Thursday, 20 July 2006

We're Partying Like it's June 29

2006-07-20
Today's Thought of the Day comes from Kevin Depew at Minyanville.

We're Partying Like it's June 29.

June 29 holds a special place in our wallet heart.

  • On June 29 the S&P 500 (SPX) opened at 1245.94, the low of the day, and went out a penny shy of the high at 1272.87.
  • Yesterday, the SPX opened at 1236.74, the low of the day, and went out just shy of the high at 1259.81.
  • After June 29s close of 1272.87, 10 days later the SPX closed at 1236.20.
  • What happened? Geopolitics? Oil? Dollar? Inflation? Stagflation? Deflation? Pick whichever one you like.
  • The issue remains the same as it has been since late 2002: liquidity and risk appetite. Alan Greenspan ultimately was able to "successfully resolve" every economic issue he faced by injecting liquidity.
  • Asian Contagion? Liquidity Injection. Long-term Capital Management? Liquidity injection. September 11? Liquidity injection. Iraq War? Liquidity injection.
  • Of course, what gets lost in this "success," the reason he was able to "successfully" do this, was because risk appetites (time preferences) were amenable to increased liquidity and risk-seeking.
  • The battle now is between risk appetites. Central banks cannot force risk-seeking behavior, they can only feed it when it exists.
  • The reason we are dealing with stagflation now, as Bernanke admitted yesterday behind a thin veil in his Home Free-Hocking testimony, is because stagflation in this case is simply the transition from risk-seeking (inflation) behavior to risk aversion (deflation) behavior and decreased time preferences.
Thanks to Kevin Depew for today's thought of the day
Mike Shedlock / Mish

Ghost Housing Market

Following is an update from Mike Morgan at Morgan Florida.
This entire post is from Morgan so I will skip my normal procedure of indenting.
It is about the "Ghost Market" in Florida.

Mike Morgan:

We recently had two more of Wall Street’s finest out on a tour of Florida real estate markets. After the first day, these guys needed diapers. They’ve been listening to the garbage from home building company management teams and what dribble they hear on the conference calls. I showed them reality, and it hit them like a ton of bricks. Here’s a review of reality.

Inventory - Our current levels are all time highs. We’ve never seen anything like this. If you want to believe the NAR numbers, so be it. In the previously hot markets, inventory levels are well beyond a year, and in some markets 2-4 years. You have hundreds of thousands of homes in the hands of flippers, not to mention all of the unsold inventory the builders are sitting on, and you still have the normal market of people selling for reasons like death, new job, etc..

Ghost Market - Why so much inventory? The Ghost Market of so called “investors.” These people were not investors. Maybe speculators, but even that is too kind. They were uninformed gamblers. For the last two years, you had better odds at the Big Six Wheel in Vegas. And the builders knew it. The builders saw buyers flipping contracts before closing a few years back. There response was to include a contract provision that you could not assign the contract, and you must close with the builder. They told the Street they were doing this to control investors. Well, that’s pure nonsense. If they wanted to keep investors out, they could have demanded sworn affidavits. They could have put deed restrictions in regarding sale and rental of the home. But there logic was not to eliminate investors from the market, but rather to capitalize on them. So with assignments prohibited, the new wave of lemmings had to buy from the builders. And away we go! So now we have a market flooded with people that had no intention of living in the home. When, in the history of the world, have you seen millions of people buying multiple homes like a box of donuts? Like donuts, the value of these homes is dropping as they sit on the market.

Quality - Builders have been selling the vast majority of their homes to flippers. Flippers don’t care about quality. Rarely does a flipper order a competent home inspection. Rarely does a flipper even do a walk through. They are only concerned with flipping the contract as soon as they close. The builders did not let this opportunity go unnoticed. They built lower and lower quality homes, often ignoring building codes. How? In many markets the pace of construction has outpaced the ability of the local authorities to inspect homes, so these markets allow the builder to hire their very own private inspectors. Now if you hired an inspector that flagged your homes, how long do you think you would keep that inspector? So the builders find inspectors that are willing to look the other way. Many of the homes on the market today do not meet building codes. We are seeing an escalation of defective roofs, defective trusses, defective stucco and the list goes on. We actually set up a website to help home buyers with information. I’d like to report on all of the home builders, but for now our site is focused on just one builder www.Lennar-Homes.info. We’ll be adding new sites over the next few months.

Location - Once again, builders realized they could sell anything as long as they pegged it as “pre-construction.” Building next to dumps, rail lines and depressed areas became the norm. Flippers never bothered to visit the sites. Let’s look at Miami. Out of area flippers just hear two things. “Miami” and “pre-construction.” Our trips through Miami reveal that many of the construction zones are in depressed areas full of crack houses, empty warehouses and worse. The flippers didn’t care, and neither did the builders. But the “real” buyers that might live in these condos and homes care. And they are not going to buy these projects.

Cancellations - If you think the cancellation rate is less than 50%, I’ve got a bridge for sale. Flippers are dumb, but they are not going to wipe themselves out. If they bought a property for $500,000 and it is now selling for $400,000, why would they close? They will simply walk away from their contract, leaving the builder with more unsold inventory. Here’s one example to drive this point home. An investor client of ours was recently released from his contract price of $490,000. The builder just resold it for $315,000. That’s a “real life” example. That’s a 36% haircut for the builder. Margins? There are none at these prices. P/E ratio low? How about no P/E ratios? One final note: The flippers have about 3% in closing costs with the builder. Then they have about 10% with the new buyer. So they need a 13% increase in price to break even. What would you do if prices have already fallen by 20%? Lose another 7% or walk away from the contract?

Affordability - Prices skyrocketed artificially because flippers did not care about price. They only cared about one thing . . . We’re they getting pre-construction pricing? Now we have a flood of inventory on the market that buyers cannot afford. First time buyers generally need homes under $300,000. Even in previously hot markets like Port St. Lucie, we saw average home prices rise above $300,000 for pre-construction homes. And the high end market is not immune to this problem either. Buyers that purchase million dollar plus homes are far more astute then the first time buyer. The high end buyers read the Wall Street Journal and follow the numbers. They see the massive build up of inventory, and they all tell me the same thing. “We’re looking, but we’re going to wait till prices come down.” And with that kind of logic, prices will continue to drop.

Interest Rates - Compounding the affordability problem are interest rates. A little over a year ago a buyer could secure a $300,000 mortgage for $1,250 a month (less if they used an ARM). Now the same buyer is looking at a $1,750 mortgage or $6,000 a year more in mortgage payments. If they could only afford $1,250, they can now only afford $215,000 mortgage. That represents a 28% drop in affordability. Margins? Not with 28% affordability drops.

ARMS - Ouch. What more can you say. With a trillion dollars in debt a year coming due for refinancing, what’s going to happen to people when their mortgaged go up 40%? They’re going to put their homes on the market. The same market that is already flooded with inventory from flippers, builders and the normal sellers. The result will be more inventory and prices dropping further as sellers scramble to sell.

ATM - Add to the problems, all of those home owners that used their homes like ATM machines to buy cars, boats, skiddos and vacations. The counted on ever increasing home prices and low interest rates to keep them afloat. What do they do now? Put their homes on the market in hopes of cashing in and downsizing. More inventory!

Costs/Margins - Take a look at the main components in a home - copper, cement and lumber. Now look at how high these prices have skyrocketed during the last three years. Once again, ask yourself where the margins are.

Jobs - Now we’re getting to the heart of the problem moving forward. The housing boom has accounted for more jobs during the last few years, than any other sector. Think about this: real estate agents, builders’ sales agents, mortgage brokers, title companies, subcontractors, suppliers, vendors, attorneys, insurance agents, and the list goes on and on. We’re going to see a dramatic drop in jobs, an increase in unemployment and fewer people able to buy the homes that are flooding the market. By the way, as these people lose their jobs, they lose their homes! More inventory.

Foreign Investors - Here’s something we’ve heard about but could not verify until this last trip. Builders are targeting oversees investors. We visited a couple of developments that are targeting investors from South America and Puerto Rico. There are companies that put on road shows overseas targeting these investors. They require larger deposits, so the builders can pay the commissions up front. These sales teams don’t care about closings, since they get most, if not all, of their commissions up front. The builders get to book a sale, even if it doesn’t close a year from now. The angle used by these teams is that the flipper can either flip the home, or rent it out. I’ve got news for you. Drive through any of these communities and you’ll see dozens of For Sale and For Rent signs. These unwitting flippers can’t sell and they can’t rent. They have massive carrying costs and prices on the homes are dropping fast. Eventually, these homes go back to the banks.

“We Don’t Sell to Investors” - I wish I had a dollar for every time I’ve heard this line. We visited one national builder that proclaims they don’t want investors, but the sales agent told us they just sold a block of 30 town homes to one investor and another block of 8 to another investor.

“We Don’t Use Incentives” - Another line we’ve heard for the last six months. Incentives are rampant. We did not find a single builder that did not offer an incentive. And these incentives are getting larger and more creative. Some builders simply told us to make an offer! One national builder told us to make an offer, and then knock another $100,000 off of a $1.8M condo that has been on the market for more than a year, and originally had a price tag of $2.4M. How does this effect margins? What margins?

“We Don’t Build Spec Homes” - Yeah, right. On this trip we saw the worst of the worst. We saw entire developments under construction on spec. No buyers. “Make us an offer.” The logic the builders use for building spec homes is simple. Component prices or homes are going up, so if we don’t build now, it will cost us more a year from now. The problem with this logic is just as simple. If no one is going to buy these homes, the builders have two choices. One, slash prices. Two, carry the homes and pay the taxes, insurance and maintenance. Neither option is sound business. The other thing we hear from builders is this. “If we don’t build spec homes, we have nothing to sell, and our competitors will have inventory to sell.” Once again, bad logic. The builders would be better off with no inventory, versus inventory they will be forced to sell at a loss or carry at a loss. But the titans of the home building industry realize they need to produce numbers now, even if it means a lot of pain a year from now. Their only concern is near term so they can capitalize on their bonuses.

Our Economy - If all of this is not enough to drive the point home that the home building market is going to crush this economy, consider this. We are sending most of our manufacturing jobs to China. GM and Ford are near bankruptcy. We don’t even answer our own phones anymore with giant call centers in India. We hire nurses from all over the world and we even have an association called Visiting Nurse Association. Take a look at any of these new developments being built. Who do you see? Who’s cutting your lawn? The Florida orange juice association just announced that six million boxes of oranges are going to be left on the trees this year, because we don’t have the immigrant labor to pick the oranges. Many of those pickers are now building the homes for flippers. What kind of quality can we expect out of that? A recession is coming and lenders simply are not prepared for the defaults we are going to see. Banks are going to be flooded with REOs (Real Estate Owned) properties and that too is going to add to supply. It’s not pretty no matter how you look at it.

Mike Morgan, Broker-Owner, REALTOR®, J.D., GRI, e-PRO
Morgan Florida Real Estate Group

Mish Comments:

I have little to add to that update other than to be completely prepared for the consumer/housing led recession of 2007. It is coming.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Wednesday, 19 July 2006

USA For Sale Part 2

Back on May 15 I wrote USA For Sale.
Following are two short clips:
Transurban Group, Australia's second- biggest toll road owner, agreed to buy Virginia's Pocahontas Parkway for $611 million, gaining its first U.S. motorway.

Dubai International Capital said Sunday it had completed its acquisition of Doncasters Group Ltd, which operates several US manufacturing plants that make parts for US military vehicles and aircraft.
You might also recall that China tried to buy Unocal and Dubai tried to buy service contracts for US ports.

Enquiring minds might be wondering "When does this stop?"
The answer is not soon.

Please consider China's Foreign Reserves. The Shanghai Daily is reporting China's Foreign reserves mount up even higher in June.
CHINA'S foreign exchange reserves, the world's largest, increased by a third from a year earlier to US$941 billion at the end of June, the People's Bank of China said yesterday.

The Chinese government's currency assets excluding gold increased from US$711 billion in June 2005, according to the Beijing-based central bank.

Money inflows from the trade surplus and foreign investment are pushing China's foreign reserves higher. Analysts say the government still faces pressure on the value of its currency.

China's reserves overtook Japan's as the world's largest this year and are set to top US$1 trillion, Moody's Investors Service said last week.

China's trade surplus tripled to US$102 billion last year and reached US$61.5 billion in the first half of 2006. The nation had a US$14.5 billion trade surplus in June, a monthly record.
In a related story, CBS News is reporting Foreign Companies Buy U.S. Roads, Bridges.
Foreign companies are buying up American highways and bridges built by U.S. taxpayers.

Roads and bridges built by U.S. taxpayers are starting to be sold off, and so far foreign-owned companies are doing the buying.

On a single day in June, an Australian-Spanish partnership paid $3.8 billion to lease the Indiana Toll Road. An Australian company bought a 99-year lease on Virginia's Pocahontas Parkway, and Texas officials decided to let a Spanish-American partnership build and run a toll road from Austin to Seguin for 50 years.

Few people know that the tolls from the U.S. side of the tunnel between Detroit and Windsor, Canada, go to a subsidiary of an Australian company _ which also owns a bridge in Alabama.

Last year, the city [Chicago] sold a 99-year lease on the eight-mile Chicago Skyway for $1.83 billion. The buyer was the same consortium that leased the Indiana Toll Road _ Macquarie Infrastructure Group of Sydney, Australia, and Cintra Concesiones de Infraestructuras de Transporte of Madrid, Spain.

Illinois lawmakers are examining privatizing the Illinois Tollway, New Jersey lawmakers are considering selling 49 percent of the state's two big toll roads and a gubernatorial candidate in Ohio wants to sell the turnpike.

Indiana Gov. Mitch Daniels, who championed his state's toll road deal, now wants investors to build and operate a toll road from Indianapolis to Evansville.

Patrick Bauer, the Indiana House's Democratic leader, says such deals are taxpayer rip-offs.

Bauer believes Macquarie-Cintra could make $133 billion over the 75-year life of the Indiana Toll Road lease _ for which Indiana got $3.8 billion.

"In five, maybe 10 years, all that money is gone, and the tolls keep rising and the money keeps flowing into the foreign coffers," Bauer said.

Texas Gov. Rick Perry's vision [is] to attract more than $80 billion in private funds for roads by 2030.

Not everyone in Texas buys the idea. Harris County officials recently voted against selling three toll roads. Also, independent gubernatorial candidate Carole Keeton Strayhorn opposes Perry's toll road plan.

"Texas freeways belong to Texans, not foreign companies," she said.
The best analysis of the situation comes from Indiana house leader Patrick Bauer: "In five, maybe 10 years, all that money is gone, and the tolls keep rising and the money keeps flowing into the foreign coffers".

Bauer understands the situation perfectly. What most do not understand is that the money to buy our roads and bridges comes from huge and growing balance of trade problems as well as overconsumption in the US.

Asset Selloff Questions
  1. Is that a sign of strength?
  2. Is that a good thing?
I think the first question is easy enough to answer. How can it be? If the current pace continues long enough, foreigners will eventually own 100% of US assets. I fail to see how that can be construed as any sign of strength. Furthermore, we seem to be willing to sell public assets because we have to rather than because we want to.

Given the current balance of trade deficit, foreigners have more dollars than they know how to dispose of. Ultimately those dollars will come back to US investments whether we like it or not. In no way can this be construed as a "sign of strength".

The second question "Is this a good thing?" is a much harder to answer.

Given that governments in general can not possibly know the correct value of anything, nor can they possibly know how to price for services, one can only conclude it is a good thing for the government to give up control of roads and bridges and ports to corporations that have a vested interest in maintaining and repairing those assets in a profitable manner. Note too that foreigners have a tendency to buy US assets at market peaks and thus inflated values. If that is indeed the case once again, it is a good thing we are selling off US assets to foreigners at another peak. Finally, there is every reason to assume that private interests (either foreign or domestic) will be more cost effective at maintaining those assets than various federal, local, and state governments.

When it comes to Unocal, Congress had no legitimate reason to block that sale.
Oil is fungible. It simply does not matter who controls Unocal. Neither shareholders interests, nor the United State's interests were served by that Congressional blockage.

Yet, as we sell off parts of the US piece by piece to foreign companies who will then control the amount of tolls we pay on roads and bridges, perhaps questions will be raised about our weak dollar policy that not only allows but actually encourages that to happen.

All things considered, the balance of trade deficit is not a sign of strength as some have suggested. Yet depending on one's outlook it may or may not be a "good thing" to sell off US assets to foreign corporations to finance that imbalance. Short term it helps to keep US interest rates low. It also gets the government out of building and maintaining toll roads and bridges into private hands that are likely to do the job better and cheaper. That is unarguably a good thing, especially in light of building bridges to nowhere in Alaska. Ideally maintenance of toll roads and bridges belongs in the hands of people living in the area, but debtors, especially on large maintenance contracts like roads and bridges, may not have that great a selection of bidders. Nor can debtors dictate terms to the creditors. The real crux of the problem is that longer term, you can not sell off more than you have. As long as we keep overconsuming while underproducing, that long term problem will only get worse.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Tuesday, 18 July 2006

Deflation Strawman

Once again Steve Saville is at it.

In The Main Flaw in the Deflation Case he proposes a strawman that simply does not exist. It amazes me that after everything that deflationists such as myself have written, that not a single inflationist can accurately state the deflationist point of view.

They continually build and attack deflation cases that as best as I can tell, no one has proposed. Time and time again we go through this. It is tiring. Some have proposed that Saville was referring to me in that article but rest assured I have not been talking about deflation for more than two years. Regardless, here is the latest strawman:
A theme that appears to be common to the most eloquent arguments in favour of a deflationary outcome is that consumers, at some point, will have to start reducing their collective indebtedness, and when this happens the total supply of money and credit will begin to contract (deflation will occur). Given the current enormous height of the collective debt burden it seems likely that the point at which the debt accumulation of consumers tops out cannot be far off, which is, we think, why the idea that the world is about to plunge into a deflationary quagmire has proved to be so seductive. After all, there must be some limit to how much debt people will be able or willing to take-on and, with the savings rate in negative territory and debt repayments constituting an uncommonly-high proportion of disposable income, we simply MUST be close to that limit.

The problem is, the argument for deflation outlined in the above paragraph is based on the incorrect premise that the consumer is the engine of inflation. And when you start with an incorrect premise and then apply perfect logic you are GUARANTEED to come to the wrong conclusion.

The central bank, not the consumer, has always been and always will be the engine of inflation.
Let's stop right there.

In In Praise of Saville I said:
It sure is nice to see someone properly explain what inflation is, what it is not, and why measuring the CPI is fraught with so many problems as to make it useless. Steve [Saville] wrote:

The correct definition of inflation is an increase in the supply of money that CAUSES a decrease in the purchasing power of money, but we usually define it as simply an increase in the supply of money. This is done, in part, for the practical reason that it's impossible to measure changes in the purchasing power of money on an economy-wide basis.

It is not possible to measure changes in the overall purchasing power of money because it is not possible to come up with a meaningful number that represents the average price level within an economy. There are, of course, price indices such as the CPI that purportedly represent the average price level, but these indices are generally worse than useless because they are calculated in such a way that they are guaranteed to paint a misleading picture.
I have on numerous occasions said that inflation was an increase in money supply and credit. How many times do we have to say it? It really gets tiring. I am glad that Saville agrees because unless one can agree on a definition, then there can be no meaningful debate.

I agree with Saville that the consumer is not the source of inflation.
So why does Saville post the strawman that he did?
Perhaps he was responding to someone else. If so who?
That is another problem with many inflationists. They attack ideas that as best as I can tell no one said. If someone said the consumer is the source of inflation then who was it? I will agree with Saville that idea is absurd. I will also tell Saville that is not the basis for most deflationist beliefs. It's easy to attack a strawman that does not exist.

Does that mean the consumer is out of the picture?
No, of course not. That is what Saville does not seem to understand.
Banks can print but they can not force consumers to either borrow or spend. If bankruptcies expand faster than borrowing, the net of money supply and credit will contract. That is deflation.

There is one other twist that I have talked about and that is the velocity of money.

In Inflation: What the heck is it? I wrote:
Some argue that Japan never went through deflation. One basis for that argument is that "money supply" as measured by M1 never contracted over a sustained period. The other argument is that prices as measured by the CPI never fell much. Once again we have a flawed argument about consumer prices and a flawed argument that only looks at money and not credit.

Although Japan was rapidly printing money, a destruction of credit was happening at a far greater pace. There was an overall contraction of credit in Japan for close to 5 consecutive years. Property values plunged for 18 consecutive years. The stock market plunged from 40,000 to 7,000. Cash was hoarded and the velocity of money collapsed. Those are classic symptoms of deflation that a proper definition incorporating both money supply and credit would readily catch. Those looking at consumer prices or monetary injections by the bank of Japan were far off the mark.
Now given that we hopefully agree on what inflation and deflation are, we can discard the strawman that Saville proposed.

The question then is to what extent the Fed can prolong that monetary expansion if consumers refuse to borrow or banks refuse to lend.

In that respect the consumer IS the key.
It is a key the Fed can not control.

Japan printed money for years and no one wanted it.
Yes, the US is different than Japan. We are far worse off and much deeper in debt. That adds to the deflationist case.
Wage fundamentals are much worse now especially with outsourcing and the internet. That adds to the deflationist case.
Ultimately it comes down to the question of "will the banks destroy themselves and their wealth" to bail out consumers deep in debt.

The answer to that question is "Of course not. Why would they?"
I have heard time and time again that banks can at will cause hyperinflation.
I have admitted that yes they can in theory, time and time and time again.

The real question is then is: "Will they"?
That is what we are debating. We are not debating if they can, we are debating the likelihood of it happening.
I have heard all of the inflation answers before.

We have not had deflation since 1930 and will never see it again.
The Fed will bail out consumers.
The Fed will do this.
The Fed will do that.

It seems that everyone feels the Fed is all powerful, and that the Fed can defeat the business cycle by forever printing money.
That is the fallacy of the inflationist arguments.
It can not be done. The root cause of the great depression was an overexpansion of money and credit. "Helicopter Drop Bernanke" could no more cure that by printing more money than I could take on Michael Jordan in one on one basketball at his prime.

So why has there been persistent inflation since 1940? The answer to that is the k-cycle. Please read The Kondratieff Cycle Revisited for a more in depth look at the k-cycle.

Three fourths of the cycle there is inflation. Each season is long (18-24 years). By the time we get to deflationary winter, many (most) people that have only known inflation all their lives dismiss the idea. No one believes that deflation can happen. They have seen nothing but inflation all their lives. Prechter's huge mistakes were not allowing sufficient time for each season, and for thinking that gold will fall in deflation.

Yes I agree that the Fed could eventually induce hyperinflation by dropping money out of helicopters. OK, so would they? The reason they would not do so is because it would bail out consumers at the expense of banks. Does anyone really believe the Fed would bail out consumers at their own expense? I don’t.

Yes, I believe they will try to help consumers, not by dropping money out of helicopters but by lowering interest rates. However unless jobs are created, with salaries that will allow consumer debts to be paid off, the Fed loses. Asset bubbles in the stock market and then in housing kept the consumer ready and willing to spend. What's next?

If housing is the bubble of last resort, what would happen if the Fed turned on the pumps? I suspect money would go into gold and silver, but no jobs would be produced, certainly nothing like the housing boom produced. That last sentence should explain why many deflationists like gold. That answer is also why it would be game set and match for the Fed. Yes the Fed could in theory drop money out of helicopters, but only if they wanted to destroy themselves. There is theory and there is practice. If consumers are finally at the end of their ropes as I suspect, inflationists are in for one rude shock.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

State Farm seeks 78% increase

Florida Today is reporting Potential loss drives rate hike
Meteorology, computer models and targeted policy cancellations don't offer enough financial comfort for State Farm Florida.

State Farm seeks a record 78 percent average rate hike -- more than doubling what it charges policyholders in Brevard -- to cover a guess as to the worst potential luck it might suffer in a hurricane season many times worse than any the Southeast has seen.
  • In two years, rates for much of coastal Florida will have more than doubled, including almost 20,000 State Farm customers who face 125 percent increases in this filing.
  • It will force similar hikes for the nearly 1 million Floridians covered by Citizens Property Insurance, the state-run insurer of last resort, because Citizens is required by law to charge more than the private market. Together, State Farm and Citizens insure about 30 percent of Florida homes.
  • And it sets a precedent for nearly 200 other property insurers doing business in the storm-struck state, allowing them to look beyond predicted losses and bolster rates to soothe investors.
Rate shock

State Farm's math confounds consumers like Eddie Moran, who moved his family here from California five years ago. Now the commercial airline pilot is ready to bail from Florida.

"If I move out, which I'm seriously considering, who's going to move into my house?" he asked. "Can they afford the property taxes, have kids who go to public schools, be two people who work? Or is it going to be New Jersey or New York retirees who spend six months a year living elsewhere?"

In 2001, State Farm charged $1,800 to insure Moran's dockside home on Merritt Island. The premium now is $5,361 and, if the state approves the company's rate hike, Moran's bill will top $12,000. Even his agent finds the premium hard to digest, Moran said.
Let's see...... $1,800 in insurance cost soars to a proposed $12,000 annual insurance cost.
What about property taxes? What did those do? Hmmm. In Florida the bulk of those do not kick in until he sells and the new buyer has to pay those property tax increases.

Moran made a serious mistake.
He should have "Gottin while the gettin was good".

I fully expect people to be harping at me about how "inflationary this is". It is nothing of the kind. It will drive down asset prices in Florida while putting speculators further behind. The process is just starting. "Get before the gettin gets worse" applies to Florida perhaps more than anywhere else.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Monday, 17 July 2006

Get before the gettin gets worse

I remain in "awe" of some of the wisdom offered by those in the real estate industry.

Please consider This could be the right moment to sell.
"Buyers today are more committed, which is good for sellers," says Susann Haskins, co-manager of the Long & Foster Real Estate Inc. Potomac/Cabin John office.

"When we had the frenzied buying of recent years, we saw people buying without giving thought to what they were doing," she says. "Sometimes, they would find ways to back out of contract. But today's buyers are more committed to the transaction because they've had time to see the house more than once. They've thought about it, and made a conscious decision rather than an impetuous one."
I am going to nominate the above for the "silliest real estate comment of the week" award.
For starters she is point blank wrong about cancellations: They are soaring right now vs. a year ago. But more to the point the best time to be a seller of anything is when there is frenzied buying. That fact should be inherently obvious to everyone.

Furthermore I suspect Haskins was harping about how great it was during that frenzy as well. Well what a great time it WAS.

But it's time to face the facts Haskins. It is a very difficult time to be a seller. Now that may not be true in every market but it is certainly true in many of them. You can play all of your phony games saying how this market is more normal and how great that is for everyone, but I am calling you on it.

You know you are speaking nonsense, I know you are speaking nonsense, and most importantly the public is finally catching on to the fact that cheerleaders like you are speaking nonsense.

But yes, in a sense it is a good time to sell. That sense is as in "get while the gettin is good". Well actually it is too late for that. The correct logic now is more like "get before the gettin gets worse".

That logic not only pertains to houses, but more obviously to the stock market, and also to real estate jobs in general.

Realtors lobby for laws

The USA Today is reporting Realtors fight for business model.
Traditional real estate brokers are fighting the Justice Department and lobbying state lawmakers to protect their business model, which generated $60 billion in commissions last year. Associations of Realtors — big political donors in many states — have pushed for state rules to bar real estate agents from providing less than the traditional full suite of services.

So far, Realtor groups in nine states have lobbied successfully for laws requiring all brokers to provide the full services. (Oklahoma Realtors succeeded in getting a law passed late last year, but the state attorney general said it couldn't be enforced against discounters.) Ten other states have passed laws that forbid agents to rebate part of their commission to buyers.

The result: Brokers who offer a la carte services at lower prices have sometimes been shut out.

This isn't the first battle between traditional real estate agents and discounters. Last year, discounters won limited access to the Realtors' Multiple Listing Service (MLS), though the Justice Department is still suing the National Association of Realtors over some of its restrictions.

This time, the full-service brokers are arguing that discounters can hurt sellers who don't fully grasp the complexities of selling a home.Some buyers'agents complain that they, too, often have to bail out sellers who were trying to fly solo and ran into problems.

"This was an effort brought forth by the Illinois Realtors that the agency thought was a good idea to help protect consumers," says Daniel Bluthardt, a top regulator in Illinois, one of the first states to pass a minimum-service law.
"Protect the Consumers"

What a bunch of nonsense.
It should not take much to figure out that this is all about protecting Real Estate Agents from competition. Such laws are in effect anti-consumer as the previous article goes on to say.
The Justice Department and the Federal Trade Commission have tried to stop states from passing such rules, with mixed success.

But they aren't giving up. On Thursday, the FTC will announce an enforcement action against a regional MLS for restricting access to discount brokers, and the agency says it expects to file more complaints.

After Illinois, Texas, Missouri and others passed their laws, discount brokers in those states either raised their prices to cover their costs for offering more services or pulled out entirely, says Tom Barnett, assistant U.S. attorney general for antitrust.

"We've not seen evidence that there was any need to adopt a measure that would impose that kind of harm on consumers," he adds.

The Justice Department also sued the Kentucky Real Estate Commission and forced it to drop its anti-rebate law. West Virginia and South Dakota then repealed theirs. But most other states have retained theirs. And companies such as ZipRealty, which gives buyers a 20% rebate on commissions, won't do business in states that bar rebates.

"There's no reason to take on the extra challenge of trying to adjust our business model," says Pat Lashinsky of ZipRealty. "It's a significant hurdle for us to overcome."

The current battleground is in Michigan, where the association of Realtors has gotten a bill through the state House and a Senate committee and is trying to convince the governor — who threatened to veto it — that the bill would "make sure everyone can compete," says Rob Campau of the Realtors association
What is interesting to me is the fact that the US Justice department is siding with the consumer against Realtors. This administration seldom sides with consumers on anything. The only possible reason that I can think of is that big banks want to get in on this lucrative business somehow and want open competition to make the job easier. Who knows?

Quadruple Whammy

What I do know is that Realtors have a quadruple whammy right now.
  1. Increased competition
  2. Falling sales
  3. Rising interest rates
  4. Federal deregulation long over due
Realtors react the way most companies do. Demand protection. No industry likes competition. Under the guise of "consumer protection" various states have enacted anti-consumer laws.

What the industry is worried about is the internet.

Changed by the Internet
The internet changed Steven Sizemore's business model. After working for a decade as a traditional full-service agent in Oklahoma, he decided to continue as an agent but to sell just three services: MLS listing, consulting/negotiating and closing — each at $499. Home sellers can choose any combination at any time in the process.

Before Sizemore started The Real Estate Place in 2000, he was a typical agent with 10 to 15 listings a month. Now, he has 50 to 75 listings a month — volume that's made up for his lower prices.

He said Oklahoma Realtors were "not trying to protect consumers," they were "trying to protect their commissions."

The trend of states clamping down on discount brokers, and the Justice Department's mixed success in fighting it, show how deeply the Internet is shaking the real estate industry, says Nicolas Retsinas of the Joint Center for Housing Studies at Harvard University.

"The technology is so pervasive and so disruptive, I think it's going to be very difficult to stick your finger in all the holes in the dike," Retsinas says.
Lower prices, fewer sales, fewer jobs, increased competition, and lower commissions lie dead ahead. This is all very deflationary of course. More amazing is the fact that hardly anyone sees it.

Whether you are a flipper trying to flip a house or a marginal real estate agent/broker struggling in this turndown, you may wish to consider to "Get before the getting gets worse". Unfortunately for the latter group, and for the economy in general, Real Estate has provided close to 50% of the jobs this recovery. Where to "get to" is likely to become a real problem.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Procrastinator's Market

The Post Gazette is reporting A different kind of fall in New England.
Kim Bronson's West Windsor, Vt., home has everything a buyer might expect in a pastoral North Country property: a five-bedroom, Federal-era main house, several fenced horse paddocks and four guest cottages. It's located just 12 miles south of Woodstock, a vacation spot known for its quaint New England charm. It even has a celebrity pedigree. Ms. Bronson shared the home with her late husband, actor Charles Bronson.

The only thing the property doesn't have is a buyer. Ms. Bronson put her home on the market more than a year ago at $4.9 million, then shaved the price by $1 million in April. "I'm really surprised it hasn't sold," she says. "I don't think Vermont and New England is going with the same real-estate flow as the rest of the universe."

Melanie Eleftherio's renovated five-bedroom home in Newport, R.I., has been on the market for almost a year at $1.3 million. Though the 1860s Victorian includes new bathrooms and a renovated kitchen, the property -- sandwiched between the ocean and the Bellevue Avenue mansions -- has failed to fetch a single serious offer. But the 46-year-old former advertising executive isn't ready to cut the asking price. "The home is priced right for the market," Ms. Eleftherio says. "Serious buyers will recognize that."

Andrew Heiblien has been trying to sell his four-bedroom home in Mystic, Conn., since January. As in many of the small towns that dot the Connecticut shore, the number of for-sale signs in tiny Mystic (pop. 4,001) has doubled since then, area brokers say. Mr. Heiblien, a 46-year-old private ferry operator, says he anticipated a slowing market when he listed the property for $515,000. But, he says, he "never dreamed" he'd need to cut the home's asking price four times before finding a buyer. The property went under contract last week for $405,000. "I really thought the market was stronger when I put the home up for sale," says Mr. Heiblien. "I had to adjust."
I don't think Ms. Bronson has any idea of what is really happening in "the rest of the universe". Obviously Bronson was asking at least $1 million too much for her property. Who knows? She might still be asking $1 million too much for her property.

Andrew Heiblien walked the market down 5 times before getting a sale. But at least he finally got out. It seems Melanie Eleftherio still believes in the "different universe theory" when she made this statement: "The home is priced right for the market. Serious buyers will recognize that."

Tough All Over


LOCATION: Las Vegas
MAY 2006: Condominium and town-house sales volume fell 19 percent compared with the same 2005 period. Single-family home sales declined 17 percent.
COMMENTS: The number of overall home listings reached 20,000 in June, an all-time high, up 32 percent from the same month a year ago.

LOCATION: Los Angeles County
MAY 2006: Home-sales volume down 11.6 percent compared with the 2005 period.
COMMENTS: Though sales volume is slipping, the median price of a home in the county rose 13.5 percent from the previous month to $568,550, second-biggest gain in state.

LOCATION: Miami
MAY 2006: Home sales down 26 percent compared with the 2005 period.
COMMENTS: Median prices for single-family homes were up 1 percent from both the previous month and the year before, to $379,700.

LOCATION: New York
MAY 2006: Condominiums and co-operative apartment sales rose 35 percent compared with the same 2005 period.
COMMENTS: Virtually all of the increase was attributed to closings at recently completed condominiums.

LOCATION: San Francisco
MAY 2006: Home sales down 18 percent compared with the same period a year earlier.
COMMENTS: May marked the third consecutive month that the year-over-year price increases were in the single-digit range.

It seems we have proof that New England is not in a different universe.

Buyer's Market

I have been thinking about the terms "buyer's market" and "seller's market".
What exactly do they mean anyway?

I found the following definitions of "Buyer's Market" on Answers.Com
  1. A market condition characterized by low prices and a supply of commodities exceeding demand.
  2. A market condition characterized by an abundance of goods available for sale.
  3. A market in which supply exceeds demand. As a result, suppliers usually have to lower their prices, thus favoring the buyer.
  4. a market in which more people want to sell than want to buy
What is interesting is that real estate cheerleaders are suggesting that now is a great time to buy because "It's a buyer's market". Of course when it was a seller's market the mantra was "better get in now before prices rise further". Thus we have the situation where "It's always a good time to buy".

Just because "It's a buyers market" does not mean "It's smart to buy". To suggest that "now is a good time to buy" because prices are 4-10% lower after a maniac period where prices doubled in five years is disingenuous at best. Now is not a good time to buy and the smartest Realtors know it. Some will do what they have to do to stay in business, lie.

Drama Pricing

Boston.Com is reporting To fight the glut, home sellers push their prices down.
Today, what's important is what is not selling. Drama pricing focuses on what buyers see on the market, forcing sellers to look at the prices of active listings.

Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage, Massachusetts' largest real estate firm with more than 3,500 agents, is coaching agents on how to persuade clients to list their homes at an asking price that undercuts those of comparable ones on the market.

The hope is low prices will attract more prospective buyers, leading to faster sales. Other real estate agents in the Boston area report success with similar strategies in a housing market with an unprecedented glut of properties for sale.

Called "drama pricing" or "energy pricing," it is a drastic measure for difficult times. And it seems to run counter to the conventional strategy of selling your home for the highest price possible.

"It's another indication that it's clearly a buyers' market," said Timothy Warren Jr., chief executive of The Warren Group, a Boston real estate research and publishing firm that tracks the market. "There's a lot of stuff on the market, and it's going to have downward pressure on prices."

The median price of a single-family house in Massachusetts has declined 4 percent over the past year, to $331,000 in May, and sales volume has fallen five consecutive months.

The traditional strategy of incremental reductions in asking prices can frustrate sellers because properties grow stale and buyers lose interest.

Prudential Maxfield & Co. in Boston also is tinkering with asking prices with the same goal to attract more bidders. Instead of a single asking price, owner John Maxfield places a range on a listing, say, $469,000 to $529,000. Sellers were hesitant to try this when the firm introduced the idea in 1999, but the slowdown has made them more open to the tactic.

Kathleen Horigan is selling a tidy four-bedroom house in North Attleborough she purchased eight years ago for her sister and family. A few weeks after they moved out in February, Horigan listed the house for $319,900. There were no offers.

Her agent suggested drama pricing, and Horigan dropped the price to $279,900.

Nine more people have looked at the house -- ``unheard of in this market," she said. While she was optimistic last week she'd receive an offer over the weekend, none came. During the selling process, she has gained new insight into Massachusetts' housing market.

"It's not a buyer's market," she said. "It's a procrastinator's market."
Drama pricing [is] forcing sellers to look at the prices of active listings.
Yeah right. No one can force people who do not need a house into looking at listings. There are so many houses on the market because investors bought two and three houses and now do not know what to do with them. 40% of the houses sold in 2004 and 2005 were as second homes or investments. The market is now flooded with inventory from those who now want to cash out.

Prices have only one way to go and that is down. Why buy today when home prices will be cheaper tomorrow? He who procrastinates, wins. That's what makes it "A Procrastinator's Market".

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/