Friday, 5 March 2010

Case-Shiller CPI Now Tracking CPI-U; Real Interest Rates Are Once Again Negative

It's been about 4-5 months since I last talked about Case-Shiller CPI (CS-CPI). Case-Shiller CPI is formulated by substituting the Case-Shiller housing index for Owner's Equivalent Rent (OER) in the CPI for all urban consumers (CPI-U) index, commonly shortened to CPI.

For a complete description of the reasons and methodology for making this substitution, please see What's the Real CPI?

With year-over-year home prices flattening, the effect of substituting the Case-Shiller housing index for Owners' Equivalent Rent in CPI calculations has worn off as the following charts show.

CS-CPI vs. CPI-U



click on chart for sharper image

OER vs. Case-Shiller Housing Index



click on chart for sharper image

My friend "TC" who produced the charts had this to say...
CS-CPI � January 2010

CS-CPI has risen YOY for the third month in row and measures +2.4% YOY. Meanwhile the government�s CPI-U also has risen YOY three consecutive months and measures +2.6% YOY (see first graph). The divergence between the two is to due to using the Case Shiller 20 city index, rather than the government�s housing metric of Owners� Equivalent Rent (OER). The OER now makes up an amazing 25.2% of CPI, it's heaviest percentage on record.

While the divergence was huge during the housing boom (due to OER underestimating home prices) and even wider during the housing bust (due to OER overestimating home prices), it is now relatively small.

January 2010 OER is at +0.4% YOY, while the Case-Shiller 20 city index for January will likely read -0.3% YOY for only a 70 basis point divergence as noted in the second chart.
What the charts shows is how low real interest rates were (and thus the Fed Funds Rate was) between 2003 and 2006. Greenspan missed the negative real interests that fueled the housing bubble by focusing on rent as opposed to housing prices.

Likewise, starting in 2007 real interest rates were high, even after Bernanke cut rates to zero.

With home prices stabilizing and OER falling, CS-CPI and CPI-U are tracking together. Moreover, real interest rates which had been positive since mid-2006 (as measured by CS-CPI), are once again negative.

Yet, If housing takes another turn down and OER continues to drop (both of which I suspect will happen), we can easily see the Fed Funds Rate, CPI-U, and Case-Shiller CPI converge towards zero, especially if energy prices drop as well.

That deflationary combination is not what Bernanke is hoping for at all.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Thursday, 4 March 2010

Seven in Ten Putting Off Retirement Do So for Financial Reasons; What are the Implications?

Here is an interesting pair of articles, one on California the other on boomers postponing retirement for financial reasons.

In California, it's no surprise that economists are surprised at just how bad things are. Please consider California job losses grow.
"The economy was a lot worse than everybody thought," said Howard Roth, chief economist with the state's Department of Finance. "The job market is weaker than we figured."

It appears California lost 871,000 jobs in 2009, suggests an estimate provided by the state Employment Development Department.

"This is the worst recession for California since the Great Depression," said Brad Kemp, director of regional research with Beacon Economics.

If those estimates hold up when final revisions are released this month, the actual job losses in the state would be far more grim than first believed. In the initial EDD estimate, released Jan. 22, the EDD reported California employers chopped 579,000 jobs from payrolls in 2009.

"We will have a really big downward revision," Roth said.

That would translate into an 292,000 more jobs that were lost, on top of the prior losses.
Seven In Ten Boomers Put Off Retirement For Financial Reasons

Inquiring minds are noting More Than Seven-in-Ten Workers Age 60+ Are Putting Off Retirement Due to Financial Restraints, According to a New CareerBuilder Survey
The economy continues to change the retirement timeline for many mature workers, leaving them with tough decisions about their futures. More than seven-in-ten (72 percent) workers over the age of 60 who said they are putting off their retirement are doing so because they can't afford to retire financially, according to a new survey by CareerBuilder. When comparing genders, the survey found that three-quarters (76 percent) of female workers over the age of 60 who said they are putting off retirement are doing so because they can't afford it, while 68 percent of males said the same.
Note: The title of the article on Yahoo Finance: More Than Seven-in-Ten Workers Age 60+ Are Putting Off Retirement Due to Financial Restraints, According to a New CareerBuilder Survey is misleading.

The correct take-away is "Of those putting off retirement, 7.2 out of 10 do so for financial reasons". Another key number is how many are putting off retirement. That the article does not say, but unprecedented debt levels are no doubt a big problem, with serious implications.

What Are The Implications?

This is proof of a statement I made years ago that boomers would be competing against their kids and grandkids for jobs at Walmart.

Other boomers in good paying jobs are reluctant to give them up.

Implications

  • The labor pool participation rate will stay elevated instead of contracting as much as one might have thought. In turn ...
  • The unemployment rate will stay elevated longer than economists think.
  • Kids out of college will have a harder time finding jobs.
  • Kids out of college will be forced to move back in with their parents.
  • Kids out of college will have no way of paying back college loans.
  • Parents who co-signed for their kids education will come to regret it.
  • The above factors will pressure discretionary spending of both boomers and those just out of college.
  • Those out of college will postpone family building.
  • Postponement of family building will further pressure housing prices.
  • Bankruptcies, foreclosures, credit card defaults, and walk-aways will continue longer than economists think.

The deflationary pressures of the cycle described above are immense.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Range of Snow Impact on Jobs: Negligible to 220,000; Have Your Snow Job Decoder Ring Handy?

Having read Weekly Unemployment Claims At 469,000; Prepare for Friday's BLS Snow Job, inquiring minds just might be asking "What is the range of estimates given by economists for the impact of February blizzards?"

February 28, 2010

Please consider Payrolls Probably Declined in February: U.S. Economy Preview
Payrolls probably fell by 50,000 after declining 20,000 in January, according to the median forecast of 62 economists surveyed by Bloomberg News before the Labor Department�s March 5 report.

�Even leaving aside the effects of inclement weather, the economy still appears to be shedding jobs,� said Aaron Smith, a senior economist at Moody�s Economy.com in West Chester, Pennsylvania. �Although businesses have stopped cutting inventories and are beginning to invest more, they have been more hesitant to increase their hiring.�

�The weather will certainly play a role,� said Raymond Stone, managing director and an economist at Stone & McCarthy Research Associates in Skillman, New Jersey, who projects payrolls will be reduced by as many as 200,000 because of the storms. His overall forecast is for a decline of 150,000 and he referenced a snow-related payroll drop in January 1996.
March 3, 2005

All that snow talk got economists to revise their forecasts. On February 28, the estimate was -50,000. The jobs estimate is now -65,000.

Please consider Weather to Make U.S. Jobs Report Hard to Decode, Economists Say
Amid signs that the U.S. economic recovery is about to start creating jobs, the influence of bad weather will make the government�s February employment report difficult to decipher, economists said.

The world�s largest economy probably lost 65,000 jobs last month, more than triple the 20,000 drop in January payrolls, according to the median forecast of economists surveyed by Bloomberg News before the Labor Department�s March 5 report.

Snow in parts of the country that caused some businesses to temporarily close during the government�s survey week may potentially depress the payroll count by as much as 220,000 workers, according to Joel Prakken at Macroeconomic Advisers LLC. One thing is certain, the Labor Department will not precisely quantify the storms� effect.

�The inability to gauge the impact of weather-related distortions with any real degree of precision means Friday�s employment report is one of the least important in quite some time,� David Greenlaw, chief fixed-income economist at Morgan Stanley in New York, said today in a note to clients.

Household Survey

Any divergence from established patterns for the month will help inform economists of the snow�s impact. About 290,000 people on average say bad weather has prevented them from getting to work, according to February figures going back three decades.

The most recent storm of similar intensity that occurred during a survey week was in January 1996. The current data for payrolls that month, which have gone through several revisions since the initial estimate, show a 19,000 drop in employment.
Snow Analysis

Raymond Stone, an economist at Stone & McCarthy Research Associates projects payrolls will be reduced by as many as 200,000 because of the storms. His overall forecast is for a decline of 150,000 and he referenced a snow-related payroll drop in January 1996.

Snow Fact

The most recent storm of similar intensity that occurred during a survey week was in January 1996. The current data for payrolls that month, which have gone through several revisions since the initial estimate, show a 19,000 drop in employment.

Snow Analysis

The government�s survey week may potentially depress the payroll count by as much as 220,000 workers, according to Joel Prakken at Macroeconomic Advisers LLC.

Snow Fact

Payroll count might be depressed by 220,000 workers?
How?

For the household survey: Who is counted as employed?
Persons also are counted as employed if they have a job at which they did not work during the survey week, whether they were paid or not, because they were:
  • On vacation
  • Ill
  • Experiencing child-care problems
  • Taking care of some other family or personal obligation
  • On maternity or paternity leave
  • Involved in an industrial dispute
  • Prevented from working by bad weather

For the establishment survey: What is the CES definition of employment?
Employment is the total number of persons on establishment payrolls employed full or part time who received pay for any part of the pay period that includes the 12th day of the month. Temporary and intermittent employees are included, as are any employees who are on paid sick leave, on paid holiday, or who work during only part of the specified pay period.
Thanks to Caroline Baum for the above links.

Snow Job Decoding

Did 220,000 people not receive any pay for the period in question?

Color me skeptical.

In terms of the unemployment rate, the blizzards will not have an effect. In terms of the reported jobs number there will be an impact but the most likely impact is in the number of hours worked.

Regardless, expectations as to the importance of the blizzard range from negligible all the way to 220,000. Whatever the affect was, it will be over by next month although I have seen analysis that says the effects will last until May.

Based on the 4-week moving average of weekly unemployment initial claims, something in the neighborhood of 60,000 to 100,000 jobs lost would seem reasonable. Guesses are always a pot shot, but let me guess an optimistic 85,000 jobs lost.

However, I have no idea what kind of seasonal adjustment nonsense the BLS will pull off, or if further revisions to the Birth-Death adjustments are coming. Those adjustments could balance out or have a cumulative effect, with widely varying results.

If the number is much higher, just don't blame it on the weather. And whatever it is, short of a preposterous -10,000 or better, try not to be surprised.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Weekly Unemployment Claims At 469,000; Prepare for Friday's BLS Snow Job

Inquiring minds are investigating the Unemployment Weekly Claims Report for March 4, 2010.
In the week ending Feb. 27, the advance figure for seasonally adjusted initial claims was 469,000, a decrease of 29,000 from the previous week's revised figure of 498,000. The 4-week moving average was 470,750, a decrease of 3,500 from the previous week's revised average of 474,250.
Weekly Unemployment Claims



The weekly claims numbers are volatile so it's best to focus on the trend in the 4-week moving average. That 4-week average has not show any improvement for quite some time.

4-Week Moving Average of Initial Claims



4-Week Moving Average of Initial Claims Detail



The 4-week moving average of claims for the last three weeks is above where it was on December 12, 2009 and just slightly better than it was on December 5, 2009. By this measure, the recovery has stalled.

Blaming The Weather

A week ago in "Nascent" Recovery or "Nascent" Economic Collapse? I noted how economists were blaming the weather for last week's rise in weekly claims and possible jump in the monthly job report.
Weather Related Questions

I have a few simple questions for all the dim-bulb economists now blaming the weather:

  • "Did you not know there was a snowstorm on the East coast?"
  • "If you did, then why didn't you factor it in to your estimates?"
  • "How can you be surprised by something you knew?"

Bernanke's Snow Job

To refresh your memory, last week Bernanke blamed the weather for the jump in claims and warned about overinterpreting the data.

From Yahoo Finance Jobless claims rise due to weather-related factors.
"Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke told a congressional committee that the snowstorms are likely to have a short-term -- but not permanent -- effect on unemployment and layoffs. He said policymakers will "have to be careful about not overinterpreting" the upcoming data."
Summers Shovels Snow

Inquiring minds are reading Summers Shovels Snow on Winter�s Job Prospects by Caroline Baum.
Summers came out of virtual retirement Tuesday to tell CNBC the blizzards last month were likely to distort February�s employment statistics. It�s �very important to look past whatever the next figures are to gauge the underlying trends,� the White House economic adviser said in a TV interview.

What he really meant was, it�s important to look past bad numbers.

At the risk of inspiring accusations of naivete from conspiracy theorists convinced government agencies cook up the numbers in the basement, I decided to go to the source.

The only people who know the numbers several days before the release work at the Bureau of Labor Statistics, according to Tom Nardone, assistant commissioner for current employment analysis at the BLS.

�Larry Summers did not have the number when he made his comment,� Nardone said.

Economists surveyed by Bloomberg News expect a decline of 65,000 in February non-farm payrolls. Trotting out Summers to lay the groundwork for what clearly isn�t good news and what could be worse news is standard operating procedure for any White House. Why traders are so invested in their conspiracy theories is beyond me.

Now let�s turn to the weather. There were two snowfalls that overlapped with the survey reference period last month: Feb. 4-7 and Feb. 9-11. For the household survey, if you have a job and were absent in the reference week, you are counted as employed whether or not you were paid. You can read about it here: Who is counted as employed?

The survey of establishments is a bit trickier. If you were paid for work you did in any part of the pay period that includes the 12th of the month, whether you worked or not, worked a full or reduced week, you are counted as employed, Nardone says. If you didn�t work that week but got paid, you�re still counted. You can read the BLS definition of employment here: What is the CES definition of employment?

Only if you didn�t receive any pay for the entire pay period are you not counted as employed. (The federal government closed its Washington offices for four of five work days, and those folks got paid.)

What categories of workers would be affected? Primarily part-time workers and new hires as counted in the payroll survey.

Temporary Distortions

The fact that the blizzards last month affected highly populated areas along the East Coast and occurred during the key week for both surveys suggests there will be some depressing effect on payrolls. The major effect will be reflected in a reduction in hours worked.

Here�s the good news: What the weather taketh away in February, it giveth back in March and April. All the distortions are temporary. Businesses with a long-term outlook aren�t about to change hiring plans because of a few feet of snow.

A month from now, if the expected snapback in employment is too robust, Summers might be back to damp enthusiasm about employment growth that�s too good to be true.
Thanks Caroline, But Who Wants Facts?

Summers and Obama will be happy to take credit for the improvement in March (if any) but continue to blame the weather if there is no snapback.

Indeed, Summers purposely laid the groundwork for blaming the weather for Friday's report no matter what it is. Moreover, Summers and Bernanke (no conspiracy here - just each acting individually in their own best interest to buy time) trotted out statements practically begging economists to overshoot their estimates of snow damage.

Finally, while all this talk is on snow, there is next to no talk about how hiring a million census workers will temporarily affect the jobs statistics. That "temporary" effect is likely to last until June, but don't expect Summers to talk about that.

Instead expect economists to be surprised tomorrow no matter what the number.

Surprise Surprise Surprise

For all of Bernanke's and Summers' attempted snow jobs, it should be intuitively obvious that the "primary effect will be reflected in a reduction in hours worked" on the East coast as noted by Baum. The unemployment rate should not be impacted at all.

Nonetheless, I am looking forward to three surprises tomorrow.

1. The jobs report was much better than expected in light of the snow
2. The jobs report was much worse than expected because of the snow
3. The unemployment rate was much worse and much better than expected because of the snow.

Expect economists, easily surprised by anything and everything, to be surprised by all of the above, at the same time. Pay no attention to the obvious conflicts in the above projected surprises. Economists are seldom concerned with logic. Thus, when Friday's job report is out, don't be surprised by economists being surprised about multiple conflicting things.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Wednesday, 3 March 2010

Is anyone else sick of this "Nascent Recovery" talk?

The buzzword of the day is "nascent". It means "beginning to exist or develop". The word is everywhere you look.

Moreover, talk of "nascency" seems like it has been going on forever. Perhaps because it has. Here are some prime examples.

March 3, 2010 - Big Picture: Read it here first: St. Louis Fed Tracks Nascent Expansion
The St. Louis Fed has made it official, at least through their lens. The recession ended in June 2009. As you read here first in January, late last year the St. Louis Fed discontinued the use of recession shading (thereby signalling its end) in its graphs as of mid-2009.

They have now retooled their Tracking the Recession page to Tracking the Economy, and the default graphs are indexed to 100 in July 2009 (the economy�s apparent trough).
Feb 26 2010 - FXStreet: Canada: export sector is betting on nascent recovery
Today, we were very pleased by the results of a survey published by Statistics Canada. As Today�s Hot Chart shows, factories plan to increase their investment in machinery & equipment by 8.8% in 2010. Furthermore, the improvement is fairly widespread, 14 major industries out of 20 having reported an increase. The increase planned in 2010 in these productivity enhancing investments is of the same order of magnitude than the one that followed the recession that took place at the beginning of the decade. This occurs despite the fact that this heavily export-dependant sector is now facing the challenge of a strong CAD. Nevertheless, Canadian manufacturers chose to position themselves in order to take advantage of the nascent U.S. recovery.
February 24, 2010 - Bloomberg: Bernanke Says �Nascent� Recovery Requires Low Rates
Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke said the U.S. economy is in a �nascent� recovery that still requires low interest rates to encourage demand by consumers and businesses once federal stimulus expires.
February 2, 2010 - Todays�s Zaman Istanbul: Manufacturing sees nascent recovery in Q3 productivity.
Turkey�s manufacturing industry productivity increased by 0.9 percent in the third quarter of 2009 as compared to the same months of 2008, data from the National Productivity Center (MPM) have revealed. ....
February 2, 2010 - Aclara: Despite A Nascent Recovery, Prospects For U.S. Finance Companies In 2010 Are Mixed

Note: That is an ad wanting $500 for a report about the "nascent recovery"

November 19, 2009 - Wall Street Journal: Dell Trails Tech Peers in Nascent Recovery
Dell Inc.'s quarterly profit dropped 54% despite recent signs of recovery in the technology sector, raising questions about the personal-computer maker's strategy of focusing on profitability at the expense of market share.
September 2, 2009 - Seeking Alpha: Robert Shiller on the Nascent Recovery

August 20, 2009 - CNN
: IMF: 'Nascent recovery' under way
The International Monetary Fund's chief economist described a "nascent" global recovery on Wednesday, but warned that US policymakers walked a tightrope in timing the end of the fiscal stimulus.
June 23,2009 - LiveMint: Truant rains could nix nascent recovery
The threat to the Indian monsoon, which has barely progressed in the last two weeks, increased on Monday when a top meteorological organization raised the risk levels of the occurrence of a weather phenomenon, El Nino.

A setback to the monsoon could nix the nascent economic recovery that is currently under way.
June 4, 2009 - CBS MoneyWatch: Higher Mortgage Rates Could Snuff a Nascent Housing Recovery.

March 28, 2009 - Business Line: Are steel and cement leading a nascent recovery?
If the performance of the steel and cement industries is any indication, a nascent recovery in economic activity seems under way.
December 7, 2008 - Seeking Alpha: Weekly Rewind: Signs of a Nascent Recovery?

February 2, 2008 - CBS News: U.S. Stocks Hope To Cement Nascent Recovery
(MarketWatch) NEW YORK (MarketWatch) -- Investors will attempt to cement a nascent recovery in stocks next week, seeking help from earnings growth outside the battered financial sector and trying to gauge whether much lower interest rates will be enough to prevent the U.S. economy from sliding into recession.
February 2, 2008 - MarketWatch: U.S. stocks hope to keep bullish momentum going
NEW YORK (MarketWatch) -- Investors will attempt to cement a nascent recovery in stocks next week, seeking help from earnings growth outside the battered financial sector and trying to gauge whether much lower interest rates will be enough to prevent the U.S. economy from sliding into recession.
The original title of that post was U.S. Stocks Hope To Cement Nascent Recovery. Apparently someone had second thoughts or back revised it away. Here is the actual link: http://www.marketwatch.com/story/us-stocks-hope-to-cement-nascent-recovery-2008220100

Whoever revised the title at MarketWatch, forget to tell CBS News.

Nascent Recovery Talk

That was just a small sample. I did a google search for nascent recovery and turned up 74 pages of entries.

How long can something be nascent? This happy talk has been going on for two full years at least.

Of course I made my own contribution on nacency.

Thursday, February 25, 2010: "Nascent" Recovery or "Nascent" Economic Collapse?
Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke is one of the best contrarian indicators one could possibly find. Yesterday, Bernanke told the House Financial Services Committee that the U.S. economy is in a �nascent� recovery.

Given his historical track record of complete failure on matters like housing, the recession, and jobs, his yapping about the �nascent� recovery suggests the very best we can expect is for the recovery to stall, and more likely enter a double dip recession if not completely collapse.
I don't know about you, but I'm Sure Glad The Recession Ended. In theory, that should mean use of the word "nascent" will soon behind us. In practice, don't count on it.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

New Jersey Firefighter Quits Union Over Volunteer Duties; What is a Public Servant?

Inquiring minds are interested in the story of Michael Schaffer, a Cherry Hill, New Jersey firefighter brave enough to take a stand against union greed.

Schaffer resigned from his union over its policy forbidding members from volunteering for departments that employ union members or are targets for union expansion.

Please consider South Jersey firefighter takes stand against union.
For more than three decades, Michael Schaffer has willingly run into burning buildings. He's performed CPR on children. He's freed people trapped in crashed vehicles. Last June, the union Schaffer has belonged to for 21 years brought him up on charges for volunteering with the fire department where he resides.

The International Association of Fire Fighters forbids members from volunteering for departments that already employ some IAFF firefighters or are viewed as targets by the IAFF for expansion.

Schaffer's hometown firehouse is all-volunteer and employs no union workers directly. But through mutual aid agreements, the firehouse -- in the West Berlin section of Berlin Township -- makes runs in neighboring towns that employ some IAFF firefighters.

Rather than risk expulsion by his "brothers" for doing something that he loves and that runs in the family, Schaffer resigned last month from his union, Cherry Hill Firefighters Local 2663.

"Especially with the economic times, if we went to a paid department, it would kill our town with taxes. People would have to move out," said West Berlin Fire Chief Joe Jackson. Jackson, who is also Berlin Township's police chief, said he backs Schaffer in this dispute.

Schaffer must still pay $35 out of every pay period to the union because of contract obligations, though he receives none of the union benefits. He said he harbors no ill will toward the IAFF, but hopes union leaders rethink their approach to enforcing the rule.

"I don't work for the union. I work for the fire department. This in no way is going to affect my job at all," Shaffer said. "I don't feel any repercussions so far. I stood by what I thought was right."
What is a Public Servant?

The key to this story is Michael Schaffer's comment "I don't work for the union. I work for the fire department. I stood by what I thought was right."

What a refreshing comment.

I would like to hear a teacher say "I don't work for the teachers' union, I work for the school district, for the benefit of the kids. As a public servant, I have a duty to work for what is in the best interest of the children I teach, not the best interest of me or the union."

I would like to hear a police officer say "I don't work for the police union, I work for the city. As a public servant, I have a duty to protect the city, not rape the taxpayer. Public servants should serve, not be served."

I realize it's a novel concept, but we would all be better off if public servants served someone besides themselves.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

ISM Service Sector Expands, Backlog of Orders and Employment Still Contracting; Public Sector Catchup Coming

The service sector is in expansion for the second straight month, with the diffusion index sitting at 53. Anything over 50 is in expansion. Let's take a look at some tables from the February 2010 Non-Manufacturing ISM Report On Business�.
* Non-Manufacturing ISM Report On Business� data is seasonally adjusted for Business Activity, New Orders, Prices and Employment. Manufacturing ISM Report On Business� data is seasonally adjusted for New Orders, Production, Employment, Supplier Deliveries and Inventories.

** Number of months moving in current direction



NMI (Non-Manufacturing Index)

In February, the NMI registered 53 percent, indicating growth in the non-manufacturing sector for the second consecutive month. A reading above 50 percent indicates the non-manufacturing sector economy is generally expanding; below 50 percent indicates the non-manufacturing sector is generally contracting.

NMI HISTORY



INDUSTRY PERFORMANCE (Based on the NMI)

The nine industries reporting growth in February based on the NMI composite index � listed in order � are: Information; Arts, Entertainment & Recreation; Transportation & Warehousing; Public Administration; Professional, Scientific & Technical Services; Other Services; Retail Trade; Wholesale Trade; and Finance & Insurance.

The eight industries reporting contraction in February � listed in order � are: Educational Services; Health Care & Social Assistance; Management of Companies & Support Services; Construction; Utilities; Accommodation & Food Services; Real Estate, Rental & Leasing; and Mining.
While clearly the best report in years, it is a mixed bag. Moreover it is hard to tell if February is an outlier or just sideways consolidation based on easier year-over-year comparisons.

City, State Cutbacks Coming

The service sector started to expand in September 2009, but went nowhere for 5 months. Of course, every expansion starts somewhere. However, the effect of city and state cutbacks which I guarantee are coming, have not yet been felt.

For example, please consider Governor Christie: "Time to Hold Hands and Jump Off the Cliff"
In an amazingly candid appraisal of the sorry state of affairs in New Jersey, Governor Chris Christie laid it on the line in a speech to about 200 mayors at the New Jersey League of Municipalities.

The speech is 24 minutes long and well worth a listen because it is both an honest admission of the problem, and a refreshingly accurate appraisal of what the solutions are. He chastised the legislature, unions, municipalities, and affordable housing initiatives while promising to do something about all of those.
You have to listen to the speech to believe it.

Points Covered

  • He froze aid to schools
  • Challenged school boards.
  • Wants to change arbitration rules for public workers
  • Requests public-private salary and benefits parity
  • Demands pension reform
  • Property tax hikes not an option
  • Wants to get rid of programs like COAH
  • Is not thinking about the next election

I applaud Chris Christie. Not only is he saying the things that need to be said, he is acting with executive actions, freezing 375 government programs out of 378 suggestions. That is leadership, something sadly lacking from president Obama and Congress.

Regardless of how you feel about it, city, state, and municipality cutbacks are coming.

15,000 Layoffs Coming In San Francisco

Even San Francisco recognizes the need to do something about budget constraints. Bear in mind most of those 15,000 workers will be rehired, but at reduced hours. Please consider Up to 15,000 City Workers Bracing for Pink Slip Friday.
As many as 15,000 unionized city workers are anticipating layoffs on Friday in part of a work-week reduction plan in which most of them will be re-hired at reduced, 37.5-hour weeks.

The 3,000-strong Local 21, meanwhile, claims that such a forced work week reduction would be a violation of their contract -- though labor says the City Attorney disagrees. Vallejo promised "We'll lawyer up" if members are dismissed as part of the 37.5-hour scheme.
Similar themes are playing out across the country.

Please consider Ohio Mayor Seeks To Eliminate Public Unions

Mayor Robart: "...As we can see from the desperate economic and fiscal woes of California, New Jersey, New York and other states with dominant public unions; this has become a major problem for the U.S. economy and smaller �d� democratic governance. The agenda for American political reform needs to include the breaking of public unions' power to capture an even larger share of private income."

With the above articles in mind, and you can easily find thousands more article about forced layoffs at the city, state, and local level, let's return once more to the ISM report.

Services Employment


Employment activity in the non-manufacturing sector contracted in February for the 26th consecutive month. ISM's Non-Manufacturing Employment Index for February registered 48.6 percent. This reflects an increase of 4 percentage points when compared to the seasonally adjusted 44.6 percent registered in January.

Two industries reported increased employment, nine industries reported decreased employment, and seven industries reported unchanged employment compared to January.

The industries reporting an increase in employment in February are: Retail Trade; and Transportation & Warehousing. The industries reporting a reduction in employment in February � listed in order � are: Educational Services; Real Estate, Rental & Leasing; Mining; Accommodation & Food Services; Utilities; Health Care & Social Assistance; Information; Public Administration; and Wholesale Trade.
Inventory Replenishment

The only services industries reporting an increase in employment are the two industries that would show the strongest growth in an inventory replenishment cycle, trade and transportation.

Let's not confuse inventory replenishment with the start of a robust expansion.

Public Sector About To Play Catchup

From a jobs perspective, let's also not get too carried away in thinking a big round of hiring is coming. Instead, it's time to think that the public sector is about to play catchup to the private sector on the downside.

It's a must needed adjustment and one that will happen whether anyone wants it or not. Layoffs and benefit reductions in the public sector have barely begun. This will put pressure on jobs and wages for years to come.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List