallied nearly 50% amidst a two-million job slide since March. That is either whistling past the graveyard or at the lows the market was indeed pricing in a full-fledged depression.

Think about that last comment. Whatever the market was pricing in at the March lows was obviously a pretty bad outcome, but isn�t that what we saw in the end? To be sure, the government established a floor under the financials, but when you go back and think about the fresh lows posted in late 2002, it was about earnings and the economy, not about financials.

In the four months after the recent lows in March, employment plunged by two million, which is as much carnage as we saw in the entire 2001 recession � and we are talking about the entire cycle including the jobless recovery that spanned from March 2001 to June 2003! We will guarantee you one thing � it is doubtful that the two million folks who lost their jobs are going to be heading to the malls, dealerships or restaurants anytime soon. And while that is only a sliver of the 130 million U.S. workforce, change does occur at the margin.

Usually, government plays a small role, but this time around, it may be the only actor in the play, and what multiple does that deserve is a very good question, especially now that Uncle Sam�s generosity is supporting a record of nearly 20% of personal income. The fact that we have now resorted to �Cash for Clunkers� to support consumption is a very sorry state of affairs.




While the hosts on the CNBC show we were on yesterday afternoon claimed that the bounce in July auto sales was evidence of pent-up demand, we would simply have to disagree. If there was pent-up demand we wouldn�t need the subsidy to begin with � it just goes to show that there will always be people who will be willing to accept free money. What we think is important is how low the level of auto sales were in July, at barely more than 11 million units at an annual rate. It was only nine-years ago that auto-related stimulus (�0% financing�) brought us 21 million units; and just four-years ago another gimmick (�Employee discount for everyone�) brought us 20 million units. The �new normal�, we would have to assume after the response to �Cash for Clunkers�, is 11 million units. That�s supposed to get us excited over the consumer spending outlook? Keep in mind that we never saw 21 or 20 million units again after those prior programs were unveiled � could it be that we just saw 11 million for the last time too?

Low Quality Rally

Reuters did some nifty work and showed that in this last leg of the rally, which started on July 10th, CCC-rated stocks have surged 26.4%, BB-rated stocks are up 19.3%, while AAA-rated stocks have risen 9.5%. Look � when China is up 80% year-to-date, India 60%, and both the Kospi and Hang Seng up 40% � and dare we say, the SOX index up 60% in less than six months � it�s probably safe to assume that we have a huge speculative junky market on our hands. And, we know from the 2000-2001 and 2007-2008 experiences, they don�t tend to end well.

Bear Market Stages



click on chart for sharper image

Too Much Complacency For Our Liking

We mentioned how bullish the latest Market Vane Sentiment reading was, and now we have the latest data-point on the Investors Intelligence poll. The envelope please:

� Bulls: 47.2% versus 42.2% a week ago
� Bears: 25.8% versus 31.1% a week ago

The bull/bear spread widened by over 10 percentage points this week; a nightmare for the technical analyst (from a contrary perspective).
Video on Bear Market Rally



Rosenberg suggests there will be no recovery without the consumer. I suggest there will be no recovery in consumer spending, discounting of course "free money" programs like "cash for clunkers".

Of course this all depends on the definition of "recovery". At best, I think we have a "Recoveryless Recovery" before the economy slips back into a double or triple dip recession. Regardless, the stock market is priced for perfection while the odds of perfection are close to zero.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

United Healthcare Workers Postpones Pension Problems

United Healthcare Workers East, SEIU1199, the largest union in the East for non-nursing healthcare workers, started a campaign to rescue its pension plan while simultaneously demanding no reduction in benefits.

RR Described The Process:
Mish,

The 1199 is the largest union in the north east for non nursing healthcare workers. Almost all of the hospitals in NYC are 1199 hospitals.

In the past couple of months I began seeing "The price of peace" and "Save our Benefits" buttons around my department. My employees were either unsure or unwilling to divulge the issue the slogans represented.

At a managers meeting we learned that the union was requesting the CBA (collective bargaining agreement) be reopened. Evidently their pension fund has lost about 40% since the market fell off a cliff and they were demanding the employers double their per employee contribution!! That is a jump from 6% to 12%, an incredible and unreasonable request.

The league of hospitals responded that if that is to be the case there is going to have to be changes made to the benefits the union employees currently enjoy. Hence the buttons and slogans. In every conversation all I heard was how the horrible employers want to take away the golden benefits of the employees. Never once was mentioned how the Union requested the CBA be reopened and how they want the employer to pick up the tab for their poor investment choices!

Of course the union got their way however the contributions will be in the form of employee raise deferrals directly into the pension plan. The employees get guaranteed 3% increases at least once per year and now these increases will enter the pension fund instead.

It is truly disgusting to me that employers must cater to such outrageous demands. Since the union members also have a 401k I'm surprised they didn't ask for some kind of reimbursement for those losses. The 1199 and NYSNA unions have some phenomenally generous benefits:

- Higher education completely covered up to doctorate level

- 0$ office visit copays and prescription benefits

- Separate sick time, paid time off and vacation days

At a time when many NYC hospitals are on the brink of financial disaster and ObamaCare looms, I cannot see how these diamond encrusted benefits can possibly continue.
As RR stated the unions got their way in the Contract Re-Opener proclaiming "We Saved Our Benefits".

All this will do is postpone the inevitable problems for a date down the road in the not too distant future. No one wants to make the tough choices now.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Friday, 7 August 2009

US Payrolls Less Than Meets The Eye

In today's Lunch With Dave Dave Rosenberg shows how US Payrolls Less Than Meets The Eye.
Today�s employment report is being treated as a �green shoot� of major proportions. While it was by far the best jobs performance of the year, much of the better-than-expected tally in nonfarm payrolls reflected the bounce in auto production as well as the distortion from the federal census workers. Combined, these two influences effectively �added� 100,000 to the headline number, so net-net, the consensus view of -325,000 was not as far off the mark as the market believed at first glance.

The auto sector added 28,200 to the industry payroll in July, which was the highest tally in 11 years. To show you just how big that really is, it is a 69% annualized surge. Normally, the industry, which is in secular decline, posts job losses of between 20,000 and 30,000 consistently, so this alone represented roughly a 50,000 swing. We estimate that there was about a 30,000 swing in the rest of the manufacturing sector due to the spillover from the current inventory adjustment in the motor vehicle industry. The 0.3% MoM increase in the workweek was also skewed by the 4.1% MoM jump in the auto sector.

As we mentioned, there have been large fluctuations in the federal government payroll too. After hiring a slew of Census workers in the spring, there were 57,000 layoffs in May-June and then we saw in today�s report that 12,000 federal workers were �hired� in July. Again, mathematically, this contributed about 20,000 to today�s headline number. In other words, and we have no intent on raining on anyone�s parade, there was about 100,000 non-recurring payrolls in that top-line figure. It may be dangerous to extrapolate today�s report into a view that we are about to fully turn the corner on the job market front.

Yes, the income number was also firm; average weekly earnings popped 0.5%, but again, this reflected the bounce in the auto sector as well as the 10.7% increase in the minimum wage to $7.25 an hour. Again, this is a non-recurring item and does not at all reflect an improvement in underlying income fundamentals in the personal sector. We had a similar bounce in the summer of 2008 when the minimum wage was last boosted.



To be sure, the drop in the unemployment rate was a surprise, but it was all due to the slide in the labour force � the employment-to-population ratio gives a more accurate picture of the slack in the labour market and the hidden secret in today�s report was that this metric slid to a 25-year low of 59.4% from 59.5% in June and 61.0% at the turn of the year. Of those unemployed, 33.8% of them have been unemployed now for over 27 weeks � a record amount (was at 29.0% in June and was at 17.5% at the start of this recession).
I talked about the participation rate this morning in Jobs Contract 19th Straight Month; Unemployment Rate Inches Lower to 9.4%

Taking one time auto sector anomalies and manipulation of the participation rate into consideration, today's job report was much weaker than looks at first glance.

As I said earlier, "The BLS stopped counting".

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List