Tuesday, 24 July 2007

Is $100 Oil Coming? $200 Anyone?

Analysts at Goldman and CIBC say $100 oil may be just months away.
The $100-a-barrel oil that Goldman Sachs Group Inc. said would prevail by 2009 may be only a few months away.

Jeffrey Currie, a London-based commodity analyst at the world's biggest securities firm, says $95 crude is likely this year unless OPEC unexpectedly increases production, and declining inventories are raising the chances for $100 oil. Jeff Rubin at CIBC World Markets predicts $100 a barrel as soon as next year.

Higher prices will increase revenue for energy producers from Exxon Mobil Corp. to PetroChina Co., while eroding profit at airlines including EasyJet Plc and railroads such as Union Pacific Corp. The U.S. and other oil-importing nations risk accelerating inflation, while higher energy costs threaten to restrain growth.

Benchmark crude oil futures ended last week at $75.57 a barrel on the New York Mercantile Exchange, up 51 percent since mid- January and twice the level of early 2003. A record number of options have been sold that give the buyer the right to buy crude oil at $100. The contracts, covering 50 million barrels, only pay off should oil go above the target price.

A National Petroleum Council study led by former Exxon Mobil chairman Lee Raymond, released last week, predicted a growing gap between production and demand for oil and gas during the next two decades. As recently as 2005, Raymond said oil prices had probably peaked and dismissed the possibility that supply and demand could not be brought back into balance.

"There are questions about whether the oil industry can keep up with demand," U.S. Energy Secretary Samuel Bodman said last week, commenting on the Petroleum Council report.

Oil prices could triple in three months to more than $200 a barrel, given the right circumstances, according to Matthew Simmons, chairman of Simmons & Co., a Houston investment bank.

Gasoline pump prices averaging more than $3 a gallon across the U.S., the consumer of 25 percent of the world's oil, haven't dented sales. Deliveries of gasoline were a record 9.23 million barrels a day in the first half of this year, according to a July 18 report from the American Petroleum Institute in Washington.

"It appears that high prices are acceptable to the American consumer," said Robert Ebel, chairman of the energy program at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Washington. "People want the house with a yard and white-picket fence so they are moving further and further out of the cities. They have to just get up earlier and drive further."

A pullout from Iraq may be the event that pushes oil to $100 a barrel, according to Boone Pickens, the Dallas hedge fund manager who has joined Forbes Magazine's list of billionaires because of his bullish bets on energy prices. Pickens predicted a year ago that $100 oil would probably occur by now. Today he is looking for $80 within six months, and he says growing chaos in Iraq would be a bad sign. "That could run prices pretty high," he said.

Goldman Sachs's Currie also notes similarities to a year ago, with global inventories at about the same level and U.S. government data showing an increasing bet on higher prices.

"At face value this market is strikingly similar to a year ago," Currie said. "What is different? Supply is down a million barrels a day, demand is up a million barrels a day. The market is in a deficit."
If Bush is dumb enough to invade Iran, $200 could come in a hurry. But the idea that oil surges on a U.S. pullback from Iraq is debatable. The sooner we leave Iraq, the sooner Iraq will recover (I might add just as Vietnam did), and the less jet fuel we will be wasting on needless missions.

Could there be a short term spike when we leave Iraq? Perhaps, but the long term benefits of us getting the hell out will be enormous.

Gasoline Demand Is Inelastic

It's not so much that "high prices are acceptable to the American consumer" as opposed to the fact that the demand for gasoline is relatively inelastic. Consider the plight of taxi drivers and the Chicago Tribune article Pinched taxi drivers hope to fare better by organizing.
His fares for the last two days were dismal and now halfway through the day, Khalid al Hag had only $20 in his pocket.

At this rate, he figured he would have to dip into savings to make his $520 weekly payment to the cab company for use of the car.

"I'm going to have to work at least 12 or 14 hours today and still I won't get by," he said, gulping down a meal so he could get back into his cab, which lately he has been driving seven days a week.

Other cabbies -- independents who have to pay out of their pockets for gasoline and other expenses and benefits -- flitted through the restaurant with the same laments. At $3.46 for a gallon of regular gas, high fuel prices are swallowing their thin profit margins.

The drivers' distress is why Sampat thinks an effort to organize many of Chicago's nearly 11,000 cab drivers, including 2,500 who own their own cabs, will succeed. Similar efforts are ongoing across the country.

The organizing efforts are more of a cry for rights and recognition waged largely on behalf of thousands of immigrants who have quietly slipped behind the steering wheels of most the nation's cabs.

Why are cabbies the focus of organizing efforts? Taxis are today's Ellis Island for many immigrants, statistics show. And cab driver is the first line of work in the U.S. for many without good language skills and without credentials to land easier, safer and better-paying jobs.

The last fare hike in Chicago was in 2005. Soon after that, Chicago ranked 18th out of 23 cities in the U.S. for the price of an average cab ride, according to an industry study that city officials said still is relevant.

The organizers presented figures compiled from a handful of drivers, showing that the drivers were spending an average $44 a day on gas last month and were earning $6 an hour when all of their expenses were deducted.

But Ald. Thomas Allen (38th), chairman of the Committee on Transportation and Public Way, said he doesn't sense any support within the City Council or from city officials for a surcharge. "Gas prices have kind of settled," he added.

"Every day when I go home, I ask myself the same question, 'When am I going to stop being a cab driver?' And every day I say I'm going find something better, but I can't," grumbled Omar Shire, 29, a Somali refugee, who has been driving for the last three years in Chicago.

"I work 14 hours a day, seven days a week. That's all I do," he said, his voice rising in anger, his eyes wide. The city does not limit how many hours cabbies can drive.
Is there a real choice here? The bottom line is you have to drive and you have to eat. While one can cut back eating expenses by switching from steak to hot dogs, there is no cheaper substitute for gasoline.

Monthly Crude Trendline Still Intact

The weekly chart has had a few busted trendlines but the monthly still looks great. But there is a looming US recession and liquidity crunch that is likely to bust an enormous number of trendlines and test the resolve of more than a few energy bulls.

Click on any chart for a better view.



Those watching crude may also we watching the US$ index and the Yen vs. the Dollar.
Let's take a look.

US$ Index



Yen / US Dollar



Forex traders will note that the chart of the Yen vs. the dollar is inverse of normal trading pairs.

It's now do or die for both the US$ index and the Yen vs. the US dollar. Both currencies
have been anemic lately compared to anything else. The US$ is on the verge of collapse, and the Yen is at lows compared to the British Pound and the Euro.

With trillions in carry trade bets riding on the outcome, the impact of a major breakdown in either currency could be very significant. Out and out disasters are most often in the direction of the prevailing trend. Here, two competing losers also are going head to head. Resolution should come soon. The US dollar is going to eventually break hard but one must be on the lookout for a major headfake with all the stops in too obvious places.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Monday, 23 July 2007

Class Warfare

Bernanke was grilled by Congressmen Ron Paul, Luiz Gutierrez, and Barney Frank at the Fed's semi-annual report to Congress. Caroline Baum was discussing this in Congress Draws Bernanke Out on Class Struggle.
Just when you thought increased transparency on the part of the Federal Reserve was contributing to enhanced sophistication on the part of the public, along comes evidence to the contrary.

"I believe economic inequality is a product of monetary policy choices on the part of the Fed," said Congressman Luiz Gutierrez, Democrat of Illinois, at yesterday's monetary policy hearing before the House Financial Services Committee.

Redistributing income has never been part of the Fed's mandate. Nor was it considered the province of monetary policy makers to orchestrate a better balance between society's haves and have-nots.

When it was Gutierrez's turn to question Bernanke -- he had shared his views with the chairman earlier -- he focused on immigration and China, not income inequality. Had the congressman asked, here's what Bernanke could have said:

Through its ability to create reserves out of nowhere, the Fed affects the rate of inflation. Inflation, or a rise in the price level (to Austrian economists it's an increase in the money supply), harms savers more than borrowers because borrowers get to pay back their loans in depreciated dollars.

Even so, inflation ends up hurting the poor more than the rich because it reduces the purchasing power of their modest wages.

So, yes, Congressmen Gutierrez and Frank, the Fed indirectly contributes to income inequality when it allows inflation to increase. It makes everyone poorer absolutely and the poor relatively more so.

Maximum sustainable employment is one of the Fed's dual mandates, but it can't be achieved with more inflation. Artificially manufactured employment is unsustainable and therefore violates the Fed's mandate.
"Maximum sustainable employment is one of the Fed's dual mandates, but it can't be achieved with more inflation. Artificially manufactured employment is unsustainable and therefore violates the Fed's mandate."

Bingo!

On that note, the Mish telepathic question lines are open once again.
The questions are pouring in.

It's time for some Q&A

Q: If artificially manufactured employment violates the Fed's mandate why do they do it?
A: There are lots of reasons and hubris is arguably at the top of the list. The more cynical will suggest that it is all part of a grand scheme to transfer wealth from the poor to the rich. That is in a nutshell what inflation does and Bernanke favors a positive inflation rate at 2%. If it's held low enough the poor and increasingly the middle class don't notice until it's too late. In the meantime, the power of the state grows and grows and grows.

Q: Was not the housing bubble an artificially manufactured employment scheme?
A: Absolutely. To top it off, Greenspan recommenced adjustable rate mortgages right at the bottom in yield.

Q: Why did Greenspan do that?
A: Greenspan slashed rates to 1% and made that recommendation to bail out his banking buddies that were in deep cereal trouble over bad loans to emerging markets, dotcom bubble blowups, and other such nonsense. The effect was that banks were once again bailed out of stupid lending decisions. But Greenspan had to know full well what this would eventually do to consumers or he was a senile idiot. Take your pick. Either way history will not be kind to Greenspan.

Q: Can "Maximum sustainable employment" be engineered by a bunch wizards sitting behind a curtain in OZ?
A: Obviously that is a rhetorical question.

Q: What about Ron Paul questioning Bernanke?
A: Good question. I will address that next. With that reply the telepathic question lines are now closed.

Ron Paul vs. Bernanke



Click here to play Ron Paul vs. Bernanke.

Who Benefits By Inflation?

That was a good exchange but unfortunately it did not address the issue as to why inflation is a tax on the poor. The long answer can be found in Ron Paul's message about Paper Money and Tyranny.

The short answer is that inflation benefits those with first access to money. If ever there was any doubt to that statement, those doubts should now be erased. Take one good look at the housing bubble. Banks and lending institutions benefited by pushing junk upon junk to consumers, to pension funds, to insurance companies and to foreign investors. The fees collected were enormous. Last in line were the suckers buying Florida condos at absurd prices, homes in California, Boston, Las Vegas, Phoenix, etc, etc, at absurd prices as lending standards fell through the floor. The bottom line is that the bottom end of the recipients of the boom made a horrid mistake by participating.

One can debate Ad nauseam whether this was intended or not, but does it matter to the lower (and now middle classes) that are affected by the blatant policy of theft by inflation by the Fed?

Bernanke wants to have a goal of positive 2% inflation. In other words he wants to initiate robbery at the expense of the lower and middle classes by this amount (compounded annually). Given that Bernanke (like Greenspan) ignore asset bubbles in their pricing methodology, the effect is far worse than 2%. Furthermore when things blow up, the Fed is willing to bailout banks but unfortunately consumers late to the party are stuck. This process makes debt slaves out of ever increasing percentages of the population.

The moral implications are obvious. It's time to abolish the Fed and it's time to return to sound money backed by gold and/or silver. Only one candidate stands for that idea. Vote for Ron Paul.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Sunday, 22 July 2007

All Recessions Are Local

Anyone remember the mantra "All Real Estate is Local"? How long did we hear that as contagion spread from Florida, to Las Vegas, to Boston, to Phoenix, to San Diego, to Minneapolis, to Atlanta, to practically everywhere. Now that real estate generally sucks no matter where you go, we no longer hear that mantra.

It's time for a new mantra. How about "All Recessions are Local"? I talked about that in American Dream: Overbought & Overbuilt.
Florida's robust economy of 2001 to 2005 was driven by the thousands of well-paying jobs related to the real estate market and homeowners who used home-equity loans to pay for items such as boats and big-screen TVs, McCabe said.

"All those jobs are going away now, and we're seeing the trickle-down effect in declining sales in big-box retailers and home-furnishing manufacturers," McCabe said. "Florida is headed to a recession."

[Florida is headed for a recession or the US is? Perhaps some real estate agents want to tell us that recessions are local. Perhaps they are, except when they are national.]
Shortly after posting the above I see Job growth stalls in San Diego County.
Job growth has nearly ground to a halt in San Diego County, raising the risk of a recession later this year, two economists who track the local business climate said Friday.

The latest monthly employment report shows that woes in real estate and construction have spilled over into the local economy, said the economists, Kelly Cunningham of the San Diego Institute for Policy Research and Alan Gin of the University of San Diego.

The county's unemployment rose to an estimated 4.6 percent in June, from 4.2 percent in May, the California Employment Development Department reported Friday. The unadjusted rate was also 4.2 percent in June 2006. California's unemployment rate for June was 5.2 percent, the same as in May and up from last June's rate of 4.9 percent.

Unemployment normally rises during summer, as schools go out of session and students look for work, Gin and Cunningham said. But much more worrisome, they said, is that overall job growth has slowed down over the last three years. The number of jobs added for the year June 2006 to June 2007 increased by just 1,600, or 0.1 percent.

"This to me is a pretty bad report," Gin said. "Last year, we added 18,000 jobs. And the year before that, we added 20,000 jobs."

Cunningham said, "That's the worst job growth we've had since '93." That year was when San Diego was just beginning to emerge from recession.

Gin, who compiles a monthly index of leading economic indicators, said last month that his numbers indicated a recession was possible. His index has been fallen in 13 of the last 14 months, signaling a steady deterioration in San Diego's economy.

The chance of a recession is "getting higher," Gin said. "I wouldn't say over 50 percent, but it's not infinitesimal.

"The culprit is real estate," Gin said. "You've lost 7,400 jobs year over year in construction. And in the real estate side, you've lost 3,300 jobs there. The rest of the economy is OK fundamentally, but the problem is now this real estate fallout is spreading into other sectors."

Cunningham said that nonresidential real estate construction has also begun to slacken.

"The commercial side of it is starting to see slowing down," Cunningham said. "So both of those things together seem to reflect a slowing economy and perhaps pulling us into recession."
Obviously Gin is an optimist. Anyone who think the odds of recession are less than 50% is an optimist. The telling factoid is jobs creation dropped from 20,000 to 1,000 in the bat of an eye. Gin blames real estate. But it is going to spread far beyond real estate. Anyone who still has a job and also has no concerns better get religion. No job is really safe here.

One State Recession?

Back in April Stateline.Org wrote ‘One-state recession’ hampers Michigan.
The Great Lakes State has lost jobs for six consecutive years, Michigan’s longest run of workplace shrinkages since the Great Depression. Automakers are laying off tens of thousands. Pharmaceutical giant Pfizer is closing up shop in Ann Arbor and Kalamazoo. The state ranks among the top three in the country for home foreclosures and mortgage delinquencies.


Analysts at Comerica Bank, which is moving its headquarters from Detroit to Dallas, say Michigan is stuck in a “one-state recession.”
What About Colorado?

US Bancorp was writing about Colorado as well as the US in general way back on Sept 12, 2006 in their 2007 economic forecast.
Colorado's economic growth will slow in 2007, as a late-year recession interrupts a five-year period of national economic expansion, according to the "U.S. Bank 2007 Economic Forecast," prepared by Tucker Hart Adams, Ph.D., U.S. Bank's Rocky Mountain Region chief economist.

"Consumer financial stress in the face of rising interest rates, along with the potential for housing prices to flatten or fall are the big threats to the Colorado economy in 2007," Adams writes in the annual forecast. "There is a 75 percent probability that a national recession will be underway before the end of 2007 - driven by falling consumer spending.

Nationally, the U.S. economy can expect a recession to occur in the second half of the year, with annual output growth slowing to 2.1 percent, according to Adams' forecast. A 12.3 percent decline in U.S. housing starts and a 2.4 percent drop in automobile and truck sales are projected for 2007.
Looking back it was an interesting forecast. Certainly a 12.3 percent drop in starts was overly optimistic. Also there was no recession yet (except locally of course) if you believe official government numbers about the GDP.

What about Ohio?

In Ohio Jobs vanish and incomes plunge. Interestingly enough the article talkes about the Ohio recession of 2000-2004. That's a lot longer than the rest of the country. Did Ohio, like Michigan ever really recover?

The Economic Policy Institute on July 11, 2007 reports Michigan and Ohio labor markets still struggling to recover.
Since November 2001, the end of the most recent recession, the economy has created more than 7 million new jobs—increasing employment by over 5%. Although this growth is not especially strong relative to past recoveries, and weak wage growth shows that the labor market is far from strong, it is growth.

However, the growth has not been evenly distributed throughout the country. Three states, in fact, have lost jobs since the recession ended: Massachusetts, Michigan, and Ohio. Massachusetts, though it has not yet broken even with November 2001 jobs levels, has seen consistent job growth since January of 2004.

But Michigan and Ohio have continued to lose jobs. The problem, not surprisingly, is in manufacturing. Michigan and Ohio have lost 159,000 and 136,000 manufacturing jobs, respectively, since November 2001. Ohio's losses add up to just under 15% of the state's manufacturing jobs, while Michigan has lost about 20%—or one in five—of such jobs.
What about Indiana?

I was inclined to put Indiana in the list of states already in recession based on manufacturing but there is little discussion on that point so far. I am however quite sure that Indiana localities dependent on auto parts manufacturing are indeed in recession.

However, I did come across this interesting article asking Is Indiana is prepared for a recession?
Should a recession occur before 2010, Indiana will not be ready. At the start of the last recession the state had balances of almost two billion dollars. This reduced the need for tax hikes and budget cuts. If a recession occurs before 2010, tax hikes and budget cuts will have to be considered right away.

The small balances mean that achieving fiscal health will still be a task in the next long session of the legislature, in 2009. In the 2010-2011 budget, revenues will have to exceed appropriations by $450 million to get there.

In a sense, the General Assembly has made a gamble. The risk is being unprepared for the next recession. The payoff is higher education spending. For the sake of education, we’re gambling that our current expansion will last at least nine years, through 2010. That would make it the second longest expansion in U.S. history, after the expansion of the 1990’s.
States in Recession
  • Florida
  • Michigan
  • Ohio
States Possibly in or Quickly Headed to Recession
  • California
  • Indiana
  • Arizona
  • Nevada
  • Colorado
States Eventually Headed to Recession

All 50

States Prepared for a Consumer Led Recession

Zero

The stunning fact that nearly everyone is missing is that we are clearly headed into a recession with unemployment (if you believe the official rates) near all time lows. What's will happen if the official unemployment rate rises to a mere 6%? By the way, 6% was a number not too long ago thought to be the very bottom achievable before inflation would massively kick in.

The Fed will try and fight this upcoming recession tooth and nail. On that I have two predictions:

1) It won't work.
2) It will be good for gold.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Saturday, 21 July 2007

American Dream: Overbought & Overbuilt

They say that owning your own home is the American dream. That dream was overbought, overbuilt (continues to be overbuilt), and is increasingly being foreclosed upon.
There were 926,000 first half foreclosures and the carnage is just starting. Amazingly enough an insane level of building still continues, the reasons will be explained below.

Whooping Cranes

The Whooping Crane was just declared to be the state bird of Florida. Did I say whooping crane? Excuse me, I meant building crane. Please consider Miami Condo Glut Pushes Florida's Economy to Brink of Recession.
In the middle of the biggest glut of condominiums in more than 30 years, Miami developers keep on building.

[Mish comment: A housing bubble in Florida proceeded the Great Depression. Is this the second coming?]

The oversupply will force prices down as much as 30 percent, the worst decline since the 1970s, and help push Florida's economy into recession as early as October, said Mark Zandi, chief economist at West Chester, Pennsylvania-based Moody's Economy.com, who owns a home in Vero Beach, Florida.

[Mish comment: 30%? Zandi is an optimist]

"Florida is the epicenter for all the problems that exist in the housing industry," said Lewis Goodkin, president of Goodkin Consulting Corp. and a property adviser in Miami for the past 30 years, who also foresees a recession. "The problems we have now are unprecedented and a lot of people will get burnt."

Thirty-seven new high-rise condos and 20,000 new units are being built in Miami's 1,040-acre downtown, where sales fell almost 50 percent in May, according to the Florida Association of Realtors. The new units will join the 22,924 existing condos in Miami-Dade County that were for sale in April, according to Jack McCabe, chief executive officer of McCabe Research & Consulting LLC in Deerfield Beach, Florida.

[Mish comment: 42,924 units with virtually no demand is a hell of a lot of units isn't it?]

"Have you been to Miami lately?" Florida Governor Charlie Crist said at a homebuilders' conference last week in Orlando. "It's like we have a new state bird: the building crane."

[Mish comment: Wasn't Florida bragging about all of those birds a few years back as a sign of a robust economy?]

Florida's robust economy of 2001 to 2005 was driven by the thousands of well-paying jobs related to the real estate market and homeowners who used home-equity loans to pay for items such as boats and big-screen TVs, McCabe said.

"All those jobs are going away now, and we're seeing the trickle-down effect in declining sales in big-box retailers and home-furnishing manufacturers," McCabe said. "Florida is headed to a recession."

[Florida is headed for a recession or the US is? Perhaps some real estate agents want to tell us that recessions are local. Perhaps they are, except when they are national.]

A Florida recession could be averted and the state housing industry's "serious problems'' solved by an influx of American retirees and foreign buyers, said David Denslow, a University of Florida economist in Gainesville.

"The wave of baby boomer retirees is gathering momentum, and the weaker dollar makes Florida seem like a bargain to Europeans," Denslow said. "With any luck at all that will sustain us."

[Mish comment: Denslow is delusional. He's not asking for luck, he asking for something akin to winning Powerball twice in a row. Besides, Denslow should check his facts. There is a net exodus of boomer retirees from Florida now. They have had enough. Who can blame them?]

Florida banks posted a 43 percent jump in the first quarter in loans no longer paying interest compared with the last three months of 2006, while the number for banks nationwide rose 13 percent, according to the FDIC.

[Mish comment: This is going to get worse, much worse. A look at all those cranes with no buyers for what is being constructed tells the story.]

Loan payments that were one to three months overdue to Florida banks increased 30 percent in the first three months of 2007 from the fourth quarter of last year. The same number for banks nationwide fell 1.8 percent, the FDIC said.

Chicago-based Corus Bankshares Inc. Corus has lent a total of $1.07 billion to eight condo developments in downtown Miami, according to the company's Web site. Corus's net income in the first three months of 2007 was $26.4 million, a 39 percent drop from a year earlier, according to a company regulatory filing.

[Mish comment: Hey. Look at the bright side of things like I always do. Corus Bank is frequently near the top of the list in CD rates guaranteed by the US government. Corus bank is willing to roll the dice on insane condo action in Florida and the average Joe can participate basically risk free up to the FDIC limit at the expense of everyone else if and when a government bailout occurs. Seriously, short term CDs are a very decent play right here right now. But if you'd rather bet on equities after this runup with subprime contagion spreading to Alt-A, be my guest. If you buy CDs make sure you do not go over the FDIC limits]

Miami condo sales fell to 599 in May, a drop of 46 percent from a year earlier, according to the state realtors association. Condo sales in Orlando, home of Walt Disney World, have plummeted 80 percent, said Zandi of Moody's Economy.com.

"The statistics are scary," said Michael Wohl, a partner in the Pinnacle Housing Group, a Miami developer that has stayed out of the condo market. "There's going to be a lot of blood in the water in the next 18 months."

Lenders typically require enough advance sales to cover the cost of a construction loan. Customers' deposits, however, don't always mean the sales will close, said Ian Bruce Eichner, a developer whose latest Miami Beach condo tower is scheduled to open in November.

"The market is as close to a depression as Miami has seen in 30 years," Eichner said. "There's a gargantuan supply of homes and the overwhelming preponderance were built for speculators, not for people who are living there."With sale prices falling, McCabe said he expects up to 50 percent of them to walk away from their deposits in the next 18 months rather than complete the sales.

"What's going to happen to all those units?" Eichner asked. "God only knows. You couldn't give me a piece of property in Miami for nothing. I like sleeping at night."

[Mish comment: This is quite interesting. Ian Bruce Eichner, developer of Miami Beach condos is saying "You couldn't give me a piece of property in Miami for nothing. I like sleeping at night." Isn't this like an enormous warning to potential customers to not buy his properties?]

In the 1970s, when condos were a new product, Florida developers built 500,000 units and prices fell 50 percent, said Brad Hunter of MetroStudy, a research firm in West Palm Beach.

"The difference is, back then they were two-story condo buildings that had $50,000 units," Hunter said. "Nowadays they are $700,000 units in 20-story buildings. Instead of building too much stuff that people could afford like we did then, this time we built too much stuff that people can't afford."

The skyline of Miami is visible from Key Biscayne, the barrier island where John Rosser lives. Some nights the real estate broker scans the new buildings and sees more dark windows than lighted.

"This is dumbfounding to me," Rosser said. "It's a building boom in the middle of a housing bust."

[Mish comment: Correction - It's a building boom at the beginning of a housing bust. The sheer amount of oversupply relative to demand insures that.]
Telepathic Question Line

The inquiring mind no doubt has questions. The Mish telepathic question line is once again open for questions . I am being flooded with telepathic questions. Fortunately most are similar.

Q: Why do builders keep building smack in the face of a bust?
A: Builders build because that's what they do. They build until they go bust or as long as they can get funding (which is typically the same thing). Insiders profit as long as they can keep building.

Q: Didn't the homebuilders see this coming?
A: Judging from public comments at the peak of the boom with Robert Toll declaring he would crush the shorts, the answer would appear to be no. Judging from insider sales with literally all of the homebuilder insiders cashing out as fast as they could, the answer would appear to be yes. That said, the depth of this slowdown probably has astounded them. It shouldn't have and it isn't over either. Still, they all keep building, each hoping the other builders stop. While the process continues the amount of money that will be eventually written off because of this will keep on rising.

Q: Why should anyone invest in a homebuilder?
A: Except to play the greater fool theory they shouldn't. The basic fact of the matter is that homebuilders pay no dividends and sink every penny every cycle into ever escalating land prices until they blow up. In the meantime the CEOs of the corporations and other insiders grant themselves options and cash out on those options as close to the top as they can. Investors ride the wave up and then down. From a practical standpoint it makes no sense. But lucrative fees and commissions are made all the way up and all the way down by the brokerage houses and insiders. By the way, the same theory applies to more than just homebuilders if you think about it. After the next major market blowup I fully expect to see a return to companies that return solid dividends as opposed to companies chasing growth for growth's sake.

Q: Which homebuilders are going to go bankrupt?
A: All I can say is that several likely will. Probably some major ones. It happens every cycle. Those with the lowest stock prices are the likely candidates. Unfortunately I can't address the critical question as to when.

Q: Aren't some of the homebuilders trading close to book value? Does that make them a possible buy?
A: Book value is a mirage. For some, book value can (and will) go to zero.

Q: Why do banks keep funding all of those towers?
A: Banks financing condo towers in Florida are basically stuck. Those over leveraged to real estate are really stuck. If they write off those loans (which is what they would have to do if they stopped funding these condo towers half-way up), they might go under. At a minimum they would have to take a serious hit to earnings. Instead they hope on a wing and a prayer that these condo towers get completed, that the developers can sell the units, and that they can get their money back. It is a race against time and price and quite possibly a losing battle. But the lenders have nothing to lose by trying. As long as the lenders have a means to fund the condo developments they can continue to finance the projects (as well as pay themselves lucrative salaries). In the meantime it is highly unlikely that those loans are remotely close to being marked to market.

Q: Where are banks getting the money to finance all this construction?
A: One way of attracting money is by offering above market rates on CDs. Such rates ought not be be government guaranteed but they are. If they were not, we might see more responsible lending. Perhaps not. But at least there would not be a government bailout at taxpayer expense when some of the lenders go under. The moral hazard of bailouts should of course be obvious. And if the projects fail, the taxpayer is left holding the bag on the FDIC bailout of the guarantee. Does this ring a bell? It should.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Friday, 20 July 2007

Implications of Basis Capital Fund Missing Margin Calls

Australian Basis Capital Fund complains of guilt by association.
July 19 (Bloomberg) -- Basis Capital Fund Management Ltd., an Australian hedge fund caught up in the rout in U.S. subprime mortgages, suffered losses as early as February.

In a letter sent to investors July 6, Basis Capital said its investments in collateralized debt obligations, or CDOs, had been tarnished by ``guilt by association.'' Less than a week later, the Sydney-based hedge fund, which had assets of $1 billion in May, said its two funds lost 9 percent and 14 percent last month. Withdrawals from the funds have been frozen and some margin calls have been missed, research firm Zenith Investment Partners Ltd. said in an e-mailed note today.
MarketWatch has more on the Basis fund misses margin calls story.
Basis Capital, a firm with more than $2 billion in assets that was named Australian hedge fund of the year in 2006, has become the latest to be hit by turmoil in the subprime mortgage market.

The Basis Yield Alpha Fund (Master) has failed to meet margin calls and some of its lenders have declared the fund in default and are trying to seize its assets, Zenith Investment Partners, a research firm, wrote in a report on Thursday. Zenith's report cited a notice that Basis Capital sent to investors on Wednesday.
Basis warned that if its lenders seize assets of the Basis Yield fund and sell at "distressed sale prices," the net asset value of the fund could be halved compared to its May 31 level, Zenith's report said.

Basis Capital, founded in 1999 by Steven Howell and Stuart Fowler, didn't return a phone call and an e-mail seeking comment on Thursday morning. Zenith also didn't return a call and an e-mail.

Merrill Lynch (MER) is the fund's prime broker, according to Basis Capital's Web site. A spokeswoman for the investment bank declined to comment.

After missing margin calls, the Basis Yield fund is negotiating with creditors and has appointed accounting firm Grant Thornton to help with an orderly sale of assets at prices which reduce the losses to investors, Zenith's Thursday report said, citing Basis's July 18 notice to investors.
Letter To Investors

Subprime crisis - the Basis Capital letter to investors

DISCLOSURE NOTICE

BASIS YIELD FUND (ARSN 107 898 048)
Basis Capital Funds Management Limited (ACN 092 478 441) as the responsible entity of the Basis Yield Fund (”Fund”) advises that the Basis Yield Alpha Fund (Master (”Master Fund”) in which the Fund indirectly invests most of its assets has liabilities to its financiers secured over most of its assets. The financiers have reduced their valuations of those assets as a consequence of the disruption in US credit markets following concerns in relation to sub-prime residential mortgages and have made margin calls. The Master Fund is in default in meeting some margin calls which has resulted in a number of its financiers declaring events of default. Some of the financiers are seeking to realise their security over the Master Fund’s assets. As there is no liquid market for many of these investments there is a serious risk of substantial losses in the Master Fund as the prices obtained by financiers may be significantly below the book value in the Master Fund’s accounts as at 31 May 2007.

The Master Fund is negotiating with its financiers and has appointed the accounting firm Grant Thornton to assist it to do so in an attempt to achieve an orderly sale of assets at prices which reduce the losses to investors. However, it can not control the exercise by financiers of their enforcement rights. .....
The key idea here is that Basis Capital Fund was over leveraged in assets with "no liquid market". There is going to be a round of lawsuits over this idea. But the bottom line is that Basis Capital was rolling the dice with OPM (other people's money) just as Bear Stearns did, and the dice came up snake eyes.

The Bright Side

Basis Fund investors might lose only 50% of their money. Investors in Bear Stearns High-Grade Structured Credit Strategies Enhanced Leverage Fund are worthless as noted in The Alt-A Word.

J.P. Morgan Chase (JPM), Citigroup (C), Morgan Stanley (MS), Goldman Sachs (GS), and Bear Stearns (BSC), and Deutsche Bank (DB), are creditors to the fund according to the Financial Times. No doubt all of the above are scrambling like mad to get their money while there is still anything to get (tough luck for Basis Capital Investors).

Click on any chart in this series for a sharper view.

JPM



C



MS



GS



BSC



DB



Except for BSC which already has busted both its weekly trendline as well as the 50 day exponential moving average (EMA) the key question in relation to the other charts is "Will these 50 EMAs hold?". If not, and fundamentally there is no reason they should with subprime contagion clearly spreading, look for a test of the 200 EMAs (at a minimum).

Creditors having learned a lesson watching the Bear Stearns hedge fund go to zero and may start acting quicker. The implication to those in leveraged hedge funds should be obvious: Get out ahead of trouble while you can (if you can). If you wait until you need to get out, it is simply too late. More and more hedge funds and pension plans are going to be finding out "It's Already Too Late".

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Thursday, 19 July 2007

Can the Fed control prices?

The question on my mind today is: Can the Fed Control Prices? In Long-Rate Folderol Is Reaching Inflection Point Caroline Baum quotes Bernanke as follows:
Fed Chairman Bernanke pretty much summed up the official party line in a March 30, 2005, speech, when he was one of seven governors on the board. The Fed has "no direct control over the key interest rates and asset prices that jointly determine the extent of financial stimulus," Bernanke said. Instead, policy makers are stuck setting "an otherwise obscure short-term interest rate, the federal funds rate."
There you have it. Bernanke admitted that he has no control over asset prices or even key interest rates. But does he have control over any prices? For that, let's take a look at Fed Isn't Boxed in by Open Windows or Dry Powder. Caroline Baum writes:
The Fed's dual mandate -- maximum sustainable growth and price stability -- is fine for public consumption: It keeps members of Congress off its back. But as far as policy makers are concerned, price stability is both an end in itself and a means to that end and therefore commands the upper hand.

The idea that a central bank can produce faster growth by tolerating a little more inflation has been "entirely discredited," Bernanke said last week in a speech to the National Bureau of Economic Research's Summer Institute in Cambridge, Massachusetts. "Policies based on this proposition have led to very bad outcomes whenever they have been applied."

So maybe this is a new era of straight talk (OK, they could improve on the boilerplate statement) and a crooked tilt except when deflation, or a decline in the price level, threatens.

Even then, it seems, the Fed would still be more concerned about prices than growth. After all, in the long run, prices are all it can control.
Bernanke might agree with that last sentence (after all he does want an inflation target of 2%), but I strongly disagree.

What the Fed can control.
  • Base Money Supply
  • Short Term Interest Rates
That's it. If the Fed could control prices, oil would not be over $70 a barrel, food prices would not be soaring and housing prices would not be collapsing. Perhaps someone wants more exclusions as to what prices the Fed is not in control of.

Prices the Fed clearly does not control
  • Food prices
  • Energy prices
  • Shelter prices
  • Equity prices
  • Asset prices
But the list does not stop there. Can the Fed control the cost of medical care or is the that too heavily influenced by various government giveaways like Medicaid and Medicare? Can the Fed control shirt prices? How? Isn't one of factors influencing the price of shirts the price of raw materials making up the shirt? Isn't a huge portion of the cost labor costs? Does the Fed control labor costs in China? Can the Fed control runaway government spending? If not, how can it control any prices?

Can someone name the price of any goods or services the Fed is in control of? I can't think of one (unless you call a short term interest rate a price). Interestingly enough I agree with two statements made by Bernanke:
  • The Fed has "no direct control over the key interest rates and asset prices that jointly determine the extent of financial stimulus"
  • The idea that a central bank can produce faster growth by tolerating a little more inflation has been "entirely discredited"
Out of Control

With M3 expanding at close to 13% the Fed is clearly out of control. But the Fed likes a good party. It helped create the biggest bubble to date in both consumer credit and housing. Supposedly this must be "good inflation" because it primarily affected asset prices like houses and equities. For some reason the Fed can't control those but it can control other prices even though I challenge anyone to name the price of anything the Fed can control.

Oddly enough Bernanke claims to know that "faster growth does not come by tolerating more inflation" yet has embarked on the most extreme if not downright insane fiscal policy the world has ever seen. Bernanke can't see it because he ignores asset bubbles just as the Maestro (Greenspan) did.

Nonetheless the Fed can (and does) micromanage base money supply and short term interest rates. This management is quite like the failed central planning strategies of Russia and China. When monetary policy is too loose one of two things typically (but not necessarily) happens: Prices in general rise or asset prices rise. It is the latter that creates bubbles because the Fed ignores them until things get out of hand.

Furthermore the Fed is in a Fool's Fantasyland from the start because prices cannot be accurately measured and also because there is no such thing as a representative basket of goods and services to begin with. For more on the difficulty of measuring prices please see Inflation: What the heck is it?

When the world was more US centric than it is today, the Fed arguably had "more influence" on prices than it does today, but it never had "control". And although the US is still the top economic dog, its importance is decreasing over time. The Fed cannot set wages in China, Brazil, or Vietnam. Nor can it control demand at the margin for base metals in China. Nor can the Fed control oil prices ever because of growing peak oil constraints. Nor can the Fed control the price of gold or silver. Nor can the Fed rein in government spending.

Simply put, the Fed simply is not in control of any prices and its ability to even influence prices of any kind is diminishing given the ever increasing influence of a truly global economy vs. a US centric economy. What the Fed can do however, is encourage speculation by keeping interest rates too low (on purpose or by accident). But unfortunately for the Fed, it cannot control which asset prices or prices in general change by that encouragement nor can it control the bubble that ultimately results.

But the important point here is that the Fed can only encourage speculative activity. A limiting factor arises because the Fed simply cannot force speculative borrowing. Eventually there comes a time when the whole system breaks down simply because the Fed can lower rates but it can't force consumers to borrow or businesses to invest. (See Interview with Paul Kasriel for more discussion of this idea).

That is when the payback comes from years of ignoring and/or directly encouraging asset bubbles to form. When it happens, we will see the emperor has no clothes when it comes to controlling prices, controlling speculation, and controlling the expansion or contraction of credit itself.

Caroline, I am going to let you take that one back. The Fed is not in control of prices no matter how much they want everyone to think they are.

By the way, it's easy to pluck a single sentence out of a lengthy article and beat the heck out of it. That is not the intent of this post nor does it diminish my respect for Caroline Baum. (For my two thumbs up review of her book, please see Bookmobile: Master Traders & Just what I said.)

I am sure I have said a dozen things over the past year that would have me asking "Did I really say that?" Rather, this article came about because I simply liked the idea of discussing what the Fed is in control of, or not. As powerful as the Fed is, the answer (from where I sit) sure is not prices. And one look at M3 tells me the Fed is not in control of credit either. More precisely, the Fed is clearly out of control.

It's time to abolish the Fed and restore fiscal and monetary sanity. The way to make that happen is to vote for Ron Paul.

This is a long video but if you have not yet heard Ron Paul @ Google please play it.

Ron Paul is the only candidate that wants to get the Government, the Fed, and the IRS out of our lives.


Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/

Thoughts on Moody's "Tough Stance"

According to the Wall Street Journal Moody's Says It Is Taking Hit for its tough stance on lending standards.
Moody's Investors Service says it is paying a high price for its tough stance on lax lending standards for commercial mortgage-backed securities.

In a new report that assesses the status of the market, the Moody's Corp. unit said it was passed over and not hired for 75% of the commercial mortgage-backed securities rating assignments issued in the past few months as a result of its requirement that issuers add an extra layer of credit enhancement. Moody's said issuers are "rating shopping" -- meaning they were hiring competitors that would hand out higher ratings on securities. Because Moody's makes money rating ...
It is absolutely laughable for Moody's to claim it is taking a tough stance on ratings. For starters all of the ratings companies have fatally flawed ratings models. In addition Moody's admits the following "Moody's has no obligation to perform, and does not perform, due diligence." As I have said before, truer words were never spoken.

In Moody's In Wonderland I wrote about Moody's stunning display of twisted logic, whereby they actually made it a blessing to have rising default risk.

In Mispricing Risk / Conflict of Interest I talked about the obvious conflict of interest between ratings companies and the companies they rate.

In The Rating Game Scam I commented on a Bloomberg article accusing the S&P and Moody's of Masking $200 Billion of Subprime Bond Risk.

Original Ratings

In Stress Test I noted that Almost 65 percent of the bonds in indexes that track subprime mortgage debt don't meet the S&P ratings criteria that were in place when they were sold, according to data compiled by Bloomberg.

So far the S&P has downgraded less than 2% of of the $565.3 billion of subprime bonds issued from late 2005 through 2006. The initial claim by the S&P was $12 billion but the S&P made a mistake. It was a mere $7 billion.

In Moody's downgrades risky mortgage debt back on April 30th I see Moody's downgraded $348 million of bonds in lower-rated classes. Wow, Moody's had the nerve to downgrade a whopping $348 million of bonds out of a $14.1 pool of subprime garbage.

On July 10th I see Moody's Downgrades Residential Mortgage-Backed Securities.
Moody's Investors Service has cut its ratings for 399 residential mortgage-backed securities (RMBS), citing higher-than-expected delinquencies in the underlying loans, the same day that Standard and Poor's said it may start cutting ratings on $12.1 billion of mortgage-related debt.

Moody's has an additional 32 securities under review for possible downgrade. The securities were originated in 2006 and their downgrades would affect a total of $5.2 billion in debt.
There's another big WOW for you. Moody's downgraded $5.2 billion in 399 securities and has the nerve to consider reviewing (drumroll please...) another whopping 32 securities.

A google search for "Moody's Downgrade Debt" turns up a couple other small items but no totals were given none of it was it mortgage related that I could see.

In S&P, Moody's to cut rates of risky debt The Political Gateway posts a combined total (Moody's & S&P) debt downgrade at $17 billion ($5 billion and $12 billion respectively).

But on July 13th we see S&P: Whoops! A $5 billion subprime blunder.
Standard & Poor's admitted to making a nearly $5 billion blunder in correcting its own estimate for subprime securities it is reviewing for ratings cuts. S&P corrected the volume of residential mortgage-backed securities it placed under review for downgrade on Tuesday to $7.35 billion from $12.1 billion.

"This is obviously sloppy by S&P," said Mirko Mikelic, a fund manager at Fifth Third Asset Management in Grand Rapids, Michigan. "I don't think anyone's doing back flips."

S&P said the volume corrected represents 1.3 percent of the $565.3 billion U.S. subprime mortgage market it rated between the fourth quarter of 2005 and the fourth quarter of 2006.
So assuming the S&P downgrades all $7.35 billion it is looking at and adding in another $5 billion for Moody's and let's be real generous by adding in $5 billion for Fitch we have a grand total of $17 billion of downgrades out of a pool of $565 billion of some of the worst mortgage dates to hold. That's a whopping 3% when according to Bloomberg, Almost 65 percent of the bonds in indexes that track subprime mortgage debt don't meet the S&P ratings criteria that were in place when they were sold.

Of course not all of that debt was subprime. Then again, doesn't that make matters worse? How much of it should have been subprime but was rated as high as AAA by insane rating strategies of CDOs squared and the like. Moody's can't even bring itself to downgrade what nearly everyone on the planet knows is toxic garbage.

So this talk of a "tough stance" by Moody's is a total crock. OK so maybe Moody's is losing out on a few ratings because of shopping around. So what? Not playing the ratings game scam is easy to do now with all of these blowups we are seeing. It's much tougher to do what needs to really be done, and that is to downgrade much more debt that it has. Moody's is obviously taking the easy way out on that score. And the fact that so much more debt is deserving of these downgrades shows you just how badly Moody's failed to do the right thing in the first place.

Moody's attempt to play the role of victim is tremendously galling given that it has failed every step of the way from initial ratings to now, to do what needs to be done.

Mike Shedlock / Mish
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com/