Thursday, 25 February 2010

Suggest a Budget Solution for Illinois

Here is a wrapup of some city and state budget problems posted in various places today. The wrapup culminates with a link to an online form where you can suggest budget solutions for Illinois.

Situations like those appearing below are currently taking place in every city, county, and state in the nation. Individually, the job cuts and problems may seem small, but the cumulative impact, along with the tax hikes that are coming will be enormous.

Nevada
Gaming industry refuses to pay more to help solve state budget crisis
The Nevada Resort Association announced Thursday night that the gaming industry won't agree to a Democratic plan to obtain $32 million more a year from casinos to help balance the state budget.

If Democrats can't get the casinos to agree to cough up more revenue, it puts in jeopardy their whole budget-balancing plan that attempts to avoid deep cuts in education and social services.

Key Republicans have said they won't support any revenue-raising plan that the target industry doesn't accept.
Las Vegas
Las Vegas city budget woes: 170 jobs on the line
Thursday was a difficult day at City Hall. About 170 workers are being told their jobs are on the line.

Those layoffs are the result of a multi-million dollar budget shortfall. But Mayor Oscar Goodman says it doesn�t have to be this way. He wants all city workers to give up a little to save a lot.

The bad news was laid out by City Manager Betsy Fretwell and Goodman. A looming $70 million deficit means services and jobs are about to be cut unless the four major unions involved in city government agree to help out.

�We would much prefer everybody be a little bit altruistic, little bit caring about fellow workers. And if they did what we�re proposing, after all the cuts we�ve made, if they take and eight percent reduction in salary then nobody�s going to lose their job,� said Mayor Goodman.

Goodman says right now the city is in negotiations with the fire department only. The other union contracts, such as for marshals and corrections workers, aren�t up.
The city should privatize the entire fire department. That would end the problem in one simple step.

Peach County Georgia
Can a Four-Day School Week Work?
Like every school district in Georgia, Peach County was forced to cut their budget by 3-percent. Clark says she had only two choices that could save that kind of money: lay off 39 teachers, eliminating every art, music, and PE class -OR-something never seen before in Georgia, go to a four-day school week.

Teachers now work four 10-hour days. The day for students is slightly longer than an average 5-day school day, but there's no down time. Non-instructional parts of the day have been cut out. Individual tutoring is widely attended before and after class. The number of instructional minutes for students is the same, in some cases even higher, than it used to be.

On Mondays, the schools close. Finding daycare was a big concern for critics of the plan. Clark responded, "The mission of this school district is not to provide daycare. The mission of this school district is to provide students with an education. And while we have had the luxury of providing daycare for the community five days a week, we don't have that luxury anymore."
Rhode Island
Plan to fire teachers roils RI's poorest city
The blue-and-white banner exclaiming "anticipation" on the front of Central Falls High School seems like a cruel joke for an institution so chronically troubled that its leaders decided to fire every teacher by year's end.

No more than half those instructors would be hired back under a federal option that has enraged the state's powerful teachers union, earned criticism from students, and brought praise from U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan and some parents.

The shake-up comes as Rhode Island's new education commissioner, Deborah Gist, pushes the state to compete for millions of dollars in federal funding to reform the worst 5 percent of its schools, including in Central Falls. State law requires schools to warn teachers by March 1 if their jobs are in jeopardy for the following school year.

To get the money, schools must choose one of four paths set under federal law, including mass firings. Gallo has said she initially hope to avoid layoffs by adopting a plan that would have lengthened the school day and required teachers to get additional training and offer more after-school tutoring.

The U.S. Department of Education does not play a role in deciding which model schools choose and did not know Wednesday whether Central Falls was the first to opt to get rid of its teachers, said Sandra Abrevaya, a department spokeswoman.

The decision won praise from Republican Gov. Don Carcieri, a former math teacher who supports Gist.
This was the correct decision. Now those 50% (minimum) of the teachers who are out of a job, can ponder the loss of their $78,000 over refusal to work another 35 minutes a day. The only thing surprising about the result is the support from U.S. Education Secretary Arne Duncan.

Mesa Arizona
Mesa budget woes deepen; new deficit now $19.6 million
Mesa's City Council learned Thursday morning they will have to slash spending by another $19.6 million for the fiscal year beginning July 1.

City Manager Chris Brady said while collections for this fiscal year have fallen about $16.4 million short of projections, there's enough money
in the bank to avoid further budget cuts between now and June 30.

A year ago, for example, when the city imposed an emergency spending reduction of $61 million, some departments, such as parks, saw their budgets sliced by 30 percent. Police and fire spending were reduced 5-7 percent.
That's an amazing display of denial by City Manager Chris Brady, waiting until more funds are depleted to act, and ignoring the fire department totally. It gets worse: Mesa to offer free all-day kindergarten despite budget woes.

Carbondale Illinois
Illinois budget problems felt at local dentist office
What happens if the boss cannot afford to pay you for a full week's work?

In most instances either you work a few days for nothing, or you do what many places have been forced to do during hard times, such as one Carbondale dentists' office.

It has become another victim of Illinois's $13 billion dollar budget crisis. Recently staff members held their breath as they opened an e-mail from the chief executive officer.

"I am hoping we'll be able to eliminate this uncertainty considering furlough days in the near future. But at least we can extend the delay for another two weeks," Shawnee Health Care Chief Executive Officer, Patsy Jensen said as she read from a recently sent email.

Some 350 employees received that email. The subject is furlough days. Jensen says she started these emails back in December. "If we can't meet our payroll demands then we are going to ask our staff to take one day off a week," Jensen said.

Shawnee Health Care has clinics in Carbondale, Marion, and Murphysboro. At the Carbondale clinic, nearly 80% of dental patients are on Medicaid. In Illinois, the state must match 50% of Medicaid dollars. However, Jensen says due to Medicaid payments delays, many area dentists don't accept the program.

"We're at a minimum 90 days out," Jensen said about state Medicaid payments.
Island County Washington
Island County�s 5-year budget projection is dismal
The Island County budget director recently presented commissioners with a worrisome five-year budget projection that shows reserve funds dwindling to levels that could create cash flow problems in just a year or two.

�Island County is at a critical juncture. We have prided ourselves on having the lowest tax rate in the state for years, now we�re suffering the consequences of having the lowest tax rate. Do we want to continue with that?� Commissioner Helen Price Johnson asked at a Monday morning roundtable meeting with elected officials and department heads.

Over the last year and a half, county commissioners have dealt with $5.2 million in budget shortfalls � about a quarter of the current expense fund � largely by cutting staff and dipping into reserve funds. More than 55 positions have been cut. The budget is balanced for now, but the pain may not be over.

Budget Director Elaine Marlow created two five-year budget projections. They both estimate a low-level increase in revenues from taxes, fees and other sources. One estimates a 2 percent overall increase in expenses from salary, bases and benefits, while the other estimates twice that. Both estimates assume that staff levels won�t increase and employees will not receive cost-of-living increases.

Marlow projects that costs will significantly outweigh revenues in either scenario. Next year, she predicts the budget will be out of whack by more than $800,000. The deficit each year will slowly shrink as the economy recovers. By 2015, the projection shows the deficit at $258,000.

The commissioners will have three basic choices: cut expenditures, use more unreserved funds or raise taxes.
California
California State Legislature Establishes 'Cuss Free Week'
Californians had better start watching their mouths.

The state Assembly passed a resolution Thursday that would establish the first week of March as "Cuss Free Week" throughout the state. If approved by the Senate next week, the measure would take effect immediately.

The resolution includes no enforcement mechanism and is simply meant to promote greater harmony and connectedness, said Assemblyman Anthony Portantino, a Democrat from La Canada Flintridge and co-author of the measure.
California has serious pressing needs such as a $13 billion (and growing) budget deficit and they waste time on this nonsense.

If you were looking for more proof at how dysfunctional California is, there you have it. Of course with California, additional proof is offered every day of the week.

Illinois
Illinois' budget problems, plans are online for everyone to see
The state of Illinois wants you to see its budget problems with your own eyes.

Budget numbers for fiscal years 2009 and 2010, as well as an estimated budget for fiscal year 2011 are now posted online at budget.illinois.gov
Suggest a Budget Solution

This is may not do much good but it sure can't hurt. Please Suggest a Budget Solution for Illinois.

Ideas To Consider

  • Lower salaries for Illinois House and Senate members
  • Reduce staff for representatives
  • Lower salaries for judges
  • Lower salaries for all administrative positions especially educational
  • Killing all defined benefit pension plans
  • Insistence on no tax hikes
  • Privatization
  • Constitutional Convention to change union work rules and collective bargaining
  • Help for cities by eliminating state mandates and work rules for police and fire departments
  • Scrap state prevailing wage laws
  • Ask Congress to scrap Davis-Bacon.

You may not be heard, but this is your chance to speak. Say something.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

California Delays Payments, Ponders IOUs Again, Demands 80% of Income Tax Paid Before It's Even Earned

Tactics in California to shore up its municipal bond rating are quite humorous. Supposedly, by delaying payments to schools, California can boost confidence in its bonds.

Please consider this sure-fire confidence booster: California Passes Bill to Guard Cash as Bond Delayed.
California�s Assembly passed a bill allowing it to delay payments to programs including schools to avoid running out of cash, a move aimed at boosting confidence in bonds sold by the most-populous U.S. state.

The passage comes a day after Treasurer Bill Lockyer told lawmakers the bill was needed to send a signal to investors that California is taking steps to adequately manage its cash as it faces budget deficits through June 2011. Lockyer postponed a $2 billion sale that was initially scheduled for next week.

Assemblywoman Noreen Evans, the Democrat who chairs the budget committee, said the bill was needed so the state can return to the bond market to finance public projects that provide a jolt to the economy.

Controller John Chiang said last month that California may be forced to issue IOUs for the second year in a row because it�s spending more than it collects in revenue. The bill is aimed at preventing cash shortages projected as soon as next month by empowering officials to delay certain payments, including those to schools, universities and local governments, to conserve money for debt service and other key expenses.
California Demands Income Tax Payments In Advance

Reader "Paul" just pinged me this news affecting business owners and self-employed contractors.
Hi Mish

I just picked up tax documents from my CPA. California require me to pay 30% of my estimated tax for the year on 04/15/10 and another 50% by 06-15-10. The balance of 20% is due on 01-15-11.

They want 80% of my annual estimate after 6 months, taxing me on money I have yet to earn for the year.
Only in La-La Land could one think these actions should impress the bond market. Then again, the stock market soared mid-day after Bernanke repeated for the 40th time that he was not hiking soon. So hey, who knows?

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Detroit Mayor on Unions "They can't read, they can't add, they can't comprehend"; 33% of Detroit is Vacant Lots or Abandoned Homes

Three cheers to Detroit mayor Dave Bing for his truthful comments about unions: 'Either they can't read, they can't add or they can't comprehend'
Mayor Dave Bing today criticized leaders of the city's largest union for foot-dragging on contract negotiations, saying it's costing the financially strapped city $500,000 a month and could result in more layoffs.

"Either they can't read, they can't add or they can't comprehend," Bing said at a press conference this morning in his office at City Hall. "It has to be one of the three.

"Everyone is running with a deficit in their budgets. It's leadership or a lack of leadership that has got us to where we are."

Bing said he's ready to impose a contract on the American Federation of State, County and Municipal Employees Council 25 but said the city must follow the law. Both parties are now in fact-finding, a process which could last until July.

Bing has been at odds for months with AFSCME leaders over calls for concessions, including 10 percent pay cuts through 26 furlough days and fringe benefit cuts. The union represents about 3,600 workers such as landscapers, street pavers and crossing guards.
Problems With Bing's Approach

The big problem with Bing's approach is that he is not going far enough. He should privatize everything he can. Pussyfooting around with unions is generally a waste of time. The major goal should be to eliminate the unions entirely. The compromise position is the end of defined benefit pension plans coupled with a 33% salary reduction.

Ask for a lousy 10% cut and you end up in court, after months of delays, and all you end up with is a lousy 5% with no headway on the defined benefit issue.

By the way, Bing brought this on himself. Why is it so hard to see the need to privatize landscapers, street pavers and crossing guards? Hells bells, the goal ought to be to privatize the fire department, better yet, to have a volunteer fire department.

Thus, on second thought ... Two cheers (not three) to Detroit mayor Dave Bing. He said what needed to be said, but he certainly is not acting like he means business.

33% of Detroit is Vacant Land or Abandoned Homes

Inquiring minds are investigating Mayor Bing's Plan To Shrink Detroit
Mayor Dave Bing said Wednesday he "absolutely" intends to relocate residents from desolate neighborhoods and is bracing for inevitable legal challenges when he unveils his downsizing plan.

In his strongest statements about shrinking the city since taking office, Bing told WJR-760 AM the city is using internal and external data to decide "winners and losers." The city plans to save some neighborhoods and encourage residents to move from others, he said.

"If we don't do it, you know this whole city is going to go down. I'm hopeful people will understand that," Bing said. "If we can incentivize some of those folks that are in those desolate areas, they can get a better situation."

Bing's staff is using its own data and a survey released last weekend by Data Driven Detroit. The block-by-block study of the 139 square-mile city showed that roughly one in three parcels are vacant lots or abandoned homes.

John Mogk, a Wayne State law school professor, said Bing's on the right track but will face four major challenges: political support; money; creating a bureaucracy to administer the project and legal challenges.

Among the court challenges he sees ahead include the legality of cutting off city services to particular neighborhoods and using eminent domain to relocate residents. In 2006, voters approved a prohibition on government's ability to take property for economic development.
Talk Is Cheap

Daniel Howes, a Detroit News columnist correctly hammers the talk is cheap message in Bing must put actions behind words
A new tone at City Hall may be refreshing, necessary to steering Detroit out of a ditch deepened by its own digging. But it's not sufficient without action and the kind of rigorous financial management that should control wild overspending on overtime ($54.3 million last year), that should be more aggressive in collecting $50 million spent to demolish dilapidated buildings.

In other words, talk sounds even cheaper than it is when the numbers are so grim, because the numbers don't lie. Detroit is operating some $325 million in the red; its tax base is shrinking amid a jobs-killing recession and plunging property values; union concessions, a test of Bing's mettle, remain undelivered.

Kwame Kilpatrick, no friend to the city's unions, eliminated some 4,000 jobs during his abbreviated tenure. You, more than six months into a deepening crisis, have cut some 450 slots and reduced pay for salaried appointees by 10 percent, but have so far retreated from promises to take out more.

Another example: Look to Lansing, where a two-term governor in her final year in office steadfastly refuses to exercise the prodigious powers bestowed on her office by legal precedent and the state constitution. Gov. Jennifer Granholm is probably feared by no one, and she has the record to prove it.

Detroit's crisis, likely to deepen this year, is your opportunity to change the direction of a city whose leaders -- elected, appointed and union -- have together led Detroiters down an unsustainable path they are unable to finance, much less afford.

But we're not seeing much. Your spokesman still promises 10-percent pay cuts for union employees in the form of furloughs that don't come. Your penchant to let your actions speak for themselves (like they did on NBA basketball courts) would be admirable if you had enough actions to let do the talking.

It's a clich�, but a crisis is a terrible thing to waste. So is the support of folks inside and out of Detroit counting on you to make the difference you can.
The news commentary and columns from the Detroit News are excellent. I have several readers sending me links every day. While I can only give two cheers to Bing, I am in a cheerful mood today, so it's three cheers for Daniel Howes.

Now if only Mayor Bing would follow through with some tough actions to go with his tough words. A good place to start would be to privatize everything in sight, including the fire department. Complete annihilation is the only thing unions understand, so why not give it to them?

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

"Nascent" Recovery or "Nascent" Economic Collapse?

Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke is one of the best contrarian indicators one could possibly find. Yesterday, Bernanke told the House Financial Services Committee that the U.S. economy is in a �nascent� recovery.

Given his historical track record of complete failure on matters like housing, the recession, and jobs, his yapping about the �nascent� recovery suggests the very best we can expect is for the recovery to stall, and more likely enter a double dip recession if not completely collapse.

Unexpectedly Bad News

Let's recap some recent "unexpected" bad news.

Durable Goods "Unexpectedly" Drops

Please consider Equipment Demand Slows to Start 2010
Orders for durable goods excluding transportation unexpectedly fell 0.6 percent, the most since August, while a measure of bookings for business equipment showed its biggest decrease in nine months, the Commerce Department in Washington said. The Labor Department said new claims for unemployment insurance rose to a three-month high.

Factories may be taking a pause to gauge demand after boosting production in the second half of 2009 to replenish inventories. Reports earlier this week showed weaker consumer sentiment and home sales, underscoring Federal Reserve Chairman Ben S. Bernanke�s view that the recovery is �nascent� and still requires interest rates near zero.

�There�s no reason to think this is the start of a double-dip -- some back and fill is standard operating procedure in recoveries,� Chris Low, chief economist at FTN Financial in New York, said in an e-mail to clients. �Rising jobless claims, weaker orders and falling consumer confidence suggest the economy is retrenching in the first half of the first quarter.�
Happy Talk On Durable Goods

Just take a look at that happy talk. There is every reason to think this may be the start of a double-dip recession. All we have seen is inventory replenishment, government spending, and various stimulus measures like cash-for-clunkers and housing tax credits that have withered on the vine.

Durable Goods Details

  • Orders for non-defense capital goods excluding aircraft, a proxy for future business spending, fell 2.9 percent last month, the biggest drop since April 2009.
  • Orders for machinery slumped 9.7 percent in January, the most in a year.
  • Orders for motor vehicles and parts dropped 2.2 percent in January after a 5.5 percent gain.
  • The big bright spot was Boeing received orders for 59 aircraft two months ago, an increase that wasn�t captured in the December data.

Less Than It Seems

Michael Panzer writing on the Big Picture Blog says Durable Goods: Less Than It Seems
During the last 17 years or so, the median value of the ratio of defense-related orders to the overall orders number has been 4.4 percent. However, since the recession began (in December 2007), the average has been 6.6 percent. Last month, it hit 8 percent. As with other areas of the economy where the government appears to be playing an important role, it�s worth bearing in mind that the �recovery� may not be all that it seems.

Blaming It All On The Weather

When all else fails, economists blame it all on the weather. Today, Weekly Unemployment Claims Spike To 496,000. I asked Will Reality Soon Set In?

I should have known better. Oh, silly me. It's just the weather.

Inquiring minds are reading Jobless claims rise due to weather-related factors.
New claims for unemployment benefits jumped unexpectedly in the U.S. last week, mostly because state agencies processed a backlog of claims caused by snowstorms the previous week.

The severe weather also increased temporary layoffs in the weather-sensitive construction and transportation industries.

Many analysts expect this month's snowstorms cost up to 100,000 jobs and will artificially inflate the unemployment rate. A clear reading of the job picture may not be available until March or April.

Also Thursday, Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke told a congressional committee that the snowstorms are likely to have a short-term -- but not permanent -- effect on unemployment and layoffs. He said policymakers will "have to be careful about not overinterpreting" the upcoming data.
Weather Related Questions

I have a few simple questions for all the dim-bulb economists now blaming the weather:

  • "Did you not know there was a snowstorm on the East coast?"
  • "If you did, then why didn't you factor it in to your estimates?"
  • "How can you be surprised by something you knew?"

I was pondering the mid-afternoon market spike and here we go again. Bernanke himself is blaming the weather.

Consumer Confidence Unexpectedly Plunges

Bear in mind that economists were shocked about the sudden drop in consumer confidence numbers. Please see Consumer Confidence Plunges To 46, Lowest Since April; Current Conditions Lowest Since 1983 for details on the consumer confidence numbers.

New Home Sales Unexpectedly Plunge

Please remember that on Wednesday New Home Sales Unexpectedly Plunged to Record Low.
Bloomberg:

Sales of new homes in the U.S. unexpectedly fell in January to the lowest level on record, a sign that an extension of a government tax credit may not be enough to rekindle demand.

Purchases declined 11 percent to an annual pace of 309,000, below the lowest forecast in a Bloomberg News survey of economists, from a 348,000 pace, figures from the Commerce Department showed today in Washington. The median sales price dropped 2.4 percent from January 2009 and the supply of unsold homes increased.

It's All Weather Related Now

It's kind of hard to blame new home sales on the weather but, hey, I suppose "It's All Weather Related Now".

And with that, the bad news buyers are out in force, secure in the knowledge that on account of a snowstorm on the East coast, "A clear reading of the job picture may not be available until March or April."

After all, no one really wants a clear reading anyway.

The only real concern is how to make fairy tale economic projections. With that in mind, please note the upcoming temporary effects of the hiring of a million part-time census workers will more than smooth away the afore-mentioned ill effects of a snowstorm months earlier.

No doubt, economists will be chirping away that the boom in part-time hiring will soon mean full-time hiring. It won't.

A "nascent" economic collapse is at hand, but how can economists possibly see it with all these weather related issues? When the collapse does come, economists will be saying once again "No one could possibly have seen this coming."

Indeed. Economists have proven "It's tough to predict the weather, even in arrears with 20-20 hindsight straight out of any newspaper in the country."

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Weekly Unemployment Claims Spike To 496,000; Will Reality Soon Set In?

Yesterday the market rallied the moment Bernanke started yapping to Congress about holding interest rates low for a considerable length of time. Pray tell what did he say that anyone should not have expected?

Perhaps today the reality of "why" Bernanke feels compelled to hold rates low will set in. Following news that unemployment claims spiked to 496,000 the S&P 500 gapped down 15 points. Is there more where that comes from?

With that backdrop, let's take a look at the report.

Inquiring minds are investigating the Unemployment Weekly Claims Report for February 25, 2010.
In the week ending Feb. 20, the advance figure for seasonally adjusted initial claims was 496,000, an increase of 22,000 from the previous week's revised figure of 474,000. The 4-week moving average was 473,750, an increase of 6,000 from the previous week's revised average of 467,750.
Weekly Unemployment Claims



In reference to Feb 6, last week I said "After last week's unexpected huge dip, this week sports an unexpected huge rise. That's why it's best to focus on the trend in the 4-week moving average."

Today I suggest that perhaps that February 6th "green shoot" is an outlier. It is the only thing keeping that 4 week moving average as low as it is.

4-Week Moving Average of Initial Claims



4-Week Moving Average of Initial Claims Detail



The 4-week moving average of claims for the last three weeks is above where it was on December 12, 2009 and just slightly better than it was on December 5, 2009. By this measure, the recovery has stalled.

Is Bad News Finally Bad News?

The day is still early. Bad news buyers may still save the day.

At some point however, reality will eventually set in. Without jobs, all this happy talk about the impending recovery, and all of Bernanke's yapping about low rates, will not satisfy the market. It is going to take both jobs and an increase in consumer spending to lift the economy.

From where I sit, neither is coming.

Right now, the dollar is firm, treasuries have a bid, the stock market is down, commodities are down, and gold and the $HUI are up. That action suits me just fine.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Commercial Real Estate Deal Gone Sour: A Reader Asks "What To Do?"

Inquiring minds might be wondering what they should do if they are struggling in a commercial real estate deal. Here's a question along with an answer from my "California Business Banker" friend.

"Struggling In Atlanta" writes:
Hello Mish,

We purchased a small commercial building in Atlanta in late 2007 for $1.3 million. In an attempt to be prudent, we put 30% down and opted for a fixed rate mortgage. We got a 7.25% rate by entering into a separate interest rate swap with the bank tied to Libor.

In 2008, our major tenant went bankrupt but we were able to replace them 3 months later with a new tenant. However, the new lease rate was about 30% below what we had from the previous tenant. Since then, we have added new tenants and are almost at the prior income level, but we still are not making a profit.

Here's my question: Do banks have any incentive to come back to the table with us and renegotiate our loan before we start making late payments?

We can keep up, but only by contributing some savings. I know the banks don't want to be landlords but what is the best way to approach this with our bank?

Thanks for any assistance.
Struggling In Atlanta
Hello SIA, I have no practical experience in these situation but my commercial banker friend does. I bounced your email off "California Banker" who replied ...
Hi Mish

In regards to your friend in Atlanta with the commercial real estate investment that has turned over. The first thing they should understand is they are not alone. Finally, commercial real estate has caught up with the residential market, and I see a lot of people who have the very same issues. I actually have a client going through this issue with another bank.

There are three things I would encourage them to understand or research:

1) Virtually all commercial real estate loans are not reported to personal credit agencies, so it's highly likely a delinquent commercial real estate won't impact their personal credit.

2) They should review their loan documents to see if they signed as guarantors, which essentially puts their personal net worth on the hook. Given the interest rate swap loan, they might not have, which would be good, but the answer impacts their strategy.

3) Lastly, they should check their documents for a prepayment penalty which is very standard on fixed rate loan. And given the swap type loan I would guess they have the Yield Maintenance type which is typically an eye popping penalty.

Step one in their plan: Take their loan docs, their tax returns, and personal financial statement, and see an attorney that specializes in real estate, "NOW". Far too many people wait until the end of the process, when it's to late.

Step two, "The Bank": I haven't heard of too many banks looking to help someone while they are current on loan payments. It's the community banks that seemed to be more proactive when a problem arises. So, after a visit with the attorney and his blessing, go talk to your banker and lay out the issues. Chances are their banker will pass the info to people higher up at the bank who can actually make a decision. It's important to understand that their loan officer or relationship manager is probably not the person who makes the decision and often they have no idea what the bank will really do. So, you might get various answers over time, and it will be frustrating.

I'm going to share something about the banking industry many people just don't understand: Before a loan goes into foreclosure there are 3 stages of delinquency. They are 30-89 days late, 90+ days, and loans on non accrual (loans with no viable way to make payments). As loan moves into later and later categories, banks are forced to set aside more money for expected losses. That money comes right off the profit and loss statement, which most bank executives hate. So, if they let the payment go late 30-60 days they still might not get the bank to the table. After 90 days you should get their attention.

So, if you talk to the bank on the first go around and they are willing to play ball, that's great. However, if you don't get the answer you want in 60 days, it's probably time to let the payment go late. I do not like the idea of burning savings to keep it afloat, so I wouldn't give the bank a lot of time, as they hope you will keep making payments.

Step 3: Letting the payment go. This part of the process you want to keep your attorney involved in. It might be able to deed the property over to the bank, or do a short sale, and you'll want your attorney to review any paperwork involved. If however, the bank is willing to play ball at this point, I would request an interest only loan structure for 12 months. That should turn your building cash flow positive for 12 months, and you can rebuild your savings. Also, during the process of letting the payment go, save all the rent and build cash.

My personally opinion is that the commercial real estate market will get worse over the next few years, so getting out of the investment entirely is my preferred strategy. However, every deal is different. One size does not fit all.

Again, see an attorney first, and also share this data to make sure it works for your situation.

California Business Banker
The most important step in the process is the first one. Please do as "California Banker" suggests. Take your loan docs, tax returns, and personal financial statements, and see an attorney that specializes in commercial real estate law, "NOW".

What neither California Banker nor I know is your personal finance situation, how long you can hold out with negative cash flow, your job status, etc. You need to discuss all of that with someone who knows the laws for your state.

Good Luck.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Wednesday, 24 February 2010

Union Cannibalization: Laid-off CTA workers upset with unions, management

In every downturn, unions cannibalize their junior membership, throwing them to the dogs. This downturn is no different, except that cuts will be much deeper and far more lasting.

Please consider Laid-off CTA workers upset with unions, management.
Ralph Cleveland says getting a job driving a bus for the Chicago Transit Authority was the best thing that happened to him since moving up North 10 years ago.

"When I came to Chicago in 2000 from Bibb County, Alabama, I was so proud about having a uniform on," said Cleveland, 56, who started with the CTA almost 6 1/2 years ago. "I stood in the mirror, and I couldn't believe the Lord had blessed me with that."

He looked forward to getting up in the morning and going to work at the transit agency's 77th Street bus garage, then coming home to take care of his wife, who has severe arthritis and other ailments.

But the couple was dealt a serious setback this month when Cleveland became one of 1,059 CTA workers laid off because of CTA service cuts that slashed bus service by 18 percent.

Like many of his former co-workers, Cleveland says his labor union, the Amalgamated Transit Union, has let him and others down, almost abandoned them, to preserve the pay raises and full benefits for almost 7,000 union brothers and sisters with more seniority, who the CTA did not let go.

He has seen larger and larger deductions from his paycheck in recent years for union dues and other union expenses, Cleveland said.

In contrast to his union's strident opposition to negotiating concessions, Cleveland is willing to take a pay cut if that's what is needed for him to get behind the wheel again.

"If I could get my job back, that's what would make me happy, making money for me and my wife, who I love so much, and my grandchildren,'' he said. His CTA employee health care benefits were cut off at 11:59 p.m. on Feb. 6, a minute before the service cuts took effect.

CTA officials have called on the agency's bus and rail unions to make those concessions to help eliminate a $95.6 million budget deficit in 2010. Leaders of the Amalgamated Transit Union have refused to reopen the current contract, which expires at the end of next year.

"I'm willing to make a sacrifice,'' said Cleveland, who worries that he won't have enough money saved up to take his wife back home to Alabama for retirement at some point. "I've been making a sacrifice ever since I came into this world.''

"I ain't looking for handouts or public aid. I wish I could just go back on a bus and pick up people," he said.

CTA bus driver Vanessa Garrett, who also was laid off, shares the same wish. She recently separated from her husband of 25 years, and she is the sole provider for her large family.

"Everything is on me," said Garrett, 55. "I would take the furlough days and all the things the CTA is asking for, because the economy is affecting everybody everywhere and it's a bad time. If the CTA needs to take some things from us, fine, it's still a very good job."
Tossed To The Dogs

Union members praise the union until the union bites them in the ass. Ralph Cleveland who would gladly take less to have a job, can't. Taxpayers and those dependent on bus service are screwed as well. The city itself is screwed. The only ones benefiting from this screwed up relationship are the union members with the most seniority.

If the city needs to cut another 1,000 workers, Ralph Cleveland and other laid off workers will not get to vote. It would not matter if they did. The highest ranking union members with the most seniority will vote to eat the 1,000 members with the least seniority.

Dependability has no bearing. Service record has no bearing. Attitude has no bearing. And most importantly, skills have no bearing. The only thing that has any bearing is how long one has had their union card.

The union does not give a rat's ass for the likes of Ralph Cleveland or anyone else it tosses to the dogs.

Welcome to the union, Ralph Cleveland. You have just been cannibalized.

Ahead Of The Curve

I have been ahead of the curve on this issue and proud of it. Bloomberg is catching on: Banker Bonus Anger Is Shifting to Government Workers: Joe Mysak

By the way, unfunded obligations of state pension and medical benefits for public union retirees in Illinois is $25,000 per capita. That does not include the obligations of cities and the county. Although Illinois is one of the worst in the country, many other states have horrible liabilities as well.

For more details on just how bad the situation is, please see PEW Study Shows Trillion Dollar State Pension Gap; Can Anything Be Done?

States, unlike the federal government cannot just print the money. The only way those obligations can be met is by massive tax hikes or reduced benefits. I am hoping for the latter. This is a very big issue. I think one of the most important issues the country faces.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List