Saturday, 9 June 2012

Spain Blinks: Accepts �100 Billion Bailout Via EFSF/ESM; FROB to Receive the Money

After months of denials, a short Eurogroup Statement shows Spain will submit a formal request to Brussels for a bailout.  Here is the statement in full.
The Eurogroup supports the efforts of the Spanish authorities to resolutely address the restructuring of its financial sector and it welcomes their intention to seek financial assistance from euro area Member States to this effect.

The Eurogroup has been informed that the Spanish authorities will present a formal request shortly and is willing to respond favourably to such a request. The financial assistance would be provided by the EFSF/ESM for recapitalisation of financial institutions. The loan will be scaled to provide an effective backstop covering for all possible capital requirements estimated by the diagnostic exercise which the Spanish authorities have commissioned to the external evaluators and the international auditors. The loan amount must cover estimated capital requirements with an additional safety margin, estimated as summing up to EUR 100 billion in total.

Following the formal request, an assessment should be provided by the Commission, in liaison with the ECB, EBA and the IMF, as well as a proposal for the necessary policy conditionality for the financial sector that shall accompany the assistance.

The Eurogroup considers that the Fund for Orderly Bank Restructuring (F.R.O.B.), acting as agent of the Spanish government, could receive the funds and channel them to the financial institutions concerned. The Spanish government will retain the full responsibility of the financial assistance and will sign the MoU.

The Eurogroup notes that Spain has already implemented significant fiscal and labour market reforms and measures to strengthen the capital base of the Spanish banks. The Eurogroup is confident that Spain will honour its commitments under the excessive deficit procedure and with regard to structural reforms, with a view to correcting macroeconomic imbalances in the framework of the European semester. Progress in these areas will be closely and regularly reviewed also in parallel with the financial assistance. Beyond the determined implementation of these commitments, the Eurogroup considers that the policy conditionality of the financial assistance should be focused on specific reforms targeting the financial sector, including restructuring plans in line with EU state-aid rules and horizontal structural reforms of the domestic financial sector.

We invite the IMF to support the implementation and monitoring of the financial assistance with regular reporting.
Treasury Secretary Tim Geithner issued this meaningless statement on Spain following the Eurogroup announcement.
We welcome Spain's action to recapitalize its banking system and the commitment by its European partners to provide support. These are important for the health of Spain's economy and as concrete steps on the path to financial union, which is vital to the resilience of the euro area.
Lip Service to Reforms

In the Eurogroup statement, notice the lip service to Spain's "significant fiscal and labour market reforms and measures to strengthen the capital base of the Spanish banks".

It will be interesting to see the final terms but this bailout surely will not be the no-strings-attached request Spain had sought.

Once again, this is the wrong approach. Bondholders should have been wiped out. Instead, Spanish taxpayers will be put on the hook for another hundred billion euros.

If  another hundred billion euros is all it takes, I will be amazed.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Bailout Lite? There's Really No Such Thing; �30 Billion Needed? It's Now �100 Billion; Contagion of Economic Idiocy

A few days ago Spain was purportedly going to need another �30 billion to �70 billion to recapitalize Spanish banks. I suggested the amount would be at least triple that and it did not take long to do so.

Yahoo! Finance reports Spanish bailout could reach 100 billion euros
A bailout for Spain's teetering banks, once requested by Madrid, could amount to as much as 100 billion euros, two senior EU sources told Reuters on Saturday.

Spain has not yet made a formal request for European aid but it could come during a conference call of euro zone finance ministers, the sources, who were both on an earlier call to discuss the technicalities of a rescue, said.

"A decision on Spain will only be taken ... by the ministers (in a second call). Madrid has not officially asked for help yet," one of the officials said. "The statement will mention 100 billion euros as an upper limit."
�100 Billion Upper Limit? Until When?

When I said triple the reported amount, I meant triple the upper end of the reported amount. Bear in mind I am just guessing. However, history shows that I am more likely to be on the low end than the high end.

As with Greece, every economic number from Spain is revised to the downside, month in and month out.

For now, the EU economic wizards will likely concoct a number just under that alleged "upper limit". My best guess is �90 billion. Then within six months, possibly as soon as the money is handed over, more problems will surface, more meetings will take place, and still more money will be stolen from Spanish taxpayers and handed over to the banks and bondholders.

Bailout Lite? 

There is no such thing as a "bailout lite". Sure, they can ease conditions on Spain, but what kind of message does that send Greece with elections coming up on June 17.

Moreover, the odds the Spanish economy starts recovering later this year as forecast are virtually zero percent. Then what? Then Spain will need another "bailout lite" and still more extensions.

In the meantime, the odds France and Italy hit their budget deficit targets are also close to zero.

Contagion of Economic Idiocy

Combine the above ideas with the worst economic plan in history to combat high unemployment (please see Hollande About to Wreck France With Economically Insane Proposal: "Make Layoffs So Expensive For Companies That It's Not Worth It") and an economic disaster awaits the eurozone.

My conclusion is that Europe is about to suffer from contagion of the worst kind: contagion of economic idiocy on bailouts, on employment, and nannycrat nonsense.

The humorous quote of the day comes from "FamilyMan" who offers these thoughts on France's proposals to stem unemployment:
As a US citizen, I applaud the French strategy. Since we can't fix America, we need other countries to be even more insane than we are! Can we get France to implement a $500 euro an hour minimum wage to "wipe out poverty"?
Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Friday, 8 June 2012

Bank of Spain inspectors question the viability of BMN Bank Group

Courtesy of Google Translate please consider Bank of Spain inspectors question the viability of BMN
The latest monitoring report prepared by the inspectors of the Bank of Spain on the integration process of the Banco Mare Nostrum (BMN) group casts doubt on its viability and even states that it "virtually impossible" to "return the financial support of the FROB."

The supervisor reports that BMN has spiraled out of control.

The report, which was completed on 8 May (three days before the announcement of the second reform of De Guindos) warns that deviations are "very significant".

But the failure to meet targets set in the plan, is not the only thing that is highlighted in the report. Inspectors also note changes in accounting principles, "inflated margins," inadequate risk rating and, an incorrect adjustment to reserves that would have rid the institution of record losses in 2011.

The BMN group, born from the union of Caja Murcia, Caixa Penedes, Sa Nostra and Caja Granada, received in June 2010 915 million preference shares FROB.
Quick Translation

The BMN group is bankrupt and it is "virtually impossible" to pay back money to the Fund for Orderly Bank Restructuring (FROB).

Clearly the alleged orderly restructuring process is not so orderly.

For more on the FROB, please see Lending to Peter so Peter Can Lend to Paul

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Hollande About to Wreck France With Economically Insane Proposal: "Make Layoffs So Expensive For Companies That It's Not Worth It"

Unemployment in France touched 10.2% in April, a number last seen in 1999 according to data from Eurostat.



click on chart for sharper image

The question on newly-elected President Francois Hollande's mind is what to do about it.

Economic Insanity
 
Hollande's layoff clampdown solution according to Labour Minister Michel Sapin is to "make layoffs so expensive for companies that it's not worth it."
France's new Socialist government is planning to ramp up the cost of laying off workers for companies in the coming months, its labour minister said on Thursday after data showed the jobless rate hit the highest level this century at 10 percent.

"The main idea is to make layoffs so expensive for companies that it's not worth it," Sapin said in an interview with France Info radio.

"It's not a question of sanctions, but workers have to have compensation at the right level," he said.

Industry Minister Arnaud Montebourg is also planning legislation that would force companies to sell plants they want to get rid of at market prices to avoid closures and job losses.
Four Things, All of Them Bad

  1. Mass layoffs will occur before the law passes.
  2. Companies will move any jobs they can overseas.   
  3. Ongoing, if it's difficult to fire people, companies will not hire them in the first place. 
  4. Corporate profits will collapse along with the stock market should the need to fire people arise.

The proposal to force companies to sell plants rather than fire workers as outlined by Industry Minister Arnaud Montebourg and Labour Minister Michel Sapin is nothing short of economic insanity.

Nannycrat Dilemma

Think the Nannycrats in Brussels will go for this idea? If they do, they will wreck all of Europe. If they don't, then how are they going to "harmonize" everything?

For more on nannycrats and the nannyzone please see ...


Also see my original post on the "nannyzone" written June 2, 2011, nearly one year ago today: Trichet Calls for Creation of European "Nanny-State" and Fiscal "Nanny-Zone"

Addendum:

Reader "Bob" writes ....

Point 3 is the biggest but it gets even more insidious. The companies that have enough employees now are generally larger companies with a political voice. The companies that will need employees later are generally smaller, entrepreneurial companies with no political voice.

Since most job creation happens at the entrepreneurial level, the proposed policy will subsidize corporate stagnation while stemming the flow of entrepreneurial companies entering the market.

Over the long haul, this will kill France's economic competitiveness while increasing unemployment.

Recall government enforced jobs in the former USSR in the 1980's. How well did that go? Things got got so bad the USSR had to dissolve.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Monopoly Money vs. Bernanke Money, is there a Difference?

Occasionally I get an email from a reader that makes me pause and think. This is one of those times.

Reader Janet Dight writes ...
Hello Mish

As per Ben Bernanke Monopoly Official Rules "The bank never goes broke. If the bank runs out of money, the banker may issue as much as may be needed by writing on any ordinary paper."

Janet Dight
Clinical Psychologist
Monopoly Money vs. Bernanke Money

So what's the difference between "Monopoly Money" and "Bernanke Money"?

The difference is theory vs. practice.

In Monopoly, there is no difference between theory and practice. The rules are the rules and they will be honored and enforced by the players in the game. Money is printed and handed out without any regard as to whether it might be paid back. There is no such thing as excess reserves. Players are always willing to put money to use. If players don't put money to use, they will be bled to death by other players.

In the Bernanke's world, the Fed can print as much or as little as it wants. What the Fed does print is a loan. That money must be paid back. Collateral (even if speculative) is required and discounts are applied. In Bernanke's world, money is parked as excess reserves at the Fed if banks do not find good credit risks.

At times, it seems there is little difference between  "Monopoly Money" and "Bernanke Money". It all depends on the willingness of banks to lend and consumers and businesses to borrow.

However, even when it seems there is little difference, there is a major difference between a bank giving money to players to spend and loans that must be paid back.

Constraints are Key

Flashback November 23, 2010: Austrian economist Robert Murphy predicts "high inflation" and and writes a post Has Mish Deflated the "Inflationistas"?

My response which in retrospect has clearly carried the day was Failure to Consider Constraints - My Response to "Has Mish Deflated the Inflationistas?"

I invite you to read my detailed response to someone who was clearly wrong but here is the key snip.
Monetary Printing vs. Debt Deflation

There is $35 trillion in credit on the balance sheets of banks, little of it marked to market. Yet, printing $600 Billion is supposedly going to cause serious inflation.
Given the Money Multiplier Theory is totally bogus, The odds sure don't look very good to me

Practical Constraint Recap

  1. Ability of consumers/corporations to take on more debt
  2. Willingness of consumers/corporations to take on more debt
  3. Willingness of banks/credit companies to extend more credit
  4. Ability of banks/credit companies to extend more credit
  5. Unwillingness of the federal reserve to print themselves out of power
  6. Actions of other Central Banks
  7. Actions of Congress
  8. Demographics
  9. Global wage arbitrage
  10. Fed cannot create jobs
  11. Fed cannot give money away
  12. Fed is beholden to banks

In theory the Fed can cause inflation rather easily. In practice the Fed has to deal with many practical constraints.

Theory and Practice

Murphy claims "Bernanke has the power to raise prices if he so chooses". Can he? With whose help? At cost constraints Bernanke can ignore?

In theory, the Fed can cause massive inflation at will. In practice, they can't. As Yogi Berra once quipped "In theory there is no difference between theory and practice. In practice, there is."

You can lead a horse to money, you can't make him eat it. That's the very important difference. It's a question of attitudes.

The Fed can certainly encourage inflation by offering money at seemingly attractive rates, but it cannot force the issue.

Right now, neither consumers nor businesses want the risk. They are too loaded up with debt already, no matter how attractive the Fed wants debt to appear. It's like trying to give a kid one piece of cake too many. At some point, extra frosting makes the cake look less attractive, not more. At that point the kid will not take another bite.

That is the point we are at now. The Fed is hoping Congress will eat more cake. It's up to Congress, not the Fed, and I doubt Congress want to eat as much cake as the Fed needs.
Bernanke's Deflation Prevention Scorecard

In case no one is keeping track, Bernanke has now fired every bullet from his 2002 �helicopter drop� speech Deflation: Making Sure "It" Doesn't Happen Here.

Bernanke's Scorecard

Here is Bernanke�s roadmap, and a �point-by-point� list from that speech.

1. Reduce nominal interest rate to zero. Check. That didn�t work...
2. Increase the number of dollars in circulation, or credibly threaten to do so. Check. That didn�t work...
3. Expand the scale of asset purchases or, possibly, expand the menu of assets it buys. Check & check. That didn�t work...
4. Make low-interest-rate loans to banks. Check. That didn�t work...
5. Cooperate with fiscal authorities to inject more money. Check. That didn�t work...
6. Lower rates further out along the Treasury term structure. Check. That didn�t work...
7. Commit to holding the overnight rate at zero for some specified period. Check. That didn�t work...
8. Begin announcing explicit ceilings for yields on longer-maturity Treasury debt (bonds maturing within the next two years); enforce interest-rate ceilings by committing to make unlimited purchases of securities at prices consistent with the targeted yields. Check, and check. That didn�t work...
9. If that proves insufficient, cap yields of Treasury securities at still longer maturities, say three to six years. Check (they�re buying out to 7 years right now.) That didn�t work...
10. Use its existing authority to operate in the markets for agency debt. Check (in fact, they �own� the agency debt market!) That didn�t work...
11. Influence yields on privately issued securities. (Note: the Fed used to be restricted in doing that, but not anymore.) Check. That didn�t work...
12. Offer fixed-term loans to banks at low or zero interest, with a wide range of private assets deemed eligible as collateral (�Well, I�m still waiting for them to accept bellybutton lint & Beanie Babies, but I�m sure my patience will be rewarded. Besides their �mark-to-maturity� offers will be more than enticing!) Anyway� Check. That didn�t work...
13. Buy foreign government debt (and although Ben didn�t specifically mention it, let�s not forget those dollar swaps with foreign nations.) Check. That didn�t work...

Now What?

I wrote about Bernanke's Deflation Prevention Scorecard in April 2009.

Now, Bernanke is squealing like a stuck pig, begging Congress and China to help him produce price inflation in the US while still chastising Congress about a "fiscal cliff".

For details on the upcoming fiscal cliff please see Key Words of the Day: "Nothing", "Fiscal Cliff", "Later"; Bernanke Speech Template; U.S. Fiscal Cliff and What to Do About It

Regarding points 8 and 9 above: the Fed did purchase treasuries and agencies, but admittedly without an explicit ceiling.

Question of Timeframe

The point of this post is not to lay into Robert Murphy or any other misguided Austrian economists.  I had forgotten about the above debate and found it searching my blog for "constraints".

Also bear in mind that I happen to agree with the Austrian economists on most points of view except timeframe.

Their timeframe is way off because ...

  1. They view inflation as an exercise in printing, completely ignoring the role of credit 
  2. They ignore the changing attitudes towards lending by banks
  3. They ignore demographics and the changing attitudes of aging boomers headed towards retirement
  4. They ignore constraints on the Fed and constraints on banks
  5. They ignore the destruction of credit on the balance sheets of consumers and its effects on prices

Record Low Treasury Yields a Sign of What?

If massive inflation was coming 10-year treasury rates would not be yielding a record low 1.60% and consumers would certainly not be deleveraging!

Might massive inflation be coming down the road?

Certainly, but it will take a change in attitude by consumers and banks or massively reckless policies by Congress.

Interestingly, Congressional policies are indeed "massively reckless" just not reckless enough yet. The emphasis is on "yet". I will not be a deflationista forever, but I remain one for now.

Looking Ahead

I remain extremely amused by countless emails from people who tell me about how wrong I am going to be. 

They all miss my ability and willingness to change my mind! At some point I am going to change my tune. History suggests I will be far too early rather than late. Time will tell.

For now (and as I have been saying for as long as I have been blogging), hyperinflation or even "big inflation" is nonsense.

Constraints and Attitudes are Key

For now, attitudes, deleveraging, demographics, and the destruction of the value of credit on the balance sheets of banks absolutely and without a doubt overwhelm Bernanke's ability to do anything meaningful about it.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Thursday, 7 June 2012

Key Words of the Day: "Nothing", "Fiscal Cliff", "Later"; Bernanke Speech Template; U.S. Fiscal Cliff and What to Do About It

Everyone is pouring over the latest statements by Fed chairman Ben Bernanke and German chancellor Angela Merkel. But what did they really say?

The short answer is "nothing".

For example, Bloomberg reports Merkel Says Germany Ready to Back Use of Current Euro Tools.  

�In view of the current difficulties, it�s important to emphasize that we have created the instruments of support in the euro zone, that Germany is ready to work with these instruments whenever that is necessary and that this is an expression of our firm desire to keep the euro area stable,� the chancellor said. Merkel didn�t outline to which tools she was referring. 

Four Questions, Four One-Word Answers

  1. Is Merkel backing any new procedures? No 
  2. Is there a change of any kind? No 
  3. Did she even say what tools she was talking about? No
  4. Was this even news? No

At first glance the Bloomberg headline looks significant. However, the words "current tools" say all you need to know.

I propose a more realistic headline: "Merkel Supports What Merkel Supports"

What did Bernanke Say?

The short answer is "nothing". The exceptionally long answer can be found in Chairman Ben Bernanke's Economic Outlook and Policy Before the Joint Economic Committee, U.S. Congress June 7, 2012.

Here is one key highlight regarding "fiscal cliffs" that merits further discussion:
Even as fiscal policymakers address the urgent issue of fiscal sustainability, a second objective should be to avoid unnecessarily impeding the current economic recovery. Indeed, a severe tightening of fiscal policy at the beginning of next year that is built into current law--the so-called fiscal cliff--would, if allowed to occur, pose a significant threat to the recovery. Moreover, uncertainty about the resolution of these fiscal issues could itself undermine business and household confidence. Fortunately, avoiding the fiscal cliff and achieving long-term fiscal sustainability are fully compatible and mutually reinforcing objectives. Preventing a sudden and severe contraction in fiscal policy will support the transition back to full employment, which should aid long-term fiscal sustainability. At the same time, a credible fiscal plan to put the federal budget on a longer-run sustainable path could help keep longer-term interest rates low and improve household and business confidence, thereby supporting improved economic performance today.

A third objective for fiscal policy is to promote a stronger economy in the medium and long term through the careful design of tax policies and spending programs. To the fullest extent possible, federal tax and spending policies should increase incentives to work and save, encourage investments in workforce skills, stimulate private capital formation, promote research and development, and provide necessary public infrastructure. Although we cannot expect our economy to grow its way out of federal budget imbalances without significant adjustment in fiscal policies, a more productive economy will ease the tradeoffs faced by fiscal policymakers.
Fiscal Cliff and What Bernanke Wants To Do About It

Ben Bernanke warns Congress that the U.S. faces a fiscal cliff. However, Bernanke does not want them to do anything about it now.

There is no change in stance here. Monetarist and Keynesian clowns never want to address fiscal cliffs in advance, bubbles in advance, regulations in advance, or anything else in advance, except of course when they are dead wrong about what to do.

As with Merkel, there is no change in Bernanke's stance, just a promise to do something later if the economy worsens.  He also warned Congress they will need to do something about the U.S. fiscal cliff, but certainly not now.

Bernanke Speech Template

Blah blah blah, stimulus if needed, blah blah blah, fiscal cliff, blah blah blah, not now, blah blah blah, full employment, blah blah blah, depressed housing, blah blah blah, encouraging signs, blah blah blah, recovery,blah blah blah, maintain highly accommodative stance, blah blah blah, no inflation, blah blah blah.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Surprise Rate Cut in China; What's it Mean?

China surprised economists today with a surprise cut in interest rates by a quarter point, the first cut in rates since 2008.
Just a couple of months ago, few analysts had forecast that Beijing would cut rates, believing that China was on track for a �soft landing�. But after growth slowed to 8.1 per cent in the first quarter, recent data showed the economy was on track for a sharp deceleration.

With the cut, China�s benchmark one-year lending rate will now be 6.31 per cent, while the one-year deposit rate will be 3.25 per cent.

The People�s Bank of China, which raised interest rates three times last year, had previously characterised its monetary stance this year as �fine tuning�, arguing that nothing dramatic was needed to support the economy. The rate cut marks a definite change.

The question now is whether businesses and households will respond to the lower rates by borrowing more. Banks have reported weak loan demand over the past two months.

In an important move alongside the rate cut, the Chinese central bank said it would allow banks to set deposit rates 10 percent above the benchmark level and to set lending rates 20 per cent below the benchmark.

This is a step towards interest rate liberalisation � that is, letting banks decide for themselves, based on market conditions, the level at which they set rates. Analysts believe this is crucial to putting the economy on a more stable footing by ensuring that households earn a fair return on their bank savings, thus encouraging more income to be used for consumption.
What's it Mean?

The simple explanation is China is slowing far more than the soft-landing crowd expects.

China wants to stimulate growth but it has already exhausted every economically viable infrastructure project. All that is left is malinvestment opportunities. Moreover, new projects will add to delays in much-needed rebalancing efforts both within China and externally.

China will publish  industrial output and sales data this weekend. PMI reports suggest the data will not be very good although there has been a huge discrepancy lately between "official" reports and PMI reports.

Look for the "official" reports to reflect the slowdown shown in the PMI, and perhaps much worse.

Should China march ahead with massive numbers of new infrastructure projects, more state-owned-enterprise bad debts will undoubtedly pile up and once again private citizens will pay the price for the cleanup.

Hard Landing Coming Up

On May 12, in Screeching Halt in China; Weak Trade Data; Imports and Exports Fall Way Short of Expectations; Credit Crunch Underway; Feeble Forecasts From Pimco, Others I stated China bulls are in for a multi-year shock because rebalancing from an economy overly dependent on exports is going to be far more painful, and last much longer than most think. Data is coming in much weaker than expected, but I propose this is only the very beginning.

I am sticking with 3.5% average growth for the rest of the decade, an idea proposed by Michael Pettis in a bet with The Economist. For details, please see 12 Predictions by Michael Pettis on China; Non-Food Commodity Prices Will Collapse Over Next Three to Four Years; Nails in the Hard Landing Coffin?

Perfect Demographic Storm

For more on China, please consider China's Population Poised to Crash in Perfect Demographic Storm

Also consider "Curbs Needed to Avoid China Property Chaos" Says China's Premier; Chinese Economy Already in Hard Landing? Regardless, It's Too Late to Prevent Chaos

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List