Monday, 26 April 2010

Goldman Sachs E-Mail by Thomas Montag Described CDO as "One Shi**y Deal"

Goldman Sachs can kiss goodbye any chance it had of containing its fraudulent Subprime CDO mess to employee Fabrice Tourre aka "Fabulous Fab".

Please consider Goldman Sachs E-Mail by Montag Described CDO as �Shi**y Deal�
Thomas Montag, the former head of sales and trading in the Americas at Goldman Sachs Group Inc., called a set of mortgage-linked investments sold by his firm �one shi**y deal,� according to an excerpt from internal e-mails released today by Senate lawmakers.

The transaction was Timberwolf Ltd., a $1 billion collateralized debt obligation holding pieces of other CDOs, according to a statement today from the Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations. The CDO also included optimistic side-bets on the performance of CDOs, or derivatives, in which the firm took the opposite pessimistic side in �many� cases, the panel said.

�Boy that timberwo[l]f was one shi**y deal,� Montag, who is now Bank of America Corp.�s president of global banking and markets, said in a June 22, 2007, e-mail to Daniel Sparks, who ran Goldman Sachs�s mortgage business at the time, according to the panel�s statement. Within five months of Timberwolf�s debut, the CDO had lost 80 percent of its value, and it was liquidated in 2008, according to the panel.

Sparks, who left the bank in 2008, in one e-mail urged �personnel working on a potential Korean sale to �[g]et �er done,� and sent a mass e-mail to the sales force promising ��ginormous credits� for selling� the debt, according to Levin�s statement. �A congratulatory e-mail was sent to an employee who sold a number of the securities: �Great job � trading us out of our entire Timberwolf Single-A position,� � the panel said.
Goldman Hires PR Firms to Clear its Name

Goldman Sachs is not backing down. Inquiring minds note Goldman wages PR fight to clear its name.
Goldman has hit back hard against civil fraud charges with a public relations blitz aimed at poking holes in the Securities and Exchange Commission's case and repairing the bank's reputation. Every time the SEC has punched, Goldman has quickly counterpunched.

To help its cause, Goldman has hired Mark Fabiani, a big player in the PR world with strong ties to top Democrats. Fabiani earned the nickname "Master of Disaster" for his handling of crises during the Clinton administration. He now works as a media consultant specializing in corporate crisis management. Goldman has also brought in top corporate attorneys. And its executives, including CEO Lloyd Blankfein, have been out in public, not hunkering down.

The damage control efforts will be on display Tuesday when Blankfein and Fabrice Tourre, the employee named in the SEC fraud charges, are questioned by a Senate subcommittee probing the bank's role in the financial crisis.

Goldman's PR campaign, which runs counter to its long history of secrecy, is a bold yet risky move. Some analysts say a poor performance on Capitol Hill could worsen the bank's image problems and make it harder for it to attract and retain lucrative clients. If the strategy fails, analysts say, it could cost Blankfein and other Goldman executives their jobs.

Top financial law firm Sullivan & Cromwell LLP is heading Goldman's defense. The lead lawyer is Richard Klapper, who represented Barclays Capital when Enron shareholders sued the investment firm in 2007. Goldman has also hired Gibson, Dunn & Crutcher, the law firm of former U.S. Solicitor General Theodore Olson, and K. Lee Blalack, a partner in Washington-based law firm O'Melveny. Rounding out the team is Greg Craig, the former chief counsel under President Barack Obama.

None of the law firms responded to requests for comment.

Goldman "has become an iconic image of bankers with conflicts of interest," said John Coffee, securities law professor at Columbia Law School. "That image is out there in the public's mind and will be out there in 10 years."
I side with John Coffee.

Repeating a comment I made yesterday ... I have a serious problem with a "bank" making 90% of its income trading its own portfolio, and screwing its customers in the process, whether it's legal or not.

This will not go away quickly.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Save "Are" Teachers Act II

In response to Save "Are" Teachers Polar Bear Writes ...
C'mon now Mish. The sign obviously says "Save Area Teachers." The edge of the sign is just folded over. Clearly these kids care about more than just their own local teachers. Very commendable!
Obvious?!

Dear Polar Bear ...

I have a simple question to ask.
Was it so tough to play the video?

Here is the image I posted



Here is the link I posted:
In a KCCI video teacher, Terry Hoffman has the kids chanting "Show Us The Money".

Let's stop at the 12 second mark and take a look at what is obvious.



The clip above is as clear as I can get of a the full sign. It is perfectly obvious the sign says "Save ARE Teachers".

By the way it is exceptionally hard to stop a video of someone waving a sign and get a sharp image clip of it. I tried a half dozen times and the first image was the sharpest I could get. However, the second image shows that anyone who bothered to play the video, could easily have seen what the sign says.

Email From a School Director

Inquiring minds might be interested in an email from Patrick Brown, a director of operations of a private school in Costa Rica.
Dear Mish,

I've been following your blog for almost a year. I often post your articles on my facebook page or email them to friends and family.

I currently have one particular friend who writes, "Obviously, this will sound a little defensive; but didn't "Mish" miss adding any sort of proof to his Massachusetts teacher claim? I mean, anybody can start a blog and rattle off garbage."

He said this in response to your article titled, "Save Are Teachers", where you wrote, "In Massachusetts, teachers were telling kids that they would lose their homes if they did not get more money." If you can find the time to send me the reference for this claim, I would really appreciate it.

I happen to be in education. I'm the director of operations of a private independent K-12 American school in Costa Rica. Our school probably has much more in common with private US schools than you might think. My friend lives in la-la land and probably cannot take the fact that public schools in the U/S. and around the world have been run over by union thugs whose most minimal interest is the students.

Thanks much and please keep up the fantastic work. I cannot believe you do not charge for this!

Patrick Brown
Director Operations
Country Day School
An American School Serving the International Community
Faulty Memory

Hello Patrick, If I charged for what I did, you never would have found me. The best sites are all free. It's deflation at work.

That aside, thanks for the opportunity to clarify and to bring up a story that is truly worth revisiting.

I have no need to make stories up. The reason is simple: Truth is frequently stranger and more entertaining than fiction.

However, I do admit my memory is not perfect. I cited Massachusetts. I meant Rhode Island. With that hopefully minor transgression out of the way, and with apologies to Massachusetts, let's flashback to Wednesday, February 17, 2010.

Please consider Democratic Strategist Blasts Obama's Obeisance To Unions; Students Back Superintendent Firing All Teachers
Students Support Firing Teachers

As noted in Central Falls Rhode Island Fires Every High School Teacher the superintendent fired every teacher in a pay dispute. Teachers refused to work an extra 25 minutes a day even though 50% of the students at the school are failing all of their classes and the graduation rate is 48%.

Here's an update to the story: Students stand up for Central Falls school chief.
A student-run group called Young Voices rallied in front of the Rhode Island Department of Education at noontime on Wednesday to support Central Falls Supt. Frances Gallo, who plans on firing all of the city's high school teachers as part of a state-ordered reform initiative.

Some 20 students from Providence gathered to speak on behalf of students in Central Falls, who were not invited to the rally because Young Voices was worried about the possibility of reprisals from the Central Falls' teachers.

According to Karen Feldman, one of the co-directors of Young Voices, Central Falls youth said that teachers have been telling their students that they might lose their houses if they are fired. According to Young Voices, students have said that their teachers are using the classroom as a bully pulpit to express their outrage with Gallo's decision.
Teacher salaries at the high school average $72-78k. That does not include benefits. Nor does it factor in 3 months off in the summer. If some teachers lose their houses over this, they only have themselves to blame.

More importantly, teachers have no right to lay their personal problems on the backs of students. Those students have enough problems as it is.
I appreciate the second opportunity to point out Central Falls Rhode Island teachers, making an average of $72-78k per year, would not work an extra 25 minutes a day, even though 50% of the students at the school are failing all of their classes and the graduation rate is 48%.

The icing on the union cake was the guilt trip those teachers laid on their students in regards to their self-imposed plight of potentially losing their homes.

Here's the deal: Any teacher in that school who voted against working an extra 25 minutes and lost their job and may lose their house, deserves to lose both.

Those teachers who wanted to work an extra 25 minutes, but could not because an insanely greedy public union got in the way, need to seriously consider if they ever want to work for another public union.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Tsunami of Red Ink - Global Look at National Debt and Who Owns US Debt

The Chicago Tribune had an excellent set of charts this weekend in A Tsunami of Red Ink regarding US government debt and who owns it, and also a comparison of US debt to the national debt of other countries.



Debt as a Percentage of GDP



Comparison of US Debt to Other Countries



Click on the link at the top to see foreign holders of US debt country by country. The top three US debt holders are China, Japan, and the UK.

Some will not believe those figures on debt to GDP comparisons. I don't either. For starters the numbers are from 2009.

The footnote also says, if intragovernmental debt is included the figure is 83%. That number is approximately correct in my opinion (as of 2009).

Some will want to count unfunded Social Security and Medicare liabilities out to 2050 or whatever. This is simply wrong. That would be like counting a car you intend to buy 3 years from now as part of your debt now.

Many things can happen between now and then.

  • You may buy a smaller car.
  • You may not buy the car at all, opting for public transportation.
  • When the time arrives, you may postpone buying a car for a couple more years.
  • You may save enough to pay for the car in cash so that you incur no debt.

Likewise, the plans for Social Security and Medicare might change. Costs may go up, or down. The plans may be scaled back by the next generation of US citizens who think our generation was the most greedy in history.

Things We Know

  • The current path and current plans are not sustainable.
  • The money has not been spent, yet.
  • Costs may go up or down.
  • Political promises can easily change.
  • Taxes may go up dramatically, to pay for the costs.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Sunday, 25 April 2010

Expect Contagion in Europe, Greek Debt Crisis Will Spread; New Wave of Riots in Greece

Given that the European Commission has been 100% wrong 100% of the time in its ability to yap away the problems in Greece, I take the opposite side of Greek Debt Crisis Won�t Spread Through Europe, Officials Say
European Central Bank officials dismissed speculation that Greece�s budget crisis will spill over to other countries in the euro region.

�There is no economic cause for a contagion discussion,� ECB Governing Council member Ewald Nowotny said in an interview in Washington.

Concern that Greece�s woes could spread to other indebted euro-area countries has been pushing up borrowing costs of nations including Portugal and Spain. The countries� budget deficits as a share of gross domestic product were more than three times the European Union limit of 3 percent last year.

�Of course Spain is not Greece,� ECB President Jean- Claude Trichet said April 23 after meeting with Group of 20 finance chiefs.

Greece on April 23 asked to activate the funding mechanism agreed by euro-area nations earlier this month. The request for as much as 45 billion euros ($60 billion) is an unprecedented test of the euro�s stability and European political cohesion.

Greek Finance Minister George Papaconstantinou yesterday told investors they will �lose their shirts� if they bet cash- strapped Greece will default. Speaking to reporters in Washington, where he was negotiating terms for a three-year loan package with the International Monetary Fund and European governments, Papaconstantinou expressed confidence the talks will be �concluded rather soon� and said his country wouldn�t restructure its debt.

With 8.5 billion euros of Greece�s bonds maturing May 19, finance chiefs want a swift agreement amid concern any delay may trigger a further sell-off in its assets and hurt global markets.

�Is there a risk for other countries in the zone? No, the other situations have absolutely nothing to do with that of Greece,� Bank of France Governor Christian Noyer, who represents his country on the ECB council, said April 24.
Greece Hit By New Riots

The Mail Online is reporting Greece hit by new riots as pressure grows to quit euro
Riots erupting during workers� protests over planned public spending cuts, just hours after Greek Premier George Papandreou sought emergency �35billion of loans from eurozone countries and the International Monetary Fund.



The Greek government was finally forced to ask for international help after the cost of its borrowing spiralled to a new high, making it prohibitively expensive to borrow money to service existing debts.

Leading members of Germany�s Christian Social Union, sister party in Bavaria to Chancellor Angela Merkel�s Christian Democrats, said Greece should be forced out of the euro.

Leading CSU MP Hans-Peter Friedrich said: �Greece has not only a liquidity problem but also a fundamental growth and structural problem.� He said that this should prompt Greek politicians to �seriously consider leaving the eurozone�.

Werner Langen, head of the CDU/CSU group in the European Parliament, added: �I am extremely skeptical as to whether the aid package conforms with European Union law and the German constitution.

�The real alternative is for Greece to leave the currency union and become competitive again via hard structural reforms.�

Chancellor Merkel, whose country is the largest contributor to the Greek bail-out, has said she would be reluctant to help unless the stability of the euro was threatened and the Greek government implemented tough reforms.
Restructuring Not Off the Table

Greek Finance Minister George Papaconstantinou saysDebt Restructuring �Off the Table�
Greece will not restructure its debt as part of a plan to seek a bailout from the European Union and International Monetary Fund, Finance Minister George Papaconstantinou said today.

�Any notion of restructuring is off the table for the Greek government, has never been put on the table of negotiations and has never been part of any suggestion or proposals made by the IMF to Greece,� he said at a press conference in Washington.
That statement is clearly preposterous. If it is too painful to tell the truth, then it's better to say nothing at all. Nothing is off the table at this point and it is foolish to state otherwise.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

2010 Public Employee of the Year Award

Last week's Saturday Night Live skit on public unions was an absolute riot.



Please play that video. Unless you are a public union employee, and perhaps even if you are, it will have you in stitches.

Apologies offered to Canadian readers. Neither the above video or the link I have to it works in Canada. If someone finds a version that will play in Canada, please let me know and I will post it.

Addendum:

I am told this link works from Canada ... http://www.popmodal.com/video/5207/SNL-2010-Public-Employee-of-the-Year-Award

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Shelby Seeks to "End Casino Atmosphere on Wall Street�; Ban on Proprietary Trading Coming?

With thanks to Goldman Sachs, and lover letters from "Fabulous Fab", the White House is pushing ahead with a proposal to ban proprietary trading. Please consider Goldman Sachs E-mails Spur Democrats Push for Wall Street Rules
White House officials and Democratic lawmakers, bracing for a Senate showdown on Wall Street oversight, seized on internal e-mails from Goldman Sachs Group Inc. to push for new curbs that would include a ban on proprietary trading.

�These e-mails signify that there are all kinds of conflicts of interest on Wall Street, that Wall Street is working for its clients and working against its clients in the same sort of bundled toxic securities,� Senator Sherrod Brown, a Democrat from Ohio, said today on ABC�s This Week. �That�s why we need really strong reform that will separate the proprietary trading from banking functions.�

The e-mails show that the New York-based firm �made a lot of money by betting against the mortgage market,� said Carl Levin, a Michigan Democrat who leads the Senate�s Permanent Subcommittee on Investigations and published the e-mails yesterday. Democrats are using the revelations to bolster support for Senator Christopher Dodd�s financial overhaul, which faces a test vote in the Senate tomorrow. At least one Republican vote is needed to open debate.

A ban on proprietary trading, named the Volcker rule after former Federal Reserve Chairman Paul Volcker who�s advising the President Barack Obama, is �highly relevant� to ending conflicts of interest on Wall Street, Austan Goolsbee, a White House economic adviser, said today on ABC�s program �This Week.�

Shelby, also speaking on �Meet the Press�, said that while he and Dodd are �conceptually very, very close� on the legislation, he doubts they will reach an agreement by tomorrow. �We�ve got to end, once and for all, the casino atmosphere on Wall Street,� he said.
Dodd, Shelby Close to Agreement

Please consider Dodd Says He, Shelby �Getting There� on a Rules Deal
�We�re conceptually very, very close,� Shelby of Alabama, the top Republican on the Senate Banking Committee, said today in an interview on NBC�s �Meet The Press.� Democrats, who control the Senate with a 59-41 majority, would need the support of at least one Republican to get the 60 votes needed to proceed.

�I hope tomorrow we can get those votes; we may not, but I hope we do because we need to move forward,� Dodd said.

If there�s no deal by tomorrow, Republicans will stand united in voting against proceeding to the Dodd proposal, Shelby said. Republicans say blocking the vote would give them leverage to force Dodd to make concessions. Democrats could use the vote to say Republicans are obstructing reform of Wall Street.

Dodd�s bill would create a council of regulators to monitor the financial system for systemic risk, create a consumer protection bureau at the Federal Reserve and create a mechanism for dissolving the biggest financial institutions when their failure would disrupt the economy.

Senator Bob Corker, a Tennessee Republican and member of the Senate Banking Committee who helped write this section of the bill, said he plans to offer an amendment to the measure that would penalize executives of the liquidated firms.

�Everything that the executive team and the board members have earned through this company over the last five years needs to be clawed back,� Corker said today in an interview on ABC�s �This Week� program. �I�m going to be doing that on the floor if it doesn�t make it into the base bill.�

Senator Sherrod Brown, an Ohio Democrat and another member of the banking panel, said he planned to offer an amendment to limit bank size.

�Too-big-to-fail means too big,� Brown said on �This Week.�
Fabulous Fab's Love Letters

Inquiring minds are reading about "Fabulous Fab's" conflicted love letters
Fabrice Tourre and his girlfriend talked like a couple very much in love. They emailed back and forth about how they wanted to curl up in each other's arms and how they looked forward to tender moments together. Tourre, a Goldman Sachs bond trader, also wrote in the emails of the impending collapse of the subprime mortgage market and how he was masterminding ways at Goldman to make money from it.

Little did they know that three years later these very personal emails written through Tourre's Goldman Sachs e-mail account would become part of one of the biggest investigations into the subsequent financial crisis.

In the email exchanges between Tourre and his girlfriend, Marine Serres, Tourre comes off as a young, hotshot trader who foresaw the subprime meltdown while still selling shoddy subprime-backed products so prolifically he could peddle them to "widows and orphans."

But Tourre -- the only individual the Securities and Exchange Commission charged in its fraud case against the firm -- also seems ethically conflicted.

"Anyway, not feeling too guilty about this, the real purpose of my job is to make capital markets more efficient and ultimately provide the U.S. consumer with more efficient ways to leverage and finance himself, so there is a humble, noble and ethical reason for my job ;) amazing how good I am in convincing myself !!!" Tourre said in an e-mail to Serres in January 2007.

"It's bizarre I have the sensation of coming each day to work and re-living the same agony - a little like a bad dream that repeats itself," Tourre writes. "In sum, I'm trading a product which a month ago was worth $100 and which today is only worth $93 and which on average is losing 25 cents a day ...That doesn't seem like a lot but when you take into account that we buy and sell these things that have nominal amounts that are worth billions, well it adds up to a lot of money."
Any Teeth or Just Talk?

A ban on proprietary trading, if there was any teeth to it, would necessitate the breakup of Goldman Sachs, Citigroup, and Morgan Stanley. However, there is no guarantee that provision makes it into the bill. Moreover, if it does make it, the provision may be so watered down with exceptions that it would be totally useless.

The council of regulators and a consumer protection bureau at the Federal Reserve is a farce. The best way to protect consumers is to get rid of the Fed.

Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List

Sunday Funnies 2010-04-25: Goldman vs. SEC; Road Signs in Chicago

Goldman Sachs vs. SEC



Road Signs in Chicago

At the intersection of 47th and Wallace in Chicago, from the Chicago Tribune Photo Gallery (images change so you may not be able to find it) we find ...



Mark Writes
(No, the photograph wasn't Photoshop-ed)

As a graphic designer who has worked on many highway projects throughout my career - including highway signage - I can promise you that through the design, printing and installation process this sign was seen by no less than 15 to 20 people prior to it's finished installation.

None of them understood the mistake...
...or none of them cared.
Mike "Mish" Shedlock
http://globaleconomicanalysis.blogspot.com
Click Here To Scroll Thru My Recent Post List