To what extent should US citizens loses their constitutional right in the "war on terror". Can US citizens be apprehended without charges? Killed by drones? On US soil?
John Brennan, Obama's nomination to run the CIA, refused to disavow even that last question. In response, Senator Rand Paul courageously, and single-handedly sponsored a filibuster in the Senate to block Brennan's appointment.
Wired reports 11 Years Later, Senate Wakes Up to War on Terror’s ‘Battlefield America’Sen. Rand Paul’s filibuster will inevitably fail at its immediate objective: derailing John Brennan’s nomination to run the CIA. But as it stretches into its sixth hour, it’s already accomplished something far more significant: raising political alarm over the extraordinary breadth of the legal claims that undergird the boundless, 11-plus-year “war on terrorism.”
The Kentucky Republican’s delaying tactic started over one rather narrow slice of that war: the Obama administration’s equivocation on whether it believes it has the legal authority to order a drone strike on an American citizen, in the United States.
Paul recognized outright that he would ultimately lose his fight to block Brennan, the White House counterterrorism chief and architect of much of the administration’s targeted-killing efforts.
But as his time on the Senate floor went on, Paul went much further. He called into question aspects of the war on terrorism that a typically bellicose Congress rarely questions, and most often defends, often demagogically so. More astonishingly, Paul’s filibuster became such a spectacle that he got hawkish senators to join him.
as the filibuster picked up more and more media attention — and especially social-media attention — hawkish senators began joining in. Sen. Marco Rubio (R-Florida) praised Paul’s efforts at compelling transparency from the White House. What Paul is arguing is “no less important than our Constitutional government itself,” said Sen. John Cornyn (R-Texas), no dove.
It would be foolish to presume that Paul’s moment in the spotlight heralds a new Senate willingness to roll back the expanses of the post-9/11 security apparatus. Rubio, for instance, stopped short of endorsing any of Paul’s substantive criticisms of the war. But Paul did manage to shift what political scientists call the Overton Window — the acceptable center of gravity of discussion.
Paul’s filibuster posed a challenge to the Senate more than it does Brennan or President Obama. “Is perpetual war OK with everybody?” he asked.
Brennan will be nominated anyway, but Paul's firm stance in the face of his chicken-hawk and constitutional-hypocrite colleagues is very much appreciated.
I support Rand Paul for president in 2016. It was a pleasure meeting him in person Monday evening at a fundraiser in Palatine Illinois.
Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
The Markit Eurozone Composite PMI Final Data shows the Eurozone downturn accelerates. Key Points:
Final Eurozone Composite Output Index: 47.9 (Flash 47.3, January 48.6)
Final Eurozone Services Business Activity Index: 47.9 (Flash 47.3, January 48.6)
At 47.9 in February, the Markit Eurozone PMI® Composite Output Index came in above the earlier flash estimate of 47.3 but remained down on January’s reading of 48.6. The index therefore signalled a steepening of the downturn in business activity, contrasting with the easing trend which had been evident in the three months to January.

Divergence to France Widest in 15 Years
Chris Williamson, Chief Economist at Markit said: “The dip in the Eurozone PMI compared to January is a disappointment, but the region still looks set to see a much smaller drop in GDP in the first quarter compared to the 0.6% decline seen in the final quarter of last year, with the PMI so far consistent with a 0.2% GDP decline.
“Worryingly, the divergence between Germany and France so far this year is the widest in the 15-year survey history. Germany is on course to see the strongest quarterly growth since the spring of 2011, but France is contracting at the fastest rate for four years.
“The deteriorating picture in the periphery is also a concern. Rates of decline picked up in Italy and Spain, with further weakness likely in Italy especially in coming months due to the uncertainty caused by the elections.
“The outlook therefore seems to largely depend on whether Germany can continue to expand and offset the weakness in France, Italy and Spain, which seems a tall order, meaning hopes of a return to growth for the region by mid-2013 are now looking too optimistic.”
Illusions of Stabilization
Williamson has now changed his tune to something more in line with what I stated on February 7 in Illusions of StabilizationIn Germany Rebounds but ... I noted a recovery "of sorts" in Germany, a contraction in France at the steepest rate in four years, and a record decrease in services employment in Italy.
Thus, it should be no surprise to see the Markit Eurozone Composite PMI® shows national divergence hits record high.
Yet, in aggregate, the eurozone contraction decelerated with the eurozone composite PMI rising from 47.2 to 48.6.
So, what's it all mean?
Chris Williamson, Chief Economist at Markit offered this interpretation: "The eurozone is showing clear signs of healing, with the downturn easing sharply in January and the region moving closer to stabilisation in the first quarter. ...."
No Signs of Healing
I disagree with Williamson. Those divergences show the eurozone is getting sicker, not healing.
If there was any healing, and certainly if there was any rebalancing, manufacturing and export growth would be picking up in Spain, in Italy, and in France at the expense of Germany.
A quick check of the Markit Eurozone Manufacturing PMI will show that is not what's happening.
There were no signs of stabilization last month, in January, or in December. And with the clear deterioration in France, imbalances have accelerated to the downside.
In regards to Williamson's forecast of a 0.2% GDP decline, I will take "the under". Should "the over" line be right, don't expect it to last too long.
Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
I asked reader "AC" who is from Italy but now lives in France for some comments on "Grillonomics".
She replies ...
Hello Mish,
Your translation seems correct.
It's quite astonishing is that a serious newspaper like Les Echos reports this story. It is far from clear and proven that Stiglitz has collaborated to any significant extent on the program of M5S. Some newspapers reported a formal denial from Stiglitz.
What is true is that Stiglitz has been writing a few posts (2 or 3) on Grillo's blog, but just that. The main "ideologists" of Grillonomics seem to be Italian economist Mauro Gallegati, Alberto Bagnai (an economics professor in Pescara) and Loretta Napoleoni.
Beppe Grillo's economic program is quite a mess. Grillo provides no details on where the money for all the expenditure he wants will come from.
M5S wants free Internet, abolition of several taxes, citizenship income, revoking reforms that have made the job market more flexible, and nationalization of banks. Some things he seeks are pro-market, some others not at all. He seeks many tax cuts (a good thing) but he does not specify enough cuts elsewhere to balance.
Succinctly, his economic program is a real mess.
Grillo's campaign against the "cascade of holdings" refers to a typical Italian situation where few people get control of huge companies via control of preferred shares of intermediate companies. Italian capitalism is frequently made of "capitalists without capital".
Regards,
AC
Italian Cascade Control Explained
A search for "Italian Cascade Control" led me to Corporate governance: the Italian Story, a 63 page document that explains the cascade process is one in which companies issue "preference shares without voting rights ... Nearly all the major corporations of the country have grown in a similar manner".
Italian regulation allows the issuance of various types of stocks: a) normal or “ordinary” stocks, with full voting rights; b) stocks with limited voting rights but privileged as concerns the distribution of dividends; and c) stocks without voting rights but privileged as concerns the distribution of dividends and reimbursement. The only limitation is that the sum of b and c cannot exceed 50% of the whole capital.
Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Beppe Grillo's anti-corruption, eurosceptic, Five Star Movement (M5S) is now the largest political party in Italy.
Enter "Grillonomics"
Via Google translate from French, Les Echos reports Fitoussi and Stiglitz are working on the economic program of Beppe Grillo. All eyes are beginning to converge on the "economic program" Beppe Grillo, still limited to a page and a half on the site M5S.
With Italian economist Mauro Gallegati acting as coordinator, Nobel Prize winning economist Joseph Stiglitz and French economist Jean-Paul Fitoussi were called on to help formulate the economic doctrine M5S.
"To move from protest to proposal, the first step is to get studying. In this context, I am trying to organize a task force of academics begin to teach the newly elected" said economist Mauro Gallegati, an economics professor at the University of Ancona.
"Bruce Greenwald of Columbia University in New York and Jean-Paul Fitoussi will give me a hand," says Gallegati who rejects the label of "Beppe Grillo's Economic Guru." The real "sponsor" of M5S's economic program, based on the decay and the development of clean energy, is mainly Nobel Laureate Joseph Stiglitz (Columbia University), with Bruce Greenwald as one of the closest staff.
Paul Krugman has also maintained a dialogue with Beppe Grillo for several years.
Globalization, Guaranteed Income, Debt Reductions
"Globalization as has been managed seems a pact with the devil. We can ensure that globalization works, not only for the rich and powerful, but for everyone" said a message posted on the M5S blog with a link to a Stiglitz video "Make Globalization Work".
Grillo supports a concept of a guaranteed "citizenship income" for all, whose cost is estimated at between 20 and 30 billion euros.
M5S advocates "reducing the debt through strong interventions on the cost of the State with the fight against waste and the use of new technologies to make the citizen access to information and services without the need for intermediaries." It also provides for the abolition of stock options and cascades of holding for listed companies.
That is a substantially Mish-modified translation from French. I am not sure what "cascades of holding for listed companies" means.
It will be interesting to see what this collection of economists comes up with, because Grillo is eurosceptic and I doubt those whose advice Grillo seeks are in the same camp.
One thing is for sure: austerity is likely to head out the window, and that will cause fits in Brussels and Germany.
Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
The sheer stupidity out of nannycrats in Brussels is staggering. Smack in the midst of a depression, Brussels once again calls on Spain to hike taxes. Via Google translate from El Economista ...
The European Commission today called on Spain to restrict the application of the reduced VAT rate and raise fuel taxes to reduce the deficit, and continue reforms in the labor and pensions, delaying the effective retirement age. These requests collide with the ideas defended by the Spanish Government no further adjustment and lower taxes in 2014.
Brussels also calls on the Government to implement a stricter budgetary stability law to the autonomous regions in breach of their deficit targets and accelerate the implementation of budgetary control office.
Brussels admits that the increase in VAT which applies since last September (from 18% to 21% and the basic rate from 8% to 10% reduced rate) is a "progress" to improve the effectiveness of the Spanish tax system. "However, there is scope to limit the application of different VAT rates low and to increase environmental taxes, especially fuels," says the report.
Economic Stupidity at its Finest!
For those not familiar with the VAT system in Europe, there are varying tax rates on categories of products and services. The lowest VAT rate in Spain went from 8% to 10% and Brussels wants Spain to limit the number of items that get the lowest rate. Brussels calls the hike in the minimum VAT to 10% and the top VAT to 21% "progress".
Labor reforms are desperately needed, but tax hikes in the middle of a depression is "economic stupidity", not progress.
Monitoring Spain's Deficit
Not counting bank bailouts, El Economista reports Spain ended 2012 with a deficit at 6.74%.
The Minister of Finance and Public Administration, Cristobal Montoro, today confirmed that the total government deficit ended the year 2012 on the 6.74% of gross domestic product (GDP), as reported yesterday the Prime Minister Mariano Rajoy. Also reported that the deficit of the regions was 1.73%, two-tenths above the target.
The government closed last year with a deficit of 70.822 million euros, equivalent to 6.74% of GDP, .44 percentage points above the target agreed with Brussels (6.3%). The deficit rises to 9.99% when taking into account the banking aid, which added 3.25 percentage points. This figure is higher than that recorded in 2011, from 9.44% of GDP.
The hole in the budget of the regions was 1.73%, when the target was 1.5%, while the local government hole was 0.2%, better than the 0.3% that had been planned.
No More Adjustments
The finance minister has said he will not take further tightening measures in 2013 because it is not necessary. "There will be no need for further action," said Montoro.
Battle Over Adjustments
The problem in Spain is government spending and lack of labor reforms, so the solution cannot possibly be higher taxes. Yet, higher taxes is exactly what Brussels demands, smack in the face of a "no more adjustments" statement from Spain's finance minister.
Those tax hikes are guaranteed to be counterproductive, and one can also expect still more bank bailouts. Thus, a rational-thinking person expects another huge budget deficit miss by Spain in 2013 and beyond.
For more on the hopelessness in Spain (and the eurozone in aggregate), please see
Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Bloomberg reports Swiss Voters Approve Limits on ‘Fat Cat’ Executive Pay
Swiss voters approved some of the world’s toughest limits on executives’ pay in a referendum, a move critics say could make Switzerland less attractive to multinational corporations. The initiative against “fat cats,” proposed by Thomas Minder, head of a herbal toothpaste company, was backed by 67.9 percent of the voters today, the government said on its website today.
The proposal gives shareholders an annual ballot on managers’ pay. It eliminates sign-on bonuses, as well as severance packages and extra incentives for completing merger transactions. The initiative also includes rules punishing executives who violate the terms with as long as three years in jail.
How much executives take home was called into question in Switzerland after the country’s biggest bank, UBS AG (UBSN), had to be bailed out during the financial crisis, while in 2010 Credit Suisse (CSGN) CEO Dougan received 71 million francs ($76 million) of shares. That compares with a gross average Swiss monthly wage of $7,800 for 2011, according to UN statistics.
Fat Cats Respond
- Economiesuisse, a business lobby which had campaigned against the proposal, said "the result is a “negative signal for Switzerland as a place for doing business.”
- Nestle CEO Bulcke said the plan Switzerland less attractive to corporations and managers.
- At least five of Europe’s 20 highest-paid chief executive officers work for Swiss companies: Credit Suisse Group AG CEO Brady Dougan, ABB Ltd. (ABBN)’s Joe Hogan and Joe Jimenez of Novartis AG. (NOVN) Roche Holding AG (ROG)’s chief Severin Schwan and Nestle SA (NESN)’s Paul Bulcke are also in the top tier.
- Offshore drilling contractor Transocean Ltd. (RIG) and oilfield service company Weatherford International Ltd. (WFT) choose Switzerland as their base. It's safe to count those companies in the opposition list.
Unsurprisingly, the fatter the cat, the greater the opposition to "fat cat laws". However, that does not address the primary question at hand.
Is Executive Pay a Problem?
Before finding solutions, we must first understand the problem. Is executive pay a problem?
The answer (that too few see) is executive pay is a "symptom of a problem" not the "real" problem.
Three Real Problems
- Fractional reserve lending
- Central bank "too big to fail" policies
- Government spending out of control
Want to rein in excesses at corporations? Then fix the real problems and the executive pay problem will mostly take care of itself.
For further discussion, please see
Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
European bulls lauding the message "the worst is behind" received another dose of reality today. Data shows German car sales plunge as Europe's auto crisis deepens.
New car sales in Germany fell by more than 10 percent year-on-year in February, signaling the crisis for Europe's auto makers is deepening as recession-hit consumers curb spending. New car sales in the region dropped to a 17-year low in 2012.
Speaking ahead of the industry meeting in Geneva, the sales chief of General Motors' (GM.N) Opel brand said car sales for the whole of Europe might fall by as much as 10 percent this year.
Until recently, industry executives have been penciling in a decline of around 3-5 percent for Europe's car market in 2013. The market shrank 7.8 percent last year.
Germany continues to outperform markets such as France and Italy, where car registrations tumbled 12 percent and 17 percent respectively in February. German car sales fell 2.9 percent in 2012, including a 16 percent drop in December.
Gee Who Coulda Thunk?
"Until recently, industry executives have been penciling in a decline of around 3-5 percent."
Flashback, July 09, 2012: Global Collapse In Auto Sales Coming Up.
Employee of German Manufacturer Robert Bosch Responds
Hi Mish,
Love your blog. I've written before.
I work for Robert Bosch in Germany. We make diesel injectors for common rail systems (truck and passenger car).
Our sales forecasts are again down and there is a huge crunch now to save money to try to squeeze out a profit at the end of the year. Sales are down 10% to business plan so they are looking for every dime right now.
The retiring CEO (Franz Fehrenbach...a good man) wishes for a "black 0" at the end of the year. However, I doubt that will happen.
Numerous older people have been given incentives to leave the company before official retirement age.
There are numerous closure days still planned. I would guess we can expect more.
So what you are seeing in the PMI is reality. I do not see or hear similar hints in the rest of the German economy yet......
Regards,
Name Withheld by Mish
One did not have to hear from an employee of Bosch, the world's largest supplier of automotive components, to make that forecast.
All one had to do is think. Italy and Spain were in severe recessions and France was clearly headed there (thanks in part to the nonsensical policies of French president Francois Hollande).
With that backdrop, precisely what countries were German exporters supposed to export to?
Throw Away Your Sunglasses
Don't expect much in the way of US auto exports with Europe in severe recession, and China slowing significantly.
Some forecast increasing US sales based on pent-up auto demand from kids. I see the end of the line as the US is back in recession.
There still are few jobs for kids out of college, the 2% payroll tax restoration will take a bite out of disposable income, retiring boomers don't need new cars, and changing social attitudes towards kids are such that kids do not want the debt their parents had (nor do they have the love affair with cars their parents had).
The jobless recovery is over and the future is dim enough that people can throw away their sunglasses for a lengthy spell.
Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com