Fissures are developing among policy makers at the Federal Reserve as they debate how and when to start raising the benchmark interest rate from its current level just above zero.
With Fed officials forecasting that unemployment will average 9.8 percent in 2010, nobody appears to be arguing that monetary policy should be tightened anytime soon.
But Fed officials have hinted at new disagreement in recent weeks. The arguments go beyond the traditional split between hawks, who worry that easy money will stoke inflation, and doves, who contend that unemployment is the top problem.
The more devilish debates are about how fast to act once the decision has been made, and how to carry it out. Beyond raising the overnight federal funds rate, the Fed also has to unwind $2 trillion in special programs that prop up paralyzed banks and credit markets.
�When the economic outlook has improved sufficiently, we will be prepared to tighten the stance of monetary policy and eventually return our balance sheet to a more normal configuration,� Mr. Bernanke promised.
Policy makers are haunted by the results of previous miscalculations. Mr. Bernanke and others have warned that the central bank should not repeat its error in 1937, when it raised interest rates too early and helped extend the Depression for several years.
At the same time, officials at the Fed are acutely aware that it has been widely blamed for contributing to the housing bubble and the financial collapse by keeping the cost of borrowing too low for too long after the recession of 2001.
Fissures or Canyons?
Are these fissures we are discussing or canyons? Take a look at what some Fed Members are saying.
Thomas M. Hoenig, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of Kansas City: �My experience tells me that we will need to remove our very accommodative policy sooner rather than later. Even if we were to start immediately, much time would pass before incremental increases could be considered tight or even neutral policy.�
Richard Fisher, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of Dallas: "�That wind-down process needs to begin as soon as there are convincing signs that economic growth is gaining traction.�
What Does Bernanke Mean?
Bernanke's statement �When the economic outlook has improved sufficiently, we will be prepared to tighten the stance of monetary policy and eventually return our balance sheet to a more normal configuration� is completely ambiguous because "improved sufficiently" can mean whatever he wants it to mean.
In the absence of a definition, everyone else is left guessing.
Calculated Risk discusses the above in NY Times: Divergent Fed Views and came to the conclusion that "improved sufficiently means Bernanke will wait for a meaningful decline in the unemployment rate".
I happen to agree with CR that unemployment is what Bernanke may be hinting at, but who really knows? It's quite possible Bernanke does not know himself. It is also possible he is purposely ambiguous hoping to soothe the markets.
When Will The Fed Start Hiking?
Based on unemployment rate expectations, CR "does not expect the Fed to raise rates until late in 2010 at the earliest - and more likely sometime in 2011"
Look for unemployment to rise until late 2010 at a minimum. Mid-to-late 2011 is a distinct possibility as is an unemployment rate north of 11%. Of course real unemployment is already approaching 20%.
If unemployment is Bernanke's ticket, we might not see hikes until 2012.
However, that 2012 date assumes a lot of things: There is no treasury market revolt, unemployment stays high, a panic in the US dollar or the derivatives market does not force Bernanke's hand earlier, and that Bernanke can retain control of the Fed. That's a lot of assumptions for sure.
Bernanke's Dilemma
Bernanke wants banks to lend but not recklessly so because it will increase future writeoffs. That is an incredibly fine line to walk given the massive problems in commercial real estate, housing, and credit card portfolios in conjunction with rising unemployment, rising foreclosures, and rising bankruptcies.
Although Bernanke wants banks to prudently lend, he also wants to pay banks interest on excess reserves so that the Fed can slowly recapitalize banks over time. Yet, paying interest on reserves encourages banks to not lend. Why should banks lend when risk is high and the Fed is paying them interest to sit?
Bernanke wants a steep yield curve to help bank profits. However, Bernanke does not want mortgage rates to go up, which is what they would normally do if the yield curve steepens.
Bernanke does not want to expand the Fed's balance sheet anymore than he already has. However, the Fed is directly buying treasuries and agencies hoping to keep down mortgage rates in the face of a potentially steepening yield curve.
Outside the US, there is universal demand for the US dollar to strengthen and the US savings rate to increase. Bernanke, the Treasury, and the Administration want the opposite. Complicating the issue, Bernanke surely does not want a disorderly decline in the US dollar because he might be forced to defend it by hiking rates. Adding to the dollar crosscurrents, talk by Fed Governors encouraging Bernanke to hike is on the surface dollar supportive, if only for a while.
The Eurozone, Japan, China, the UK, and the US are all in the same boat, hoping for a weaker currency to stimulate exports. It logically cannot happen. Please see Gold And The Watched Pot Theory for further discussion of this balance of trade problem the G-7 and G-20 refused to address.
Crosscurrents Many, Solutions Zero
One thing all the central banks have in common during any crisis is they all want to buy time.
With that in mind, one might even wonder if the statements by Bernanke and the other Fed members are nothing more than an attempt to appease both the hawks and the doves simultaneously via conflicting and/or ambiguous signals, hoping to buy time.
Regardless of what they are trying to do (if indeed they even know), Bernanke in particular, and central banks in general are clearly juggling a lot of balls. In light of global and domestic crosscurrents, it is questionable how much longer this high-wire juggling act can last.
Thanks to all of those who acted on various Audit the Fed Campaigns. However, the campaign may not have been as effective as it should have been. The following Email from "Jacob" should be self-explanatory. There is still more work to be done.
Hello Mish,
Please note that Barney Frank's personal Congressional office (for his Massachusetts 4th district) is not the most effective address for registering support for Ron Paul�s �audit the Fed� bill, H.R. 1207, the Federal Reserve Transparency Act of 2009. This office is only accountable to Frank's home district and generally does not care what people in other districts or states think.
The right address is the Democratic staff of the House Financial Services Committee, which Frank chairs. It is these people who would be writing and/or editing the legislation in question, and advising Frank accordingly. In principle, they are accountable to the entire USA. Without a flood of citizen lobbying, they will most likely water down H.R. 1207 into something meaningless, or else ignore it altogether.
The committee Democrats' central phone number is (202) 225�4247, and the fax is (202) 225-6952. Alternately, and perhaps more effectively, you can politely email some or all of the committee's most senior Democrat staff directly, as follows:
Committee staff director and chief counsel: Jeanne.Roslanowick@mail.house.gov
Another technique, if you live within reasonable driving or Amtrak range of Washington and you can spare a day off work, is to show up with a group of well-dressed, like-minded people at the Committee�s front office (2129 Rayburn House Office Building, Washington, DC 20515) and have your most eloquent group member tell the receptionist that you would like to speak with one of the above staff, or anyone who is available, regarding H.R. 1207.
The Committee Democrats have over 50 staff, so there is absolutely no reason why you cannot speak to someone other than a 22-year old receptionist. Be politely insistent and try not to leave empty-handed unless threatened with eviction or arrest.
You can also contact Committee members directly, asking them to talk to Barney Frank about H.R. 1207. By �members�, I mean other Congressmen on the Committee, and specifically on its most relevant subcommittees, which would have co-jurisdiction over the legislation.
These would likely be the Subcommittee on Domestic Monetary Policy and Technology (of which Ron Paul is the minority ranking member), the Subcommittee on Financial Institutions and Consumer Credit, and possibly the Subcommittee on Capital Markets, Insurance, and Government Sponsored Enterprises as well.
Hopefully, many of your readers will find their own Congressman on this list, or failing that, a Congressman from a neighboring district or at least the same state. (Again, there is no use in contacting a Congressman with whom you have no connection, and who owes you nothing).
Given there is strength in numbers, it would be particularly effective to arrange for multiple constituents to jointly contact the same Congressman on this issue, whether in the form of a petition/letter or, if possible, through an in-person meeting with him or his staff. Any petitions/letters should include a copy of the Text of H.R. 1207: Federal Reserve Transparency Act of 2009 and a clear, concise request for the Congressman, as a Committee member, to insist on movement of the complete and unadulterated bill to Chairman Frank, ASAP.
Of course, you also want to ensure that your Congressman is signed on to the bill as a cosponsor . To see cosponsors, go to Govtrack Audit The Fed then click on �show cosponsors�. It is particularly important to have as many members of the above subcommittees, especially Democrats, signed on to this legislation as possible).
Moreover, anyone who has in the past donated money or volunteered for their Congressman's campaign, should not hesitate to play the quid-pro-quo card at this time. Make them work for you!
I hope that this helps.
Regards,
Jacob Dreizin
Thanks to Jacob for these suggestions. Please contact the various subcommittees as Jacob has suggested.
Leading economic indicators are soaring and inquiring minds are wondering if they signal a strong recovery is in the works. First let's consider the Bullish case from the ECRI.
Oct 2 (Reuters) - An index of future U.S. economic growth slipped in the latest week, but its yearly growth rate climbed to a new record high, indicating a smooth recovery in the near-term, a research group said on Friday.
The Economic Cycle Research Institute, a New York-based independent forecasting group, said its Weekly Leading Index slipped to 127.1 in the week to Sept. 25 from an upwardly revised 127.9 the prior week, which was originally reported as 127.8.
Last week's figure marked a 60-week high.
The index's yearly growth rate rose to new all-time high of 25.1 percent in the latest reading from 24.3 percent the prior week.
"With WLI growth rising to yet another record high, the economic recovery is highly unlikely to falter in the next few months," said ECRI Managing Director Lakshman Achuthan.
"With WLI growth continuing to surge through late summer, a double dip back into recession in the fourth quarter is simply out of the question," said ECRI Managing Director Lakshman Achuthan, reinstating the group's recent warning to ignore negative analyst projections.
I would agree that a slip back into recession in the 4th quarter is unlikely, assuming of course it is even possible. Bear in mind, we have not had an official end of this recession declared yet.
However, putting such a short-term target on things while telling people to "ignore negative analyst projections" is quite a bit over the top.
Oct 2 (Reuters) - A monthly gauge of U.S. inflation pressures continued to rise in September to an 11-month high, suggesting an upswing in prices expected in an economic recovery, a research group said on Friday.
The Economic Cycle Research Institute's U.S. Future Inflation Gauge (USFIG), designed to anticipate cyclical swings in the rate of inflation, rose to 90.6 in September from an upwardly revised 89.7 in August, which was originally reported at 89.6.
"The upturns in the USFIG and its components have become fairly pronounced, pervasive and persistent. Thus, while this is not yet a significant policy concern, U.S. inflation is on the cusp of a cyclical upswing," said Lakshman Achuthan, managing director at ECRI.
Cusp of Inflation?
I will gladly take the opposite side of the ECRI's inflation warning.
Yield Curve As Of 2009-10-08
click on chart for sharper image
Since June the 3 month T-Bill has floated near zero, while the 10-Year Treasury Note yield has fallen from 4 to 3.17, a huge 83 basis points flattening of the curve. This is certainly not what one would expect to see on the "cusp of inflation".
Unfortunately we do not know the exact makeup of the ECRI's WLI (Weekly Leading Indicator's Index). After all they are selling a proprietary service.
However, we do know from the ECRI's Business Cycle Glossary that the well-known monthly Index of Leading Economic Indicators (LEI), originally developed by ECRI's founder, Geoffrey H. Moore, also oversaw the development of the WLI, which represents the latest in a long series of advances made since the introduction of the original LEI.
WLI is weekly while LEI is monthly.
Conference Board (LEI) Leading Economic Indicators
"Since reaching a peak in July 2007, the LEI fell for twenty months � the longest downtrend since the mid 1970s � but it has been rising since April and its gains have become very widespread," says Ataman Ozyildirim, Economist at The Conference Board. "The six-month growth rate of the LEI continues to accelerate. At the same time, the downtrend in the coincident economic index, measuring current economic activity, seems to be stabilizing, with the index flat so far this quarter."
Says Ken Goldstein, Economist at The Conference Board: "The LEI has risen for five consecutive months and the coincident economic index has stopped falling. Taken together, this suggests that the recession is bottoming out. These numbers are consistent with the view that after a very severe downturn, a recovery is very near. But, the intensity and pattern of that recovery is more uncertain."
Unlike the ECRI's WLI, we do know the makeup of the Conference Board's LEI.
One of the things that many market commentators and research houses have pointed at to support their bullish outlook on the stock market are the leading economic indicators. I have had the sneaky suspicion that the aggressive and unprecedented actions on the part of the Fed have played a significant role in the LEI given a misleading signal as to an economic turnaround it is forecasting, while the economic components would likely paint a different picture. It is important to understand the makeup of the Conference Board�s Leading Economic Index (LEI) and the weights that each component makes up of the LEI. Below is the breakdown of the ten indicators that make up the LEI and their respective weights in the index. As seen below, the three financial indicators make up approximately 50% of the LEI while the seven economic components make up the other 50%, with the M2 money supply alone making up 35.8% of the total LEI. Money makes the world go round, I guess, according to the LEI.
Shown below are the YOY rate of change growth rates in the Conference Board�s LEI and my indexes of the economic and monetary components separated out. What is a clear take away is that the monetary LEI is doing the heavy lifting as the economic LEI remains in negative territory.
What you can also see is that beginning in the 1980s the growth rate between the monetary and economic LEI began to show a greater disparity in their growth rates than they did in the 1970s. What this would tend to imply is that a greater level of monetary stimulus measures were needed to translate into improved economic growth rates. This aligns with the second chart below that shows the dollar increase in debt per dollar increase in GDP, which shows higher amounts of debt were needed to produce a dollar of GDP, and we are fast approaching the �Zero Hour� in which rising debt does not translate into increased economic growth, or the �pay the piper� moment for our economy.
Zero Hour - Debt Fails To Add To GDP
Further illustrating the notion that it is taking record stimulus just to keep growth going is the YOY growth rate difference between the Monetary LEI and the Economic LEI, with the disparity between the two growth rates at the highest level in the last half century.
The above charts simply illustrate that our economy is fundamentally weak and instead of allowing our economy to sober up after its debt binge, our monetary and governmental authorities are trying to keep the economy drunk and chugging along, using greater amounts of monetary alcohol than ever before.
There is much more in Chris' article including a series of charts on consumer confidence numbers.
Inquiring minds will want to take a look.
M2 LEI
M2 is the highest weighted component in the LEI weighing in at a whopping 35.80%.
Interestingly the M2 annualized rate of growth is falling rapidly and total bank credit is both negative and dropping like a rock.
M2 - Annualized Rate of Change
M2 is actually down since May-August due to the decline in the rate of growth of bank lending over the summer.
If the May-June rate of deceleration were to persist, M2 could conceivably start start contracting by year end or early '10.
Table B-2. Average weekly hours of production and nonsupervisory workers
click on chart for sharper image
For some reason the LEI is unconcerned with non-manufacturing hours at an anemic 33.0, down a tick since August and essentially going nowhere since May.
Manufacturing hours dropped from 39.9 to 39.8 month to month but reached 39.9 in July and August, up .4 from June. Temporary boost from Cash-For-Clunkers?
Payroll Hours Changes August To September (Major Categories)
Total Private -.1
Goods producing -.1
Mining and Logging -.2
Construction -.4
Manufacturing -.1
Durable Goods -.1
Nondurable Goods -.1
That is the best we could do in spite of a ridiculous give away on Cash-For-Clunkers, and a free $8,000 down payment on homes, a trillion dollar deficit, numerous bailout programs, and the Fed expanding its balance sheet by trillions of dollars.
The third largest component of the LEI is the 10-year treasury bond less the Fed Funds Rate. That component has been sinking rapidly since May as the above chart on the yield curve shows (ie the 10-year treasury note has fallen 83 basis points while the Fed Funds Rate has been flat).
Somehow, the LEI is going up with manufacturing hours stalled, the yield curve flattening substantially, and the rate of change in M2 falling fast. Those three components make up 71.2% of the LEI.
If you think this makes little sense, you are not alone. Not only do I question the makeup of the LEI components, I question the conclusions based on the makeup as given.
Nonetheless, it is quite possible the LEI and WLI work quite fine in average recessions. There are probably many combination of weightings that would produce acceptable results. However, what I suspect but cannot prove, is the LEI or WLI criteria applied to data in 1930 would have shown something that did not happen: a big recovery was coming.
Bear in mind current conditions are closer to those that existed during the great depression than any time since.
Conceptually, I like Chris' approach of separating out the monetary from the non-monetary leading indicators. The divergence is staggering. Let's not mistake a false recovery in the financial sector for a true recovery in the real economy.
Finally, as I have pointed out many times, the Fed cannot force consumers to borrow or banks to lend. Without an increase in debt, it is highly unlikely for any kind of meaningful recovery. Moreover, given the problem is excess consumption and excess debt, we should not even be rooting for another borrowing binge to take place.
Given all the finger pointing at the US over monetary printing and the debasement of the US dollar, inquiring minds just might be asking "What is China doing?"
That's a good question, so let's look at monetary numbers translated from Chinese.
The Chinese central banks' printing and respective Chinese bank lending make us look like amateurs. Chinese central bank assets and the money supply are up 25-26% annualized YTD. But this growth rate of money supply and bank lending is what is required to make up for the 8-10% net contraction in output from the collapse in exports and export-related production.
Meanwhile, back in the US, total bank credit is contracting while M2 is up 5% annualized YTD.
Total Bank Credit - Annualized Rate of Change
M2 - Annualized Rate of Change
M2 is actually down since May-August due to the decline in the rate of growth of bank lending over the summer.
If the May-June rate of deceleration were to persist, M2 could conceivably start start contracting by year end or early '10.
In spite of record worldwide stimulus, a global recession is everywhere you look except perhaps in China. The reason is simple. When the Chinese government "suggests" banks should lend, banks lend. This is how command economies "work", using the word "work" loosely. Yes, the US has massive problems, but let's have an honest assessment of problems elsewhere.
Bottom line, China is busy ramping up production for consumers that don't exist: Not here, not in the EU, and not in China (not yet). This love affair with China, a country that will not float its currency or offer freedom of speech, and hides bank solvency issues even more so than the US, is way overdone.
Remind me to reconsider decoupling when China allows freedom of speech and floats the RMB instead of pegging it.
Yet in spite of all the above, nearly everyone is absolutely sure the Renminbi would soar if China allowed it to float. Conceivably it could crash.
Don't Mistake Printing For A Sustainable Recovery
It is a mistake to equate Chinese, US, and Japanese printing for any kind of sustainable recovery.
As noted in Gold And The Watched Pot Theory, "Every country wants to grow by ramping up exports in a world of decreasing consumer demand. To achieve that end, every country wants its currency to be weaker against every other currency. Of course that is logically impossible. Besides, the US consumer is tapped out. European consumers are tapped out as well. And tapped out or not, the Japanese consumer just does not want to buy."
Neither the G-20 nor G-7 did anything to address the massive global imbalances. Something critical is going to blow sky high, when and what remains to be seen.
Finance chiefs headed for Group of Seven talks in Istanbul pushing for a �strong dollar� amid concern its slide will impede their recoveries from the worst global recession since World War II.
�Everyone needs a strong dollar,� French Finance Minister Christine Lagarde told reporters in Gothenburg, Sweden, today as she met European Union counterparts. �We�ll have a chance to discuss this in the coming days.�
Her comments came four days after similar remarks from European Central Bank President Jean-Claude Trichet. Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner yesterday also pledged support for a �strong� currency.
�Market-moving announcements could be forthcoming,� said Geoffrey Yu, a foreign-exchange strategist at UBS AG in London. �We expect to hear renewed commitments to the U.S. strong dollar policy and the European delegation may be tempted to communicate their worries on further rises in the euro.�
Canadian Finance Minister Jim Flaherty yesterday pushed China to let its yuan appreciate �more quickly� after keeping it little changed against the dollar for more than a year
G7 Wimps Out, Avoids Formal Dollar Criticism
Those hoping to see a firm stand by the G-7 regarding currencies may be hoping for another 20 years.
Group of Seven finance chiefs stopped short of singling out the weaker dollar for criticism and stuck to their mantra that �disorderly� swings in currencies threaten economic growth.
�Excess volatility and disorderly movements in exchange rates have adverse implications for economic and financial stability,� G-7 ministers and central bankers said in a statement after talks today in Istanbul. Officials welcomed China�s �continued commitment� to a more flexible currency, which they said would promote balanced global growth. The statement repeated language used at the last G-7 in April.
�Following the escalated rhetoric, investors may have been braced for some escalation in language,� said Sophia Drossos, co-head for global foreign exchange strategy at Morgan Stanley in New York. �Since we didn�t get it, I look for the trend of dollar weakness to reassert itself.�
G-7 Meritorious Statements
The German Deputy Finance Minister Joerg Asmussen said G-7 "Statements will be published on merit." Please consider the following meritorious statements.
There is no room for complacency since the prospects for growth remain fragile and labor market conditions are not yet improving.
We will keep in place our support measures until recovery is assured.
We reaffirm our shared interest in a strong and stable international financial system.
Excess volatility and disorderly movements in exchange rates have adverse implications for economic and financial stability.
We will continue to promote the fundamental norms of propriety, integrity and transparency, as agreed in the Lecce Framework and the Core Values of the Charter for Sustainable Economic Activity.
Is there any merit to throwing a party just to say that? If the G-7 cannot agree on anything meaningful, how the hell is the G-20 ever going to agree on anything?
For more on the complete uselessness of these summits, please see G-20 Summit - We've Seen This Movie Before with an analysis of select entries from the historical record of a League of Nations 1930-1931 Chronology.
Export Dependency Madness
Canadian Finance Minister Jim Flaherty effectively summarized the global G-7 sentiment when he pushed China to let its yuan appreciate �more quickly�.
Every country wants to grow by ramping up exports in a world of decreasing consumer demand. To achieve that end, every country wants its currency to be weaker against every other currency. Of course that is logically impossible.
Besides, the US consumer is tapped out. European consumers are tapped out as well. And tapped out or not, the Japanese consumer just does not want to buy.
Demographics are a huge problem in Japan and ironically paying 0% on deposits does not do much for supporting consumption.
In spite of record worldwide stimulus, a global recession is everywhere you look except perhaps in China. The reason is simple. When the Chinese government "suggests" banks should lend, banks lend. This is how command economies "work", using the word "work" loosely. Yes, the US has massive problems, but let's have an honest assessment of problems elsewhere.
Bottom line, China is busy ramping up production for consumers that don't exist: Not here, not in the EU, and not in China (not yet). This love affair with China, a country that will not float its currency or offer freedom of speech, and hides bank solvency issues even more so than the US, is way overdone.
The world's largest shopping mall, South China Mall in Guangzhou, China, is almost entirely empty. Click on the link to see a fascinating video.
Spend Money Until There Is A Recovery
While politely pointing fingers at China and the US for political purposes, all such language was removed from the official statement. The only thing we can be sure the G-7 will do is keep spending money until there is a recovery.
The US, China, Japan, and UK are all in on that act. However, major cracks have appeared in the dam. Switzerland has intervened in the Forex markets with Japan and the ECB waiting in the wings. Canada is clearly unhappy about both the US dollar and the Renminbi.
Indeed no one seems happy about anything, yet the G-7 managed to put together this meritorious and flowery conclusion:
"We will continue to promote the fundamental norms of propriety, integrity and transparency, as agreed in the Lecce Framework and the Core Values of the Charter for Sustainable Economic Activity."
Japan�s currency rose to a six-month high on a trade-weighted basis last month amid speculation the Federal Reserve will keep interest rates low and the government led by Yukio Hatoyama won�t intervene to stem the yen�s gain.
Japanese Finance Minister Hirohisa Fujii said this week the government may act to stabilize the foreign-exchange market and denied that he supported a stronger yen.
The remarks signal Fujii, 77, is trying to dispel investors� perceptions that he favors appreciation of the yen and would be unlikely to step into the currency market to stem its gains. After the DPJ came into power for the first time on Sept. 16, Fujii said the idea of a weaker yen helping the nation�s exports is �absurd.�
I place credence on the more recent statements, noting that Toyota could be one reason for the flip-flop.
Toyota Motor Corp., the world�s biggest automaker, is �grasping for salvation� as it predicts a second straight annual loss, President Akio Toyoda said. The automaker is one step away from �capitulation to irrelevance or death,� Toyoda said, citing a study of how companies fail.
The company has gone through the phases of �hubris born of success,� �undisciplined pursuit of more� and �denial of risk and peril,� according to Toyoda, who cited Jim Collins, the author of �How the Mighty Fail.�
The yen�s 7.4 percent gain against the dollar in the third quarter also eroded earnings from exports. �The yen is at a very severe level, and just increasing sales won�t make Toyota profitable,� Toyoda said today.
�We�re going to get financial institutions to provide these firms with more loans,� said Kamei. �Banks won�t have to treat debt on which they provide a moratorium as bad.�
The moratorium, postponing repayment of principal and interest, will be extended to individuals as well as firms Kamei said. It will aim at giving relief to companies with about 100 million yen ($1.1 million) or less in capital.
�As long as I�m financial services minister, I�m not going to leave small companies in the lurch unable to get loans,� Kamei said. �If a bank takes that approach, I�ll hit them with a business improvement order.�
The Swiss franc fell the most in three months against the euro amid speculation the central bank sold the currency to curb its advance. Swiss National Bank Governing Board member Thomas Jordan said last week policy makers will act �with full force� to avoid an appreciation of the franc against the euro.
�Price action and market talk suggests the SNB has intervened today to sell the Swiss franc,� Marc Chandler, New- York based global head of currency strategy at Brown Brothers Harriman & Co., wrote in an e-mail today. �It appears it may be buying dollars and euros. Swiss banks have been rumored to be the featured agents, which fits into the intervention story.�
By holding back the Swiss franc, policy makers are trying to prevent deflation from worsening the steepest recession since 1992 and restore investor confidence. SNB Chairman Jean-Pierre Roth said on June 18 that the nation�s central bankers �fear deflation� and �if we want to fight against deflation we have to stop a further appreciation of the franc.�
All In Favor Of A Weaker Dollar Raise Your Hand
Europe does not want a stronger Euro, Japan does not want a stronger Yen, and Switzerland has surely proven it does not want a stronger Swiss Franc.
Given that China has pegged the Renminbi to the dollar, it is clear China does not want a stronger RMB either. If it did, it would simply change the peg.
I see no hands in support of a weaker dollar.
Dollar Devaluation Countdown
In spite of the above, within a month or two the US$ is supposedly going to be devalued. Please see Countdown To Dollar Implosion Madness for details.
The theory behind the countdown is the "Recent China/US financial Summit meeting in Washington which was requested by China, was not significantly pre-planned".
Is a dollar devaluation was the only thing that could possibly have been on China's mind? What about trade issues, pollution, the recession, or the then upcoming G-7 and G-20 meetings? My vote is for the latter.
2009 US Dollar Devaluation References
Out of curiosity, I did a search for "2009 US Dollar Devaluation"
During Depression I, I would say it was Frank Roosevelt's 40 percent devaluation of the dollar against gold which finally stopped the deflation. After Wild Ben 'Maggot Brain' Bernanke has cut his policy rate to zero, dollar devaluation is the only policy option left to ease our collective pain.
Some sage gold watchers are expecting a major dollar devaluation before the end of the year! Some say it could happen any day now. ... If the globe�s major reserve currency is devalued, no one will escape the impact on their daily lives.
For example, if the dollar is devalued against the euro by 30%, an Airbus will be that much more expensive than its Boeing equivalent. An import from China (the yuan is pegged to the dollar) will also drop in foreign currency prices by 30%, but remain the same in the U.S. dollar.
Devaluation By Decree Impossible
The US dollar floats. There is no way the dollar can be devalued by decree without pegging it to something. For example, the US cannot just come out and say "We are devaluing the dollar vs. the Euro by 30%" without pegging the dollar to the Euro and then defending that target.
Moreover, as noted above, all the G-7 countries except the US want a stronger dollar, not a weaker one. Even if a devaluation by decree was possible, the G-7 clearly would not be happy about it.
Message Of Gold
The reason for the strength in gold is not US inflation. As I have pointed out many times, gold fell from 850 to 250 over the course of 20 years, with inflation every step of the way. Thus, the inflation story just does not fit.
However, it should be clear that a major financial crisis is in store following a long period of competitive currency devaluation and massive debt and derivatives expansion by nearly every major country on the planet.
The G-7 agreed to do nothing to fix this mess, nor did the previous G-20 meeting. Countries are going to do what they are going to do: follow misguided Keynesian logic that suggests one can spend one's way to prosperity even though the problem is excessive spending across the board.
Might the US dollar blow up? Yes it might. But so could the RMB if China floated it, and so could the British pound. No one seems to see the crisis brewing in Japan with a huge demographic problem, a shrinking population, falling exports, and no way to pay back its national debt.
There is seldom a mention of the problems in European banks who foolishly lent money to the Baltic States in Euros or Swiss Francs and now those Baltic country currencies have collapsed and the loans cannot be paid back. European banks also lent to Latin America and those loans are also suspect. Arguably, European banks are in worse shape than US banks, but no one talks about it, at least in the US.
Spain has unemployment approaching 20% yet must suffer through the same interest rate policy as Germany. Seldom does one hear about this either.
Certainly the UK is a complete basket case with its banks on government life support. Iceland has already blown up, who is next?
Most are not aware of the problems in China, Japan, or Europe. However, the problems in the US are universally well understood. Indeed all eyes are on the dollar and everyone is talking about deficits, monetary printing, and especially unfunded liabilities even though the latter is tomorrow's problem, not today's.
Watched Pot Theory Revisited
A watched pot may boil, but it's not likely to explode, especially when everyone watching the pot expects an explosion any second.
Yet, it's easy to see that a financial crisis is brewing.
Somewhere, something is going to blow sky high, but from where I sit, it's as likely to be in the Yen, the Swiss Franc, the British Pound, or something no one is watching at all as opposed to the US dollar specifically.
It's important to remember that no matter how nutty things have gotten during this credit bust, even nuttier solutions are waiting in the wings.
The Japanese Minister of Finance has proven that in spades by proposing a debt moratorium to individuals as well as firms. The moratorium would postpone repayment of principal and interest on loans, in an effort to spur more bank lending.
Japanese banks� bad loans won�t be driven higher by a proposed moratorium on debt payments by struggling small companies, said Financial Services Minister Shizuka Kamei.
Lenders won�t have to classify loans encompassed by the plan as non-performing, Kamei, 72, said in an interview yesterday at his office in Tokyo. That means they won�t be forced to boost provisions when borrowers postpone repayments of interest or principal, he said. At the same time, Kamei vowed to push banks to extend more credit to small businesses after bankruptcies hit a six-year high in Japan.
�We�re going to get financial institutions to provide these firms with more loans,� said Kamei. �Banks won�t have to treat debt on which they provide a moratorium as bad.�
The moratorium, postponing repayment of principal and interest, will be extended to individuals as well as firms Kamei said. It will aim at giving relief to companies with about 100 million yen ($1.1 million) or less in capital.
�As long as I�m financial services minister, I�m not going to leave small companies in the lurch unable to get loans,� Kamei said. �If a bank takes that approach, I�ll hit them with a business improvement order.�
Japan Lending Statistics
Japan�s three largest banks, including Mitsubishi UFJ Financial Group Inc., posted combined losses of almost $14 billion last fiscal year as bad-debt charges surged.
Corporate bankruptcies increased 12 percent to 16,146 in the year ended March 31, the highest in six years.
In spite of the above Kamei states: �We�re going to get financial institutions to provide these firms with more loans,�
Unbridled Greed and Stupidity
Kamei blames �unbridled capitalism� for the global credit crisis.
The reality is this crisis was caused by the Fed (central banks in general) and Fractional Reserve Lending policies that fostered an environment of unbridled greed and stupidity. Ridiculous proposals such as offered by Kamei are guaranteed to make matters worse.
Surprise, Surprise, Surprise, Not: The oil hype story as noted in Ridiculous Hype Over Secret Oil Meetings has blown sky high already, just hours after I wrote the above.
Russia has not discussed changing the dollar's role in the global trade of oil, deputy Russian finance minister Dmitry Pankin said on Tuesday. "We did not discuss this at all," he told reporters. Pankin was asked by reporters about a story in Britain's The Independent newspaper, which quoted unidentified sources as saying Gulf Arab states were in secret talks with Russia, China, Japan and France to replace the U.S. dollar with a basket of currencies in the trading of oil.
Big oil producing nations denied on Tuesday a British newspaper report that Gulf Arab states were in secret talks with Russia, China, Japan and France to replace the U.S. dollar with a basket of currencies in trading oil.
It said the proposal was for trade in crude oil to move over nine years to a basket of currencies including the Japanese yen, the Chinese yuan, the euro, gold and a new, unified currency planned for nations in the Gulf Co-operation Council, which includes Saudi Arabia and Kuwait.
But top officials of Saudia Arabia and Russia, speaking on the sidelines of International Monetary Fund meetings in Istanbul, denied there were such talks.
Asked by reporters about the newspaper story, Saudi Arabia's central bank chief Muhammad al-Jasser said: "Absolutely incorrect." He repeated the same response when asked whether Saudi Arabia was in such talks.
Russia's deputy finance minister Dmitry Pankin said: "We did not discuss this at all."
Algerian Finance Minister Karim Djoudi told Reuters: "Oil producing countries need to stabilise revenues but...I don't see a need for oil trade to be denominated differently.
Analysts said that while individual countries would find it relatively easy to stop using the dollar in settling their oil trades, as Iran has already done, replacing the currency in which oil is priced would require a massive effort.
And apart from the strong political links between Gulf nations and the United States, the lack of convertibility for many Gulf currencies and the yuan tops the list of practical hurdles to making such a shift. Saudi Arabia and some other Gulf states now peg their currencies to the dollar.
To be fair, denial of talks does not mean talks did not happen. However, for reasons mentioned, it was easy to see the Fisk story for the hype that it was.
Here is the key sentence in the above article "Analysts said that while individual countries would find it relatively easy to stop using the dollar in settling their oil trades, as Iran has already done, replacing the currency in which oil is priced would require a massive effort."
While conceptually easy to price oil in something else, it might take a huge programming and retraining effort to do so. For what benefit? The answer is none, because outside of Yap Island stones, it does not matter what it is priced in.
Settlement, as stated above (and also by me years ago) is easy enough to do now. Iran does not want to hold dollars so it doesn't.
Who Wants To Hold Dollars?
I was just asked " Why Would Anyone Want To Hold Dollars?"
The question is actually moot.
The US runs a trade deficit. As explained in How Will China Handle The Yuan? holding dollars is a purely mathematical result of trade deficits.
The US runs a trade deficit with China. That means China must accumulate US assets. China does not have a choice in the matter; it is purely a mathematical function. When the US runs a deficit, mathematically someone must run a surplus.
There is no choice in the matter other than to raise the price of goods so high that consumers won't buy them. Pray tell, what would that do to unemployment and civil unrest in China? What would that do to demand in Europe? It is virtually impossible for China to strengthen its currency to the US dollar without affecting every other currency as well.
Some might suggest that China should buy oil with those dollars, but then what would the Mideast exporters do with them?
The reason China is buying fewer US treasuries recently is that the US deficit with China is shrinking. Again this is a simple mathematical equation, not some massive conspiracy to dump the dollar. Of course China could buy US ports and bridges or oil companies instead of treasuries, but such maneuvers have been blocked by Congress and last I checked no ports or bridges are for sale.
Simple Math Lesson
Math dictates that if the US is running a trade deficit someone else mathematically MUST run a trade surplus.
Whether someone wants to hold dollars or not is irrelevant.
That someone MUST be accumulating US dollars is a mathematically certainty. Suppose you suggest China dump those dollars.
Dump them to who, for what? Iran for oil? Surely you jest. Saudi Arabia? What will the Saudis do with them.
So China accumulates treasuries. And eventually those dollars will come home when China buys US assets, perhaps a toll road or a piece of a US corporation, or perhaps the balance of trade changes.
However, even though the question is moot, the reason why China might want to accumulate dollars is to suppress the prices of the RMB to help Chinese exports, the same reason Japan has. China, as noted above is very concerned about export jobs.
Japan is threatening once again to intervene in currency markets. To do so they would accumulate dollars in excess of what balance of trade might suggest.
The European Central Bank and the Fed are involved in currency swaps right now, to help diffuse the credit crunch.
So there are lots of reasons countries might want to hold dollars. Bear in mind, some of them are senseless, but since when do governments have policies that make any sense?